KnightofChrist Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 But yes fake traditionalist are those that are not in union with the Pope and reject VII, and their wrong for that. But their are many real traditionalist loyal to His Holiness, and embrace VII in the light of tradition. It is these traditionalist along with His Holiness that are seeking a reform of the reform, a return to sacred. Which has been lost because of the abuse of VII's true teachings. This false spirit of VII is what the fake traditionalist see, but their absolutely wrong to attack Mother Church, one can not be a traditionalist if they are not loyal to His Holiness, and reject outright VII even in the light of tradition.
tojo Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1326139' date='Jul 12 2007, 06:11 PM']That was my thought, yet as you agree both the teachings on passion for Scripture and evangelism, are found perfected in Mother Church.[/quote] Of course, but for many people in our country, it is more visible in Protestants. Individual Catholics have things we can learn from the Protties..... the Church, not so much.
KnightofChrist Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='tomasio127' post='1326161' date='Jul 12 2007, 05:20 PM']Of course, but for many people in our country, it is more visible in Protestants. Individual Catholics have things we can learn from the Protties..... the Church, not so much.[/quote] I would agree in as much it is easier to learn these things from Protestants... but if a Catholic looks with a determend will they will find such things perfected in Holy Mother Church.
tojo Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1326168' date='Jul 12 2007, 06:25 PM']I would agree in as much it is easier to learn these things from Protestants... but if a Catholic looks with a determend will they will find such things perfected in Holy Mother Church.[/quote] Of course. Altho Protestants are a bad place to start if it's easier for that person, once they get on their feet though, they should definitely look to the Church's own storehouse of treasures. And there's no reason not to start with the Church, I'm just saying the Protties can help get you started also, they definitely can't take you nearly as far as the Church can though.
Totus Tuus Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 Thanks for the quote, Era. [quote]If by 'restoration' is meant a turning back, no restoration of such kind is possible. The Church moves forward ahead to the Lord who is coming. No, there is no going back, nor is it possible to go back. Hence, there is no 'restoration' whatsoever in this sense. But if by 'restoration' we understand the search for a new balance after all the exaggerations of an indiscriminate opening to the world, after the overly positive interpretations of an agnostic and atheistic world, then a 'restoration' understood in this sense...is altogether desireable and, for that matter, is already in operation in the Church. --Pope Benedict XVI[/quote] The more B-16 I read, the more I love him
God Conquers Posted July 12, 2007 Author Posted July 12, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1326168' date='Jul 12 2007, 06:25 PM']I would agree in as much it is easier to learn these things from Protestants... but if a Catholic looks with a determend will they will find such things perfected in Holy Mother Church.[/quote] This attitude is exactly what I'm talking about. The inability to accept that the Church has in practice been misstepping a bit. Why should I have to look with a "determined will" to find exhortation to study scripture and to evangelize. It should be self-evident. If I have to do extraordinary studying in order to find out these things then there has been a miscommunication between the desire of the Church and the life of the lay faithful. Refusing to acknowledge this and pointing the finger at modernism is a huge and detrimental cop out.
curtins Posted July 12, 2007 Posted July 12, 2007 I think SJP brings up a good point, and a possible explanation. Without getting into it, I think the motu proprio will bring a tremendous balance to things, so people who want to worship using the TLM can do so and those who like the NO can do that too, neither being alienated from the church.
goldenchild17 Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 [quote name='God Conquers' post='1325878' date='Jul 12 2007, 01:21 PM']I'm super blessed to be able to work for Christ in the area of the New Evangelization, as well as being an active and not-so-active member of this forum. As such I come into daily contact with dozens of the people who are the future of our Church across Canada and the United States. Basically, I think I have the pulse of modern Catholicism pretty well down. I'm very happy that the Holy Father is moving to restore integrity of worship and belief to Our Mother, Christ's Bride: the Church. I hope that this trend continues in the form in which it has begun. What is making me pause these days as I surf the 'net and talk to young Catholics around me is how we are responding to the Holy Father's initiatives. I don't think it's the majority of people, but there are some who I think miss the point of what is happening in the Church right now. Movements and teachings in the Church take a long while to fiddler down, while being promulgated at a rapid pace from the magesterium. Take the Theology of the Body, for example... taught to us in the 1970's... taken up by us "in" Catholics in only the last 5 years or so, and still absent from the way of life of the majority. I've been perturbed by a "fake" or "hasty" traditionalism (used in the negative sense) by some young people. It's coming to be sure from a place of healthy passion for our faith, but manifests itself in a rigidity and intellectualism which is way beyond the reach of any of our peers. I've heard people state "all masses should be in latin", "only gregorian chant should be used in mass", and similar general statements about liturgy and doctrine. What's weird about this is the people I'm hearing it from... and of course I have no way of gaging sincerity on the internet I'm extrapolating from my experiences in person... don't really believe it themselves. It's a "fake" traditionalism which is being proclaimed in an effort to seem cool or hardcore or whatever. Upon examination of the claims, or a quick discussion it turns out that these people have no idea what the implication of their ideas are, nor do they know why they hold them. I'm afraid that this will have a negative impact on these individuals, especially when it comes to their own call and ability to evangelize. They hold extreme views for no good reason, and separate themselves from the mainstream Church and make it very difficult for their peers to relate to them. ... maybe it's just a phase... youthful zeal? What do you guys think? Am I way off base here? I know there is a general "traditional spirit" welling up from our generation, a spirit I in fact hold to, but the extremity of some of our bros and sis' is just grating on me... We're in the Springtime brothers and sisters! JPII has exhorted us to shout the Gospel in the streets and public places, from the rooftops! Let's go out and bring'em in! Then let's teach'em how to pray.[/quote] nice post. I think there's a fair amount of truth to it. I do agree that it might take awhile for you guys to really catch on to it all, just as it did with totb. signed: Your Resident Fake Traditionalist
KnightofChrist Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 (edited) [quote name='God Conquers' post='1326202' date='Jul 12 2007, 05:41 PM']This attitude is exactly what I'm talking about.[/quote] Your mistaken, friend... [quote name='God Conquers' post='1326202' date='Jul 12 2007, 05:41 PM']The inability to accept that the Church has in practice been misstepping a bit. Why should I have to look with a "determined will" to find exhortation to study scripture and to evangelize. It should be self-evident. If I have to do extraordinary studying in order to find out these things then there has been a miscommunication between the desire of the Church and the life of the lay faithful. Refusing to acknowledge this and pointing the finger at modernism is a huge and detrimental cop out.[/quote] Please explain for me where Holy Mother Church the bride of Christ has been misstepping? Also, "determined will" = if they really cared its there to find in the church, not outside it. Its easy to find the Church's desire to read and preach the gospel not outside Her. Because outside Her is danger and darkness, parts of truths can be found but only Mother Church has the fullness of truth. Edited July 13, 2007 by KnightofChrist
Socrates Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1326054' date='Jul 12 2007, 03:39 PM']There is a difference between being attracted to traditional Catholicism because of wanting a connection to and continuity with historical Catholicism and being attracted to traditionalism because of wanting to be cool, because everyone else is doing it.[/quote] I think for most of these kids (or at least from what I've seen from some of the young trad lads on PM) it's if anything more of rebellion against the "mainstream" and wanting to be different from what "everyone else is doing." And I think this is healthy to a certain degree. After decades of the dominance of "liberal Catholicism" in America with its watered-down fluffy theology, moral relativism, and silly hippy-dippy liturgies, I think a "traditional" revival is long overdue. I think this "traditionalism" GC speaks of does have its pitfalls, particularly if it remains primarily "reactionary" and rebellious in its spirit. However, I think some of this youthful over-zealousness will be tempered by maturity as the kids grow up. Compared with a lot of forms of teenage rebellion, this is actually pretty positive. I don't think traditionalism should be discouraged with these kids, but rather tempered and guided into something postive for the Church. I think, overall, "liberal Catholicism" remains more of a problem in the Church. And I've seen a number of younger Catholics who refuse to have anything to do with traditional worship - which I find sad. Properly channeled, I think youthful traditionalism can have a positive effect on the Church.
Luthien Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 [quote name='Socrates' post='1326363' date='Jul 13 2007, 12:52 AM']I think for most of these kids (or at least from what I've seen from some of the young trad lads on PM) it's if anything more of rebellion against the "mainstream" and wanting to be different from what "everyone else is doing." And I think this is healthy to a certain degree. After decades of the dominance of "liberal Catholicism" in America with its watered-down fluffy theology, moral relativism, and silly hippy-dippy liturgies, I think a "traditional" revival is long overdue. I think this "traditionalism" GC speaks of does have its pitfalls, particularly if it remains primarily "reactionary" and rebellious in its spirit. However, I think some of this youthful over-zealousness will be tempered by maturity as the kids grow up. Compared with a lot of forms of teenage rebellion, this is actually pretty positive. I don't think traditionalism should be discouraged with these kids, but rather tempered and guided into something postive for the Church. I think, overall, "liberal Catholicism" remains more of a problem in the Church. And I've seen a number of younger Catholics who refuse to have anything to do with traditional worship - which I find sad. Properly channeled, I think youthful traditionalism can have a positive effect on the Church.[/quote] :applause:
Luthien Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 (edited) I didnt even click the post button twice. Edited July 13, 2007 by Luthien
KnightofChrist Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 [quote name='Socrates' post='1326363' date='Jul 12 2007, 09:52 PM']I think for most of these kids (or at least from what I've seen from some of the young trad lads on PM) it's if anything more of rebellion against the "mainstream" and wanting to be different from what "everyone else is doing." And I think this is healthy to a certain degree. After decades of the dominance of "liberal Catholicism" in America with its watered-down fluffy theology, moral relativism, and silly hippy-dippy liturgies, I think a "traditional" revival is long overdue. I think this "traditionalism" GC speaks of does have its pitfalls, particularly if it remains primarily "reactionary" and rebellious in its spirit. However, I think some of this youthful over-zealousness will be tempered by maturity as the kids grow up. Compared with a lot of forms of teenage rebellion, this is actually pretty positive. I don't think traditionalism should be discouraged with these kids, but rather tempered and guided into something postive for the Church. I think, overall, "liberal Catholicism" remains more of a problem in the Church. And I've seen a number of younger Catholics who refuse to have anything to do with traditional worship - which I find sad. Properly channeled, I think youthful traditionalism can have a positive effect on the Church.[/quote]
Resurrexi Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 (edited) [quote name='SJP' post='1326085' date='Jul 12 2007, 04:05 PM']Do you mean individual Protestant's or Protestant communities?[/quote] They don't have anything to teach us. All elements of truth in Protestantism come from the Catholic Church. BTW, I agree with much of this tread. Many young trads I know (including myself) became such because of rebellious and prideful reasons and basically ignored anything that happened after 1962, while not denying its validity. But to remain a true traditional Catholic, I had to learn humility and obedience to the Supreme Pontiff and the Bishops in communion with him. Edited July 13, 2007 by StThomasMore
God Conquers Posted July 13, 2007 Author Posted July 13, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1326281' date='Jul 12 2007, 08:32 PM']Your mistaken, friend... Please explain for me where Holy Mother Church the bride of Christ has been misstepping? Also, "determined will" = if they really cared its there to find in the church, not outside it. Its easy to find the Church's desire to read and preach the gospel not outside Her. Because outside Her is danger and darkness, parts of truths can be found but only Mother Church has the fullness of truth.[/quote] You are talking as if the Church's actions are infallible, not her doctrine. The slide in Catholic belief and practice began well before the Second Vatican Council. It's only now that we are regaining the missionary and catechetical attitude we need to stem the tide of unbelief. You think that if the majority of Catholics don't believe in the Eucharist, practice birth control and don't even know how to answer the basic question "how do you get into heaven?" that it's 100% their fault? We're not to blame at all as a Church? That attitude is beyond belief and logic. It's backwards and harmful. We need to have the humility to say we have weaknesses, even as the One True Church.
KnightofChrist Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 (edited) We're not to blame the Church at all, this is nether backward, harmful or illogical. She is the bride of Christ she is the body of Christ, the Church IS CHRIST, they are one flesh, the Church is in fact divine she can not sin, because Christ can not sin. So no we are not to blame the Church at all, not her dogmas and not her actions, her actions are Christ's actions. The problems in the world are due to the sins of men, be they children of God, or of the devil, just because those men may or may not be in authority in the Church does not make their actions the Church's actions. The slide in Catholic belief and practice may well have began well before VII, but the avalanche began in the 60's with the false spirit of VII. It is the casting away of this false spirit and picking up sacred tradition, the true meaning of VII that has helped stem the tide of unbelief, and unawareness. We inneed have weaknesses, but no the One True Church does not and will never have any weakness ever, period. Edited July 13, 2007 by KnightofChrist
God Conquers Posted July 13, 2007 Author Posted July 13, 2007 Really? hmmmm... [quote]Unitatis redintegratio, 6: “Christ summons the Church, as she goes her pilgrim way, to that continual reform of which she always has need, insofar as she is a human institution here on earth.”[/quote]
KnightofChrist Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 Yes, really Mother Church is the body of Christ and He is the Head, and Christ can not sin. She is not a human institution, as you would use the VII quote. I believe you are taking the quote out of context. "insofar as she is a human institution here on earth" I think speaks of the offices men may hold. But again if they sin or make mistakes their actions are not the Church's actions. The Church is divine the Church is Christ.
KnightofChrist Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 6 And it came to pass, as I was going, and drawing nigh to Damascus at midday, that suddenly from heaven there shone round about me a great light: 7 And falling on the ground, I heard a voice saying to me: [color="#8B0000"]Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me?[/color] 8 And I answered: Who art thou, Lord? And he said to me: [color="#8B0000"]I am Jesus of Nazareth, whom thou persecutest.[/color] Saul was persecuting the Church, Christ makes it clear the church is also His body, He is the Church the Church is He.
KnightofChrist Posted July 13, 2007 Posted July 13, 2007 This no doubt looks like a debate, so I suggest to discuss this further here... [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=70352"]What Is The Bride Of Christ?, Body of Christ or human institution[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now