Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Justification For Expensive Cathedrals?


Recommended Posts

johnnydigit
Posted

i've always wondered, what is the justification for a diocese to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on a cathedral? i and many others i've asked haven't been able to come to a decisive conclusion.


some pros:

-praise of God
-large funds donated specifically for the cathedral
-historical significance


some cons (that could have used the extra money):

-the poor (but the poor will always be around)
-the hungry (but the hungry will always be around)
-homeless shelters/programs
-food centers/programs
-worn down parishes in desperate need of repair (but the parishioners should help if they really wanted to, otherwise a neglected church will eventually die on its own).
-youth ministries
-2, 3, or even more new parishes if the cathedral was done modestly.
-seminary, religious funding
-education


i honestly would like to know the answer, not only for my own knowledge, but for people who ask or mention it. i'm sure the answer is worthy, it just kind of eludes me..

thessalonian
Posted

In John 12 some women are applying expensive nard to Jesus body. Judas complains that the money could be used to feed the poor. Of course we know that Judas heart was not really concerned about the poor.

3: Mary took a pound of costly ointment of pure nard and anointed the feet of Jesus and wiped his feet with her hair; and the house was filled with the fragrance of the ointment.
4: But Judas Iscariot, one of his disciples (he who was to betray him), said,
5: "Why was this ointment not sold for three hundred denarii and given to the poor?"
6: This he said, not that he cared for the poor but because he was a thief, and as he had the money box he used to take what was put into it.


The Churches are a manifestation of the faith of the people. They increase the faith of the people. Look at how many millions flock to St. Peter's in a year. Can one measure the amount of faith that this has increased in people. Increased faith increases the charity of people. The claim that the money could be used for the pour does not take in to account that when one gives God is not outdone in the giving. That applies for the building of Cathedrals and giving to the poor. It is not a dollar that goes to a Cathedral is a dollar that could have bought bread for a hungry person. That dollar for the cathedral increases faith which provides more dollars for the poor. That dollar is a seed that can produce thirty, sixty, or 100 fold.

God bless

Posted

The church is the champion of the poor. The Catholic Church spends more money on the poor than any other group. Rich architecture and beautiful cathedrals are made for the glory of God. there is a verse i think in chronicles that talks about riches and beautiful temples being for the glorification of God.

Perhaps you can ask people who ask that question why the democratic party and liberal groups spend more money on planned parenthood and the destruction of human life than on the poor. Often it is people in those lines who ask the questions.

Posted

-praise of God
-large funds donated specifically for the cathedral
-historical significance

point # 2 makes something very apparent: if not for the cathedral project, the money would not be available to the Church to donate. The very building of a Cathedral generates the funds from donators.

also: there is plenty of money in the world that could be given to help the poor; the generation of money to build a cathedral does not take away from that pool of money that could go to help the poor.

the ONLY solution to this problem that would make these objectors happy is: the Church tells everyone it wants to build a cathedral, collects all the donations, and then donates them to the poor. but this would be mortally sinful, a direct sin against the 7th and 8th commandments involving large sums of money and lies about very sacred things.

given all this, look at the objective good that cathedrals do for the poor: it gives them a place to go worship God equal to the rich man's mansion; for one day a week (or daily if the poor man be devout enough) he gets to go to a mansion that gives glory to God; he gets to experience all the greatest beautiful artwork and gold equally with the rich man; a tremendous symbol of what happens when we all enter heaven.

now, this doesn't work for all parishes, I suppose, seeing as there do arise richer or poorer parishes depending upon areas; but in most cases even the poor areas get really nice buildings to worship in. Mother Theresa made sure every parish in India had a Gold Chalice for Our Lord. It's about bringing everyone up, even if just for the worship of God, to the greatest manifestation possible of the Kingdom of God.

Objecters to it sound so much like Judas it's eerie; they almost say things word for word as he does.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

[quote name='johnnydigit' post='1276825' date='May 18 2007, 06:31 PM']i've always wondered, what is the justification for a diocese to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on a cathedral? i and many others i've asked haven't been able to come to a decisive conclusion.[/quote]I think that I would defend the significant investment in these important houses of worship, as long as you're not talking about the cathedrals in California (e.g. Oakland and L.A.). :lol_roll:

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

I'd like to respond with a question:

If poorer countries than America can afford to both serve the poor AND build beautiful churches, how can America, the wealthiest country in the world, presume to do any less? Thess is right to quote scripture. Our Catholic faith isn't about an "either/or" between loving God and loving our neighbors, but rather, it is about [i]both[/i] loving God [i]and[/i] loving our neighbors. If any country in the world can do both, it is the U.S.

johnnydigit
Posted

ok i see it better now. it does make sense, it's just hard to get past the initial opinions and rationalizations looking in as an outsider (which goes the same for the rest of our faith to outsiders).


[quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1277145' date='May 18 2007, 08:36 PM']I think that I would defend the significant investment in these important houses of worship, as long as you're not talking about the cathedrals in California (e.g. Oakland and L.A.). :lol_roll:[/quote]

touche :topsy:


[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1277286' date='May 19 2007, 01:36 AM']I'd like to respond with a question:

If poorer countries than America can afford to both serve the poor AND build beautiful churches, how can America, the wealthiest country in the world, presume to do any less? Thess is right to quote scripture. Our Catholic faith isn't about an "either/or" between loving God and loving our neighbors, but rather, it is about [i]both[/i] loving God [i]and[/i] loving our neighbors. If any country in the world can do both, it is the U.S.[/quote]

don't forget we do often do a lot here in america, probably more than any other organization. a lot of it goes unnoticed. there is a lot of hustle and bustle, communities, groups, businesses, houses, events, centers, and a lot of other things that are actively taking place to help our poor. as a typical everyday (every sunday that is) parishioner i never would have known how much really goes on if i didn't start to become active in my church and community. of course the media skips the good and goes right for the bad as well.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

[quote name='johnnydigit' post='1277290' date='May 19 2007, 04:04 AM']don't forget we do often do a lot here in america, probably more than any other organization. a lot of it goes unnoticed. there is a lot of hustle and bustle, communities, groups, businesses, houses, events, centers, and a lot of other things that are actively taking place to help our poor. as a typical everyday (every sunday that is) parishioner i never would have known how much really goes on if i didn't start to become active in my church and community. of course the media skips the good and goes right for the bad as well.[/quote]

Actually, this is exactly my point. We [i]do[/i] help the poor. We [i]also[/i] ought to build nice cathedrals. In the U.S. (and in fact in most other places) we have the money to do both without taking away from either.

johnnydigit
Posted

also i'm not the most familiar with building costs and such, but i have heard of a local sponsor that has helped with upwards of 100k to help expand an abbey. i've seen some of the plans and it definitely seems worthy. so perhaps 100 million for a large project in Southern California isn't as much as i make it out to be..

The Joey-O
Posted

I spent some time with an amazing liturgist. His opinion on the matter was that part of the purpose of Mass is to engage the whole body in a mode of worship. You can't tell now, but the old Gothic Cathedrals were filled with light and color in their hey-day. People said that it was like being inside a gem. It was a place for the poor to go to feel the riches of Heaven. I think it's key to remember that when we build a Cathedral, a church, etc., yes we are building it for God. But, we're also building it for all the people to come and have their most intimate relations with God. To say that it should be simple and drab, because the complex, beautiful architecture is offensive to poor people, is to say that poor people hate beauty. It comes close to saying that poor people inherently don't want a "Beatific Vision" of God. If poor people have a hard time, a hard life and live without much, then coming to a place where they can experience so much beauty and glory should be considered a blessing to them. At least, that's my opinion.

johnnydigit
Posted

a glimpse of heaven for the senses, not only in the Eucharist and Sacraments, but in the building itself. interesting perspective..

farglefeezlebut
Posted

Prayers are not always words. Making a Cathedral ia an act of prayer. When I stand inside a beautiful cathedral, I am standing inside a prayer.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

Amen. :love:

P.S. And if you're online at this hour why aren't you on MSN?! This is valuable confabulation time!

farglefeezlebut
Posted

MSN has an annoying habit of crashing.

I wish the C of E hadn't taken all the best ones in England. :(

Posted

[quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1281322' date='May 25 2007, 02:20 PM']MSN has an annoying habit of crashing.

I wish the C of E hadn't taken all the best ones in England. :([/quote]

I know, it really smells of elderberries. The best cathedrals and churches in England were built before the deformation and then the Protestants took them over.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

My husband told me that a few weeks back 2 Wall Street men (dont know specifically what they do since they wished to remain anonymous) donated 28 million towards religious education.

Woot!!

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

This is a good thread. A prod asked my why the churches are decorated and why the money couldn't just go to the poor. I can't remember what I said, but I think now the money just doesn't disappear. Labourers actually had to build the building, gather the resources and sculpt the fine details (not in that order). That money puts food on the table in some sense. Any leftover cash would probably make it back into the church fund anyways. Also, as mentioned previous, the church/cathedral can be a gift for the poor too.

[quote]I wish the C of E hadn't taken the best ones in England. :([/quote]

Don't forget Wales, too. Actually, all of the churches were taken. It makes me really sad... especially seeing pictures of St. David's Cathedral in Wales. It was beautiful once. Now it is empty...

johnnydigit
Posted

[quote name='Quietfire' post='1291521' date='Jun 9 2007, 05:40 PM']My husband told me that a few weeks back 2 Wall Street men (dont know specifically what they do since they wished to remain anonymous) donated 28 million towards religious education.

Woot!![/quote]

makes me wonder sometimes though. like in the Padre Pio movie, where the bishops(?) wanted to use his money for the hospital to pay off the bad bonds(?) they had bought. i have faith in the Church, but i am curious to know exactly where all the money goes - from the parish, to the diocese, to Rome, etc.

Posted

[quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1281322' date='May 25 2007, 04:20 PM']I wish the C of E hadn't taken all the best ones in England. :([/quote]
maybe we'll get them back ;)

Posted (edited)

+

I'm on the financial administration staff at one of the largest Cathedrals in the US (I think we're number 3). Let me say first, that rarely, if ever, is the cost into the "hundreds of millions of dollars". :) Aside from that, it is a lot of money! In addition to the reasons like "Our Lord deserves the best!", which is absolutely true, we also need to realize that it points to Him. Many, many, people see our Cathedral -and they can see it from all over the city- and they come because the beauty draws them. The Lord is the beautiful, the true, and the good! Both non-Catholic and Catholic, non-Christian and Christian alike yearn for this. For example, as someone, who was once a non-Catholic and before that a non-Christian, I still came to the Cathedral for comfort. There was something here, the space, in it's grandeur and magnitude reminded me that there was something more, something beautiful and good, and that gave me great consolation. You can't put a price on that.

Essentially, people have both material AND spiritual needs and the Catholic Church takes care of both of those. Don't forget (and feel free to remind naysayers) that She is the largest provider of food, housing and healthcare on the planet! AND, she provides spiritual comfort within her beautiful edifices.

The benefit of a beautiful Cathedral is also evangelical -we have hundreds of thousand of visitors a year at ours! They come and they take tours where they learn about Catholicism, they also take catechetical brochures and cd's by the tens of thousands, and primarily they are physically close to Our Lord in the tabernacle. You can't put a price on bringing people to Christ! Unlike providing only for physical needs, we come into contact this way with the materially wealthy, but spiritually poor, who need the love of Christ just as much! Although, don't get me wrong, we have plenty of the materially poor as well!

Hope this helps. There are MANY good reasons!
God Bless you and don't forget to share what you learn :)

Edited by Veritas

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...