Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Cashiering at WallyWorld, AKA Walmart  

34 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been working at Walmart as a cashier for a few weeks.

Walmart not only sells condoms, but also has a pharmacy where I believe birth control pills can be proscribed.

As I understand it, ringing up condoms when someone is purchasing them could be classified as remote material cooperation in evil, and therefore is permissible if absolutely necessary. But you know me, I'm an idealist, and I'm looking at myself asking the question "are you going to starve if you're not a cashier at Walmart?"... and it seems to me the answer to that question defines the answer to the question of whether this is an absolutely necessary remote material cooperation in evil for me. Now I know some people wouldn't hold themselves to such a high ideal, but... it is my right to do so is it not?

I do not trust my inclination to quit, though... seems to me it's motivated not by moral outrage, but by sloth, and the moral outrage is just a manifested excuse. of course, if I just got another job it wouldn't be true sloth I guess. Anyway, it seems to me that my best course of action would be to switch departments... I worked a couple times at the produce department and they liked my work ethic... plus it pays a little more anyway... so what should I do?

1) Quit, citing as a reason a moral conflict with the sale of contraceptives.
2) Request immediate transfer of departments because of moral conflict.
3) Request transfer as soon as possible.
4) Stay as a cashier and stop being such an idealistic fool, it will be your own undoing.
5) Stay as a cashier, but refuse to ring up anyone who brings condoms up to be purchased. Let a big scene be caused, and accept whatever consequences come out of it.

KnightofChrist
Posted

1) DONT Quit, cite a moral conflict with the sale of contraceptives.
2) or Request immediate transfer of departments because of moral conflict.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1303023' date='Jun 27 2007, 02:56 AM']1) DONT Quit, cite a moral conflict with the sale of contraceptives.
2) or Request immediate transfer of departments because of moral conflict.[/quote]

I agree. This is the best scenario and if you have a good store manager, they will probably understand. Don't go in there raving, self-righteous or emotional. Be sincere in expressing your discomfort, and avoid threats and ultimatums at all costs. Give your boss the best chance he/she needs to help you.

I do believe, though, that Wal-Mart is the only pharmacy that has listened to our Catholic concerns about abortifacient contraceptives (such as the pill) and has subsequently refused to provide them to their customers. The condoms may be your only real concern.

I would also say that sloth is probably a greater sin to commit here. That would be something you directly engage in as opposed to ignorantly support from an arm's length. And you will find these conflicts occur much more often as you progress in your future career. Imagine how often a good Catholic politician has to work toward choosing the lesser of two evils. I once had to provide a cashier's check as a bank teller to a woman who I was sure was going to use it to pay for an abortion. I hated to do that job, but I had no better choice given my ignorance of her situation. She could've been buying a used car from the abortion clinic, for all I know. But I did know that I would have been fired for refusing her service, and my wife and I would have suffered greatly. You may be faced with the same ignorant position with regard to selling condoms. As strange as it may seem, soldiers use condoms to waterproof loose articles they carry during military training. A married Catholic couple, one of whom may have an outbreak of herpes, may use a condom to share intimacy without going too far. Some women are also prescribed birth control pills to control a bleeding condition of the uterus (called endometriosis), which the Church allows as long as the woman refrains from sexual activity or is married and is at a part of her Natural Family Planning Cycle where she knows she is not capable of conceiving (and subsequently contracepting and/or aborting). You would truly have to invade someone's privacy before you really knew why they were purchashing the product. You may simply have to do the job until you can find one better.

But do pray on it. God will give you your answer.

Posted

You're right -- Wal Mart does sell the pill at the pharmacy as well as condoms. I always wondered how someone with Catholic moral standards could work there in peace, because that would always be nagging on your conscience. Personally I hate wal-mart so I'd go looking for another job in the first place. However, I don't think it'd be immoral for you to stay at Wal-Mart. I voted that you should request an immediate change of departments (if you don't want to leave the store altogether) and definitely tell them exactly why you're requesting it.

Just my .02. Definitely be assured of our prayers, o.k.? ^_^ :sign:

Posted

I would certainly not go in there all self-righteous and emotional, be assured. though the thought of causing a scene has a certain appeal to me... if I were to cause a scene it'd so be by refusing to ring someone up. haha, but then I'd probably make it on the news and they'd be comparing me to the muslims who refused to ring up pork... <_< haha :ninja:

Walmart did, at least for a while, hold out against selling the morning after pill. I think I heard somewhere that they had caved, though :(... but the regular ol' abortificient pill they definitely sell. Of course, stuff purchased from the pharmacy I never know what it is because it's packaged in a pharmacy bag and doesn't tell you what it is. but condoms... yeah... and there's not even an age restriction or anything. there's an age restriction on AIRSOFT GUNS but not on CONDOMS. <_< go figure. some kid, had to be like 14 or something, bought a pack in my line and there was nothing I could do about it :annoyed:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Is it your business who buys condoms?
Is it really your business who is on the pill?

Are you called to judge?

You are a cashier in a store, you are not the moral overseer of the customers lives. You are not committing a sin by doing your job. You are possibly committing a sin by judging people while doing it.

If you don't need the money -simply quit.

Posted

That's another thought. But am I not, as a chain in the link of the sale, a remote material cooperator in evil (which would be justifiable only if necessary)?

I'm not judging them so much... I wouldn't even really cause a scene by refusing to ring up the sale or anything... just musing to myself about such things. I'm moreso just asking myself if I really must be a part of this, and the answer I seem to be getting from my conscience is no, I don't need to have this particular job (I can switch departments or find another job), and because of this and the fact that my informed conscience tells me this is remote material cooperation in evil, I don't think I should remain there.

I'm actually leaning more towards option 3, just not make any big deal about it but switch to produce.

Do you disagree with my classification of this act as remote material cooperation in evil? It's material cooperation in objective evil, I make no pretense to judge the personal actions of the customers, I am just not sure I can be a part of their purchase if they intend to purchase things with obviously evil ends.

How about this question: could I morally be a cashier in a porn shop? Would it be too judgmental of the customers of me to decide not to be a cashier in a porn shop? Or to bring the example more in line: what if walmart sold pornography? It's basically the equivalent, it's a thing that expresses clear intent towards immoral use, there is no real moral use (except in some medical circumstances when holes are poked into them, but I'd assume in such situations they get the stuff from their doctors) for either, can I be a cooperator in either one of them?

Posted

You must not need the money and must be an extremely talented pereson to quit because something you deal with ON YOUR JOB distrubs you. As a nurse I deal every day with people, medications, treatments that I feel are not of something I may do....but I can not judge another. I cannot withhold a medication because I may feel it is not with keeping of MY faith. You cannot judge the person buying it. They are not asking you to use it, they are.
As an adult, in many job situations, you will be faced with moral situations. If it is truly against your principle's, then yes, you quit. I will not assist at abortions. Do i give out the pill, sure. I have to. Cause I need to work. Because my patients come first, and if it is their belief, then I do what is needed to be done.
In each job you work at, believe me, something can always come up. Try saying a prayer for the person(to yourself, that is) if it will make you feel better. Do not UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTACES, get on your soapbox at work and defame or degrate your customers..I would fire you on the spot. And your record stays with you, so be careful.

Posted

As I said, it is remote material cooperation in evil. It is permissible when necessary. As I am currently young, without many responsibilities, and without absolute need of the money, I may have the luxury of saying it is not necessary for me.

But it's not just "ah, let them do what they want it's none of my business", it would clearly be remote material cooperation with evil. As it is on your job. It is perfectly permissible for you to do it, as it'd be perfectly permissible for someone to be a cashier. but what I mean is: these things are not things that people who follow our faith should not do; these are things which are inherent evils. thinking someone should not use them is not thinking that they should follow our faith, but merely thinking they should follow the natural law. yeah, the natural law's been quite distorted, but that's no reason not to expect people to follow it.

bleh to whether it's "on my record" or not. But anyway, I seriously was not going to get on any type of soap box... aren't I permitted at least a little bit of musing at what it'd be like to have idiotic zealous courage? In real life I'm nothing life that, I'm just musing. But there'd be worse things than such a firing. Oh, but anyway, Walmart is a ridiculous beaurocracy and I'd probably not even get fired for that... haha, I'd get a "verbal coaching". bleh, you're right that they should just fire someone who did that, but they seriously won't fire you very easily.

What would be the difference if there were pornographic material available at Walmart? Would I not be in the exact same situation?

Posted

It is wonderful to have high ideals, but they are yours. They may not be the same as mine.
You are very young obvioiusly, and you are right, you don't need this job. Then quit it.
One day you will realize the world does not do what you want. You are a small cog among many cogs. You do your best.
And your work record is very important.
Do what you want, but you run away, you might just spend alot of your life legislating to others and moralizing. And guess what, your message is lost. They arent' listening. Make a difference in others lives and they listen.
As to porn, my word it is everywhere. It is on the very internet you are utilizing. Just because it is there does not mean you have to read it. Again, what business is it of yours that someone else is reading it? You are very judgemental.

Posted

It seems kinda silly, imo, to quit for that reason. It's Wal-Mart. You knew,(or should have known) that they sell condoms before you started working there. And you knew (or should have known) that as an employee of Wal-Mart, especially a cashier, that you'd be asked to handle them and sell them to customers. Wal-Mart is not hiding the fact that they sell condoms. They're right in the health and beauty section, in plain sight where anyone can see or pick them up for purchase.

Since you should have known beforehand, it seems disingenuous to suddenly "get convicted" about it and have to quit. That would peeve me greatly as a manager ... I would think this Catholic kid just couldn't be honest about his real reasons for wanting to quit and had to come up with a lame-o "moral dilemma."

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1303077' date='Jun 27 2007, 10:31 AM']It seems kinda silly, imo, to quit for that reason. It's Wal-Mart. You knew,(or should have known) that they sell condoms before you started working there. And you knew (or should have known) that as an employee of Wal-Mart, especially a cashier, that you'd be asked to handle them and sell them to customers. Wal-Mart is not hiding the fact that they sell condoms. They're right in the health and beauty section, in plain sight where anyone can see or pick them up for purchase.

Since you should have known beforehand, it seems disingenuous to suddenly "get convicted" about it and have to quit. That would peeve me greatly as a manager ... I would think this Catholic kid just couldn't be honest about his real reasons for wanting to quit and had to come up with a lame-o "moral dilemma."[/quote]

You know, that is a very good point. And who knows, maybe the people buying condoms are trying to make a dress ;)

[mod]Picture edited for prudential reasons. --Era Might[/mod]

But, in all seriousness, why wasn't this a factor before? Why has it all of a sudden become a factor? And, if it truly bothers your conscience then you do have an obligation to do something. However, I would point out, that unless you plan on being a cashier that sells clothes, food or something else, then all of the places you go..Wal-Mart, Target, Stop & Shop etc. are all going to cause this dilemma for you. In all honesty, when I was younger, and before I was a priest, I worked at Target as a cashier and cannot once remember ringing up condoms, magazines deemed pornographic, or anything else that would have caused a moral dilemma for me. Just be happy you are not working at a photo lab, because then you have some real dilemmas to face...In hindsight, going from cashiering to photo lab probably not the smartest, but hey, it was a job.

God Bless

rollingcatholic
Posted

Wal-Mart as a corporation is inherently evil. They are anti-family, and their employment practices and donations show this. They are also anti-life. They engage in predatory business practices, and have deceptive advertising.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1303060' date='Jun 27 2007, 09:50 AM']That's another thought. But am I not, as a chain in the link of the sale, a remote material cooperator in evil (which would be justifiable only if necessary)?

I'm not judging them so much... I wouldn't even really cause a scene by refusing to ring up the sale or anything... just musing to myself about such things. I'm moreso just asking myself if I really must be a part of this, and the answer I seem to be getting from my conscience is no, I don't need to have this particular job (I can switch departments or find another job), and because of this and the fact that my informed conscience tells me this is remote material cooperation in evil, I don't think I should remain there.

I'm actually leaning more towards option 3, just not make any big deal about it but switch to produce.

Do you disagree with my classification of this act as remote material cooperation in evil? It's material cooperation in objective evil, I make no pretense to judge the personal actions of the customers, I am just not sure I can be a part of their purchase if they intend to purchase things with obviously evil ends.

How about this question: could I morally be a cashier in a porn shop? Would it be too judgmental of the customers of me to decide not to be a cashier in a porn shop? Or to bring the example more in line: what if walmart sold pornography? It's basically the equivalent, it's a thing that expresses clear intent towards immoral use, there is no real moral use (except in some medical circumstances when holes are poked into them, but I'd assume in such situations they get the stuff from their doctors) for either, can I be a cooperator in either one of them?[/quote]

You have no clue why someone is on the pill, it may be a perfectly legitimate reason. You are not remotely cooperating in evil, you are judging people which is directly cooperating with evil.

Porn is not the equivalent of the pill or condoms, porn is objectively evil.

If you don't like the job, just quit. Its still a luxury for you.

When you grow up you will find out life is not so black and white, and most people do what they have to get by to take care of themselves and their families.

Posted

Above all we have an obligation to listen to our well-formed consciences. Therefore, if your consciences is bugging you and you THINK you are sinning, but continue anyway that IS sinful.

The pill is not always used for contraceptive means. It is now, often, prescribed for medical conditions and the use of which in such situations is not immoral. (However, I still hate the birth control pill because it is highly dangerous and apparently the synthetic hormones get into our drinking water. )

Condoms...now I may be young and naive, but I can't really see a good use for them? You can always make a dress out of duct tape ;) One person refusing to sell condoms may seem silly and lacking in impact, but if everyone refused then perhaps they would no longer be sold. Idealistic, yes, but is that always such a bad thing?

It is curious that you did not know the company sold contraceptives before working there, but I can also understand if you became convicted afterwards. I would suggest requesting a transfer to a different department. People can buy contraceptives if they want to, but you dont have to be the person selling it to them.


Unlike most of the other repliers, I do not think you are being judgemental, at least not in a bad way. It's like working at a health care center that provides abortions....you aren't judging the people having abortions by quitting, you are merely resisting the participation in a company that provides something grossly immoral.

Posted

Wow. There are a lot of opinions here.

I don't think you are being judgemental, but I do think you were onto something when you mentioned the alternative reason for wanting to quit. It sure lends to a reasonably simple solution when you bring in this scenerio.

How often do you sell condoms? Is it something that happens a lot there? Or is it fairly rare?

I would suggest that you a. switch departments if you still want to work there, or b. talk to your manager and let him know that you will not distribute condoms due to moral reasons. Pharmacists have the option not to distribute the pill etc. why couldn't cashiers have the option not to ring in condoms.

I think you are making a mountain out of a mole hill, but that is your mountain to make ;)

One final idea, why not get a fun job like being a server in a restaurant? Better money, and great socializing... :)

There must be some other job out there that won't keep you awake at night.

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1303025' date='Jun 27 2007, 03:23 AM']I agree. This is the best scenario and if you have a good store manager, they will probably understand. Don't go in there raving, self-righteous or emotional. Be sincere in expressing your discomfort, and avoid threats and ultimatums at all costs. Give your boss the best chance he/she needs to help you.

I do believe, though, that Wal-Mart is the only pharmacy that has listened to our Catholic concerns about abortifacient contraceptives (such as the pill) and has subsequently refused to provide them to their customers. The condoms may be your only real concern.

I would also say that sloth is probably a greater sin to commit here. That would be something you directly engage in as opposed to ignorantly support from an arm's length. And you will find these conflicts occur much more often as you progress in your future career. Imagine how often a good Catholic politician has to work toward choosing the lesser of two evils. I once had to provide a cashier's check as a bank teller to a woman who I was sure was going to use it to pay for an abortion. I hated to do that job, but I had no better choice given my ignorance of her situation. She could've been buying a used car from the abortion clinic, for all I know. But I did know that I would have been fired for refusing her service, and my wife and I would have suffered greatly. You may be faced with the same ignorant position with regard to selling condoms. As strange as it may seem, soldiers use condoms to waterproof loose articles they carry during military training. A married Catholic couple, one of whom may have an outbreak of herpes, may use a condom to share intimacy without going too far. Some women are also prescribed birth control pills to control a bleeding condition of the uterus (called endometriosis), which the Church allows as long as the woman refrains from sexual activity or is married and is at a part of her Natural Family Planning Cycle where she knows she is not capable of conceiving (and subsequently contracepting and/or aborting). You would truly have to invade someone's privacy before you really knew why they were purchashing the product. You may simply have to do the job until you can find one better.

But do pray on it. God will give you your answer.[/quote]


Please don't try to justify the use of condoms and other contraceptives. The fact of the matter is it poses such a moral dilemma and may cause those who are opposed to contraception to feel scrupulous in the sale of them. Sure, nobody knows for sure what the intended use is, but 9 out of 10 times you can guess.

I have been in the situation before. Talk to a supervisor and explain the situation. I did and was moved to a different department in the grocery store I worked at. You'll be surprised at how understanding some managers can be. I'll keep you in my prayers.

Anthony

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1303222' date='Jun 27 2007, 12:56 PM']Wow. There are a lot of opinions here.

I don't think you are being judgemental, but I do think you were onto something when you mentioned the alternative reason for wanting to quit. It sure lends to a reasonably simple solution when you bring in this scenerio.

How often do you sell condoms? Is it something that happens a lot there? Or is it fairly rare?

I would suggest that you a. switch departments if you still want to work there, or b. talk to your manager and let him know that you will not distribute condoms due to moral reasons. Pharmacists have the option not to distribute the pill etc. why couldn't cashiers have the option not to ring in condoms.

I think you are making a mountain out of a mole hill, but that is your mountain to make ;)

One final idea, why not get a fun job like being a server in a restaurant? Better money, and great socializing... :)

There must be some other job out there that won't keep you awake at night.[/quote]

Did I miss something. I didn't know being a server in a restaurant was fun. I must be in the wrong restaurant because I don't see any of this so called money you speak of. :idontknow: :rolleyes:

Posted

I loved being a server. The tips were good, and overall the work was great. I guess it depends on the restaurant.

IrishSalesian
Posted

I think you should do what your conscience tells you. If it were me, I would request a transfer, and if that does't work, the restaurant industry isnt too bad.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...