Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

When the Church approves a [i]private revelation[/i] she is simply saying that: (1) the message contains nothing contrary to faith or morals; (2) that the message may be made public; and finally, (3) that the lay faithful may prudently give the assent of human faith (but not divine and catholic faith) to the message. That said, no one is required to accept a private revelation as true, nor is he required to have any spiritual devotion to the message or the recipient of the message.

gurlie4godsd
Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1287268' date='Jun 3 2007, 12:25 PM']I do not follow private revelation too closely. However, I have followed Fatima and the messeges there. They are truely remarkable.

The Church cannot made a determination about Madjugorje until they have been completed. Because there is so much. I doubt that they will make a determination in my lifetime as the truth of the apparitions. No matter, for me I look at the fruits. A friend of mine who was Cathollic in name only went with her family and had a radical convertion experience. She has basically dedicated the last 10 years of her life to ministry. Another friend of mine who did not at the time have a strong Marian devotion received her vocation there and deep love of Our Mother. She is now a CFR sister. I know many others who have received graces too numerous to mention. I don't know about the message but there are fruits of His work there.[/quote]


I agree. I can't imagine something so fruitful that has led to so many conversions like Medjugorje being false...at the same time once the messages are completed and the Church makes statement I will be behind her 110%.

Chiquitunga
Posted (edited)

I too like the_rev had a conversion, or "reversion" to the Catholic faith from hearing of Our Lady's apparitions in Medjugorje.

I've known of Medjugorje since I was very young, so it has always been something with me, even during my time away from the Church. Then when I stumbled upon a book about Medjugorje about 6 years ago, I read it and from then on began praying the Rosary daily and came back to the Sacraments, from whence I felt called religious life.

It was especially Our Lady's messages in Medjugorje about the Mass that had a profound effect on me .. I didn't realize anything about the Mass before, about the Real Presence .. I grew up with terrible Catechesis in CCD.

There is a beautiful cassette tape on Our Lady's messages there on the Mass called [i]The Most Beautiful Mass of My Life[/i] by [url="http://www.aracnet.com/~cfpw/sr._emmanuel.html"]Sr. Emmanuel[/url], member of the Community of the Beatitudes in France. Her personal mission is spreading the messages of Medjugorje. On that page, scroll down and there is something on her meeting with the Holy Father. Many of her other writings and tapes have had a big impact on my conversion as well.

Believe it or not, I had never even heard of the term "Blessed Sacrament" except from the messages of Medjugorje. And the little things she said to the children about preparing for Mass, coming early to the church before Mass, and staying in church after Mass to making an act of thanksgiving .. how going to Holy Mass is something much much greater than having an apparition of her .. that it is the greatest privilege given to mankind .. What an effect having an apparition of the Mother of God would have on someone's life ... yet, going to Holy Mass is something far greater ..

These messages had a huge impact in my life .. And if the apparitions should turn out to be false, I would have no problem with that as everything is there in the Mass .. I'm so glad the messages of Medjugorje made me realize this!

The vocation director for the Archdiocese of Chicago, [url="http://www.chicagopriest.org/priesthood/Meet%20Fr.%20Joe%20Noonan.html"]Fr. Joe Noonan[/url], also had a reversion to the Catholic Faith from a pilgrimage there which his mother made him go on.

Fr. Anthony Bus, an awesome priest at St. Stanislaus Kostka Parish in Chicago also believes in Medjugorje - [url="http://www.amothersplea.org/"]http://www.amothersplea.org/[/url] The Cardinal has approved his project for building a Divine Mercy Sanctuary, requested by Our Lady to him, and has recommended his book, especially to seminarians.

Dr. Mark Miravalle, STD, professor of Mariology at the Franciscan University of Steubenville is a strong supporter of Medjugorje. Here is an article by him - [url="http://motherofallpeoples.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1037&Itemid=82"]Living the Messages of Medjugorje[/url]

The official investigation by the Vatican on Medjugorje is not complete. The faithful are free to go there, just not as officially organized by a parish.

I believe whatever is the decision of the Church in the end. I'm just thankful for the impact it had on my life! I had never even heard of Lourdes or Fatima before this. Also, I had never even prayed the Rosary.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

I don't know what to think of Marian apparitions. Growing up, my family and the church I was part of was pretty skeptical of anything of that sort … they just aren’t logical or rational. So my initial reaction even to the approved apparitions is skepticism.

But, I’ve had my own unexplainable experiences over the years, both as a Protestant and as a Catholic, so I have to allow for the possibility that these are real. I still retain some skepticism … I’m still skeptical to a certain extent about the things I myself have experienced.

More important than the apparition itself, though, is the focus people take away from it – are they focused on the apparition and the novelty of it, or do they evidence an increased focus on living a faithful life, living out the graces of the sacraments in their daily work and relationships? Cuz frankly, without there being actual life change, all the apparitions in the world mean nothing. If you’re healed at Lourdes but then can’t forgive your brother for breaking your favorite vase, what good is it? Same with Medjugorje or any of the apparitions. I could care less about someone seeing a dancing sun if they’re not evidencing a changed heart as a result.

Posted

Terra, I agree with what you say somewhat. I do believe in the apparitions though, except I don't know much about Medjugorje so I can't really say. But going back to the idea of the "novelty of the apparitions", I think it is true in some cases, but that is what eventually leads them to be dismissed by the church if novelty is the dominant paradigm.

Chiquitunga
Posted (edited)

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1287102' date='Jun 3 2007, 12:52 AM']I'm not sure how much time I'll have to devote to this, but here's a few things.

"All religions are equal before God," says the Virgin. (Chronological Corpus of Medjugorje, p. 317

"I do not dispose of all graces...Jesus prefers that you address your petitions directly to him, rather than through an intermediary." (Chronological Corpus of Medjugorje, p.181, 277-278)

"God directs all denominations as a king directs his subjects, through the medium of his ministers" ("The Apparitions at Medjugorje," by Fr. Svat Kraljevic, 1984, p.58)

"It is you who are divided on this earth. The Muslims and the Orthodox, like the Catholics, are equal before my Son and before me, for you are all my children." (Fr. Ljubic, p.71)
"The Madonna said that religious are separated in the earth, but the people of all religions are accepted by her Son." Ivanka Ivankovic (The Apparitions of Our Lady of Medjugorje, Francisco Herald Press, 1984)

Question: "Is the Blessed Mother calling all people to be Catholic?" Answer: No. The Blessed Mother says all religions are dear to her and her Son." Vicka Ivankovic. (The Visions of the Blessed Mother at Medjugorje, St. Martin's Press, August, 1992)[/quote]

The little booklet I have, [i]"I Beg You, Listen to My Messages & Live Them"[/i] published by Divine Mercy Publications, Skerries, Co. Dublin, has a different message regarding different religions. I have never heard of and cannot find any of these you have quoted in the Concordance at medjugorje.org, except the one regarding us being divided on earth.

Anyone can write anything online and publish it. This message can also be misquoted or taken out of context. Here is what is published in this booklet:

[quote]"It is you who are divided here on earth. The Muslims and the Orthodox, for the same reason as Catholics, are equal before my Son and me. You are all my children. [b]Certainly all religions are not equal[/b], but all men are equal before God, as St. Paul says. It does not suffice to belong to the Catholic Church to be saved, but it is necessary to respect the commandments of God in following one's conscience. "[/quote]
Regarding, the message about disposing of graces, I also cannot find that one in the Concordance. The messages instead mention many many times of Our Lady interceding for us before God.

Edited by Margaret Clare
Posted (edited)

I strongly encourage you guys to read this, I just found a few minutes ago.
[url="http://www.geocities.com/cath_apolo/medjugo.html"]"Medjugorje Hoax"[/url]

I know that it was just addressed that anyone can publish something online, but this is quite interesting. And I remember reading this information from two other sources a while ago.

Taken from that website:

[i]H) "One day, as she (Mirjana) was waiting for the Virgin, she saw the light, and out of the light came the devil, disguised in the features and clothes of Mary, but he had a dark, hideous face...After a while, the Holy Virgin came and said to her: 'I am sorry about that...'" ("Yugoslavia and the BVM" by Tequi)

(...who is really appearing there?)[/i]
[i]
B) The Virgin was accustomed to reciting the Our father with the seers. (But how could Our Lady say: "Forgive us our trespasses," since she has none? At Lourdes, Our Lady was careful to keep her lips closed during all the Paters and Aves, reciting only the Gloria Patris.)[/i]

[i]D) From August, 1984, to April, 1985, the apparitions continued to take place in the parish church despite the Bishop of Mostar's former prohibition. (A certain sign of a false apparition, when Church authority is disobeyed by the apparition itself.)[/i]

Also:

[b][i]Medjugorje ignores the great hope of Fatima: the consecration of Russia and its conversion, followed by peace, with the triumph of the Immaculate Heart.

Finally, Medjugorje has heavy overtones of Charismaticism, a movement which infiltrated the Church from Protestantism in the late 1960's; Medjugorje is still in progress, as of this writing (1999), its length resembling the nonsense apparitions of Bayside, NY, and Necedah, Wisc. rather than the succinctness of Fatima or Lourdes.[/i][/b]

-----------
And I really don't mean to attack those who believe in the apparations. I know that there have been good fruits from it. I just wanted to share that information.

Edited by tvu_srfan
Chiquitunga
Posted (edited)

[quote name='tvu_srfan' post='1287384' date='Jun 3 2007, 03:53 PM'][b][i]Medjugorje ignores the great hope of Fatima: the consecration of Russia and its conversion, followed by peace, with the triumph of the Immaculate Heart.[/i][/b][/quote]
I don't understand how Medjugorje ignores the great hope of Fatima. There is mention of Fatima and the Triumph of the Immaculate Heart in the messages there.

There is much information here, regarding the Church's position: [url="http://www.medjugorje.org/medpage.htm"]http://www.medjugorje.org/medpage.htm[/url]

Again, anyone can publish anything online, so you have to be careful about your sources. I believe the Medjugorje.org people provide reliable information on their site, backed up by sources. I know Steve & Ana Shawl personally.

But again, I believe and adhere to whatever is the the final judgment of the Church.

Edited by Margaret Clare
johnnydigit
Posted

personally it doesn't matter to me if they are real or not. the Church has deemed them worthy of devotion, that they are safe to help you grow in your faith. they help to gather the faithful together, they inspire and give hope. God is everywhere, and Mary can enter the heart of anyone, anywhere.

if there is any sign of evil, then the Church would obviously not approve of it. they take their time, almost excruciatingly long for some people, to thoroughly make sure that an apparition is relatively safe and worthy.

making them more or less what they are without considering the above is just plain silly.


regarding Medjugorje, it's not approved (yet) so i'm not rushing to take any pilgrimages there just yet. could good fruits come from it? sure. could bad ones? sure. could none? sure, but in either case i would feel much safer with the approval of the Church.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1287310' date='Jun 3 2007, 04:03 PM']I don't know what to think of Marian apparitions. Growing up, my family and the church I was part of was pretty skeptical of anything of that sort … they just aren’t logical or rational. So my initial reaction even to the approved apparitions is skepticism.

But, I’ve had my own unexplainable experiences over the years, both as a Protestant and as a Catholic, so I have to allow for the possibility that these are real. I still retain some skepticism … I’m still skeptical to a certain extent about the things I myself have experienced.

More important than the apparition itself, though, is the focus people take away from it – are they focused on the apparition and the novelty of it, or do they evidence an increased focus on living a faithful life, living out the graces of the sacraments in their daily work and relationships? Cuz frankly, without there being actual life change, all the apparitions in the world mean nothing. If you’re healed at Lourdes but then can’t forgive your brother for breaking your favorite vase, what good is it? Same with Medjugorje or any of the apparitions. I could care less about someone seeing a dancing sun if they’re not evidencing a changed heart as a result.[/quote]
Ditto all that.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

When my SIL was pregnant the MDs told her the baby was seriously deformed and she should have an abortion immediately.
The sonagram went to Medjugorje with a group of sisters and the visionaries petitioned the Holy Mother of God to pray for the baby for a miracle. My niece Joanie Vicka is fine and today picking out colleges. :)

Can God permit His mother and various saints to visit us? Absolutely.

Posted

I would just like to point out that while our beloved John Paul the Great never personally went to Medjugorje, he was known to have a private devotion to Our Ladys apparitions there.

farglefeezlebut
Posted

Bumped
This little girl who goes to my Chruch went on a pilgrimage to Lourdes with her grandmother. She says she saw Mary in the grotto and Mary touched her. I believe her because:
1) I know her and I don't think she would lie about this.
2) When she told her grandma about it, she didn't act like it was anything unusual. The conversation (I am told) went like this:
(They had just come out of the grotto at this point
Grandma: Did you like the grotto?
Girl: Yes. I thought it was lovely how Mary put her hand on everyone's shoulder.
Grandma: (Sceptically) You felt someone's hand on your shoulder?
Girl: She had her hand on your shoulder too. I saw her. Couldn't you see her?
(Later, when they were sitting down by the well, the girl suddenly kneels down)
Grandma: What are you doing?
Girl: Just listening to Mary talking. (Points upwards)

There was also a girl in my school who went to Lourdes purely from curiosity. She was, before she went, a promiscuous agnostic. When she went to the grotto, she suddenly fell to her knees and started reciting the rosary. She had never prayed the rosary before. She didn't know how. She said the words just suddenly came to her. She is now a Catholic.

johnnydigit
Posted

[quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1289509' date='Jun 6 2007, 12:03 PM']Bumped
This little girl who goes to my Chruch went on a pilgrimage to Lourdes with her grandmother. She says she saw Mary in the grotto and Mary touched her. I believe her because:
1) I know her and I don't think she would lie about this.
2) When she told her grandma about it, she didn't act like it was anything unusual. The conversation (I am told) went like this:
(They had just come out of the grotto at this point
Grandma: Did you like the grotto?
Girl: Yes. I thought it was lovely how Mary put her hand on everyone's shoulder.
Grandma: (Sceptically) You felt someone's hand on your shoulder?
Girl: She had her hand on your shoulder too. I saw her. Couldn't you see her?
(Later, when they were sitting down by the well, the girl suddenly kneels down)
Grandma: What are you doing?
Girl: Just listening to Mary talking. (Points upwards)[/quote]

aww how adorable. aren't there usually a ton of people? so i guess she walked around to everyone?

i like stories and visions, because they let my imagination run wild during prayer and my faith stronger.

[quote name='farglefeezlebut' post='1289509' date='Jun 6 2007, 12:03 PM']There was also a girl in my school who went to Lourdes purely from curiosity. She was, before she went, a promiscuous agnostic. When she went to the grotto, she suddenly fell to her knees and started reciting the rosary. She had never prayed the rosary before. She didn't know how. She said the words just suddenly came to her. She is now a Catholic.[/quote]

a friend of a friend in bible study, who attended a few times and even went to one of our retreats, started to get interested in Catholicism mainly because his Catholic fiance encouraged him. well during one of the long periods when he didn't come around, i was told that he woke up one day and recited the Hail Mary. both said there is no ordinary reason for this. he is no longer with his fiance, and perhaps has surpassed her in her faith. he still doesn't know much about the faith.

you should listen to Father Corapi's testimony. he showed up to an oral examination, ready to give a 45 minute lecture on a random theology question. before he began, they told him they didn't want it in english, they wanted it in italian. he knew very little Italian, and wasn't going to take the Italian language course until the next following semester. he asked for a short break to collect himself. he prayed for the Blessed Mother's intercession. he came back in and tried his best. not only did he go through the entire lecture in italian, he ended up getting one of, if not the highest marks on the exam, even out of the italian students.

it's just wierd, but i believe them. do her Rosary, and you'll know..

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1287310' date='Jun 3 2007, 10:03 PM']More important than the apparition itself, though, is the focus people take away from it – are they focused on the apparition and the novelty of it, or do they evidence an increased focus on living a faithful life, living out the graces of the sacraments in their daily work and relationships? Cuz frankly, without there being actual life change, all the apparitions in the world mean nothing. If you’re healed at Lourdes but then can’t forgive your brother for breaking your favorite vase, what good is it? Same with Medjugorje or any of the apparitions. I could care less about someone seeing a dancing sun if they’re not evidencing a changed heart as a result.[/quote]

One of my best-loved spiritual books is [i]To Believe in Jesus[/i], written by Ruth Burrows, a Carmelite nun. In one chapter she asks, "Would anyone have noticed the simple holiness of Soeur Marie-Bernard of Nevers if she had not seen apparitions of the Blessed Virgin?"

Sr Ruth's point was that too many people involved in Lourdes thought that seeing Mary was enough to make you a saint, and in the resulting tidal wave of veneration Bernadette's real qualities were swept aside, out of the public view. I think there is a real danger of that happening anywhere. For me the real message of Lourdes is encapsulated in this dialogue:

[b]Teaching nun at Bernadette's school:[/b] Agh! You are too stupid to learn anything!
[b]Bernadette:[/b] At least I know how to love God.

I have a friend (mentioned a few times before on PM) who struggles with a cocktail of disabilities, including autism, auditory processing disorder, unusually severe dyslexia, and difficulties with speech. She is a very intelligent girl, but she often comes across as stupid. When she was exploring Catholicism (she is now in the process of converting formally) this exchange between Bernadette and the nun made her cry, as people have so often made similar judgements about her. She kept saying, "It's ter, it's ter. She saw Mary because it's ter." ("It's true, it's true. Mary chose her because its true.") Seeing how touched she was by the circumstances surrounding the apparitions deepened my faith in the love God has for us.

Edited by Cathoholic Anonymous
RezaMikhaeil
Posted

I don't see the intellect in denying the apparitions of St. Mary the Theotokos... she appeared in a Coptic Church in Egypt, that was witnessed by thousands upon thousands of people, including Muslims and wasn't denied by a single person that witnessed it.

[img]http://z.about.com/d/paranormal/1/0/T/K/mary_church_lg.jpg[/img]

My sister a few years back traveled to Iran and told me that in one of the water caves [Iran has magnificant water caves, if you ever get an opportunity to go see it, you should] there is a statue of St. Mary the Theotokos that the water carved out in the rocks, that appears to be an exact replica of the Icons that we see in churches but that it's so high up in the cave, there's no way that a human being could have done it.

Reza

Posted

I live now just a few hours from Medjugorje in Bosnia and am planning to visit. I have asked what the 'official' Opus Dei belief is regarding them and once I get a reply will post it here. However the comment about crass merchandising and commercialization is so true. I have been to many wonderfully spiritual sites only to be disappointed by the commercialisation there. Some were famous others smaller and off the beaten track. I know that in some cases local religious orders are responsible for the maintenance and upkeep and need to raise funds, however there are also many examples of exploitation. I have been to Bethlehem perhaps 15 times over the years and remember my first ever visit being shocked at the neon crosses giving it the appearance of Las Vegas rather than the birth place of our Lord. What most shocked me was that I waited and prayed between two tour groups going into the cave area and the church. Between the groups the monks came out, snuffed the recently bought candles, re-trimmed the wicks and sold them again! This to me was an abomination and something that I have never been able to accept as either ethical or necessary.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1290770' date='Jun 8 2007, 12:55 PM']I don't see the intellect in denying the apparitions of St. Mary the Theotokos... she appeared in a Coptic Church in Egypt, that was witnessed by thousands upon thousands of people, including Muslims and wasn't denied by a single person that witnessed it.[/quote]

I'm familiar with the apparition that you speak of, Reza. It was an amazing one. There were Muslims running down the street towards her, crying out, "Maryam, Maryam!" Everyone knew who she was, without any explanation. There were quite a few conversions on that day.

But Medjugorje smells fishy to me. We are not obligated to believe in [i]all[/i] the apparitions of Mary that are reported by everyone who claims to see her. Plenty of people fabricate apparition stories for attention or other reasons, and not all genuine apparitions are heavenly. We must exercise our judgement and caution when dealing with unapproved apparitions.

Chiquitunga
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Rod' post='1290992' date='Jun 8 2007, 12:33 PM']I live now just a few hours from Medjugorje in Bosnia and am planning to visit. I have asked what the 'official' Opus Dei belief is regarding them and once I get a reply will post it here.[/quote]
I know some people from Opus Dei and have been on a few of their retreats, which are always very nice. We have Circle meetings sometimes at our house too.

They pretty much do not recommend any private revelations that have not been completely approved yet, which is great, no problem. They're a very solid orthodox organization. I don't know if they would have their own official position on it though. I think their official position would simply be that of the Church's. I do know a very nice super-numerary mother that loves Medjugorje and believes it is true.

Here's the [url="http://www.medjugorje.org/newletter.htm"]lastest letter from Rome[/url] on Medjugorje from 1998. Currently there is a [url="http://www.medjugorje.org/newcommission01.htm"]new Church Commission[/url] on it also.

Yes, in Medjugorje there are many shops on the couple roads near the front of St. James Church. But if you go off into the fields behind the Church and climb apparition hill and especially Mt. Krizevac, it is different. I climbed Mt. Krizevac in the middle of the night one of the last nights I was there, with some pilgrims from Ireland, and it was incredible! The Irish do things like that a lot! ^_^

Another of my favorite memories there was doing the all-night shift for a sister at the Oasis of Peace Perpetual Adoration Chapel. It's a great place to go there. It's right near apparition hill. Here are some pictures, [url="http://peacepilgrim.fotopages.com/?entry=188235"]here[/url] & [url="http://www.medjugorje.ws/en/pictures/medjugorje-photos/september-feasts-photographs/"]here[/url].

Edited by Margaret Clare
Chiquitunga
Posted (edited)

The appearances of Our Lady at Zeitun are incredible!

[img]http://biblia.com/apparitions/virgin-zeitun-16gg.jpg[/img]

I read about them first in this book [url="http://www.amazon.com/God-Sent-History-Accredited-Apparitions-Mary/dp/0824518438"]God-Sent : A History of the Accredited Apparitions of Mary[/url]

The author has written something on many of both the approved and "accredited" (of our time) apparitions beginning with the first appearance of Our Lady to St. James in Spain, while she was still alive actually (which was rather bilocation than an apparition) - [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basilica_of_Our_Lady_of_the_Pillar"]Our Lady of the Pilar[/url]

It's quite an in depth study, that book. There's an interview by the author with (then) Cardinal Ratzinger on the subject of Marian apparitions also.

Here's an interesting article on some of the earliest known apparitions of the Blessed Virgin - [url="http://www.tfp.org/TFPForum/ourladythequeen/the_first_aparritions_of_our_lady.htm"]The First Apparitions of Our Lady[/url]


And a couple other ones I recently heard of, [url="http://www.ourladyofsiluva.com/our_lady/"]Our Lady of Siluva[/url] in Lithuania & [url="http://www.angelfire.com/nv2/stbruno/laus/home.html"]Our Lady of Laus[/url] in France

[img]http://www.draugaipertikejima.com/siluva2.jpg[/img]

Vision of Our Lady, with child and Calvinist pastor

Edited by Margaret Clare

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...