Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

"SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM cura ad hoc tempus usque semper fuit, ut Christi Ecclesia Divinae Maiestati cultum dignum offerret, «ad laudem et gloriam nominis Sui» et «ad utilitatem totius Ecclesiae Suae sanctae».


Ab immemorabili tempore sicut etiam in futurum, principium servandum est «iuxta quod unaquaeque Ecclesia particularis concordare debet cum universali Ecclesia non solum quoad fidei doctrinam et signa sacramentalia, sed etiam quoad usus universaliter acceptos ab apostolica et continua traditione, qui servandi sunt non solum ut errores vitentur, verum etiam ad fidei integritatem tradendam, quia Ecclesiae lex orandi eius legi credendi respondet»...."

:woot:

The Supreme Pontifs have always been concerned that the Church of Christ offer the Divine Majesty worthy rites of worship, 'for the praise and glory of His name" and "for the utility of all His Church"

From immemorial times and into the future, the principal to be followed is "all the particular churches must be in accordance with the universal Church not only in the doctrine of the faith and the signs of the sacraments, but also in the universally accepted uses from apostolic times and in continuing tradition, that has served not only to protect against errors, but also to hand down the integrity of the faith, because "the Church's law of prayer corresponds to her law of beleif."

:woot:

TO BE CONTINUED.... on July 7.

Posted

I'm so excited! Only two more days!

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I already translated it on the other thread. :(

Posted

haha I just saw that, and yours is better anyway.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted
:yahoo: times googleplex.
missionarybelle
Posted

So what is MP going to do? because I thought the TLM was already allowed to be celebrated and that most bisops chose not to provide it. what change is it actually going to make?

Posted (edited)

[b]8 points of wisdom[/b].... from [u]Shawn Tribe [/u]of NewLiturgicalMovement blogspot

"Friday, July 06, 2007
Prepare Ye the Way...
posted by Shawn Tribe

Probably the only thing now surer than the fact the MP is being released tomorrow is that there will be some whose first reaction will be disappointment, or they will feel the document to be insufficient, even problematic. Some will think it goes too far; others, not far enough. Some will also try to minimize the import of the document. Expect to hear all of these things. Of course, how one will react depends greatly upon the principles one holds, and thus, one's standard of judgement.

That, however, is not my main point of focus. To some extent this kind of reaction is also natural since the anticipation of this document has been going on for so long. I've made the analogy before that it is like waiting for Christmas morning as a child. Once the gift-wrapping is all removed and the gift exposed, despite the fact that the child has before them all sorts of new toys, there can yet be an all too human tendency to think, "that's it?" and to feel a bit of a let down after so much anticipation -- rather than looking at precisely what has been given to us, which we did not have before, and being grateful.

We saw this with Sacramentum Caritatis and we certainly will see such here as well.

However, I think we can manage this natural human reaction by managing our own expectations and thinking ahead.

To that end, I want to propose a few suggestions in the lead up to tomorrow:

[b]1.[/b] Think about Pope Benedict's liturgical teaching. It would be good if people really stop and think about Pope Benedict's vision for the liturgy and the Church, which sees liturgical co-existence, but one which attempts to address the Council and might eventually lead to synthesis. Get your mind into that mode and read Summorum Pontificum in that light, understanding it from that perspective as the seeds of a 'corrective' of the hermeneutic of rupture.

[b]2.[/b] Forget about what you've heard about the document and simply read it for what it is. Consider this as well: if this document came as a complete and total surprise with no lead up to it these past months, how would you respond to it then? Respond to it accordingly as such.

[b]3.[/b] In the same vein, think not about what you personally would like to see happen, but rather think about the present state of things and ask, regardless of my own opinion of what would be for the best, how does this motu proprio change the landscape for the better (for both the ordinary and extraordinary forms of the Roman rite)? How does it help in the process of reclaiming our tradition from the margins of ecclesial life? How does it build for the future?

[b]4.[/b] Realize as well that Benedict may also have had to make a prudential decision about precisely what he thought he could promulgate with a reasonable chance of being successful in the here and now, building for the future. Think of this as another step in a process rather than the "end game". Think about what was released in 1984, which was very restrictive; then the loosening of 1988 with Ecclesia Dei, and now this next step in the process.

[b]5.[/b] Be aware, now, before you read it tomorrow, that you probably won't get everything you hope for in one document. Don't expect magical juridical solutions, nor one's that implement all of your own desires.

[b]6.[/b] Presume that there no document can absolutely safeguard against those who determined to foil it, but, again, how does it make it that much harder to do so, or that much freer where such a situation doesn't exist, and how does the document build for a better future by redefining attitudes?

[b]7.[/b] At the end of the day, your wish-list aside, take real note of the proverbial "new toys" that this motu proprio provides and that you didn't have as of today and be thankful for yet another step back toward our tradition, toward a hermeneutic of continuity, and toward a sensible implementation of the Council.
[b]
8.[/b] Finally, before you even read the document tomorrow, might I recommend you place it before yourself, and then go through this list of considerations one more time.

Posted by Shawn Tribe on 6.7.07 "

Edited by EJames
Posted (edited)

oops.

Edited by EJames
Posted (edited)

[quote name='missionarybelle' post='1315058' date='Jul 6 2007, 07:29 AM']So what is MP going to do? because I thought the TLM was already allowed to be celebrated and that most bishops chose not to provide it. what change is it actually going to make?[/quote]
one thing ,among many...that one no longer needs the bureaucracy and The Bishops approval/permission/choice...
so one could have a new TEEN Mass, in a Parish a TridenTINE...hahaha

Edited by EJames
Posted

Does anybody know what time the document is actually being released?

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='SJP' post='1315364' date='Jul 6 2007, 12:37 PM']Does anybody know what time the document is actually being released?[/quote]
There is an embargo until 12 noon Rome time, July 7th, which is 6 am Eastern, 5 am Central, 4 am Mountain, and 3 am Pacific. So at that time in each respective area, the press is allowed to release the document. I would assume it will also be available on the Vatican website at that time.

geetarplayer
Posted

I wonder to what extent and how quickly this will affect the Church's relationship with groups like SSPX. ^_^

Posted (edited)

14 hours and 20 minutes... :clap:

Edited by DAF
bonoducchi
Posted (edited)

I read it today (yes, my judicial vicar gave me his "advance copy" from the bishop). Its very pastoral in it sensitivity and leaves criteria purposefully vague (the rumored 30 person minimum did not materialize). I would have liked to have seen some safeguard to ensure that the Mass is celebrated properly, since few priests have the training to celebrate the rite, let alone pronounce it correctly. However, that would seem to violate the purpose of "universal indult." Overall, it seems to land more on the side of "much ado about nothing" than something more earth shattering.

I still question the wisdom of doing this. The old rite does not seem to be in constant harmony with post-V2 documents. Can we apply the concept of full, active, and conscious participation to a rite that by its nature encourages individualism and private devotion?

I was glad to see the call for inclusion of some more recent orations in the 1962 rite. There is a good vision of synthesis of the best of both worlds, something to be expected from someone as smart as Benedict.

Will it give peace of mind to those who long for the old rite? Yes. Will it have any sort of appreciable effect on the Catholic Church in America? Probably not.

By the way, has anyone actually been denied access to the 1962 rite by their ordinary?

Edited by VaticanIILiturgist
Posted

JMJ
7/6 - St. Maria Goretti

It seems extremely narrow-minded to say that the classical rite encourages individualism and private devotion. I recommend reading pre-conciliar documents to get a handle on the official line regarding the liturgy - the pre-conciliar Liturgical Movement incorporated this very well.

What individual bishops, pastors or lay faithful may have done with the liturgy is another issue. Often, it seems that current liturgies are influenced more and more by the individual whims and private devotions of either the pastor or the liturgical committee of a parish. Also, receiving communion in a line akin to that of the post office takes away from the Ecclesial nature of sacramental communion. It has its benefits, but when we all stand/kneel next to each other to receive Jesus, the corporate nature of the act is more clearly driven home.

And yes, I'm not free to discuss the situation, but one bishop I know in particular has refused every request to permit the classical Liturgy from being celebrated by his own priests.

I do agree that Benedict is wise in including some new prayers and saints in the old calendar. He suggested this at Fontgambault (sic) in 2003, and it sounded like a great idea then as well. He even suggested including some new prefaces, but that would be problematic - the Roman Rite has historically always opted in favor of fewer, not more, prefaces. We're not Ambrosian here. :P:

I think it is wise, as well, to allow what seems like a synthesis of the lectionaries. That seems to respect the wishes of the Council.

Posted

this is going to be big!

Posted

It is only the beginning.

bonoducchi
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1315658' date='Jul 6 2007, 08:19 PM']It is only the beginning.[/quote]

Of what?

Posted

Of a big change... the beginning of another adventure... Anywho, that was not a bad translation on first post, I think. I'm starting to study a bit of Latin now. I might take this new document in it's original Latin and translate a bit myself, then compare with the Holy See's translation. Should be interesting, and it would get me more personally involved in the Motu Proprio's meaning. :) I Can't wait! :D:

Posted

7 hours and 10 minutes... :birds:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...