Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='tomasio127' post='1348950' date='Aug 3 2007, 05:45 PM']Dude, you don't know the right (actually, wrong) kind of Protestants. I've met plenty Catholic-haters. I've also meant plenty of others who don't hate Catholics, and are so kind as to grant that maybe, just maybe, some of us might go to Heaven, maybe.[/quote]


so have i. its cool that you were a "nice" protestant, but through my formerly protestant husband, i've been exposed to lots of protestants who don't necessarily HATE catholics, but who definitely don't consider us to be Christians on the way to heaven <_<

Posted

[quote]Heresy differs from apostasy. The apostate a fide abandons wholly the faith of Christ either by embracing Judaism, Islamism, Paganism, or simply by falling into naturalism and complete neglect of religion; the heretic always retains faith in Christ. Heresy also differs from schism. Schismatics, says St. Thomas, in the strict sense, are they who of their own will and intention separate themselves from the unity of the Church. The unity of the Church consists in the connection of its members with each other and of all the members with the head. Now this head is Christ whose representative in the Church is the supreme pontiff. And therefore [b]the name of schismatics is given to those who will not submit to the supreme pontiff[/b] nor communicate with the members of the Church subject to him. Since the definition of Papal Infallibility, schism usually implies the heresy of denying this dogma. Heresy is opposed to faith; schism to charity; so that, although all heretics are schismatics because loss of faith involves separation from the Church, not all schismatics are necessarily heretics, since a man may, from anger, pride, ambition, or the like, sever himself from the communion of the Church and yet believe all the Church proposes for our belief (II-II, Q. xxix, a. 1). Such a one, however, would be more properly called rebellious than heretical.
Catholic Encyclopedia, Heresy[/quote]
Given this portion of the article wouldn't it be more appropiate to refer to them as schismatics rather than heretics?

As for Jack Chick and anti-Catholic Protestants, the former definitely proposes a threat to uneducated, unformed Catholics in the United States, and since he has the largest book publishing company on Earth, the world as well. Just because most Protestants disagree with Chick doesn't make uneducated Catholics anymore capable of defending themselves against him. What will help them is educating Catholics about their faith so they can defend themselves not only against his tracts but the much larger and much more prevalent culture of death as well.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='tomasio127' post='1348950' date='Aug 3 2007, 08:45 PM']Dude, you don't know the right (actually, wrong) kind of Protestants. I've met plenty Catholic-haters. I've also meant plenty of others who don't hate Catholics, and are so kind as to grant that maybe, just maybe, some of us might go to Heaven, maybe.[/quote]

Those kinds of Protestants are definitely out there (such as our friend Budge), but I really don't think they're as significant as they used to be. Of course, in the rural South that may not be the case.

[quote name='Justin86' post='1349416' date='Aug 4 2007, 11:29 AM']As for Jack Chick and anti-Catholic Protestants, the former definitely proposes a threat to uneducated, unformed Catholics in the United States, and since he has the largest book publishing company on Earth, the world as well.[/quote]

Largest in the world? I'm skeptical of that claim :) I tried to find something on the Internet, but apparently a list of the largest publishers isn't easy to find.

VeniteAdoremus
Posted

I really think you can't put all of Protestantism in the same heretic box, so to speak (as others have said). There are for instance those that use the Apostle's Creed, including the "One, holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church", and would honestly want all Christian churches to be one (if only we would follow their theology, but still ;) ). I would say we are in schism with them, and it's a painful schism. We really should strive to be one.

Look at it from Christ's perspective, or from the Father's: you've got a couple of billion people you love, who try to follow you. Loads of them are misguided in some way or another (and I'm not exclusively referring to Protestants), but instead of honestly, charitably and lovingly trying to find the Way together they're busy calling each other names and trying to define just how bad the others are.

I'm not saying that we should meet them halfway or something. The Truth is, was, and will be in the Catholic Church. But calling them heretics, while maybe technically true, is in no way charitable, in no way loving, and in [b]no way at all[/b] helpful to a good conversation.

Charity and love should be argument enough by themselves, but if that isn't enough, consider the last one. No one wants to belong to a group who calls the group you're in a bunch of heretics. What they need to hear is why the Catholic Church holds the Truth, NOT why their church doesn't. And you can really tell the first without ever referring to the latter (while I'm not even mentioning that they know their churches' theology probably better than we do, and can argument it well).

Christ has told us to love one another. So let's. (And really, you don't walk up to a person and say "Your clothes are ugly - here, buy this cool t-shirt!", now do you?)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...