Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Kindergarten Socialism


Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

If its like my school district there are not enough books for the kids to take home.

homeschoolmom
Posted
:(
Posted

Groo the Wanderer (Hi Joseph) had a great Idea....Tag everything so your Kinder gets her stuff back....That is my plan...I do not want to explain to my daughter why Suzy got her High School Musical folder and pencils....either Jessie gets them or Suzy is going home thinking that her new name is Jessie :scratchhead:

Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1349069' date='Aug 3 2007, 07:13 PM']I will take a Catholic school that that spends less than half of what a public school spends per student any day. Any the Catholic school provides not only a better education but a moral one as well.[/quote]


umm, if you're lucky enough to FIND one that has a moral education. the state of catholic schools in american is p-o-o-r. with a capital P. :ohno:

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1349364' date='Aug 4 2007, 07:20 AM']Sooooo... they have no homework?[/quote]

Oh they have homework. The prinicpal requires that teachers give them homework. The kids just don't do it.

Posted

Well some of it may be practicality. You may not want a 5 year old to have all his supplies with him at all times, last time I remeber there was like a whole garbage bag full of stuff the kids have to bring. Every folder would be writen on and glued together, ripped up, and then when It came time to use the stuff it wouldn't work. But if every kid brings a box of crayons and a glue stick, the teacher can collect them, put them away, and pass out each a glue stick and a box of crayons when the kids need them recollect them when they are done. Does it really matter if your kid uses the exact construction paper you bought?
I more understand personal items like pencils, folders, and notbooks. But I highly doubt someone is going to take away a kids My Little Pony folder and give it to the girl in the next desk, I think teachers are a little smarter than that. I mean really....kid needs to blow his nose....."Wait Johnny...you can't use that tissue, its Sara's....wait....let me find your box of tissue.....it was just here.....oh...no...that was Jimmy's. You must be out...I'm sorry...but you can't use Sara's....her mom might sue the district!"

homeschoolmom
Posted

I'm not talking about snacks, tissues and the like that is brought in with the understanding it's for community use. I'm talking about notebooks and folder etc.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1349873' date='Aug 4 2007, 07:42 PM']I'm not talking about snacks, tissues and the like that is brought in with the understanding it's for community use. I'm talking about notebooks and folder etc.[/quote]

My point is at that age almost everything IS for community use out of practicality. They don't take away their bookbags and mix them up do they? All I am saying is I think this practice is more about practicality than anything else. But I agree the teachers should let parents know what will remain with their child and what goes in the supply room.

Posted (edited)

hsm, unless you spoke with a parent who knew for sure, I think you may have misinterpreted the policy, a policy that is usually cleared up on "Meet the Teacher" night or the first week of school.

However, if it is happening, the folders need to given back to the students if it's thiers.

However I pick up everything as well, which is my policy. However most binders, etc have thier names on it, (THANK YOU PARENTS!) so it's not a big deal when we distribute them back to thier owners. The first year I didn't know what I was doing, so the kids kept the supplies and all the kids supplies were all eaten up in the first 6 weeks of school with everything else coming out of my pocket.

Pencils- I have a strict rule. If you have a fancy one, take it home, if you are not willing to share. MOst of the time they end up on the floor and any child will pick it up and use it, then you have the "She STOLE my PENCIL!!!!" scenerio that doesn't need to happen. You have tears and wails and cries........ All pencils will be shared no matter what. If they have names on it, it goes home and I will supply that child pencils. you have no idea how much time gets eaten up (if you are lucky you'll be aware of it) by a child looking for "his" pencil, or "his" was lost, or "someone is using MY pencil" or refusing to use any other pencil but thiers. I start off with almost 500 new pencils every year that I order. Good ones too. Most parents rarely buy good ones, most can't even be in a sharpener before it's eaten up without even being used!

I order new pencils by Christmas. Almost 600 more and they are gone by the end of the year. And parents, heads up: they take pencils from the classroom ALL the time because they don't have anything at home to do their homework with.

Good teachers will distribute accordingly and most do. If not, talk with your child's teacher. Conferences are readily available almost any day of the week, and most teachers would love to clear the air.

As far as vendors, they are making a million bucks off of their 10 dollar folders that are really generic by disguise. If you have only 250 dollars to spend, why would you want to spend it on only one class set of folders, and other items you can get elsewhere for a bargain? In the defense of teachers, we bargain shop. If we find another vendor that sells for a better price, we'll do it. If not, we are stuck buying only 3 items from Lake shore because everything in there is expensive.

And if the list says RED folder, GREEN folder and you choose HIgh school musical instead, your child will be able to keep the folder, but will still have to be issued a color coordinated folder that is more than likely coming out of the teacher's pocket. It happens EVERY YEAR. I already bought 25 of each primary color (also because the wear and tear throughout the year) but it will sit in your childs desk unused unless they want to use it for whatever they want. The older they are the easier it is for them to put it to use in place of the colored folder.

alot of parents talk without talking with teachers, and if your that upset about it, go and find out. Find out before you believe your child. If you believe half of what your child tells you about us, we'll believe only 1/4 of what they say about you.

I can almost guarantee that no teacher takes those folders. Thats just stupid and insane and a battle that (rightly) can't be won.

Edited by jmjtina
Posted (edited)

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1346284' date='Aug 1 2007, 03:56 PM']What I found most interesting in this coversation is that they don't tell the parents in advance that these things will go into a corporate collection for the entire class... It's learned by experience.[/quote]

because parents feel they have a right to say how a teacher runs her classroom and if they are already talking like this, it's like talking to a brick wall trying to explain to them that their angels will shred everything up before they have a chance to use it.

don't peg teachers as dictators. Even the worst teachers like to keep their parents happy.

We are not thieves. We do not steal your children's school supplies. Surprisingly, I have those few parents who always ask if I am ever low on anything, they will buy. They are true angels of mercy. If it weren't for them, I'd probably be paying to teach.

Bottom line, your child will learn and use their own labeled necessities. I just hate the tone of this thread.

Edited by jmjtina
Posted (edited)

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1346986' date='Aug 1 2007, 11:05 PM']:yes:

If my kids were in school, I would buy them each a gross of pencils that said, "Please return to ___ " with their names on it... They'd have a lifetime supply.[/quote]


You wouldn't be the first.

I am convinced that due to schoolchildren, that there will be no more trees in the next 10 years. You can NEVER have enough pencils!!!!! (maybe kindergarten) And then administration has the nerve to ask WHY I need a 60 buck sharpener!!! Cheap will break down and burn up. I had to choose between a sharpener and the rest of my supplies one year.

I chose the sharpener.

I hate sharpening.

Lets say you have 22 children in a classroom. Each child uses approximately 4-6 pencils a day. (approximately 744 pencils a year.....and you buy 20 in the beginning of the year and expect that to last? Especially if your child CHEWS the pencils!!!) They start the day with new one from a group bucket, and it gets dull or breaks, so they grab a new one from the group bucket without wasting time. (Sharpening during the day is out of the question, due to noise, interruption during learning time, and the fact that they sharpen and sharpen and sharpen and don't know when to stop..........) This continues until the end of the day. So by the end of the day you have 88 broken or dull pencils that need to be sharpened with maybe 1/4 are too short or broken to use again.

And mechanical pencils are a nightmare for young children.

Did I mention I hated sharpening? But hey, if I want my kids to get the most out of the day, have a smooth day of learning, not waste precious time and have those kids ready to start the day, I will do what I have to do.

That's enough of my ranting.

It's out of my system now. Proceed.

Oh and just for the record, most parents are truly understanding of what I do and why I do it. In the end, all they want is the best education for their child, and when we explain what we do and why we do it, they are 100% with us. Those irate and irrational parents are few. As long as we have the right reasons of doing what we are doing, everything works out!

Edited by jmjtina
homeschoolmom
Posted
:huh: :blink:

[quote name='jmjtina' post='1350110' date='Aug 5 2007, 04:17 AM']don't peg teachers as dictators. Even the worst teachers like to keep their parents happy.

We are not thieves. We do not steal your children's school supplies.[/quote]

That was certainly not my intention..... I used to be a classroom teacher. I know about first graders and their need to sharpen... and I'm aware of parents sending in crappy supplies or stuff that's not on the list (when I was being specific with my list)... and I taught in a private school-- my classroom budget was pretty much whatever I wanted to spend out of my pocket. I know all about that.

But I never seemed to have trouble collecting up supplies from my students at the beginning of the year and giving it back to the same student at mid-year.
Posted

Wow jmjtina...you really hate sharpeners....

I think that every parent is thankfull to all of their childrens teachers...You have them longer then we do. For homeschool teachers I personally would goes crazy! All my kids 24-7 all year long..NO, NO, NO :ohno:

I work at an Elem. School here in Arlington and i too would rather send most of my budget of a $60 sharpener to save my nerves.

Posted

I'm in favor of everyone chipping in $25 and having the school buy generic supplies for everyone. Kids really could care less about fancy stuff, as long as everyone is the same, and sending them to school with 30 pencils at the beginning of the year is silly because they roll around inside their desk (I know, it happened to me). Take away what creates distractions (High School Musical folders, Harry Potter pencils...) and we can focus on actually learning something, like, oh I don't know....MATH!

Don't get me started on school funding...apparently building a wall to keep out immigrants is more important than training our kids to be more competitive in the global job market.

Posted (edited)

Socialism implies a dictator.

I've worked in private and public schools, so I know pretty much the difference between the two, and there is a BIG difference. If you never had trouble, kudos. But that is not the norm, even though I truly wish it was!

Also, I'm looking for a volunteer to sharpen pencils. Please apply within.

Woot!!!!!!! WOOOOOT!!!!!!!!! We have another Texas teacher in the house!!!!! I teach in South Texas!!!!!

I found that having a good sharpener was worth EVERY PENNY!!!!!!!!! :P

Edited by jmjtina
Posted

I love sharpening pencils. Really. Next time I'm in the great land of TX I will stop by and sharpen for an afternoon. ;)

homeschoolmom
Posted

I agree that a good sharpener is worth its weight in gold. Mechanical pencils and those kind that have pencil tips that you shove in the end are a pain.... they should be forbidden from the planet.

But I don't agree that "socialism implies a dictator." Many countries are socialist without being dictatorships. I didn't call the teachers "dictators," "fascists" or "Nazis." Socialism implies redistribution of goods. That's what the thread is about. Not dictatorships....

Posted (edited)

Socialism, IMHO, implies a Karl Marx.

which is why I took offense.

and also because others on this thread have said it was wrong to take up school supplies, and have called it stealing, without regards of what really goes on in the classroom.

Edited by jmjtina
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1350307' date='Aug 5 2007, 12:44 PM']I agree that a good sharpener is worth its weight in gold. Mechanical pencils and those kind that have pencil tips that you shove in the end are a pain.... they should be forbidden from the planet.

But I don't agree that "socialism implies a dictator." Many countries are socialist without being dictatorships. I didn't call the teachers "dictators," "fascists" or "Nazis." Socialism implies redistribution of goods. That's what the thread is about. Not dictatorships....[/quote]
In this context, I can see where she is coming from. The way in which the situation was set up, it implies a teacher who has no or little regard for the personal property of students and simply gathers it all up for redistribution at a later date as the teacher sees fit. These are dictator-ish qualities, and it's against this particular scenario that Tina is arguing, not the concept of socialism in general.

Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1350302' date='Aug 5 2007, 11:38 AM']I love sharpening pencils. Really. Next time I'm in the great land of TX I will stop by and sharpen for an afternoon. ;)[/quote]


:P

I thought I liked it, but that was before I found out that they overheat and you have to wait 30 minutes for them to cool down and start all over again!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...