Veritas Posted June 18, 2007 Posted June 18, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1297529' date='Jun 17 2007, 09:59 PM']This is a good thread. A prod asked my why the churches are decorated and why the money couldn't just go to the poor. I can't remember what I said, but I think now the money just doesn't disappear. Labourers actually had to build the building, gather the resources and sculpt the fine details (not in that order). That money puts food on the table in some sense. Any leftover cash would probably make it back into the church fund anyways. Also, as mentioned previous, the church/cathedral can be a gift for the poor too.[/quote] + That is an excellent point! AND, let's not forget the dignity of work. As opposed to just being given money, it is much more enjoyable, in accordance with how God created us, to participate in work! That is a huge gift. Also, for example, my poor Great Aunt was married at our beautiful Cathedral. She was just one of the thousands (the 2-3 weddings weekly, thousands of confirmations yearly, baptisms weekly, and funerals weekly that happen here) that enjoy the space whether they are rich or poor. At the Cathedral, EVERYONE enjoys something of the most beautiful -oftentimes, these are individuals who have never had a beautiful home, been in a fancy restaurant, or felt comfortable at the opera or another grand space. However, they know this Cathedral is theirs and the most important moments of their lives happen in this space. It is their house of worship: A gift from them to God, which he has given them -it is a beautiful and continual exchange.
jiyoung Posted June 20, 2007 Posted June 20, 2007 It's true--the cathedral belongs to the Church, yes, but that means to everyone in the Church--a beautiful building of another nature is usually limited as far as who is allowed to see it and enjoy it, but the poorest beggar on the street and the richest person in the world can both pray in a beautiful church and appreciate it. And yeah, building a cathedral creates jobs--instead of just giving the money to the poor, it gives them a chance to earn it, to refine their skills in a trade, and take those skills elsewhere--also, the upkeep for a cathedral also creates jobs for many years to come. The cathedral in Cologne took hundreds of years to complete, and there is always work happening on it to clean off the grime of the ages--how many jobs is that? It's not a waste of money. However, there are some that are completely in excess, and I'm pretty sure you're talking about the LA cathedral, John--and I personally think there is no excuse for spending so much money on something that looks like a warehouse and seems like basically a personal monument to Cardinal Mahoney. You can build a huge, beautiful cathedral with a fraction of what that monstrosity cost, and maybe with the rest we could've started to pay off the settlements or whatever for those sexual abuse cases, or something.
Veritas Posted June 20, 2007 Posted June 20, 2007 [quote name='jiyoung' post='1298839' date='Jun 20 2007, 03:22 AM']It's true--the cathedral belongs to the Church, yes, but that means to everyone in the Church--a beautiful building of another nature is usually limited as far as who is allowed to see it and enjoy it, but the poorest beggar on the street and the richest person in the world can both pray in a beautiful church and appreciate it. And yeah, building a cathedral creates jobs--instead of just giving the money to the poor, it gives them a chance to earn it, to refine their skills in a trade, and take those skills elsewhere--also, the upkeep for a cathedral also creates jobs for many years to come. The cathedral in Cologne took hundreds of years to complete, and there is always work happening on it to clean off the grime of the ages--how many jobs is that? It's not a waste of money. However, there are some that are completely in excess, and I'm pretty sure you're talking about the LA cathedral, John--and I personally think there is no excuse for spending so much money on something that looks like a warehouse and seems like basically a personal monument to Cardinal Mahoney. You can build a huge, beautiful cathedral with a fraction of what that monstrosity cost, and maybe with the rest we could've started to pay off the settlements or whatever for those sexual abuse cases, or something.[/quote] + I agree, the taj mahoney is quite ridiculous.
Veritas Posted June 20, 2007 Posted June 20, 2007 [quote name='jiyoung' post='1298839' date='Jun 20 2007, 03:22 AM']It's true--the cathedral belongs to the Church, yes, but that means to everyone in the Church--a beautiful building of another nature is usually limited as far as who is allowed to see it and enjoy it, but the poorest beggar on the street and the richest person in the world can both pray in a beautiful church and appreciate it. And yeah, building a cathedral creates jobs--instead of just giving the money to the poor, it gives them a chance to earn it, to refine their skills in a trade, and take those skills elsewhere--also, the upkeep for a cathedral also creates jobs for many years to come. The cathedral in Cologne took hundreds of years to complete, and there is always work happening on it to clean off the grime of the ages--how many jobs is that? It's not a waste of money. However, there are some that are completely in excess, and I'm pretty sure you're talking about the LA cathedral, John--and I personally think there is no excuse for spending so much money on something that looks like a warehouse and seems like basically a personal monument to Cardinal Mahoney. You can build a huge, beautiful cathedral with a fraction of what that monstrosity cost, and maybe with the rest we could've started to pay off the settlements or whatever for those sexual abuse cases, or something.[/quote] + I agree, the taj mahoney is quite ridiculous.
Veritas Posted June 20, 2007 Posted June 20, 2007 [quote name='jiyoung' post='1298839' date='Jun 20 2007, 03:22 AM']It's true--the cathedral belongs to the Church, yes, but that means to everyone in the Church--a beautiful building of another nature is usually limited as far as who is allowed to see it and enjoy it, but the poorest beggar on the street and the richest person in the world can both pray in a beautiful church and appreciate it. And yeah, building a cathedral creates jobs--instead of just giving the money to the poor, it gives them a chance to earn it, to refine their skills in a trade, and take those skills elsewhere--also, the upkeep for a cathedral also creates jobs for many years to come. The cathedral in Cologne took hundreds of years to complete, and there is always work happening on it to clean off the grime of the ages--how many jobs is that? It's not a waste of money. However, there are some that are completely in excess, and I'm pretty sure you're talking about the LA cathedral, John--and I personally think there is no excuse for spending so much money on something that looks like a warehouse and seems like basically a personal monument to Cardinal Mahoney. You can build a huge, beautiful cathedral with a fraction of what that monstrosity cost, and maybe with the rest we could've started to pay off the settlements or whatever for those sexual abuse cases, or something.[/quote] + I agree, the taj mahoney is quite ridiculous.
Norseman82 Posted June 20, 2007 Posted June 20, 2007 Try to find out first if the person asking the question has a bigger anti-Catholic agenda. He/she may just be a troublemaking troll.
jiyoung Posted June 21, 2007 Posted June 21, 2007 He's not--I know him personally. It's an honest question, and I know that until I understood what I stated above, I also thought that all of this art and beautiful architecture and stuff was nice but the money could've been used to help the poor--it wasn't until I realized that free handouts help nobody that I started to understand this concept.
johnnydigit Posted June 21, 2007 Author Posted June 21, 2007 nah the conversations i've had were with strong catholics. we were just like, "uh.. hm, yeah i don't remember why either," or "i forget but i remember the answer sounded somewhat valid when i heard it." it's just funny we couldn't really deduce it properly ourselves. [quote name='jiyoung' post='1298839' date='Jun 20 2007, 01:22 AM']However, there are some that are completely in excess, and I'm pretty sure you're talking about the LA cathedral, John--and I personally think there is no excuse for spending so much money on something that looks like a warehouse and seems like basically a personal monument to Cardinal Mahoney. You can build a huge, beautiful cathedral with a fraction of what that monstrosity cost, and maybe with the rest we could've started to pay off the settlements or whatever for those sexual abuse cases, or something.[/quote] for the record, i have no idea what you're talking about and categorically deny any idea thereof. Veritas i like the accidental timing of your triple post
jiyoung Posted June 21, 2007 Posted June 21, 2007 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1299365' date='Jun 21 2007, 04:03 AM']for the record, i have no idea what you're talking about and categorically deny any idea thereof.[/quote] Lies.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now