missionarybelle Posted June 27, 2007 Posted June 27, 2007 (edited) I vote for produce. Edited June 27, 2007 by missionarybelle
Aloysius Posted June 27, 2007 Author Posted June 27, 2007 it's a rare event. cmom, I'm quite surprised at you. I am definitely not seeing the world as black and white, I have made it quite clear that remote material cooperation in evil is acceptable when necessary (I do it all the time with my usurious credit card) and have never suggested that no one should be a cashier at a place where such things are sold, I have simply questioned whether I should seeing as it is not a necessity for me at the moment. and talk about being judgmental or whatever... look at how harsh your posts have been directed at me, what have I done to deserve blanket accusations of the sin of judgment, black-white-simple-mindedness, and the like? I have merely stated that I am not sure it is necessary for me to take part in this. as regards the pill: I have no idea when or where anyone is purchasing it, proscriptions are wrapped up and I have no way of knowing what is in there... but when people buy condoms it is absolutely clear what they're getting them for. you keep calling me judgmental, but you have absolutely no idea about my attitude towards people who use condoms and/or have sex outside of marriage. in fact, I don't believe I've said anything about their sins, or them being sinners, or them being terrible people like you've painted me as saying. my attitude towards it is an odd skitzophrenic mixture of sadness for them, terrible envy, complete understanding of what has driven them towards it, and anger that our society does not offer them any good viable moral paths through which to travel that are not ridiculously contrary to the natures of their bodies. the question is whether I want to be a part of the sale of the contraceptives or not. condoms are, for all intensive purposes, inherently evil in their usage. to say they are not is like saying a pornographic magazine is not inherently evil because all it really is is paper and ink. like I said, on very rare occasions good Catholic couples must use them with holes in them for the sake of medical tests and such... but I presume it likely that in such scenarios they would be provided them by the doctor... or otherwise considering the rarity of such situations I don't think it even calculates into the question of if any one place should sell condoms. it's called remote material cooperation in evil, it's the textbook definition: I am remotely cooperating in the material evil by processing the purchase of the evil material, namely the contraceptive. It would be an acceptable role, because it is remote and unintentional and I am not actually causing contraceptives to be sold where they would not otherwise be sold, but it's only acceptable if it is necessary. Since I am still young without a lot of responsibilities in the world, I have questioned whether it is necessary for me. [quote]But, in all seriousness, why wasn't this a factor before? Why has it all of a sudden become a factor?[/quote]On the one hand, I just never thought about it... I just applied for a job and got it and didn't really realize until after I had started... but like I said, my motives are clearly not pure moral outrage. Alot of that is just a mental smokescreen, partly for sloth (the part that says: "just quit and be a bum" haha), and partly because I'm bored and thought some sort of confrontation might spice up my life. haha, but I'm not actually going to do anything ridiculous; though I am probably going to switch to produce anyway because of the better pay and looser schedule with the breaks and stuff. Also, the near 14 yr old kid buying condoms pretty much freaked me out...cause I had no means of stopping him. got me thinkin... Anyway, I never said I thought I was sinning. I said I was remotely cooperating in material evil. That's not sinning. But it does bother me to a little extent and when it is possible to get through life without remotely cooperating in material evil, it tends to be preferable. like: it'd be preferable to get through life without having need for credit cards and bank loans, but if it must be done it must be done: remote material cooperation in usury. the accusations of judgementalism have been absolutely unfounded here. I thought you people knew me better than that .. ah well. I don't think I ever once mentioned the word "sin" until this post. you all have treated me with utter ridiculosity here... I think I'll just forget about it cause it probably had something to do with a misunderstanding of what I meant by "remote material cooperation" though. [quote]I think you are making a mountain out of a mole hill, but that is your mountain to make[/quote] Yep, I'll readily admit that I'm just utterly bored at the moment and needed something interesting to think about... whilst avoiding some other really interesting issues in my life that I don't feel like thinking about haha... anyway, this discussion is all in good fun. stop telling me I've judged the customers of Walmart as being satan's spawn though, cause I've clearly done no such thing. they're good people, and I totally understand their motivations; I think "but for the grace of God go I", not "oh those heathens!!"... actually, then I start to get a little annoyed at how the grace of God cooperates with our society to totally frustrate me... and then I return to all those other interesting things in my life. lalala
Luthien Posted June 27, 2007 Posted June 27, 2007 "Let no one look down on you because of your youth, but be a continuing example of love, faith, and purity to the believers." - 1 Timothy 4:12
Theologian in Training Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1303305' date='Jun 27 2007, 03:05 PM']On the one hand, I just never thought about it... I just applied for a job and got it and didn't really realize until after I had started... but like I said, my motives are clearly not pure moral outrage. Alot of that is just a mental smokescreen, partly for sloth (the part that says: "just quit and be a bum" haha), and partly because I'm bored and thought some sort of confrontation might spice up my life. haha, but I'm not actually going to do anything ridiculous; though I am probably going to switch to produce anyway because of the better pay and looser schedule with the breaks and stuff. Also, the near 14 yr old kid buying condoms pretty much freaked me out...cause I had no means of stopping him. got me thinkin...[/quote] Now, see this is what you should have said in the beginning, and though some part of this was based on being confrontational, it seems as though that may have been perceived as something else, perhaps, being judgmental. Regardless, it seems the thing that has affected you the most, and rightly so, is the near 14 yr old kid buying condoms, I am sure it would cause all of us to pause and think about what it is we are doing. Perhaps, that is what you should have said in the beginning. God Bless
cmotherofpirl Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1303305' date='Jun 27 2007, 03:05 PM']it's a rare event. cmom, I'm quite surprised at you. I am definitely not seeing the world as black and white, I have made it quite clear that remote material cooperation in evil is acceptable when necessary (I do it all the time with my usurious credit card) and have never suggested that no one should be a cashier at a place where such things are sold, I have simply questioned whether I should seeing as it is not a necessity for me at the moment. and talk about being judgmental or whatever... look at how harsh your posts have been directed at me, what have I done to deserve blanket accusations of the sin of judgment, black-white-simple-mindedness, and the like? I have merely stated that I am not sure it is necessary for me to take part in this. as regards the pill: I have no idea when or where anyone is purchasing it, proscriptions are wrapped up and I have no way of knowing what is in there... but when people buy condoms it is absolutely clear what they're getting them for. you keep calling me judgmental, but you have absolutely no idea about my attitude towards people who use condoms and/or have sex outside of marriage. in fact, I don't believe I've said anything about their sins, or them being sinners, or them being terrible people like you've painted me as saying. my attitude towards it is an odd skitzophrenic mixture of sadness for them, terrible envy, complete understanding of what has driven them towards it, and anger that our society does not offer them any good viable moral paths through which to travel that are not ridiculously contrary to the natures of their bodies. the question is whether I want to be a part of the sale of the contraceptives or not. condoms are, for all intensive purposes, inherently evil in their usage. to say they are not is like saying a pornographic magazine is not inherently evil because all it really is is paper and ink. like I said, on very rare occasions good Catholic couples must use them with holes in them for the sake of medical tests and such... but I presume it likely that in such scenarios they would be provided them by the doctor... or otherwise considering the rarity of such situations I don't think it even calculates into the question of if any one place should sell condoms. it's called remote material cooperation in evil, it's the textbook definition: I am remotely cooperating in the material evil by processing the purchase of the evil material, namely the contraceptive. It would be an acceptable role, because it is remote and unintentional and I am not actually causing contraceptives to be sold where they would not otherwise be sold, but it's only acceptable if it is necessary. Since I am still young without a lot of responsibilities in the world, I have questioned whether it is necessary for me. On the one hand, I just never thought about it... I just applied for a job and got it and didn't really realize until after I had started... but like I said, my motives are clearly not pure moral outrage. Alot of that is just a mental smokescreen, partly for sloth (the part that says: "just quit and be a bum" haha), and partly because I'm bored and thought some sort of confrontation might spice up my life. haha, but I'm not actually going to do anything ridiculous; though I am probably going to switch to produce anyway because of the better pay and looser schedule with the breaks and stuff. Also, the near 14 yr old kid buying condoms pretty much freaked me out...cause I had no means of stopping him. got me thinkin... Anyway, I never said I thought I was sinning. I said I was remotely cooperating in material evil. That's not sinning. But it does bother me to a little extent and when it is possible to get through life without remotely cooperating in material evil, it tends to be preferable. like: it'd be preferable to get through life without having need for credit cards and bank loans, but if it must be done it must be done: remote material cooperation in usury. the accusations of judgementalism have been absolutely unfounded here. I thought you people knew me better than that .. ah well. I don't think I ever once mentioned the word "sin" until this post. you all have treated me with utter ridiculosity here... I think I'll just forget about it cause it probably had something to do with a misunderstanding of what I meant by "remote material cooperation" though. Yep, I'll readily admit that I'm just utterly bored at the moment and needed something interesting to think about... whilst avoiding some other really interesting issues in my life that I don't feel like thinking about haha... anyway, this discussion is all in good fun. stop telling me I've judged the customers of Walmart as being satan's spawn though, cause I've clearly done no such thing. they're good people, and I totally understand their motivations; I think "but for the grace of God go I", not "oh those heathens!!"... actually, then I start to get a little annoyed at how the grace of God cooperates with our society to totally frustrate me... and then I return to all those other interesting things in my life. lalala[/quote] Sorry Al. It just sounds like your saying, "well, I really don't need to work, so this is a good a reason as any to quit", and that annoys me. In the real world, most people don't really have a choice to just quit if they percieve a remote cooperation with evil. They have to eat and pay bills. Be not slothful!, now go play in the pool.
Birgitta Noel Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 [quote name='abercius24' post='1303025' date='Jun 27 2007, 03:23 AM']Some women are also prescribed birth control pills to control a bleeding condition of the uterus (called endometriosis), which the Church allows as long as the woman refrains from sexual activity or is married and is at a part of her Natural Family Planning Cycle where she knows she is not capable of conceiving (and subsequently contracepting and/or aborting).[/quote] I just want to note that if you are taking hormonal contraceptives that you cannot use NFP to determine whether or not you are ovulating. NFP relies on physical signs that are triggered by the fluxuation in hormone levels, the pill adds more hormones to the mix preventing those fluxuations and the physical signs of fertility are masked by the pill or are absent because the pill has worked and has actually prevented ovulation.
abercius24 Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1303051' date='Jun 27 2007, 08:35 AM']but condoms... yeah... and there's not even an age restriction or anything. there's an age restriction on AIRSOFT GUNS but not on CONDOMS. go figure. some kid, had to be like 14 or something, bought a pack in my line and there was nothing I could do about it [/quote] Oh, that would give me the willies for at least a couple of weeks if that happened to me. Ick.
abercius24 Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1303060' date='Jun 27 2007, 08:50 AM']How about this question: could I morally be a cashier in a porn shop? Would it be too judgmental of the customers of me to decide not to be a cashier in a porn shop? Or to bring the example more in line: what if walmart sold pornography? It's basically the equivalent, it's a thing that expresses clear intent towards immoral use, there is no real moral use (except in some medical circumstances when holes are poked into them, but I'd assume in such situations they get the stuff from their doctors) for either, can I be a cooperator in either one of them?[/quote] You have to consider the core mission of the business to start. Wal-Mart is a department store with the core mission of providing a large variety of discount general merchandise for a profit. There is nothing wrong with this mission, and to work for Wal-Mart is to contribute to the good Wal-Mart does for people. Of course, there are evil elements that come along with the good, but that happens no matter what. The best situation is one where great good comes with as little evil as possible. A porn shop's core mission is that of making profit by selling purient material that ultimately contributes to the degredation of society. Such a mission would be completely reprehensible to contribute to. There is very little good, and quite a bit of evil that can come from working there -- not to mention what personal exposure to those materials would do to you. Edited June 28, 2007 by abercius24
kamiller42 Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 Aloysius, good news! I'm not going to tell you you are judging Wal-Mart customers. I understand your concern for remote material cooperation. If it bothers you, you should change jobs. However, I believe you will find potential remote material cooperation in almost any other job you take. In Wal-Mart, they sell ammunition and guns (Guns are only at some locations.) which could be used to commit a murder. They sell alcohol which could be used to commit gluttony. Ditto for food. If you work in a movie theater, would you allow a minor to enter an R movie when escorted with parent? If you wait tables in a restaurant, will you serve greasy fried chicken or steak to an obese man? Would you work in a hospital where abortion is 1 of thousands of procedures offered? This is not to mean you can never be in remote material cooperation based on where you work. I think the difference between Wal-Mart and Planned Parenthood/Third Reich is intent. Wal-Mart's intent and primary business is not birth control. In fact, they fought it, but ended being forced to sell it by the government. We can't say Wal-Mart is in full consent of selling it. However, there's full consent with Planned Parenthood to give out irresponsibility and death. Ditto for Third Reich. If it helps, whenever you see someone buying this merchandise, look for the name on the credit card or ask for his/her name. If he/she asks why, say "I want to remember you this Sunday." Do not say you are going to pray for him/her. You will likely get in trouble if you do. "Remembering" and "Sunday" seems secular enough to keep you out of trouble. If they ask what it means, you can safely say "I spend Sundays thinking about what happened the previous week." It's true.
abercius24 Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 [quote name='The Little Way' post='1303906' date='Jun 27 2007, 11:26 PM']I just want to note that if you are taking hormonal contraceptives that you cannot use NFP to determine whether or not you are ovulating. NFP relies on physical signs that are triggered by the fluxuation in hormone levels, the pill adds more hormones to the mix preventing those fluxuations and the physical signs of fertility are masked by the pill or are absent because the pill has worked and has actually prevented ovulation.[/quote] I know it's off topic, but if a woman had a regular cycle prior to taking the pill, she would know about when her phases usually occur and can use that calandar as her guide while on the pill.
XIX Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 [quote name='alicemary' post='1303070' date='Jun 27 2007, 08:24 AM']It is wonderful to have high ideals, but they are yours. They may not be the same as mine. You are very young obvioiusly, and you are right, you don't need this job. Then quit it. One day you will realize the world does not do what you want. You are a small cog among many cogs. You do your best. And your work record is very important. Do what you want, but you run away, you might just spend alot of your life legislating to others and moralizing. And guess what, your message is lost. They arent' listening. Make a difference in others lives and they listen. As to porn, my word it is everywhere. It is on the very internet you are utilizing. Just because it is there does not mean you have to read it. Again, what business is it of yours that someone else is reading it? [b]You are very judgemental.[/b][/quote] Utterly ironic last sentence there...
XIX Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 It is an act of judgement to accuse your neighbor of having the sin of judgement on his soul. You have no way of knowing whether Aloysius is sinning or not. You just have "He doesn't want to remotely cooperate with evil...You must be judgemental! How dare you draw such unfounded conclusions of other people?"
prose Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 [quote name='abercius24' post='1303998' date='Jun 27 2007, 11:18 PM']I know it's off topic, but if a woman had a regular cycle prior to taking the pill, she would know about when her phases usually occur and can use that calandar as her guide while on the pill.[/quote] The rhythm method? Not very effective nor accurate NFP. Generally it is ocnfusion about this that leads people to think ALL forms of NFP don't work.
Church Punk Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 Here is my thoughts, quit (after sucuring a job else where first of course). By working at Walmart you are not only supporting the beast and its aweful immorallity, but you are helping them royally screw over all of their suppling companies. They place many unjust demands on their suppliers and force them into situations where one mistake will result in the company going out of business. They steal from all of their suppliers for the sake of being able to sell the products at a lower price. It is their fault so many of our jobs in N. America are going over seas. For instance look at their R.A. policy. They hold you (the supplier) responsible for any returns of the product. Not only charging you fees just to stock it, but for every product returned you must pay the full retail price ontop of your cost to merely produce it, if you dont deliver on time they will cancel you from their supplier list! I used to work for a company that supplied Walmart and sams club. Needless to say, that company doesnt exist anymore and many people lost their jobs over it. I wont even go near a Walmart now!
Franimus Posted June 28, 2007 Posted June 28, 2007 freakin' a.. Aloysius, if anybody here can really relate to what you're talking about, it's me. I'm a shift supervisor at Sheetz (gas station/convenience store for those of you not near PA), where they sell porn, condoms, cigs, alcohol (at some stores), and greasy food. I also didn't know they sold porn and condoms when I started working there. Fortunately, I rarely ring up a customer purchasing those (then again, I usually don't work register, I usually make food). My sister, who is going to be a nun, worked there with me one or two summers ago, and did not return after that summer for that reason, although she did not quit in the middle of the summer. I've had the same dilemma as you a few times (or rather, it creeps back up every so often). Unfortunately, I can't really transfer to another department (since 1. I'm a supervisor and 2. I already usually just make food). I'd consider quitting, but I need a job to pay for school. I'd consider another job, but the longer I wait, the less point there is to it, since this is my last summer working a minimum-wage (although i get paid about twice minimum wage) job. Also, I would be hard-pressed to find another job that is better morally and financially for me that I could work only while on breaks from school. If you still have another summer ahead of you working at Wal-Mart, I would encourage you to find another (and better paying) job. In the meantime, however, transferring departments (while making known to at least your manager the reasons for your transfer) would be good. However, be sure to carefully pick and choose which manager you ask, if you can. Some might say "Sure, I don't see why not" while others might say "No way!". Regarding working at a hospital, doctors are allowed to refuse to perform a procedure for moral reasons. Nurses I'm not sure about. The same goes for prescribing meds. I would think that the responsibility for distributing birth control pills rests solely on the prescribing doctor and the recipient. I suppose a pharmaceutical technician (or whoever it is that fills the bottles) could replace BC and abortion pills with sugar pills, but that goes into deception and the like, so you'd be better off with a more direct opposition. Following this line of reasoning, cashiers are certainly not morally responsible for the sale of birth control and porn. However, as an employee, I think it is our responsibility to use appropriate channels to oppose the company's sale of said items. For instance, right now I am thinking that I should post in the company forum my objection to the company's sale of said items, although I would not refuse to ring the customer up, especially since then the cashier next to me would just ring the customer up anyways.
abercius24 Posted June 29, 2007 Posted June 29, 2007 (edited) [quote name='prose' post='1304262' date='Jun 28 2007, 12:51 PM']The rhythm method? Not very effective nor accurate NFP. Generally it is ocnfusion about this that leads people to think ALL forms of NFP don't work.[/quote] I would be happy to explain elsewhere, if you would like, as I have taught Sympto-Thermal Method and studied Napro-technology; but I believe we are greatly off topic. Edited June 29, 2007 by abercius24
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now