Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Question On The Eucharist...


Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted

Ummmmm. You said my post was anecdotal. I.e. the effects on the two parishes was questionable. If you don't doudt the effects then you should not have said it was anecdotal. Pretty clear. Whether or not someone is poorly catechized does not mean the effects cannot be postitve. Plopping them in front of the Blessed Sacrament where there is a library of books does in fact help. Prayer helps whether someone is well catechized or not. I disagree with what you are saying. I am all for good catechesis but that does not mean we should not start adoration until the Catechesis is laid down.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1217298' date='Mar 22 2007, 10:56 AM']Ummmmm. You said my post was anecdotal. I.e. the effects on the two parishes was questionable. If you don't doudt the effects then you should not have said it was anecdotal. Pretty clear. Whether or not someone is poorly catechized does not mean the effects cannot be postitve. Plopping them in front of the Blessed Sacrament where there is a library of books does in fact help. Prayer helps whether someone is well catechized or not. I disagree with what you are saying. I am all for good catechesis but that does not mean we should not start adoration until the Catechesis is laid down.[/quote]

I doubt the effects in all people who aren't sure of the theology of EA. Like many people on this forum, you seem to present an "all or nothing"approach to this. Either its good or it isn't. Not so simple in real parishes.

Another example - why are teens drifting away from Mass in droves? Because they don't' understand it. Forcing them to go and sit through it doesn't seem to help. When they understand the Mass's construction and relationship to their lives, they actually unite themselves to the liturgy and pray through it. At least that's what I see in parish ministry.

I think we should just agree to disagree. We have different ideas and truth lies somewhere in the middle.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Looking for where I said I was against catechesis. :idontknow:

Apparently you know all about real parishes. Guess the ones I go to aren't real or something.

I don't believe in making the uncatechized go to adoration. :rolleyes: I do believe in making my teenagers go to Mass.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

[quote]She says the eucharist is great, but some people can;t see Jesus in it and are more comfortable seeing Jesus in things like nature.[/quote]

I know for a fact there are Catholics who do not believe in Transubstatiation, who dont see Jesus in the bread wafer either.

I asked Catholic friends as I was leaving my last Catholic Church, what their viewpoint was, three said they do NOT believe the wafer was actually the body and blood of Jesus Christ.

Im curious do you all believe that someone who believes that way is really Catholic?

Posted

[quote name='Budge' post='1217632' date='Mar 23 2007, 09:44 AM']I know for a fact there are Catholics who do not believe in Transubstatiation, who dont see Jesus in the bread wafer either.

I asked Catholic friends as I was leaving my last Catholic Church, what their viewpoint was, three said they do NOT believe the wafer was actually the body and blood of Jesus Christ.

Im curious do you all believe that someone who believes that way is really Catholic?[/quote]

No, this is a dogma of the Church. To be Catholic one must agree with the dogma's of the Church.

I dare say there are many 'Catholics' in name only...

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1217438' date='Mar 22 2007, 06:06 PM']Looking for where I said I was against catechesis. :idontknow:

Apparently you know all about real parishes. Guess the ones I go to aren't real or something.

I don't believe in making the uncatechized go to adoration. :rolleyes: I do believe in making my teenagers go to Mass.[/quote]

Looking for where I said I was against adoration. idontknow.gif

We keep missing each other's intent. This is a discussion that involves subtlety and gray area. We can't bludgeon an answer out of this.

Posted

[quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1217802' date='Mar 23 2007, 05:31 PM']Looking for where I said I was against adoration. idontknow.gif

We keep missing each other's intent. This is a discussion that involves subtlety and gray area. We can't bludgeon an answer out of this.[/quote]

This is true.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Budge' post='1217632' date='Mar 23 2007, 09:44 AM']I know for a fact there are Catholics who do not believe in Transubstatiation, who dont see Jesus in the bread wafer either.

I asked Catholic friends as I was leaving my last Catholic Church, what their viewpoint was, three said they do NOT believe the wafer was actually the body and blood of Jesus Christ.

Im curious do you all believe that someone who believes that way is really Catholic?[/quote]


That someone rejects a teaching is no proof of anything. Whether they do or not an whether they are Catholics or not or we think they are doesn't mean much with regard to this discussion. Once again budge this is not a debate board. You might want to go back to one. :rolleyes:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...