Totus Tuus Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 [quote name='Pontifite 7 of 10' post='1215637' date='Mar 18 2007, 09:45 PM']I would probably not join any other type of religion. The Catholic faith is special, and without that special call you get from Jesus, other religions just don't seem right. Without our church I would most likely just live for me and do whatever I wanted, I wouldn't worry about no church.[/quote] But there are some religions in which you are much closer to the true Faith than others; for example, wouldn't you rather be a Protestant, believing in Jesus and the power of grace, than a Satanist?
N/A Gone Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 If there was no catholicism, then there would have been no bible. So throw out the protestant denominations. What would the greeks be if not the catholics so throw out the greeks. Basically you are asking what would we be if not christian faith community existed. Catholicism is the nomination it is where the denominations come from. Before I became catholic, I had a brief agnostic encounter where I was so bitter towards every denomination. I would worry that would be my thing. If I did not have a higher authority I can be a mess
Pontifite 7 of 10 Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1215741' date='Mar 19 2007, 09:09 AM']But there are some religions in which you are much closer to the true Faith than others; for example, wouldn't you rather be a Protestant, believing in Jesus and the power of grace, than a Satanist?[/quote] Yes, thats true so I'll guess I'll vote. I voted Orthodox because I hear its really close to our faith, but I don't really know that much about it. Edited March 19, 2007 by Pontifite 7 of 10
Anastasia13 Posted March 24, 2007 Posted March 24, 2007 [quote name='CoffeeCatholic' post='1215493' date='Mar 18 2007, 12:17 PM']"Jews for Jesus" = Catholic At least in the theoretical sense. Technically all Catholics ARE Jews for Jesus, and the Jewish faith is the closest you can get without adding heresy and falsity. Of course, it's missing a HUGE thing, you know, the fulfillment. But it's not adding any carp either...[/quote] Umm, you must mean the Messianic Jewish faith. In regular Jewish faith, you really are saved more by being a good person than anything else. Atheists and Hindus who are good people are saved.
track2004 Posted March 25, 2007 Posted March 25, 2007 I'd be chilling with the Budda. I figure if I can't be Catholic I wouldn't want to settle for another Christianity and Judiasm never seemed a good choice. The other options are a bit too out there, I guess. There a lot of parts of Buddism that I really like and that make me think I'd enjoy being Buddist.
RezaMikhaeil Posted March 25, 2007 Posted March 25, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1215803' date='Mar 19 2007, 09:29 AM']If there was no catholicism, then there would have been no bible. So throw out the protestant denominations. What would the greeks be if not the catholics so throw out the greeks. Basically you are asking what would we be if not christian faith community existed. Catholicism is the nomination it is where the denominations come from. Before I became catholic, I had a brief agnostic encounter where I was so bitter towards every denomination. I would worry that would be my thing. If I did not have a higher authority I can be a mess[/quote] I think it meant if you weren't roman catholic... if there were no roman catholic church, there still would be the other 3 original rites. Reza
Aloysius Posted March 25, 2007 Posted March 25, 2007 no, it meant if you were not any rite of the Catholic Church. to me: if Catholicism (all sui juris churches included) is not true, Christianity is not true. Period. The entire logical basis of Christianity rises or falls on whether or not Christ's Church with Peter at its base succeeded or fell through the test of time. if Christ's Church did not succeed as I believe it did, then there's no chance Jesus was Divine. So yeah, if I was to not be Catholic, I'd not be a Christian. Anything and everything would be open then... I don't know what I'd do. Without Christianity being true, I'd really see absolutely no motivation to believe in the religion of ancient Israel anymore than there'd be reason to believe in the religion of any ancient people. I'd probably still believe in monotheism as the most logical truth as observed by ancient greek philosophy... and I even have a pretty sound belief in some sort of Trinitarian Nature to God whether or not there's a Christ... though I might allow myself to let that trinitarian procession accrue into many more persons sprung by infinite love within the Godhead... so I'd be susceptible to some aspect of pagandom there (except with a monotheistic unity) so I'd probably arrive at some sort of western equivalent to modern hinduism applied to the experiences of gods in the west (I wouldn't actually go hindu, because that's clearly, to me, a culturally eastern phenomenon which has no philosophical basis to be made universal; only Catholicism among all the world's religions ever had a sound philosophical basis to be made universal) making them all persons of one God and interpretting mankind's encounters and stories about them accordingly. But that entire system cannot stand in the light of the True Church's success down through the millenia.
zwergel88 Posted March 25, 2007 Posted March 25, 2007 I really don't know. I would believe in God, but not in any set way, I'd probably some sort of amorphous Buddist-ish type, but not really committed to anything in particular.
RezaMikhaeil Posted March 25, 2007 Posted March 25, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1219088' date='Mar 24 2007, 09:58 PM']no, it meant if you were not any rite of the Catholic Church. to me: if Catholicism (all sui juris churches included) is not true, Christianity is not true. Period. The entire logical basis of Christianity rises or falls on whether or not Christ's Church with Peter at its base succeeded or fell through the test of time. if Christ's Church did not succeed as I believe it did, then there's no chance Jesus was Divine.[/quote] Then you shouldn't have put orthodox down for a possible option on your poll [as most people have elected it] because the Orthodox Church is 3 rites of the original church. Reza
carrdero Posted March 28, 2007 Posted March 28, 2007 [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1219307' date='Mar 25 2007, 02:46 PM']Then you shouldn't have put orthodox down for a possible option on your poll [as most people have elected it] because the Orthodox Church is 3 rites of the original church. Reza[/quote] Grew up Catholic, now I study Patrickism. True Story
Guest T-Bone Posted March 28, 2007 Posted March 28, 2007 [quote name='carrdero' post='1221012' date='Mar 28 2007, 12:16 AM']Grew up Catholic, now I study Patrickism. True Story[/quote] Is that a division of the Church of Spongebob? Really...what is it?
carrdero Posted March 28, 2007 Posted March 28, 2007 (edited) [quote name='T-Bone' post='1221023' date='Mar 28 2007, 02:23 AM']Is that a division of the Church of Spongebob? [/quote] I have to laugh because Patrick Starfish used to be my avatar on Phatmass a couple of years ago. [quote]T-Bone writes: Really...what is it?[/quote] Webster’s Dictionary defines Patrickism as the way that GOD perceives Patrick. It is the accumulated experiences and wisdom that defines Patrick’s existence. It's also my first name. Edited March 28, 2007 by carrdero
Piamaria Posted March 28, 2007 Posted March 28, 2007 I probably would have taken Buddhist Precepts as the members of my extended family that I most love and respect are Buddhist and culturally I am comfortable with the practices. But having found Jesus and the True Church, I can hardly imagine my life otherwise.
LouisvilleFan Posted March 29, 2007 Posted March 29, 2007 Interesting results... I'm surprised at how many chose Buddhism and that I was the only one to pick Baptist. Orthodoxy and Judaism are to be expected, but I think some of you might be surprised at how far an Orthodox believer can be from Catholicism. I personally think it's easier for a Baptist to become Catholic than any other type of Christian, and if I were not Catholic I would be Baptist (actually Calvinist, to be more specific). Orthodox embrace the Living Tradition and Lutherans believe some tradition, although their faith is based on Scripture alone, but because they are so "close" to Catholicism they also know exactly why they [i]aren't[/i] Catholic. On the other hand, most Baptists only [i]think[/i] they know why they aren't Catholic, but their perception of Catholicism is usually far more skewed. So once a Baptist starts to embrace Tradition, it's either all or none. For me, the issue of where my Christian faith was going was between embracing the fullness of Tradition, and becoming Catholic, or rejecting all of it in favor of being a Sola Scriptura, Sola Fide, Sola Christe, Sola Gracia, Five Point Calvinist!
Aloysius Posted March 29, 2007 Posted March 29, 2007 [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1219307' date='Mar 25 2007, 03:46 PM']Then you shouldn't have put orthodox down for a possible option on your poll [as most people have elected it] because the Orthodox Church is 3 rites of the original church. Reza[/quote] We believe that the Catholic Church consists of all 23 sui juris churches each with their own patriarchs and rites united with Rome. The Orthodox are currently in schism from what we hold to be the whole and entire True Church. Obviously you disagree, but you should understand that we use the term Catholic to refer to that, because that is not just Roman Catholic-- there are 23 sui juris churches in this Church. We do believe that to become Orthodox is to leave the Catholic (not Roman Catholic, Catholic) Church, but that to switch rites would be to leave the Roman Catholic Church but remain in the Catholic Church. There is the Catholic Church, consisting of all 23 sui juris churches ONE of which is the roman church; and then there are the Orthodox Churches which are not all in communion with each other let alone with the Catholic or Universal Church. Take the terminology up in the debate table if you wish... but as far as this poll is concerned that's what Catholic means I totally understand your terminological disagreement; but you're not going to get us to call it the Roman Catholic Church when it is, in fact, a universal communion of 23 sui juris churches.
RezaMikhaeil Posted March 29, 2007 Posted March 29, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1221613' date='Mar 28 2007, 07:12 PM']We believe that the Catholic Church consists of all 23 sui juris churches each with their own patriarchs and rites united with Rome. The Orthodox are currently in schism from what we hold to be the whole and entire True Church. Obviously you disagree, but you should understand that we use the term Catholic to refer to that, because that is not just Roman Catholic-- there are 23 sui juris churches in this Church. We do believe that to become Orthodox is to leave the Catholic (not Roman Catholic, Catholic) Church, but that to switch rites would be to leave the Roman Catholic Church but remain in the Catholic Church. There is the Catholic Church, consisting of all 23 sui juris churches ONE of which is the roman church; and then there are the Orthodox Churches which are not all in communion with each other let alone with the Catholic or Universal Church. Take the terminology up in the debate table if you wish... but as far as this poll is concerned that's what Catholic means I totally understand your terminological disagreement; but you're not going to get us to call it the Roman Catholic Church when it is, in fact, a universal communion of 23 sui juris churches.[/quote] Catholic just means universal actually, but again the Roman is just 1/4th by tradition, as the proper terminology would be "Roman Catholic". Edited March 29, 2007 by RezaLemmyng
Totus Tuus Posted March 29, 2007 Posted March 29, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1219088' date='Mar 24 2007, 11:58 PM']no, it meant if you were not any rite of the Catholic Church. to me: if Catholicism (all sui juris churches included) is not true, Christianity is not true. Period. The entire logical basis of Christianity rises or falls on whether or not Christ's Church with Peter at its base succeeded or fell through the test of time. if Christ's Church did not succeed as I believe it did, then there's no chance Jesus was Divine.[/quote] I think most of us were under the impression that the question was if we were not Roman Catholic [i] but Catholicism[/i] still existed. Like if we were raised something else or converted away from Catholicism. Edited March 29, 2007 by Totus Tuus
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now