Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1208639' date='Mar 5 2007, 09:10 PM']BUT the couple of times I've gone to services after that year have only confirmed for me that I made the right choice, and it helped to defuse the attraction and lingering nostalgia I felt. Now that I've been Catholic for a while ... I miss the substance of the Mass when I go to a Protestant service. It feels empty. The emotional high is not enough, because I have had SO much more, and I leave feeling like I've missed out on something. Because I have.[/quote]

Amen. That's exactly how I feel. I love the music at my parents' church, but they don't have the Real Presence, and it just feels so, well empty is the only word I have for it.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1208971' date='Mar 5 2007, 10:40 PM']that assumes I have catholic friends here...

Just protos

my only catholic friends are here. the phamily[/quote]
If you ever decide to come up to the Twin Cities, you can sing praise songs with me. I know a few. :D:


[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1209105' date='Mar 6 2007, 11:43 AM']Amen. That's exactly how I feel. I love the music at my parents' church, but they don't have the Real Presence, and it just feels so, well empty is the only word I have for it.[/quote]
Yes. It is weird, too, because at one point, the music was SO important. Now, I feel more fulfilled at a daily Mass with no music than I ever did at a praise and worship service. Now all that stuff seems like so much window dressing ... I would rather have the real thing any day than the emotional roller coaster.

Posted

WHat are you doing in the cities?

As a protestant I was really into the music, I would have hours where I would put on a cd and just die to myself. Brokeness and reflection and all that. The music does that to me, where I cant just sing it, but I learn to experience from it. Thats what Im scared of getting sucked into; it is very different than what I feel it should be. It is a different experience then what I feel.

St T is a great school, I considered the CSMA program (i have a dear friend there) but decided on the FUS distance program

Posted

UST Law :)

Oh and my former Prot church was HUGE on brokenness. It was like a mantra ...

  • 2 weeks later...
theculturewarrior
Posted

If it challenges your faith, stay away. Otherwise, if you want to go, go. I find that I feel more comfortable at evangelical services when I am quietly saying Hail Mary's for the congregation.

Posted

That is exactly what I do at our chapel. Im still forced to go to chapel for my school, but I usually just bring a book with.

Posted

I would not go to a Protestant service because I would be bored to death, but as long as you do nothing contrary to the faith it is okay to attend.

God bless,
Todd

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1208971' date='Mar 6 2007, 01:40 AM']that assumes I have catholic friends here...

Just protos

my only catholic friends are here. the phamily[/quote]
Not nice
What I had been thinking is that, though I like P&W music, I sing it with Catholic friends... for some reason I don't think I'd be comfortable singing it with a bunch of prots.
Is there anything going on in your diocese that you can get involved with? Diocesan WYD is coming up, for instance...

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1214540' date='Mar 16 2007, 09:48 AM']I would not go to a Protestant service because I would be bored to death, but as long as you do nothing contrary to the faith it is okay to attend.

God bless,
Todd[/quote]

Yeah, compared to the beautiful Divine Liturgy, a Protestant service probably would be extremely boring (I've never attended a Protestant service but I have attended many Eastern Divine Liturgies)

Posted

hehe,

protestants would say the same thing brother. that catholic mass is repeatitive and boring

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1215223' date='Mar 17 2007, 07:47 PM']hehe,

protestants would say the same thing brother. that catholic mass is repeatitive and boring[/quote]
:yes:

but they are missing out. Seriously.


I am staying with my brother and sister-in-law this weekend; she's a former Catholic, I'm a former Protestant. Pray for me ... maybe we can get some good talks going ...

Posted

if they understand then they are missing, if they dont understand then they think we are lacking.


Terra, understand the litugry if you want to engage your famly

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1215793' date='Mar 19 2007, 10:22 AM']if they understand then they are missing, if they dont understand then they think we are lacking.
Terra, understand the litugry if you want to engage your famly[/quote]
Oh I had the BEST talk with my brother tonight. He and my sister-in-law went to Mass with me on Sunday, and today he and I started talking about love and self-giving and how we should model Jesus' gift of unconditional love and sacrifice in our relationships ... then he made a comment about how he felt like he needed to be reminded more regularly about what it means to love, and how he connected communion with a reminder of Jesus' love for us. He's on his own practically come to a belief in the Presence of Christ in the Eucharist, and feels like he needs communion more than once a month ... we talked about how the Mass is structured, he was impressed with much of what he saw and wants me to give him books. I also shared with him more details about my conversion than we've talked about in the past, and I think he was really moved. It was SUCH a great talk, and he really sounds like he wants to learn more. I also told him that one of the things that convinced me that the Catholic Church was right was in examining the reformation ... I talked about how I came to see it not as people standing up for their personal beliefs, but as family members stepping back from the common table and breaking ties -- like if he and I were to fight, and he were to go off and never eat at the same table again and instead start up his own Thanksgiving traditions. I told him that we want him to come home ... he got a little misty. I get to spend some extended time with he and his wife later this week ... we're doing a road trip to the Grand Canyon ... so I'm hoping we can pick up the conversation with her around.

I am trying not to push too hard ... I want to be responsive rather than invasive, but I am really, really thinking that God is working in my brother's heart.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1216322' date='Mar 20 2007, 05:54 AM']Oh I had the BEST talk with my brother tonight. He and my sister-in-law went to Mass with me on Sunday, and today he and I started talking about love and self-giving and how we should model Jesus' gift of unconditional love and sacrifice in our relationships ... then he made a comment about how he felt like he needed to be reminded more regularly about what it means to love, and how he connected communion with a reminder of Jesus' love for us. He's on his own practically come to a belief in the Presence of Christ in the Eucharist, and feels like he needs communion more than once a month ... we talked about how the Mass is structured, he was impressed with much of what he saw and wants me to give him books. I also shared with him more details about my conversion than we've talked about in the past, and I think he was really moved. It was SUCH a great talk, and he really sounds like he wants to learn more. I also told him that one of the things that convinced me that the Catholic Church was right was in examining the reformation ... I talked about how I came to see it not as people standing up for their personal beliefs, but as family members stepping back from the common table and breaking ties -- like if he and I were to fight, and he were to go off and never eat at the same table again and instead start up his own Thanksgiving traditions. I told him that we want him to come home ... he got a little misty. I get to spend some extended time with he and his wife later this week ... we're doing a road trip to the Grand Canyon ... so I'm hoping we can pick up the conversation with her around.

I am trying not to push too hard ... I want to be responsive rather than invasive, but I am really, really thinking that God is working in my brother's heart.[/quote]

I'll be praying! :)

Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1216322' date='Mar 20 2007, 12:54 AM']I also told him that one of the things that convinced me that the Catholic Church was right was in examining the reformation ... I talked about how I came to see it not as people standing up for their personal beliefs, but as family members stepping back from the common table and breaking ties -- like if he and I were to fight, and he were to go off and never eat at the same table again and instead start up his own Thanksgiving traditions. I told him that we want him to come home ... he got a little misty.


I am trying not to push too hard ... I want to be responsive rather than invasive, but I am really, really thinking that God is working in my brother's heart.[/quote]


That is an awesome analogy.

let me know if i can help

theculturewarrior
Posted

I used to feel alone in the faith. Unsolicited suggestion... pray for the circle of friends that God wants you to have. He doesn't feed us stones. :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...