hoosieranna Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 (edited) Null vote. I'm not Catholic. I went to a Lutheran college, and my mom currently goes to a Lutheran church. She liked having some sort of liturgy. Very different from the Church of Christ denomination she grew up in. I'm currently figuring things out. I'm not a fundy, and am actually sort of leaning toward Catholicism. There are some issues, both with me and my family, that need to be worked out. We'll see. If nothing else, I have very great respect for the Church. Really bored, huh? Me too. Edited March 18, 2007 by Nadezhda
Apotheoun Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 I would be Orthodox, because as an Eastern Catholic the doctrine, spirituality, and liturgy of my Church is nearly identical to Eastern Orthodoxy.
DemonSlayer Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 If Jesus hadn't arrived yet, I probably would've been Jewish, otherwise nothing but Catholic.
Dust's Sister Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 [quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1215362' date='Mar 18 2007, 03:22 AM']If Jesus hadn't arrived yet, I probably would've been Jewish, otherwise nothing but Catholic.[/quote] [b]exactly[/b]
Sojourner Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 I picked Orthodox ... but I am not sure I would have converted to Orthodoxy had Catholicism not been an option. It's funny, though ... I can't imagine now not being Catholic. Which is cool, because it took a while for me to self-identify as Catholic. Now it's so ingrained I can't imagine being anything else ...
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 I would be Jewish because they are God's chosen people, that is of course Catholicism has not been established. My priest asked my youth group this, and he chose Jewish...everyone questioned him, but I saw his reason.
Resurrexi Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Proud2BCatholic139' post='1215437' date='Mar 18 2007, 08:57 AM']I would be Jewish because they are God's chosen people, that is of course Catholicism has not been established. My priest asked my youth group this, and he chose Jewish...everyone questioned him, but I saw his reason.[/quote] The Jews were the Chosen People before the coming of Christ but now the Catholics are the Chosen People. BTW, I refuse to speculate because I could never be any other religion. Edited March 18, 2007 by StThomasMore
Apotheoun Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 There is nothing in the poll question that says that Word of God did not become incarnate; instead, it simply asks what religion you would be if you could not be Catholic. Moreover, if the incarnation had not happened the following groups would have to be removed from the poll: Jew for Jesus Lutheran Methodist Orthodox Baptist
CoffeeCatholic Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 "Jews for Jesus" = Catholic At least in the theoretical sense. Technically all Catholics ARE Jews for Jesus, and the Jewish faith is the closest you can get without adding heresy and falsity. Of course, it's missing a HUGE thing, you know, the fulfillment. But it's not adding any carp either (like teaching young children how to speak in tongues because "that's what we do" or "symbolic communion" or worshiping the potluck supper instead of the Last Supper).
Apotheoun Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 The Church is the "New Israel," which is not the same thing as being Jewish. Rabbinic Judaism is not the religion that Christ followed. In fact, Rabbinic Judaism only arose after the destruction of the Temple by the Romans, and is built upon the reorganization of religious life in the Holy Land following the Rabbinic council of Jamnia.
Totus Tuus Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 (edited) For a long time I thought Jewish, because then I could come to the fullness of faith without being associated with heretical sects. However, I have come to see that it would be better to be Eastern Orthodox than Jewish, I think, because I'd have more of a head-start on getting into the Catholic Church! Protestantism would be a runner-up, but EO would be my first choice because, although I would still be in schism/heresy, I'd have the Sacrament of the Holy Eucharist Edited March 18, 2007 by Totus Tuus
Mercy me Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 I have no idea. I am Catholic because the Lord led me to the Catholic church and nowhere else. I would just have to trust that He would lead me where he wants me.
Pontifite 7 of 10 Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 I would probably not join any other type of religion. The Catholic faith is special, and without that special call you get from Jesus, other religions just don't seem right. Without our church I would most likely just live for me and do whatever I wanted, I wouldn't worry about no church.
Ash Wednesday Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 It would depend on the reason I wasn't Catholic. If it were due to something of a crisis of faith where I decided religion was pointless, or something catastrophic happening with the Church -- if in some scenario the Church became some fallible institution that proved itself or declared itself wrong, I would be a Buddhist or an agnostic. Probably an agnostic.
reelguy227 Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 I picked Buddhist, I've always thought Buddhism was an interesting religion. And plus, I love all things Asian.
Paladin Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 Prolly depends on what religion I was raised in. I've taken a bit of interestin Buddhism as well, all the asceticism and whatnot (though theologically, of course, completely incompatible with Christianity).
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now