Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

philosophette
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1317139' date='Jul 7 2007, 08:01 PM']Sounds like there was a lack of active participation. IMHO, Archbishop Fulton Sheens little book "[i]The Mass and Calvary[/i]" is a good way to increase one's appreciation of the [i]Forma Extraordinaria[/i]. The theological and spiritual richness of this Liturgy cannot be overstated. I've heard of people who say that Rosary is boring etc. but when one enters deeply into the mysteries of the Holy Rosary and interiorly communes with Christ through Our Lady it is a great spiritual joy. I think full participation in the [i]Forma Extraordinaria[/i] can be compared to this one some level (although it is a partial analogy).[/quote]


I have been to ones where people kneel like they are zombies and ones where the people are really "into it". I have had some wonderful spiritually enriching experiences at the Trid Mass, but all in all the Novus Ordo is somewhere that I feel most at home and is also rich.

It is not that one is better than the other - I think that one fits some people better than another and there is nothing wrong with that. Some might disagree, but that is what I think.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='philosobrat' post='1317140' date='Jul 7 2007, 07:02 PM']I agree completely. I mean, I am happy for those who feel the Trid Liturgy fits them, but it is not for me and when the Novus Ordo is put down as not as good it really irks me.[/quote]
The [i]Forma Ordinaria[/i] has a beauty of its own and when celebrated properly is a noble Liturgical form, but there are very real and objective differences between the two forms and I don't think it is appropriate to suggest that they are equal in every respect. The Pope has made clear that the use of the [i]Forma Extraordinaria[/i] has the power to greatly enrich the life of the Church. It is possible to affirm this fact without putting down the [i]Forma Ordinaria[/i]; in fact, to do otherwise would be foreign to the spirit of the Church on this subject.

Posted

I am not Roman Catholic, but I think that the use of the older Roman Rite will be a good thing for the Latin Church.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='philosobrat' post='1317141' date='Jul 7 2007, 10:04 PM']It is not that one is better than the other - I think that one fits some people better than another and there is nothing wrong with that. Some might disagree, but that is what I think.[/quote]


I think more Traditionalist agree with you than you might think. ;)

Edited by Luthien
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='philosobrat' post='1317141' date='Jul 7 2007, 07:04 PM']I have been to ones where people kneel like they are zombies and ones where the people are really "into it". I have had some wonderful spiritually enriching experiences at the Trid Mass, but all in all the Novus Ordo is somewhere that I feel most at home and is also rich.

It is not that one is better than the other - I think that one fits some people better than another and there is nothing wrong with that. Some might disagree, but that is what I think.[/quote]
Don't get me started on my typical "Novus Ordo" experiences. Besides the fact that saying people "kneel like zombies" is extremely nasty and presumptuous (for all you know they were in the seventh mansion), I would say that in a conversation of this kind the Novus Ordo would certainly lose.

Posted

Yes. People actually dress up like Zombies at some "Halloween" Masses celebrated according to the revised Roman liturgy.

Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1317083' date='Jul 7 2007, 06:28 PM']Actually I would guess that the vast majority of American Catholics are with you on this one.

What we see on PM is not a representative sampling of the U.S. Church.[/quote]
The "vast majority of American Catholics " could really care less about their Faith.

Catholic Phatmassers care more about the Faith than the "average pew-sitter," and are also more knowledgable.

And for those on here who "could care less about the Motu Proprio," why are you even wasting time posting about it?
Does the joy of "traditionalists" about this bother you?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1317170' date='Jul 7 2007, 07:35 PM']The "vast majority of American Catholics " could really care less about their Faith.

Catholic Phatmassers care more about the Faith than the "average pew-sitter," and are also more knowledgable.

And for those on here who "could care less about the Motu Proprio," why are you even wasting time posting about it?
Does the joy of "traditionalists" about this bother you?[/quote]
:applause:

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1317129' date='Jul 7 2007, 06:56 PM']I doubt most American Catholics have ever assisted at the [i]Forma Extraordinaria[/i].[/quote]
well, it's been, what, less than 50 years since it was the ordinary? There are a lot of Baby Boomers, and I'm guessing those who grew up Catholic attended the 1962 form regularly.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1317163' date='Jul 7 2007, 08:20 PM']Yes. People actually dress up like Zombies at some "Halloween" Masses celebrated according to the revised Roman liturgy.[/quote]


This is hardly a common experience, and has nothing to do with which form of the Mass being celebrated.

Valid, holy, touching, orthodox Masses are celebrated with great care to follow liturgical norms under both forms of our Rite by devout, orthodox Catholics who are well-catechized. Latin Masses are almost always worthy of such a positive description because they are attended by such Catholics almost exclusively, but such Catholics by no means almost exclusively attend Mass said in Latin, and in those communities where they form a large segment, Masses said in the vernacular tend to merit equally positive description.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1317175' date='Jul 7 2007, 07:41 PM']well, it's been, what, less than 50 years since it was the ordinary? There are a lot of Baby Boomers, and I'm guessing those who grew up Catholic attended the 1962 form regularly.[/quote]
Ok, most have either never been or just have some vague childhood memory from 40 years ago and have since been immersed in a culture of anti-tradition. Either way I don't think a poll taken from the masses of American Catholics has much bearing on the issues. The fact is the Church in America is largely impoverished and uncatechized. I think Plato's critique of democracy applies here.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1317181' date='Jul 7 2007, 07:45 PM']Ok, most have either never been or just have some vague childhood memory from 40 years ago and have since been immersed in a culture of anti-tradition. Either way I don't think a poll taken from the masses of American Catholics has much bearing on the issues. The fact is the Church in America is largely impoverished and uncatechized. I think Plato's critique of democracy applies here.[/quote]
Perhaps, but I was responding to Scardella's question of whether he was alone in the way he feels about the MP. I was merely pointing out that he is not.

Posted

[quote name='tomasio127' post='1317177' date='Jul 7 2007, 06:43 PM']This is hardly a common experience, and has nothing to do with which form of the Mass being celebrated.[/quote]
It may not be common where you are from, but it is quite common in Roman Church's in the Bay Area.

Here is a picture of a Mass at Christ the King parish in Pleasant Hill California.

[img]http://www.geocities.com/apotheoun/christ_the_king.jpg[/img]

These kinds of things are fairly common at parishes in the SF Bay Area. I am concerned about things like this -- even though I am a Byzantine Catholic -- because the terrible liturgical situation in the Roman Church will no doubt eventually be manifested in my own Church. The use of so-called [i]inclusive language[/i] has already made in-roads into the Ruthenian Church.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Okay... stop right there... Let's not turn this into that kind of thread... we already have enough. This does nothing to promote unity as a Church.

As a friend of mine as speculated, this is going to cause division among Catholics... and it seems to be...

Posted

I grew up with the latin Mass, not so sure I care if it returns. I prefer the Mass as it is today, for me that is rich liturgy.I like understanding it and the words mean alot to me.
Most people in my church only care that the sermon is short and the Mass lasts less then 40 minutes. People come in late, leave early.

Posted

Abuses happen, why pretend that they do not?

The only way to end abuses to to work actively against them.

The picture is from Christ the King parish in Pleasant Hill California and was taken on 1 September 2002.

I recommend that anyone offended by the picture contact the parish, click the link below to get the contact information:

[url="http://www.ctkph.org/"]Christ the King, Pleasant Hill, CA[/url]

philosophette
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1317156' date='Jul 7 2007, 08:12 PM']Don't get me started on my typical "Novus Ordo" experiences. Besides the fact that saying people "kneel like zombies" is extremely nasty and presumptuous (for all you know they were in the seventh mansion), I would say that in a conversation of this kind the Novus Ordo would certainly lose.[/quote]


Whoa you are taking this WAY out of the context in which I was saying it.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1317201' date='Jul 7 2007, 07:56 PM']Okay... stop right there... Let's not turn this into that kind of thread... we already have enough. This does nothing to promote unity as a Church.

As a friend of mine as speculated, this is going to cause division among Catholics... and it seems to be...[/quote]
I don't think the MP is [i]causing[/i] division among Catholics - it is simply bringing to light already existing division, brought about largely by "liberal" liturgical abuse.

And call me a naive optimist, but I really don't think the Bay Area insanity represents the future direction of the Church - it's left-over 70s goofiness.

Edited by Socrates
homeschoolmom
Posted

The topic of this thread is whether or not people are tired of hearing about or reading about the MP, NOT about abuses. We are not going to turn this into a Catholic vs. Catholic debate.

Thank you.

journeyman
Posted

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?act=Post&CODE=02&f=2&t=69932&qpid=1315687"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?a...mp;qpid=1315687[/url]


[quote name='cappie' post='1315687' date='Jul 6 2007, 07:32 PM']Time again to repost these, I think:
Fr. Z’s 5 Rules of Engagement for after the Motu Proprio is released:

1) Rejoice because our liturgical life has been enriched, not because “we win”. Everyone wins when the Church’s life is enriched. This is not a “zero sum game”.

2) Do not strut. Let us be gracious to those who have in the past not been gracious in regard to our “legitimate aspirations”.

3) Show genuine Christian joy. If you want to attract people to what gives you so much consolation and happiness, be inviting and be joyful. Avoid the sourness some of the more traditional stamp have sadly worn for so long.

4) Be engaged in the whole life of your parishes, especially in works of mercy organized by the same. If you want the whole Church to benefit from the use of the older liturgy, then you who are shaped by the older form of Mass should be of benefit to the whole Church in concrete terms.

5) If the document doesn’t say everything we might hope for, don’t beesh about it like a whiner. Speak less of our rights and what we deserve, or what it ought to have been, as if we were our own little popes, and more about our gratitude, gratitude, gratitude for what God gives us.

[url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/[/url][/quote]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...