Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Our Response To The Motu Proprio And Future Change


Recommended Posts

God Conquers
Posted

I'm super blessed to be able to work for Christ in the area of the New Evangelization, as well as being an active and not-so-active member of this forum. As such I come into daily contact with dozens of the people who are the future of our Church across Canada and the United States. Basically, I think I have the pulse of modern Catholicism pretty well down.

I'm very happy that the Holy Father is moving to restore integrity of worship and belief to Our Mother, Christ's Bride: the Church. I hope that this trend continues in the form in which it has begun.

What is making me pause these days as I surf the 'net and talk to young Catholics around me is how we are responding to the Holy Father's initiatives.

I don't think it's the majority of people, but there are some who I think miss the point of what is happening in the Church right now. Movements and teachings in the Church take a long while to fiddler down, while being promulgated at a rapid pace from the magesterium. Take the Theology of the Body, for example... taught to us in the 1970's... taken up by us "in" Catholics in only the last 5 years or so, and still absent from the way of life of the majority.

I've been perturbed by a "fake" or "hasty" traditionalism (used in the negative sense) by some young people. It's coming to be sure from a place of healthy passion for our faith, but manifests itself in a rigidity and intellectualism which is way beyond the reach of any of our peers.

I've heard people state "all masses should be in latin", "only gregorian chant should be used in mass", and similar general statements about liturgy and doctrine.

What's weird about this is the people I'm hearing it from... and of course I have no way of gaging sincerity on the internet I'm extrapolating from my experiences in person... don't really believe it themselves. It's a "fake" traditionalism which is being proclaimed in an effort to seem cool or hardcore or whatever.

Upon examination of the claims, or a quick discussion it turns out that these people have no idea what the implication of their ideas are, nor do they know why they hold them.

I'm afraid that this will have a negative impact on these individuals, especially when it comes to their own call and ability to evangelize. They hold extreme views for no good reason, and separate themselves from the mainstream Church and make it very difficult for their peers to relate to them.

... maybe it's just a phase... youthful zeal?

What do you guys think? Am I way off base here? I know there is a general "traditional spirit" welling up from our generation, a spirit I in fact hold to, but the extremity of some of our bros and sis' is just grating on me...

We're in the Springtime brothers and sisters! JPII has exhorted us to shout the Gospel in the streets and public places, from the rooftops! Let's go out and bring'em in! Then let's teach'em how to pray.

Posted

Young people are the future of the Church, but they aren't the best people to look to for a model of how Catholicism should be lived. I speak from experience because I've been a young, new Catholic and went through all the "zeal" going from one extreme to another, including a phase where I wanted all Latin and no Bible except the Douay-Rheims and saying very harsh things against the Bishops, and so on. I think I get what you're saying, there is the sense that some young people want to bring back an idealized 1962, some picture of what Catholicism used to be in their minds. There has to be room for the faith to live and breathe and be given new forms, while staying firmly rooted in the essence of what came before. This is not 1962, or 1862, or 62. This is 2007, and we have to live the faith in the context of our times. I think there is a tendency toward legalism or moralism among young Catholics who genuinely want to live their faith, but just don't have the maturity to see how complex the world is, and how we have to be wise as serpents and simple as doves. This is all kind of general, but I hope you get the point. Tradition and traditional Catholic culture are great goods, and we should help build them organically, but also let the faith take root in our own times, with our own contributions.

[quote]If by 'restoration' is meant a turning back, no restoration of such kind is possible. The Church moves forward ahead to the Lord who is coming. No, there is no going back, nor is it possible to go back. Hence, there is no 'restoration' whatsoever in this sense. But if by 'restoration' we understand the search for a new balance after all the exaggerations of an indiscriminate opening to the world, after the overly positive interpretations of an agnostic and atheistic world, then a 'restoration' understood in this sense...is altogether desireable and, for that matter, is already in operation in the Church.

--Pope Benedict XVI[/quote]

God Conquers
Posted

Exactly what I'm talking about!

Thanks for the quote Era.

Oh Papa B, how could you be such a good pope!

Posted

The thing is that nostalgia makes things look shinier.

The Church is living. It is something that grows and moves forward. When Catholics of any age get stuck in a certain time, they tend to forget this.

The prof in one of my theology classes described it as the Church being like the cross. It goes up vertically towards God, and horizontally towards the future. If either is forgotten then there is no Cross.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1325895' date='Jul 12 2007, 02:42 PM']I think there is a tendency toward legalism or moralism among young Catholics who genuinely want to live their faith, but just don't have the maturity to see how complex the world is.[/quote]

This also tends to happen amongst certain subsections of Protestants, those same ones tending to lack intellectual depth and maturity in their faith also (often despite non-youth). Types who tend to see everything in black and white. Black and white exists, true, we mustn't pretend they don't, but they're not the only colors in the world.

Posted

I can totally understand why young Catholics are attracted to Tradition.

Just look at our culture. Very little (dare I say "nothing") in pop culture speaks to devout young Catholics. Practicing the great Traditions of the Church gives Catholics something to cherish, it creates culture, a unique Catholic culture. What (especially in this day and age) can compare to Traditions of the Church?

It's no surprise that young Catholics who want to live their faith are going to look to the treasure of Tradition.

Posted

What a great topic, thanks GC.


I also see this inflexibility, and I think some of it is due to age ... a faith that has been tested over time allows for some grey areas that a young, untested faith might not. Experience and an increased knowledge inform and shape faith pretty significantly.

And, I think a more mature faith is willing to admit the possibility of being wrong ... I think when I was younger it was harder for me to admit the possibility of being wrong, but now I totally see that as an option ... I mean, I am not wrong in trusting that the Church has things right, but I might be very wrong in my understanding of things. Not that I like being wrong. But the possibility is there ... and I think that means my faith is firmer, oddly enough. Because often a younger faith is rooted in being absolutely right, so being wrong somewhere shakes the foundations of the whole. Now, if I'm wrong on some point it doesn't negate my entire faith, so I'm more able to engage in dialogue and debate.

I'm not sure this is directly relevant to where you're going, but it is at least tangentially related. ;)

God Conquers
Posted

SJP,

Although I agree with you a bit on what modern culture has to offer (I don't think it's completely without its merits) I'm not sure what good for our world rigid traditionalism is.

There is very little attractiveness for the majority of people, and by neglecting the modern treasures of our Church we lose the opportunity to speak to our world in a life-giving way which can bring about lasting conversion and renewal.

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

I totally hear what you are saying, GC. I haven't really been blogging these days, but when I did I said something to that effect -- It was a post I made inspired by some video from YouTube that said "Everything old is new again." It's in some ways a really cute video, but it did make me think of a lot of young traditionalists that want to demonize modern things and glorify all that was before Vatican II. I got a few responses from people saying "wow, I'm glad someone said this" and THEN, of course, some kid posted a long diatriabe saying all the kinds of arrogant things that you can possibly expect -- along the "V2 and Novus Ordo smells of elderberries" lines.

Don't get me wrong. I LOVE the Latin Mass and traditional things. There are some things that are universal and traditional. But -- you CAN'T go back. Sometimes people get so "more Catholic than thou" and almost cultish about it, and that is not good. It is often a phase with people, usually before they discover what life and the world is really like. I went through it, too. Sometimes I am embarrassed by some of the things I said and did during that time. Radical pompousness and triamphantalism has a lot of spiritual pitfalls and believe me, God will be there to smack you down to reality.

I speak not of older, mature traditionalists but cultish youth that like throwing latin slogans around like nobody's business and REALLY love to bash those goshdarned Protestants and anything else that isn't Catholic, or Catholic enough.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='God Conquers' post='1326001' date='Jul 12 2007, 05:12 PM']SJP,

Although I agree with you a bit on what modern culture has to offer (I don't think it's completely without its merits) I'm not sure what good for our world rigid traditionalism is.

There is very little attractiveness for the majority of people, and by neglecting the modern treasures of our Church we lose the opportunity to speak to our world in a life-giving way which can bring about lasting conversion and renewal.[/quote]


I don't think that there's such a thing as "rigid traditionalism". The only way that genuine renewal and growth can be accomplished is by knowing who we are and where we come from. Unfortunately, I'm not sure that the modern Catholic world has a very good understanding of either.

The loss of our Tradition has resulted in a generation of Catholics who are without bearings. It's impossible for Catholic culture to flourish if we sever ourselves off from the traditions of our ancestors. Culture and tradition are inseparable.

Furthermore, I'm of the opinion that people will be more attracted to Traditional Catholicism than a Protestantized version of Catholicism. There is a sense of mystery and beauty in Traditional Catholicism that simply can't be matched.

Posted

There is a difference between being attracted to traditional Catholicism because of wanting a connection to and continuity with historical Catholicism and being attracted to traditionalism because of wanting to be cool, because everyone else is doing it.

And honestly, you can have a connection and continuity with historical Catholicism without immersing yourself in every aspect of traditionalism.

God Conquers
Posted

Agreed.

It is also wrong to think that protestants have nothing to teach us. Cause they do.

Posted

[quote name='God Conquers' post='1326079' date='Jul 12 2007, 05:55 PM']Agreed.

It is also wrong to think that protestants have nothing to teach us. Cause they do.[/quote]

Do you mean individual Protestant's or Protestant communities?

God Conquers
Posted

both

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1326022' date='Jul 12 2007, 03:22 PM']I totally hear what you are saying, GC. I haven't really been blogging these days, but when I did I said something to that effect -- It was a post I made inspired by some video from YouTube that said "Everything old is new again." It's in some ways a really cute video, but it did make me think of a lot of young traditionalists that want to demonize modern things and glorify all that was before Vatican II. I got a few responses from people saying "wow, I'm glad someone said this" and THEN, of course, some kid posted a long diatriabe saying all the kinds of arrogant things that you can possibly expect -- along the "V2 and Novus Ordo smells of elderberries" lines.

Don't get me wrong. I LOVE the Latin Mass and traditional things. There are some things that are universal and traditional. But -- you CAN'T go back. Sometimes people get so "more Catholic than thou" and almost cultish about it, and that is not good. It is often a phase with people, usually before they discover what life and the world is really like. I went through it, too. Sometimes I am embarrassed by some of the things I said and did during that time. Radical pompousness and triamphantalism has a lot of spiritual pitfalls and believe me, God will be there to smack you down to reality.

I speak not of older, mature traditionalists but cultish youth that like throwing latin slogans around like nobody's business and REALLY love to bash those goshdarned Protestants and anything else that isn't Catholic, or Catholic enough.[/quote]

Ash, great post...please start blogging again! I'll add you to my 'blogroll'.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Aww shucks, thanks Seven77. I somehow managed to let all of my old posts get lost somehow and I guess it took a lot of wind out of my sails. :ohno:

God Conquers
Posted

yeah Ash.

Seriously, I can relate to being passionate and young, but it seems that people aren't thinking about the implications of their "slogan throwing" as you call it.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='God Conquers' post='1326087' date='Jul 12 2007, 04:11 PM']both[/quote]

What truth does Protestant communities have that we can not learn first from Holy Mother Church?

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1326122' date='Jul 12 2007, 06:04 PM']What truth does Protestant communities have that we can not learn first from Holy Mother Church?[/quote]

I'm guessing he's referring to things like passion for Scripture and evangelism, as well as methods of conveying ancient truths (that they got from us) to the modern world.

KnightofChrist
Posted

That was my thought, yet as you agree both the teachings on passion for Scripture and evangelism, are found perfected in Mother Church.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...