Apotheoun Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 The Eastern Churches condemned (i.e., in the [i]Synodikon of Orthodoxy[/i]) the idealism of Plato. Thus, in the Byzantine tradition the liturgy on earth is identical to that which is celebrated in heaven; in fact, it is that one heavenly liturgy made manifest. In other words, it (i.e., the divine liturgy) is not simply a symbolic representation of the celestial liturgy, it is the celestial liturgy. That said, my main concerns about the revised Roman liturgy are theological, and are expressed nicely in Dr. Pristas' articles, which I posted links to earlier in this thread.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320653' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:05 PM']The Eastern Churches condemned (i.e., in the Synodikon of Orthodoxy) the idealism of Plato. In the Byzantine tradition the liturgy on earth is identical to that which is celebrated in heaven; in fact, it is that one heavenly liturgy made manifest. In other words, it (i.e., the divine liturgy) is not simply a symbolic representation of the celestial liturgy, it is the celelstial liturgy.[/quote] haha, I knew you were going to say that! I actually heard you saying more or less that same thing as I read the Terra's post. As you know Catholic teaching is that the Mass manifests that one heavenly liturgy. I don't share your hang up with expressing things in terms reminiscent of Platonism. Many fathers (Greek and Latin) employ the language of forms or ideas, it is the understanding of God and of the ontological status of the forms which fundamentally separates this from Platonic idealism proper. But regardless of this, I think you would be correct insofar as the form/participation paradigm is not a technically accurate way of describing the liturgy. But of course the form-participation thing does not imply that the earthly liturgy is simply a symbolic representation of the celestial liturgy. The "form" in this context is the perfect and transcendent reality from which the temporal and earthy is derives in an ontological sense, not a symbolic sense. There is a validity to this kind of conceptualization since even Biblical motifs imply something of this sort. Certainly not Platonism, but the idea of transcendent/heavenly realities that are expressed, and in which we can participate historically. This however does not keep me from appreciating the gist of Terra's point.
Apotheoun Posted July 9, 2007 Author Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320659' date='Jul 9 2007, 01:11 PM']haha, I knew you were going to say that! I actually heard you saying more or less that same thing as I read the Terra's post. As you know Catholic teaching is that the Mass manifests that one heavenly liturgy. I don't share your hang up with expressing things in terms reminiscent of Platonism.[/quote] My rejection of Platonic idealism is not some kind of personal hang up; instead, I am simply being faithful to the tradition of my Church, which condemned Platonic idealism as heretical. Nevertheless, my main worries in connection with the modern Roman rite, as I have said already, are theological in nature.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320670' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:17 PM']My rejection of Platonic idealism is not some kind of personal hang up; instead, I am simply being faithful to the tradition of my Church, which condemned Platonic idealism as heretical. Nevertheless, my main worries in connection with the modern Roman rite, as I have said already, are theological in nature. [/quote] My beef is that it often seems that you extend the banner of Platonism too broadly (this may be a false perception on my part). Certainly Platonic idealism is not orthodox, but there is a valid Christian appropriation of certain Platonic themes. Much of the Platonic tradition (in the broad sense) has been "baptized", and I'm not merely referring to Augustine, it would be absurd to suggest that Platonic themes are altogether lacking in Nyssa and other Eastern Fathers. I shall allow the exclusion of Clement, Origen, Pseudo-Dionysius, etc. from this discussion since I believe the point can be made even with the select handful of Fathers that are considered true pillars of Orthodoxy.
Apotheoun Posted July 9, 2007 Author Posted July 9, 2007 My beef is that you seem to think that because the Fathers used Greek philosophical terms, that they meant the same thing by them that the pagan Greeks did, which is false. For example: [i]Ousia[/i] and [i]hypostasis[/i] were synonyms in Greek philosophy. The Cappadocian Fathers altered their meanings radically.
Apotheoun Posted July 9, 2007 Author Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320681' date='Jul 9 2007, 01:22 PM']Much of the Platonic tradition (in the broad sense) has been "baptized", and I'm not merely referring to Augustine, it would be absurd to suggest that Platonic themes are altogether lacking in Nyssa and other Eastern Fathers. I shall allow the exclusion of Clement, Origen, Pseudo-Dionysius, etc. from this discussion since I believe the point can be made even with the select handful of Fathers that are considered true pillars of Orthodoxy.[/quote] I reject the idea that Plato's doctrine as been "baptized." Your viewpoint is very Western indeed, and I am not, nor will I ever again be, Western. P.S. - Origen is NOT a Church Father, and as far as St. Clement is concerned, he is not a Platonist. I recommend reading the book "Clement of Alexandria and the Beginnings of Christian Apophaticism."
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320691' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:26 PM']My beef is that you seem to think that because the Fathers used Greek philosophical terms, that they meant the same thing by them that the pagan Greeks did, which is false. For example: [i]Ousia[/i] and [i]hypostasis[/i] were synonyms in Greek philosophy. The Cappadocian Fathers altered their meanings radically.[/quote] Of course I don't think that Apotheoun. Well, I think some Fathers used terms in the obvious Neo-Platonic sense, but there are still contextual qualifications that ought to be considered. But as far as orthodoxy goes I am certainly opposed to the silly and naive view that the Christian use of terms originating in Greek philosophy ought to be understood simply within their Greek philosophical context.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320696' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:28 PM']I reject the idea that Plato's doctrine as been "baptized." Your viewpoint is very Western indeed, and I am not, nor will I ever again be, Western.[/quote] That's not what I said. I said that certain Platonic themes have been "baptized", not Plato's doctrine. There is a vast difference and I don't see how this can honestly be denied. If we limited this discussion to the early apologists alone I could adequately substantiate this point.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320696' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:28 PM']I reject the idea that Plato's doctrine as been "baptized." Your viewpoint is very Western indeed, and I am not, nor will I ever again be, Western.[/quote] Western? Really? It was the Greeks who first explicitly stated the idea that Plato was to the Greeks what Moses was to the Jews. It was the Greeks who first considered Plato's writings to be "from God", etc. Contrast this with Tertullian (a Latin) and we see the first unabashed statements of the "what has Athens to do with Jerusalem" viewpoint. "Philosophy, the mother of all heresies" is an historically Latin perspective.
Apotheoun Posted July 9, 2007 Author Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320701' date='Jul 9 2007, 01:29 PM']That's not what I said. I said that certain Platonic themes have been "baptized", not Plato's doctrine. There is a vast difference and I don't see how this can honestly be denied. If we limited this discussion to the early apologists alone I could adequately substantiate this point.[/quote] Right, and on this we disagree, because I do not believe that certain "Platonic themes" have been baptized. Once again, I accept the teaching of the [i]Synodikon[/i] on this issue, which is chanted on the Sunday of Orthodoxy. God bless, Todd
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320696' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:28 PM']I reject the idea that Plato's doctrine as been "baptized." Your viewpoint is very Western indeed, and I am not, nor will I ever again be, Western. P.S. - Origen is NOT a Church Father, and as far as St. Clement is concerned, he is not a Platonist. I recommend reading the book "Clement of Alexandria and the Beginnings of Christian Apophaticism."[/quote] It depends on how you define Platonism. I read Clement's Stromata a couple weeks ago (so it is fresh on my mind) and there is no doubt in my mind that one who has a problem with Terra's point would be at least equally scandalized by Clement's perspective (perhaps more so).
Apotheoun Posted July 9, 2007 Author Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320710' date='Jul 9 2007, 01:35 PM']It depends on how you define Platonism. I read Clement's Stromata a couple weeks ago (so it is fresh on my mind) and there is no doubt in my mind that one who has a problem with Terra's point would be at least equally scandalized by Clement's perspective (perhaps more so).[/quote] Read the book I recommended, because it will clarify issues for you. That said, if I must choose between your casual reading of the [i]Stromata[/i] in English, and a reading by an expert in the theology of Clement, I will go with the latter.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320709' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:35 PM']Right, and on this we disagree, because I do not believe that certain "Platonic themes" have been baptized. Once again, I accept the teaching of the [i]Synodikon[/i] on this issue, which is chanted on the Sunday of Orthodoxy. God bless, Todd[/quote] I've read those canons a number of times and there is nothing in them which really bothers me. I tend to understand them in the context of conciliar orthodoxy and patrology in general.
Apotheoun Posted July 9, 2007 Author Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320714' date='Jul 9 2007, 01:40 PM']I've read those canons a number of times and there is nothing in them which really bothers me. I tend to understand them in the context of conciliar orthodoxy and patrology in general.[/quote] I am glad that you have read them, and your interpretation is interesting, but as a Byzantine Christian I do not agree with your interpretation. God bless, Todd
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320712' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:36 PM']Read the book I recommended, because it will clarify issues for you. That said, if I must choose between your casual reading of the [i]Stromata[/i] in English, and a reading by an expert in the theology of Clement, I will go with the latter.[/quote] That's not fair. So I must read some book before we can discuss this issue? Seems like evasion to me. Why not simply state the conclusion of this book and perhaps back it up with some of the discussion in the text? My "casual" reading of the Stromata was supplemented by secondary sources and a partial reading of the Greek. But in any case you have not stated clearly what this book of yours concludes and how this is relevant to our discussion. I already know that Clement was not a Platonist in any strict sense of the word, but that Clement admired Platonic philosophy and considered it to be useful for theology seems beyond dispute.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320715' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:41 PM']I am glad that you have read them, and your interpretation is interesting, but as a Byzantine Christian I do not agree with your interpretation. God bless, Todd[/quote] You may be jumping the gun a bit as I have not stated my interpretation and my interpretation is to some extent informed by Eastern Christian theologians.
Apotheoun Posted July 9, 2007 Author Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320719' date='Jul 9 2007, 01:44 PM']That's not fair. So I must read some book before we can discuss this issue? Seems like evasion to me. Why not simply state the conclusion of this book and perhaps back it up with some of the discussion in the text? My "casual" reading of the Stromata was supplemented by secondary sources and a partial reading of the Greek. But in any case you have not stated clearly what this book of yours concludes and how this is relevant to our discussion. I already know that Clement was not a Platonist in any strict sense of the word, but that Clement admired Platonic philosophy and considered it to be useful for theology seems beyond dispute.[/quote] Life isn't fair. The problem I have with your views on Clement is that they reflect the position taken by scholars in the 19th century, much of which is now discredited.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 The list price on amazon for that text is $77.35.. I won't be able to buy it any time soon but I will read it at some point. After I have done so I will remind you of this conversation so that perhaps we can continue it more on your terms. Looks like a very interesting text.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320725' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:46 PM']Life isn't fair. The problem I have with your views on Clement is that they reflect the position taken by scholars in the 19th century, much of which is now discredited.[/quote] We have yet to get deep into any issues. My statements were informal which may suggest that my real intent was not conveyed.
KnightofChrist Posted July 9, 2007 Posted July 9, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320726' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:48 PM']The list price on amazon for that text is $77.35.. I won't be able to buy it any time soon but I will read it at some point. After I have done so I will remind you of this conversation so that perhaps we can continue it more on your terms. Looks like a very interesting text.[/quote] Visit your local Library!
Recommended Posts