chelsea Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 Let me know if this has been debated recently, as i only joined PM a few weeks ago. The church does not say that we need to believe in apparitions or miracles. That being said, many marian apparitions have been approved (fatima, lourdes, guadaloupe, etc). Do you believe in these? Also, do you believe in the ones supposedly occuring now (ex. Medjugorje, akita, etc). discuss.
goldenchild17 Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 (edited) I'm a firm believer in the approved apparitions (especially Fatima). And strongly against Medjugorje, Akita etc. Edited June 3, 2007 by goldenchild17
homeschoolmom Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 Interesting conversation, but not exactly a debate. So, I'm moving it to Open Mic.
CatholicWing Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 [b]Yeah that a good question and I am really believed on this with my heart. I am from Pakistan and in one city named Marriam Abad. Where Mother Mary was appeared. People have had been gone there and they healings with their sickness and illness. [/b][i][/i] [quote name='chelsea' post='1286791' date='Jun 2 2007, 07:31 PM']Let me know if this has been debated recently, as i only joined PM a few weeks ago. The church does not say that we need to believe in apparitions or miracles. That being said, many marian apparitions have been approved (fatima, lourdes, guadaloupe, etc). Do you believe in these? Also, do you believe in the ones supposedly occuring now (ex. Medjugorje, akita, etc). discuss.[/quote]
CatholicWing Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 Hi Golden Child, Could you tell me why you against Medjugorje, Akita etc? [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1286873' date='Jun 2 2007, 08:33 PM']I'm a firm believer in the approved apparitions (especially Fatima). And strongly against Medjugorje, Akita etc.[/quote]
goldenchild17 Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 [quote name='CatholicWing' post='1286898' date='Jun 2 2007, 08:44 PM']Hi Golden Child, Could you tell me why you against Medjugorje, Akita etc?[/quote] I need to re-check my sources on Akita, but I know that at least with Medjugorje I believe the messages from the vision contained some very non-Catholic teachings and so I'm not convinced that it can be from heaven. I think it could very possibly be a real vision and message, but I don't believe it came from heaven, or Mary.
Tindomiel Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 (edited) I definitely believe in Fatima, Guadalupe, Lourdes, etc. I'm not so sure about some of the others. I know very little about them. Edited June 3, 2007 by Tindomiel
jmjtina Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1286924' date='Jun 2 2007, 07:56 PM']I need to re-check my sources on Akita, but I know that at least with Medjugorje I believe the messages from the vision contained some very non-Catholic teachings and so I'm not convinced that it can be from heaven. I think it could very possibly be a real vision and message, but I don't believe it came from heaven, or Mary.[/quote] please site your sources that are contrary to the Church's teachings........I have read and seen the debates that support your statement, yet I still remain unconvinced. Reading the messages myself, I haven't found anything contrary to the Church's teachings and if you have a source, I would appreciate it. Other than that, Marian devotions help to foster a deeper devotion to Jesus. No Marian Devotion, is about Mary, but the message: Repent, return to God and love Jesus. (that's a nutshell, if ever I made one) Extreme cases are all about Mary, not about Jesus and one should be able to distinguish, through prayer if their personal devotion is focused on Mary or on Jesus. True devotions lead a more devout love and appreciation for Our Blessed Mother and a deeper love and closer relationship for Jesus. Remember: Mary "magnifies" the Lord! =) It is through my personal devotion to Our Lady of Guadalupe and the Holy Rosary that my relationship with Jesus has been strengthened and nurtured. Most saints had a strong devotion to the Mother of God.
tvu_srfan Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1286873' date='Jun 2 2007, 10:33 PM']I'm a firm believer in the approved apparitions (especially Fatima). And strongly against Medjugorje, Akita etc.[/quote] I am a firm believer in the Fatima apparitions too, but Akita has been approved for a while. The Bishop of that area actually went to the Vatican several times in regards to the apparation, and apparently the message of Akita mirrored the message of Fatima. But yes, Medjugorje hasn't been approved.
Katholikos Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 As promised, I checked Akita. It has been approved, first by the local bishop, and by Cardinal Ratzinger (in his previous life in June of 1988: [url="http://www.apparitions.org/akita.html"]http://www.apparitions.org/akita.html[/url]
the_rev Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 I was converted in Medjugorje and began to think about a priestly vocation after visiting there. My story here: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=68334&hl="]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...c=68334&hl=[/url] There have been many conversions of Athiests and those who profess other faiths because of these apparations. So where am I going with this? Even if the Blessed Mother isn't appearing there, it is a Catholic parish still, and it is a parish many visit, and receive a renewal within their own faith. Is Mary appearing there? She might be, the messages some speak of that are not of the Catholic Church, have either been purposely mis-translated by the person who wrote an article or for some other reason. I would encourage you to search for the real message and the critique to see what some priests thought of it. Anyways, I think before we condemm Medjugorje, we must look at the good fruit and conversions that happen. If these apparations are "of the devil" as some say, well then I don't think the Devil knows what he is doing.
Moneybags Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 I strongly support and encourage devotion to Our Lady of fatima, lourdes, guadaloupe, knock, etc. However, I am extremely reluctant to believe in Medjugorje after someone said that one of the "visionaries" said that Mary wants centering prayer or something along those lines.
goldenchild17 Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 [quote name='jmjtina' post='1286950' date='Jun 2 2007, 09:26 PM']please site your sources that are contrary to the Church's teachings........I have read and seen the debates that support your statement, yet I still remain unconvinced. Reading the messages myself, I haven't found anything contrary to the Church's teachings and if you have a source, I would appreciate it. Other than that, Marian devotions help to foster a deeper devotion to Jesus. No Marian Devotion, is about Mary, but the message: Repent, return to God and love Jesus. (that's a nutshell, if ever I made one) Extreme cases are all about Mary, not about Jesus and one should be able to distinguish, through prayer if their personal devotion is focused on Mary or on Jesus. True devotions lead a more devout love and appreciation for Our Blessed Mother and a deeper love and closer relationship for Jesus. Remember: Mary "magnifies" the Lord! =) It is through my personal devotion to Our Lady of Guadalupe and the Holy Rosary that my relationship with Jesus has been strengthened and nurtured. Most saints had a strong devotion to the Mother of God. [/quote] I would never question devotion to Mary as that is what I rely upon for strength, so that's not what my objection would be about. As you say that you've already seen the opposing viewpoint's arguments I doubt I will be of much help to you and for that I am sorry for wasting your time. I'm not sure how much time I'll have to devote to this, but here's a few things. "All religions are equal before God," says the Virgin. (Chronological Corpus of Medjugorje, p. 317 "I do not dispose of all graces...Jesus prefers that you address your petitions directly to him, rather than through an intermediary." (Chronological Corpus of Medjugorje, p.181, 277-278) "God directs all denominations as a king directs his subjects, through the medium of his ministers" ("The Apparitions at Medjugorje," by Fr. Svat Kraljevic, 1984, p.58) "It is you who are divided on this earth. The Muslims and the Orthodox, like the Catholics, are equal before my Son and before me, for you are all my children." (Fr. Ljubic, p.71) “The Madonna said that religious are separated in the earth, but the people of all religions are accepted by her Son.” Ivanka Ivankovic (The Apparitions of Our Lady of Medjugorje, Francisco Herald Press, 1984) Question: “Is the Blessed Mother calling all people to be Catholic?” Answer: “No. The Blessed Mother says all religions are dear to her and her Son.” Vicka Ivankovic. (The Visions of the Blessed Mother at Medjugorje, St. Martin's Press, August, 1992) ______ Aside from these messages in particular (still reading through the rest of the messages as recorded by Medjugorje Web (medjugorje.org), the overall banality (for lack of a better term) of many aspects of it, and a number of questionable events surrounding it give me reason to question. "Whereas the divine vision always conforms to the gravity and majesty of heavenly things, diabolical figures will infallibly have something unworthy of God, something ridiculous, extravagant, disorderly, or unreasonable about them." (Treatise on Mystical Theology" by Fr. Farges - 1923) The alleged bloodstained handkerchief, Jakov's inquiry about the soccer title, and Mary's leaving the apparition site because of people stepping on her veil (imagine such a haughty attitude coming from Our Lady) all come to mind. Then, especially, the occurrence of the devil seen coming out of the light of the apparition and Mary's simple reply "I am sorry about that...". I understand the need for context which is why I am going through the messages again to see if I missed something. I encourage anyone to post the context if they feel it brings about a different understanding of some of the questionable messages above. "But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach a gospel to you other than that which we have preached to you, let him be anathema!" (Gal. 1:9)
goldenchild17 Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 [quote name='the_rev' post='1287072' date='Jun 2 2007, 11:24 PM']I was converted in Medjugorje and began to think about a priestly vocation after visiting there. My story here: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=68334&hl="]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...c=68334&hl=[/url] There have been many conversions of Athiests and those who profess other faiths because of these apparations. So where am I going with this? Even if the Blessed Mother isn't appearing there, it is a Catholic parish still, and it is a parish many visit, and receive a renewal within their own faith.[/quote] A number of things I would object to here, but probably better suited for a different thread and probably not something allowed for discussion on this board. Suffice it to say that I don't believe they are converting to the true Catholic Church or that the parish is indeed Catholic at all. [quote]Is Mary appearing there? She might be, the messages some speak of that are not of the Catholic Church, have either been purposely mis-translated by the person who wrote an article or for some other reason. I would encourage you to search for the real message and the critique to see what some priests thought of it. [/quote]The messages certainly could be mistranslated. But I will assume the good faith of the objectors until this is shown. If you believe mistranslation has occurred, then I would appreciate it if you could share your insights as to the correct translation (as well as its context if that helps you) of the passages I posted above. I am reading the full message again to be sure I am not misreading it, and used to believe in the apparitions and thus have read many books in its defense. [quote]Anyways, I think before we condemm Medjugorje, we must look at the good fruit and conversions that happen.[/quote] Absolutely this must be taken into account. I would dispute them being true Catholic conversions and thus not good fruits, but that is probably not for this thread to discuss. [quote]If these apparations are "of the devil" as some say, well then I don't think the Devil knows what he is doing.[/quote] I think we all quite underestimate Satan. Even if he is not the author of this apparition I have no doubt that he knows full well what his plan is and is doing everything he can to effect its result. Of course heaven will win in the end, but who knows just how many Satan will take before the end? Per my questioning of the catholicity of the conversions/church etc. I think Satan could be quite happy with the result. Satan has no problem feeding us many many truths, just so long as we also take in the few lies that he has planted within and I think Medjugorje is a perfect example of this.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 Personally I don't believe in Medjugorje, but I don't doubt that God can accomplish good in that parish. He's capable of bringing roses out of manure, so I don't question the sincerity of people's conversions after visiting Medjugorje. I believe whole-heartedly in the approved apparitions, although the only one I really focus on is Lourdes.
Jaime Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 The Church will eventually make a decision about Medjugorje and one of the secrets of Medjugorje is that there will be something permanent and unmovable placed at the site of the first apparition. So within our lifetime, we should know if the apparitions are true or not. Personally, I have no problem believing that Mary is appearing there. And I don't mean this to be argumentative Goldenchild, but I would think you don't believe that this site is truly Catholic either.
Budge Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 I believe they are happening but they are NOT from heaven but the deception of Satan in the last days. The true Mary is in heaven with God, this isnt her showing up preaching things agianst Gods Word.
farglefeezlebut Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 Budge, I don't want to seem rude, but do you actually know anything about the apparitions? What exactly has been said that is "against God's word"? Idon't know much about Fatima, but I have been to Lourdes and Walsingham and they are wonderful places. Saint Bernadette Soubirous is my confirmation Saint. She is a wonderful example. My mother was healed at Walsingham. After several miscarriages, she was told she would never have children. She went to Walsingham and prayed. Now there are six children in our family. Also, I think that a close friend's recovery from mental illness (although she is not completely healed yet) is down to the intercession of OLoW. One thing that bothers me about these places (not the apparitions themselves) is how people have exploited them to make money. Lourdes is particularly bad. They sell all sorts of tawdry rubbish (little glow-in-the-dark plastic statues of Our Lady of Lourdes spring to mind.) I guess the best way to deal with this is just to ignore it - stupid glow-in-the-dark plastic statues cannot detract from the glory of what God has done in these places.
Mercy me Posted June 3, 2007 Posted June 3, 2007 I do not follow private revelation too closely. However, I have followed Fatima and the messeges there. They are truely remarkable. The Church cannot made a determination about Madjugorje until they have been completed. Because there is so much. I doubt that they will make a determination in my lifetime as the truth of the apparitions. No matter, for me I look at the fruits. A friend of mine who was Cathollic in name only went with her family and had a radical convertion experience. She has basically dedicated the last 10 years of her life to ministry. Another friend of mine who did not at the time have a strong Marian devotion received her vocation there and deep love of Our Mother. She is now a CFR sister. I know many others who have received graces too numerous to mention. I don't know about the message but there are fruits of His work there.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now