Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Holy Ghost or Holy Spirit?   

54 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Both are acceptable, but Spirit is most correct these days, since the meaning of ghost has changed a bit over the centuries....

Chiquitunga
Posted (edited)

[quote name='prose' post='1331450' date='Jul 16 2007, 07:39 PM']Holy Ghost makes me think of a dinner prayer my dad said once:

"Father, Son, Holy Ghost: whoever eats fastest gets the most. Amen."

:hehe:[/quote]

Me too! St. Bernadette's brother said that in the movie, [i]Song of Bernadette[/i]. ^_^

I pretty much always use Holy Spirit, as that's all I ever heard until recently. I think it's a better translation of the Latin really.

But in some traditional hymns like, "Come Holy Ghost, Creator Blest .." I think it definitely should not be changed to "Come Holy Spirit," as I've seen some translations. :/ It sounds totally off then.

Edited by Margaret Clare
Posted

Normally I use Holy Spirit, but I voted both. I did have to explain it to my catechism class this past year, though I used Bible Lessons (Kingdom of God series) a couple of times in the year, and of course they said Holy Ghost. The kids thought it was hilarious.

Holy Ghost has Germanic origins
If we wanted it to have Latin origins, it would be Saint Spirit
Holy Spirit is mixed up, like all of English.

Posted

i use Holy Spirit cuz thats what i grew up with.. but just like what everyone said.. it doesnt really matter..

Posted

I prefer "Holy Spirit". I't what I am used to and it seems a bit more formal and less "buddy-ish".

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1331447' date='Jul 16 2007, 10:38 PM']I use Holy Spirit most often, but I voted both, because I have used both.[/quote]

Me, too. Actually when I THINK about it I can't figure out which one I use more often. But I do use both.

Posted

Personally I use "Holy Spirit" but in principle I think both are acceptable, which is why I voted EITHER.

I'd be somewhat cautious about using the "Holy Ghost" especially when you are trying to evangelise people, due to the connotation that (now) comes with the word ghost. It takes an opportunity away for a cheap shot against the faith to be made ^_^

God Conquers
Posted

I call him "The HS".


I'm all about "the HS".

Man... "HS" man... "HS" man... man.

"HS" it up!

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1331185' date='Jul 16 2007, 05:58 PM']Which do you use when referring to addressing the third Person of the Holy Trinity in English?[/quote]

I call him Angelino.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

Holy Ghost. Used to use Spirit exclusively until I converted and then I switched. Not exactly sure why, I think it just sorta happened. All the people at my church use Ghost and that's how we say it during the rosary before all our Masses etc. so I went with it. Holy Spirit, and this is just me and don't intend to make any judgments so don't take it as such, Holy Spirit kinda sorta seems to have a new-agey sort of ring to it nowadays. Don't really have much to back that up with, mostly just the feeling I get when I hear it a lot. For me, Ghost just seems to have a more awe-inspiring meaning to it. I think it correctly invokes the feeling of holy fear that we should have for God.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

whatever cognitive definitions we ascribe to the words, germanic words tend to have more concrete feels to them and french based words tend to have more abstract feels to them in the English language (has to do with the fact that the germanic ones survived illegally underground and thus were used with more direct, pointed, and sincere things)

even comparing it including what we have learned to cognitively assosiate the word with we have "ghost" as something more personal and concrete; "spirit" as something which is more of an abstract concept. a ghost, whether he be Casper or the Holy Ghost, elicits from the hearer a concrete personal subject; a 'spirit' is much wider abstract conceptual thing, generally speaking... not in what we think about when we hear the word, but in our visceral emotional direct response to the word; all the actual conceptual connotations are much more changeable than these visceral responses to the words, which stay pretty static in language; which is why english speakers tend to use germanic words when being sincere and drawn out french words when being precise and guarded about what they want to say.

I think they both have their usages depending on in which sense you intend to speak... but I totally use "ghost" for prayer based on this reasoning.

goldenchild17
Posted

nice post, I never really considered that.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Note: ghost comes from German "geist", which is equivalent to the Latin "spiritus".

For me, it depends on context which I use. Typically, in conversation or theological writing or whatnot, I use "Holy Spirit", as it fits better with modern English.

When I pray, it's different. I prefer a much more formal, older language for prayer. I tend to either pray in Latin or the type of English found in the Douay-Rheims bible. My Latin vocabulary and grammar is limited at best, and though I know how to say the prayers of the mass, the rosary, etc. in Latin, I tend to do mental prayer and the breviary in English, but an older form. In this type of English, "Holy Ghost" sounds and feels more formal. I like having a form of speech set aside for prayer alone.

I get some funny looks from people when I'm praying in groups, and I'm leading a decade of the rosary or something, and end it with "Glory be to the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Ghost..." (even more funny looks from "Gloria Patri..."), but I don't think it really bothers any one. Except baby-boomer liberals. And in that case, it's a good thing :)

Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1341569' date='Jul 26 2007, 04:58 PM']I get some funny looks from people when I'm praying in groups, and I'm leading a decade of the rosary or something, and end it with "Glory be to the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Ghost..." (even more funny looks from "Gloria Patri..."), but I don't think it really bothers any one. Except baby-boomer liberals. And in that case, it's a good thing :)[/quote]

I get looks for using "thee" and "thy" in the Hail Mary.... lol, I bet you get looks busting out the Latin!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...