kujo Posted February 24, 2007 Posted February 24, 2007 I wouldn't say that it is ever "fake," persay. I suppose that the groupthink mentality could set in, causing most of these people to truly want to be rested or slain or whatever. Granted, especially amongst teenagers, there is pressure to conform and to be "as holy" as your peer. Could some (perhaps even most) instances of this phenomenon be not entirely-true? Sure; however, I would caution the skeptics out there to realize that we don't always know the way God works in people's heart. Maybe these people, though they are not actually being "slain in the Spirit," are experiencing a profound increase in faith due to their ardent desire to be slain. I have seen God have the proclivity to take apples and turn them into oranges (and take water and turn it into wine).
prose Posted February 24, 2007 Posted February 24, 2007 Okay, I understand the skepticism. My intent was not to be skeptic. My intent was to discuss whether this phenomenon [i]could[/i] be ever attributed to something else. I think people could psychologically convince themselves something like this. But does anyone else have any other explanations? I believe that it truly happens to some people, but certainly not to everyone who claims it to have happened.
toledo_jesus Posted February 24, 2007 Posted February 24, 2007 [quote name='kujo' post='1204005' date='Feb 24 2007, 06:42 PM']I have seen God have the proclivity to take apples and turn them into oranges (and take water and turn it into wine).[/quote] I'd like for God to give me proof that He's up there, but He doesn't seem to want to...and some part of me says that I shouldn't need it. Perhaps that is another reason people start this charismatic stuff. If God puts you to sleep then it is easier to believe in Him.
Mercy me Posted February 25, 2007 Posted February 25, 2007 I must admit that that I have felt that it is forced at times. But will reserve judgement on this because I know that with God all things are possible. It has never happened to me but I have been in the presence of those whose are being "slain in the spirit." I know for a fact that God works differently in each of us and gives each of us different gifts. I have recieved some that I have never spoken about because they just seemed too strange and yet they moved me closer to God. I think that you have to look at the fruits. If we get too hung up looking for a logical explanation we could find that we are missing the message that we were being given.
XIX Posted February 25, 2007 Posted February 25, 2007 [quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1204152' date='Feb 24 2007, 06:48 PM']I'd like for God to give me proof that He's up there, but He doesn't seem to want to...and some part of me says that I shouldn't need it. Perhaps that is another reason people start this charismatic stuff. If God puts you to sleep then it is easier to believe in Him.[/quote] What, the Fatima apparition isn't enough? Maybe people "Start this Fatima stuff because then it is easier to believe in Him."
toledo_jesus Posted February 25, 2007 Posted February 25, 2007 [quote name='XIX' post='1204219' date='Feb 25 2007, 12:09 AM']What, the Fatima apparition isn't enough? Maybe people "Start this Fatima stuff because then it is easier to believe in Him."[/quote] Oh, you were at Fatima? What was it like? I didn't get here in time to see the sights...there is no immediacy to this miracle, which is what I meant by my previous comment. I can't relate because nothing has happened to me. And it would be foolish to believe that these occurrences are commonplace, when that would make the fantastic mundane...less oomph, you know.
XIX Posted February 25, 2007 Posted February 25, 2007 Just by the fact that the Fatima miracles obviously happened, you have practically irrefutable evidence that God exists. And that He is into Marian devotion. I'm not sure what point you are trying to make with your first two lines, could you clarify? You are buying into the lie that something has to be rare to have oomph. That if something happens to a lot of people, that makes it somehow less important. Using your logic, Daily Mass has no "oomph." Daily Rosary has no "oomph." I don't like how we are applying one standard to Catholicism and a completely different standard to charismatic prayer. There's charismatic prayer in the Bible, for crying out loud! What if I started doubting everyone who says that the Rosary has changed their life? What if I said that I think they are faking it or fooling themselves into believing that they are getting Sacramental grace? We really need to give this a rest. Chasrismatic prayer is approved by the Vatican, and there is no way we could ever say that other people are faking it without passing judgement. Skepticism is one thing, but there is no reason to let it get beyond skepticism.
CrossCuT Posted February 25, 2007 Posted February 25, 2007 [quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1204152' date='Feb 24 2007, 05:48 PM']I'd like for God to give me proof that He's up there, but He doesn't seem to want to...and some part of me says that I shouldn't need it.[/quote] [size=1]Proof? You have all the proof you need. The world, people, stars, everything! Thats proof enough. [/size]
philosophette Posted February 25, 2007 Posted February 25, 2007 Just curious, does anyone know of anyone who feels that they were slain in the spirit when they were alone with no one around and not at a prayer meeting? Also, doesn't Teresa of Avila speak of something similar? I do not have my book here, but I think it is in the Interior Castle and it is a kind if mystical absorption in God; I remember while reading it that it sounded a lot like being slain in the spirit. I might be recalling it incorrectly. At any rate... always in community or not?
prose Posted February 25, 2007 Posted February 25, 2007 That is a great question. Is this something that exists only when others are around?
scardella Posted February 26, 2007 Posted February 26, 2007 [quote name='CrossCuT' post='1203769' date='Feb 23 2007, 11:26 PM'][size=1]Personally, I tend to assume its fake before I go believe it. Maybe some people really experience it, but I think 98% of it is their mind playing a trick on their body because they want to experience it so bad...or they are just faking for attention. They just want to believe it happened sooooo bad that they trick themselves into thinking that it acctually did. I just have a hard time believe that sort of thing. [/size][/quote] I've seen some people who were dead set against the idea, thought it was fake, etc. have it happen to them. I'd say the majority of the time it's not fake. I do believe that there are times when the person wants it to happen, but when he forces it, he really doesn't get anything out of it. It's like they're beginning to idolize the experience. That's usually when their prayer life starts to dry up, to keep them focused on the God of miracles rather than the miracles of God. [quote name='philosobrat' post='1204253' date='Feb 24 2007, 10:56 PM']Just curious, does anyone know of anyone who feels that they were slain in the spirit when they were alone with no one around and not at a prayer meeting? Also, doesn't Teresa of Avila speak of something similar? I do not have my book here, but I think it is in the Interior Castle and it is a kind if mystical absorption in God; I remember while reading it that it sounded a lot like being slain in the spirit. I might be recalling it incorrectly. At any rate... always in community or not?[/quote] I have heard of it happening in other circumstances. I do think that it happens more often in prayer meetings where they're prepared for that sort of thing b/c people have an easier time letting go. I would tend to think that solitary examples of it often go less reported anyway. You tend to lose your sense of time, etc. when it happens.
Seven77 Posted February 26, 2007 Posted February 26, 2007 it happens and is real. now, if it happens ALL the time--we may be talking of something different in that case. i've seen someone who did that several times unwarranted--falling before hands were to prayed over her, dancing sporadicly and falling during praise and worship sessions---totally unaware of having danced. THAT is not normal "slain in the spirit" behavior and is of very questionable origin.
Seven77 Posted February 26, 2007 Posted February 26, 2007 [quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1204152' date='Feb 24 2007, 06:48 PM']If God puts you to sleep then it is easier to believe in Him.[/quote] it is?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now