Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote]VaticanIILiturgist:
I still question the wisdom of doing this. The old rite does not seem to be in constant harmony with post-V2 documents. Can we apply the concept of full, active, and conscious participation to a rite that by its nature encourages individualism and private devotion?[/quote]

Well you bring up an interesting point there. "The old rite does not seem to be in constant harmony with post-V2 documents". I think that the Pope is attempting to remind the Church that Vatican II must be seen in light of the great Traditions of the Church. Not the other way around. What is a more sacred Tradition than the Tridentine Mass, the Mass of the Ages? Nothing. The reverence and beauty of the Tridentine Mass will eventually influence how the New Mass is celebrated. This will be a long process, but it's a great start!!

As the Pope stated:
“[b]There is no contradiction between the two editions of the Roman Missal,” Benedict says. “In the history of the liturgy there is growth and progress, but no rupture. What earlier generations held as sacred, remains sacred and great for us too, and it cannot be all of a sudden entirely forbidden or even considered harmful. It behooves all of us to preserve the riches which have developed in the Church’s faith and prayer, and to give them their proper place.”[/b]
Deo Gratias!!!!

Posted

[quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1315576' date='Jul 6 2007, 08:08 PM']By the way, has anyone actually been denied access to the 1962 rite by their ordinary?[/quote]
In the diocese where I go to my college there was a petition of about 400 ppl asking for the mass, and it was denied.

any analysis that calls the 1962 mass individualistic is absolutely blind and simplistic, it has a different way of expressing community which is at the very least equally expressive of community to the way it is done now, and at the most it expresses it more authentically than the current usages.

Posted

Here is part of a speech given by the Holy Father in 1998:

[quote]On the other hand one has to admit that the celebration of the ancient liturgy was too lost in the realm of the individual and the private. One must admit that the communion between the priest and the faithful was lacking. I have great respect for our ancestors who during the Low Mass, said the prayers "during Mass" which their prayer book recommended. Certainly one cannot consider that as the ideal of the liturgical celebration! Perhaps, these reduced forms of celebration are the fundamental reason why the disappearance of the ancient liturgical books had no importance in many countries and caused no pain. There was never any contact with the liturgy itself. On the other hand, where the liturgical movement had created a certain love for the liturgy, where this movement anticipated the essential ideals of the Council - for example the prayerful participation of all at the liturgical action - there was a greater pain at the liturgical reform undertaken too much in haste and limiting itself often to externals. Where the liturgical movement never existed the reform did not at first pose a problem. The problems arose in a spasmodic way where a wild creativity made the sacred mystery disappear.

This is why it is so important to obey the essential criteria of the Constitution on the Liturgy [of the Second Vatican Council], which I cited above, even if one celebrates according to the Ancient Missal. At the moment when this liturgy truly touches the faithful by its beauty and depth, then it will be alive and there will be no irreconcilable opposition with the new liturgy - provided that these criteria are truly applied as the Council wished.

Different spiritual and theological emphases will continue to exist, but they will no longer be two opposing ways to be Christian. They will be, rather, the riches which belong to the same unique Catholic faith.

[url="http://www.fssp.org/en/annivratz.htm"]http://www.fssp.org/en/annivratz.htm[/url][/quote]

Posted

[quote]I think it is wise, as well, to allow what seems like a synthesis of the lectionaries. That seems to respect the wishes of the Council.[/quote]

i agree, father. as beautiful as the Tridentine Mass sounds (i have never attended one, myself), i was disappointed in my research about the Tridentine mass to find that they only had two readings, and they didn't seem to have the same flow as they do now. obviously, lots of psalms as well, but i think it is truly beautiful the way in which the readings are now arranged, especially in regards to liturgical seasons. the old reveals the new and the new enlightens the old, and the psalm and new testament reading to complement. so cool beans ^_^

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1316165' date='Jul 7 2007, 01:07 AM']Here is part of a speech given by the Holy Father in 1998:[/quote]


I think the previous paragraph is also an important part of that speech:

[quote]Here then are, the Council directives. They can give everyone matter for reflection. There is unfortunately a tendency, amongst some modern liturgists, to develop the ideas of the Council in one direction. One overturns the intentions of the Council, acting in this way. The role of the priest is reduced by some to the purely functional. The fact that the entire Body of Christ is the subject of the liturgy is often deformed to the point where the local community becomes the self-sufficient subject of the liturgy and it allots the various roles. There also exists a dangerous tendency to minimalise the sacrificial nature of the Mass and to make the mystery and the sacred disappear under the so-called imperative pretext of making oneself more easily understood. Finally, one notices the tendency to fragment the liturgy and the unilateral emphasizing of its communitarian character by giving the assembly the power to decide about the celebration.

Happily, however, there is a certain disgust for a rationalism full of banality and the pragmatism of certain theoretical and practical liturgists. One notices a return to mystery, and to adoration and the sacred, and to the cosmic and eschatological nature of the liturgy. To this, the Oxford Declaration on the Liturgy of 1996 bears witnesses.[/quote]

Posted

my observations of the two calenders: the old one is an organic synthesis which connects the readings directly with the feast days and such. the new one is arranged more like one would arrange a 3-year bible study, less organic and more surgical. the new readings tend to be much more arbitrary compared to the feast days and seasons, I totally don't see what you mean about them flowing more, the old ones have a much better flow in my opinion.

the old certainly has many more prayers directly from the scriptures, especially drawing from the psalms and such.

mostly, it seems like generally the word "organic" applies to the aspects of the Old Mass more than the new in most everything... it's intricate and deeply connected; the readings of the New Mass tend to, for the most part, reflect a more arbitrary randomized cycle of readings. it's like the difference between the national borders of European Nations and the national borders of African Nations... sure, if you get together and look at a map, you might just wanna draw some squares up and divide things logically; but the old lectionary seems to organically form out of the feasts and seasons et cetera.

but it is true, of course, that the New Mass has actual placed readings from the Old Testament whilst the old simply draws prayers from the Old Testament.

Posted

you don't think al, that the readings have to do with the feasts? that's funny, because for the most part, i really think they do....

and yes, i had heard about more prayers from scripture, i think it would be nice to have more of that ^_^

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1316294' date='Jul 7 2007, 12:16 AM']my observations of the two calenders: the old one is an organic synthesis which connects the readings directly with the feast days and such. the new one is arranged more like one would arrange a 3-year bible study, less organic and more surgical. the new readings tend to be much more arbitrary compared to the feast days and seasons, I totally don't see what you mean about them flowing more, the old ones have a much better flow in my opinion.[/quote]
This is an interesting observation. I would love to see a few examples of what you mean by the readings being "more organic." Perhaps you could compare the readings for a particular feast day according to the two Roman usages.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1316111' date='Jul 6 2007, 10:43 PM']In the diocese where I go to my college there was a petition of about 400 ppl asking for the mass, and it was denied.[/quote]
Same here! The Bishops response seemed to suggest that we were all a bunch of old fogies who need to get with the times. The fact is most of the people who signed the petition were young families including a number of well known Catholic figures. It was a very sad and disappointing response.

I'm hoping that this Moto Proprio will soften our Bishop to the use of the [i]forma extraordinaria[/i] in this diocese.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...