Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Motu Proprio "signed And Imminent"


Recommended Posts

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[url="http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2007/06/for-record-italian-papal-news-website.html"]http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2007/06/f...ws-website.html[/url]

[quote]The Papal "Motu Proprio" for the liberalization of the Latin Mass according to the Tridentine rite of Saint Pius V is ready, is about to be translated into several languages and will be published right before the departure of Benedict XVI for the summer vacation. [Rorate note: The Pope's early vacation this summer will be spent in a small villa owned by the Diocese of Treviso, in the tiny hamlet of Lorenzago di Cadore, Province of Belluno, in the Veneto region, in the July 9-27 period.]The text has already been signed by the Pontiff, who has even written a long exaplanatory letter, of a theological character, "addressed to all the Bishops of the world", as it can be read in its introduction, "so that they may receive this document with serenity and patience".

The Pope thus asks the Bishops, the clergy, and the faithful for a serene mood in the acceptance of the "Motu Proprio", which will be presented in a Press Conference by Cardinals Francis Arinze, Dario Castrillon Hoyos, and Julian Herranz.

The delay in the publication of the document seems to be related to strong oppositions from some sectors of the clergy (especially from the French Episcopal Conference).

Monsignor Nicola Bux (a personal friend of the Pope), a theologian and collaborator of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, declares: "You may write calmly [that] Pope Benedict XVI loves agreement and collaboration, and does not wish to decide everything on his own, which is why he has heard several and repeated opinions, but the Motu Proprio for the liberalization of the Latin Mass has been signed and its publication is imminent, I would say it is a matter of days."

The Tridentine Mass is completely celebrated in Latin, with the exception of a few words and sentences in Ancient Greek and in Hebrew; it is interspersed with long periods of silence, to allow the faithful to adequately meditate on the greatness of the Eucharistic mystery which they are called to attend. The faithful follow the liturgy reading the bilingual handmissal or leaflet, which carry, side by side with the Latin text, the integral translation of the actions in Italian or in the other national languages.

It is not only the use of the ecclesiastical and universal language ("Catholic" means precisely universal) which represents the sole standing difference between the Tridentine Mass and the modern one. The priest, differently than what takes place in the course of the new rite, turns his back to the faithful, as he celebrates turned to the tabernacle and the altar which constitutes the representation of Calvary; the image is that of the celebrant who guides the people.

The Gospel is always read at the right side of the altar, while the Epistle on the left side (from whence the terms "in cornu evangelii" and "in cornu epistulae"). Communion - only the Host [sic] for the faithful - is received while kneeling and in the mouth.

[The faithful] mostly kneel during Mass, because [they] believe in its great mystery, because [they] believe in the real presence of Jesus in body, blood, soul, and divinity, because kneeling is the posture of the humble sinner who begs for God's mercy.

The limitation of the Tridentine Mass by the Second Vatican Council [sic] has been the main cause of the schism between the followers of French bishop Marcel Lefebvre and the Church of Rome. A painful schism [i.e. "schismatic group"], which arose in the Pontificate of John Paul II, which, with the "Motu Proprio" of Benedict XVI, seems destined to return definitively.[/quote]

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I LOVE YOU POPE BENEDICT XVI!!!! :twothumbsup:

Posted

Rest assured folks...it's coming :D:

geetarplayer
Posted

I heard it will be released on July 14 to corespond with the release of Pope St. Pius V's encyclical, Quo Primum in 1570. :idontknow:

-Mark

Posted

That was one theory on when it would be released, apparently the opposition from bishops is making the Pope delay.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Well again, I cant wait!

Theologian in Training
Posted

I just wish they would stop saying the priest will have "his back to the people" rather, "he will be in front of the people leading them in prayer." Also, I know he wishes for a "serene mood" but I don't think that will be the case. I know many many people, faithful and clergy alike, who feel as though it might be a bad idea. We shall wait and see, and let the Holy Spirit have the final say.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1295950' date='Jun 15 2007, 10:34 AM']I just wish they would stop saying the priest will have "his back to the people" rather, "he will be in front of the people leading them in prayer." Also, I know he wishes for a "serene mood" but I don't think that will be the case. I know many many people, faithful and clergy alike, who feel as though it might be a bad idea. We shall wait and see, and let the Holy Spirit have the final say.[/quote]
Yeah, I'd love to be able to go to Tridentine Mass, but I think it could cause a lot of difficulties.

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Raphael' post='1295952' date='Jun 15 2007, 12:39 PM']Yeah, I'd love to be able to go to Tridentine Mass, but I think it could cause a lot of difficulties.[/quote]

As one bishop told me, if the Pope does this, the clergy and the faithful may see and think that the bishops really do not have all the power, which is a double edged sword. It is good with regard to those abusing the power, but what of those who need the power in order to get a diocese in shape? If they show that, essentially, they do not have any power, what is to prevent even more people to ignore and disobey their bishops?

A good example is the article floating around here on Frances Kissling

Edited by Theologian in Training
Posted

The problem I hear is that it doesn't ensure proper execution of the ancient liturgy. Some priests will take there liberty with the ancient liturgy and change things as they please. I think this is part of the plan to deal with the liturgical crisis by creating some form of synthesis between the ancient rite and the new one.

Posted

interesting thought mortify interesting thought.

Church Punk
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1295960' date='Jun 15 2007, 12:48 PM']As one bishop told me, if the Pope does this, the clergy and the faithful may see and think that the bishops really do not have all the power, which is a double edged sword. It is good with regard to those abusing the power, but what of those who need the power in order to get a diocese in shape? If they show that, essentially, they do not have any power, what is to prevent even more people to ignore and disobey their bishops?

A good example is the article floating around here on Frances Kissling[/quote]

But the bishops dont have "ALL" the power in the first place. If they are using the power to shape up their diocese to bring it in-line with Rome, wouldnt the Pope be all for what they stand for and what they are doing?

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Church Punk' post='1296010' date='Jun 15 2007, 02:10 PM']But the bishops dont have "ALL" the power in the first place. If they are using the power to shape up their diocese to bring it in-line with Rome, wouldnt the Pope be all for what they stand for and what they are doing?[/quote]

But think of those bishops who have a hard time already. this does not help them. And, what you are saying is not exactly the same thing. The fear is if jurisdiction is taken away at the local level, because remember, it used to be the bishop who granted permission, then what happens when the issue is not about Latin Mass, but about something else, something that the bishop excommunicates for, how seriously will those excommunicated take that? Case in point, that article about Frances Kissling.

I am not saying that this is set in stone and this is what will happen, but what was expressed to me by my bishop (very orthodox, many know him) to a major concern, especially given everything he has done for the diocese to pull it out of its many liturgical abuses and outright disobedience to the bishop. Just one major example is that this diocese used to be notorious for General Absolution.

God Bless

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1295967' date='Jun 15 2007, 12:03 PM']The problem I hear is that it doesn't ensure proper execution of the ancient liturgy. Some priests will take there liberty with the ancient liturgy and change things as they please. I think this is part of the plan to deal with the liturgical crisis by creating some form of synthesis between the ancient rite and the new one.[/quote]

Here is what my friend said at another forum:

I don't think this Moto Proprio is going to solve any of the liturgical problems in the Church. I think it will only exacerbate the problems, with conservatives leaving the new Mass for the old Mass, so that liberals prevail over the new Mass, increasing their errors.

It would be best to have one form of the Mass, in every language on earth. But we are headed for a time of schism and confusion in the Church.


I thought that was interesting

Posted

JMJ
6/15 - Tenth Friday

Cardinal George expressed his own concerns about the de-restriction of the classical liturgy at Mundelein last fall. The only one he really had was basically what Theologian in Training said - that jurisdiction proper to him was being taken away from him.

All of these concerns would be legitimate, I think, if the Holy Father says, "Basically, here's the deal - this is a universal indult, a complete and total de-restriction, and if you don't like it, tough snot."

However, it would be an entirely different scenario if he basically says, "Here's what's up - the classical liturgy was never formally abolished, and those rules which restricted a priest from saying it are abrogated." Now it looks like the priest has always had the right to say the classical liturgy, but was prevented by the Pope, not his bishop. Thus, no real jurisdictional power is being taken away from the bishops. In fact, the Pope is curtailing his own authority on the matter.

This second scenario makes the most sense in my mind, if this is going to be an olive branch to the SSPX (and like-minded groups). Schismatics would not be pleased with a universal indult; they would want the Vatican to say that every priest has the right to say the classical liturgy.

That's all I got.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1296099' date='Jun 15 2007, 02:07 PM']Here is what my friend said at another forum:

I don't think this Moto Proprio is going to solve any of the liturgical problems in the Church. I think it will only exacerbate the problems, with conservatives leaving the new Mass for the old Mass, so that liberals prevail over the new Mass, increasing their errors.

It would be best to have one form of the Mass, in every language on earth. But we are headed for a time of schism and confusion in the Church.
I thought that was interesting[/quote]
From my perspective we are already in a time of schism and confusion in the Church—and I would dare say apostasy. I see the traditional Roman liturgy as a most laudable and fitting end-in-itself, apart from base considerations of utility or manipulation. It is to me this latter genus of predilection which is at the heart of our dejected and depraved ethos.

I just hope that the Latin Mass hits hard in my own town. :yahoo:


:bigpray:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1295960' date='Jun 15 2007, 11:48 AM']As one bishop told me, if the Pope does this, the clergy and the faithful may see and think that the bishops really do not have all the power, which is a double edged sword. It is good with regard to those abusing the power, but what of those who need the power in order to get a diocese in shape? If they show that, essentially, they do not have any power, what is to prevent even more people to ignore and disobey their bishops?

A good example is the article floating around here on Frances Kissling[/quote]

Yeah, but bishops who are trying to get the diocese in shape are simply trying to get their flock to see that the [i]Pope is in charge[/i]. So it seems to me that it would be good all-around. It doesn't seem like it would be easy for people who are opposed to their orthodox bishops to use the pope in their defense. Or maybe I'm misunderstanding what you're saying.

Edited by Totus Tuus
Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1296214' date='Jun 15 2007, 05:57 PM']Yeah, but bishops who are trying to get the diocese in shape are simply trying to get their flock to see that the [i]Pope is in charge[/i]. So it seems to me that it would be good all-around. It doesn't seem like it would be easy for people who are opposed to their orthodox bishops to use the pope in their defense. Or maybe I'm misunderstanding what you're saying.[/quote]

I know I am not being clear, but I cannot think of another way of explaining it. It is not that these bishops don't want them to see that the Pope is in charge, it is that they fear if their power is seen as undermined, it doesn't matter if they point to the Pope, Jesus, or anyone for that matter, because their authority will mean nothing, or at least seen to mean nothing. The bishops need the authority for someone to listen to them when they point in any direction, and if they don't have it or seen to have it, even less will listen. I am merely reiterating a concern by a bishop, like I said, I don't know what will happen...pray the Holy Spirit is guiding this one with a heavy hand...

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Nice. It hasn't even been released to the public and already people know and are sharing with everyone the ins and outs of what's wrong with it. :huh:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...