Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Motu Proprio "signed And Imminent"


Recommended Posts

Posted

Problems with an Universal Indult,
Fr. Ripperger FSSP

[url="http://www.sensustraditionis.org/multimedia.html"]http://www.sensustraditionis.org/multimedia.html[/url]
Under "Sermons," section #1, "universal indult" (audio file)

Posted

[quote]Kafka writes:
Here is what my friend said at another forum:

I don't think this Moto Proprio is going to solve any of the liturgical problems in the Church. I think it will only exacerbate the problems, with conservatives leaving the new Mass for the old Mass, so that liberals prevail over the new Mass, increasing their errors.[/quote]That could very well be the case, but only for the short term. Anyone who expects the Motu Proprio to immediately solve all of the liturgical problems is not being realistic. I would have to agree with mortify who stated:
[quote]I think this is part of the plan to deal with the liturgical crisis by creating some form of synthesis between the ancient rite and the new one.[/quote]
Bingo!!!

It should also be noted that all reports seem to suggest that the Pope has done his best to calm the fears of the many Bishops who oppose the MP. Perhaps if the Vatican was this cautious when they implemented the New Mass, we wouldn't be faced with the unfortunate liturgical situation that we find ourselves in today.

[quote]It would be best to have one form of the Mass, in every language on earth. But we are headed for a time of schism and confusion in the Church.[/quote]

Seeing as some 95% of Catholics in the United States do not follow Church teaching on contraception, and judging by the abhorrent state of the Church in the rest of the Western World, I'd say that you're friend is behind the times. We're already in a time of schism and confusion.

Posted

[quote name='SJP' post='1296454' date='Jun 16 2007, 02:18 AM']Seeing as some 95% of Catholics in the United States do not follow Church teaching on contraception, and judging by the abhorrent state of the Church in the rest of the Western World, I'd say that you're friend is behind the times. We're already in a time of schism and confusion.[/quote]


True but I dont think it has officially begun. He is referring to the Great Schism an actual prophetic event which will occur in the future. I think the seeds for it are well planted.

Posted

But isn't the Pope just giving permission for those churches that wish to participate in the saying of Latin Mass? That would mean those that do not want to wouldn't have to, right?

Posted (edited)

I haven't read over all this in detail, but I'll just say that I'm a bit surprised at all the negativity about this on here, particulary from traditionally-minded people.

Personally, I think a universal indult would be a good thing. It wouldn't be a magic solution to all the Church's problems, but it would provide opportunities for a a powerful and beautiful liturgy for those that desire it. And it's not like anybody would be forced to attend a Trindentine Mass.
I think this could be a step towards restoring reverence to the liturgy, particularly where all people know of the mass is hippy-dippy silliness.

Edited by Socrates
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1296994' date='Jun 16 2007, 08:01 PM']I haven't read over all this in detail, but I'll just say that I'm a bit surprised at all the negativity about this on here, particulary from traditionally-minded people.

Personally, I think a universal indult would be a good thing. It wouldn't be a magic solution to all the Church's problems, but it would provide opportunities for a a powerful and beautiful liturgy for those that desire it. And it's not like anybody would be forced to attend a Trindentine Mass.
I think this could be a step towards restoring reverence to the liturgy, particularly where all people know of the mass is hippy-dippy silliness.[/quote]
Amen Socrates. :smokey:

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='1295773' date='Jun 14 2007, 11:49 PM'][url="http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2007/06/for-record-italian-papal-news-website.html"]http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2007/06/f...ws-website.html[/url][/quote]
:sign: :D: :topsy: :lol_roll:
:clap: :sign: :bigclap: :biglol:

Posted (edited)

Pray that this is true!

Edited by SJP
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1296994' date='Jun 16 2007, 10:01 PM']I haven't read over all this in detail, but I'll just say that I'm a bit surprised at all the negativity about this on here, particulary from traditionally-minded people.

Personally, I think a universal indult would be a good thing. It wouldn't be a magic solution to all the Church's problems, but it would provide opportunities for a a powerful and beautiful liturgy for those that desire it. And it's not like anybody would be forced to attend a Trindentine Mass.
I think this could be a step towards restoring reverence to the liturgy, particularly where all people know of the mass is hippy-dippy silliness.[/quote]

I think you really hit home in the last sentence, Socrates. I have a music teacher who converted from the Anglican faith, and thinks (despite the fact I tell him otherwise) that the Church "threw out" the traditional music in Vatican II. If this mass is ever said in my diocese, I'm taking this teacher to it. I'm showing him it's not just hippy guitar with G A and D through the whole thing. As for the other comments about causing problems: what problems DON'T we have? Seriously, The Holy Spirit is dealing with the problems. What I see now is simply pruning. Prune prune prune!

Laudate_Dominum
Posted
:yahoo:

TRADITIONAL MASS!!!
Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1297023' date='Jun 16 2007, 08:42 PM']I think you really hit home in the last sentence, Socrates. I have a music teacher who converted from the Anglican faith, and thinks (despite the fact I tell him otherwise) that the Church "threw out" the traditional music in Vatican II. If this mass is ever said in my diocese, I'm taking this teacher to it. I'm showing him it's not just hippy guitar with G A and D through the whole thing. As for the other comments about causing problems: what problems DON'T we have? Seriously, The Holy Spirit is dealing with the problems. What I see now is simply pruning. Prune prune prune![/quote]

so the Church can grow, grow, grow more musicians who can play or direct "traditional" music ???

Posted

I'm going through training in music. I'm getting into "traditional" music more and more. Can I not be one of them? Are you dissing my position?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...