Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1320729' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:51 PM']Visit your local Library![/quote]
Haha, the selection at the local library here is a joke, but I may have some luck at Franciscan's library. Thanks! :smokey:

Posted

It will come out in paperback eventually, and a substantially reduced price.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320732' date='Jul 9 2007, 01:52 PM']Haha, the selection at the local library here is a joke, but I may have some luck at Franciscan's library. Thanks! :smokey:[/quote]
I have a better library than FUS.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I must of course read the book before we can meaningfully discuss it, but I do find the brief description to be somewhat interesting. It speaks of "his [Clement's] indebtedness to Middle Platonism and its concept of God."

Middle Platonism can be an ambiguous term given the often ecclectic character of the thought of many persons typically grouped into that category. I have studied Middle Platonism (although I make no claim of expertise) and am pretty familiar in particular with the relationship between it and Neo-Pythagoreanism, Stoicism and the influence of MP upon Neo-Platonism. The first thing that comes to mind when I read that sentence from the book's description (in light of my recent reading of Clement) is the particular ways in which certain Middle Platonists began the trend of locating the Platonic "ideas" in the mind of God. I do indeed look forward to scooping up this text.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320735' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:55 PM']I have a better library than FUS.[/quote]
LOL! Too bad you're in Cali. :(

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320743' date='Jul 9 2007, 01:58 PM']I must of course read the book before we can meaningfully discuss it, but I do find the brief description to be somewhat interesting. It speaks of "his [Clement's] indebtedness to Middle Platonism and its concept of God."

Middle Platonism can be an ambiguous term given the often ecclectic character of the thought of many persons typically grouped into that category. I have studied Middle Platonism and am pretty familiar in particular with the relationship between it and Neo-Pythagoreanism, Stoicism and the influence of MP upon Neo-Platonism. The first thing that comes to mind when I read that sentence from the book's description (in light of my recent reading of Clement) is the particular ways in which certain Middle Platonists began the trend of locating the Platonic "ideas" in the mind of God. I do indeed look forward to scooping up this text.[/quote]
Yes, terminologically speaking, but the main thrust of the book is to highlight the distinction between the divine [i]ousia[/i] and the divine [i]dynamis[/i]. Clement rejects the Greek idea that [i]ousia[/i] can be known, just like the Cappadocians did a couple of centuries later.

The important point is not the fact that Greek terms are used, after all the Eastern Fathers were Greeks, and wrote and spoke in Greek, but that they radically altered and rejected the positions of the pagan philosophers about God. God, in essence, is beyond being, and so nothing postive can be said about the divine essence, nor can it be known at all. That is why the Eastern Fathers can say things like, "the divine essence is not the good," because God is in fact beyond the good. The good as a divine energy can be experienced, but the divine essence cannot be referred to as "the good."

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320734' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:54 PM']It will come out in paperback eventually, and a substantially reduced price.[/quote]
That's good to hear since I would much rather own a copy of this book.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320747' date='Jul 9 2007, 03:00 PM']Yes, terminologically speaking, but the main thrust of the book is to highlight the distinction between the divine [i]ousia[/i] and the divine [i]dynamis[/i]. Clement rejects the Greek idea that [i]ousia[/i] can be known, just like the Cappadocians did a couple of centuries later.

The important point is not the fact that Greek terms are used, after all the Eastern Fathers were Greeks, and wrote and spoke in Greek, but that they radically altered and rejected the positions of the pagan philosophers about God. God, in essence, is beyond being, and so nothing postive can be said about the divine essence, nor can it be known at all.[/quote]
It is my view, in spite of the complexity of patristic sources, that any truly Christian theology which speaks in terms of [i]ousia[/i] must utterly reject or modify the meaning of this term as it is used in Pagan philosophy. I consider the transcendence and absolute incomprehensibility of the Divine Essence to be nothing less than an essential feature of the Christian revelation. I find this to be explicitly affirmed in Roman dogma as well as the thought of Augustine, Thomas and others. There are semantic and conceptual difficulties between Orthodox and Roman Catholic theology that I do not wish to deny, but I am convinced of an underlying agreement.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320768' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:09 PM']It is my view, in spite of the complexity of patristic sources, that any truly Christian theology which speaks in terms of [i]ousia[/i] must utterly reject or modify the meaning of this term as it is used in Pagan philosophy. I consider the transcendence and absolute incomprehensibility of the Divine Essence to be nothing less than an essential feature of the Christian revelation. I find this to be explicitly affirmed in Roman dogma as well as the thought of Augustine, Thomas and others. There are semantic and conceptual difficulties between Orthodox and Roman Catholic theology that I do not wish to deny, but I am convinced of an underlying agreement.[/quote]
Interesting. I cannot say that I agree with you as far as St. Augustine and St. Thomas are concerned, but you have a right to your opinion.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1320775' date='Jul 9 2007, 03:15 PM']Interesting. I cannot say that I agree with you as far as St. Augustine and St. Thomas are concerned, but you have a right to your opinion.[/quote]
I am aware of antiquated and superficial interpretations of Augustine and Aquinas which understand them to be saying that the Divine Essence is comprehensible or even the object of direct knowledge (perhaps qualified by saying "through grace").

There is a somewhat common 19th century of Augustine's "illumination theory" which suggests contact with the Divine Essence in every act of certitudinal knowing. With a good bit of independent study and the authority of more objective and respectable scholars behind me I would say that such understandings are beyond absurd. They are anachronistic, eisegetical and blind readings which often force statements into the mouths of such Doctors that are in many cases the opposite of their actual views.

We could discuss it in depth if you like, as I consider my perspective on this matter to be beyond mere opinion.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1320784' date='Jul 9 2007, 02:20 PM']I am aware of antiquated and superficial interpretations of Augustine and Aquinas which understand them to be saying that the Divine Essence is comprehensible or even the object of direct knowledge (perhaps qualified by saying "through grace").

There is a somewhat common 19th century of Augustine's "illumination theory" which suggests contact with the Divine Essence in every act of certitudinal knowing. With a good bit of independent study and the authority of more objective and respectable scholars behind me I would say that such understandings are beyond absurd. They are anachronistic, eisegetical and blind readings which often force statements into the mouths of such Doctors that are in many cases the opposite of their actual views.

We could discuss it in depth if you like, as I consider my perspective on this matter to be beyond mere opinion.[/quote]
Thomas held that man, as a finite being, cannot [i]comprehend[/i] the divine essence. Nevertheless, for St. Thomas the beatific vision is a vision, although not comprehensive one, of the divine essence. The Eastern Fathers reject this idea entirely, because for them the vision of God is a participation in the divine energies, and not in the divine essence, which is not only beyond comprehension, but is utterly transcendent and unknowable. Moreover, the inability of man to see the divine essence in the theology of the Eastern Church is not based on man's finitude, but on the fact that God's essence is beyond being (i.e., [i]hyper-ousios[/i]).

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...