Resurrexi Posted August 23, 2007 Posted August 23, 2007 (edited) What exactly does abstaining "from blood, and from things strangled" [cf. Acts 15:20] entail for Eastern Catholics who follow the traditional custom of their churches? And when exactly did the Latin Church discontinue this custom? Edited August 23, 2007 by StThomasMore
Apotheoun Posted August 23, 2007 Posted August 23, 2007 It means that an animals blood must be drained after it is slaughtered. The West maintained this practice up until the beginning of the second millennium.
kateri05 Posted August 23, 2007 Posted August 23, 2007 does that mean that eastern catholics only buy kosher meat?
Apotheoun Posted August 23, 2007 Posted August 23, 2007 Many Eastern Catholics no longer follow the Traditional rules for fast and abstinence, so you will find many who are indistinguishable from Latin Catholics and Protestants on this issue.
Resurrexi Posted August 23, 2007 Author Posted August 23, 2007 Does this bind under pain of mortal sin in most Eastern Catholic Churches?
Apotheoun Posted August 23, 2007 Posted August 23, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1368579' date='Aug 22 2007, 09:50 PM']Does this bind under pain of mortal sin in most Eastern Catholic Churches?[/quote] The Eastern Churches do not operate in that manner. In other words, the canons are not normally seen as "laws" requiring punishment if a person fails to fulfill them properly; instead, they are guides (i.e., like a ship's rudder) in the development of the spiritual life. Moreover, there is also a principle called "economia," which allows the spiritual confessor to take into account a man's state in the spiritual life at a particular moment, exempting him from some things for a time, in order to allow him to progress to a higher spiritual level, so that he may fulfill the canons more perfectly later. That said, a theological truth, like the veiling of women while in the presence of the angels during the liturgy, is not subject to economy.
kateri05 Posted August 23, 2007 Posted August 23, 2007 wait a sec, if veiling of women is not subject to economy because it is divinly revealed through scripture, then why is abstaining from blood not subject either, since it is also divinely revealed? that seems to be contradictory. also, on a practical note, i'm genuinely curious on how one ensures that one's meat isn't strangled. kosher meat would work, but what about ham and pork roast? i'm sorry if this seems facecious, but i'm really interested
Apotheoun Posted August 23, 2007 Posted August 23, 2007 [quote name='kateri05' post='1368600' date='Aug 22 2007, 10:20 PM']wait a sec, if veiling of women is not subject to economy because it is divinly revealed through scripture, then why is abstaining from blood not subject either, since it is also divinely revealed? that seems to be contradictory. also, on a practical note, i'm genuinely curious on how one ensures that one's meat isn't strangled. kosher meat would work, but what about ham and pork roast? i'm sorry if this seems facecious, but i'm really interested [/quote] I do not believe that abstaining from eating blood is open to eonomy either, but I do know that some priests are treating it that way. As I said, many Eastern Catholics are Latinized. In answer to your second comment, I do not eat a lot of meat now as it is, but I buy kosher meat when I do eat it. God bless, Todd P.S. - Abstaining from eating blood and the veiling of women are both contained in scripture, as such they should not be open to economy. My response to StThomasMore was focused upon what the West calls "Canon Law" and what the East normally calls "The Rudder" (i.e., the post-biblical conciliar canons).
Norseman82 Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 What about [i]czarnina[/i] (duck blood soup), which is a Polish dish?
Aloysius Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 The west takes St. Peter's dream where Our Lord declared all foods clean as meaning that we are not bound by these dietary laws. The passage in acts describes the discipline imposed by the Council of Jerusalem, I believe. Whilst that discipline may be laudable in place still today in the East, it is my opinion that this is not a mandate of scripture like the veiling of women is, but the description of a fact that the Early Church bound this practice upon the Church at that time. Whereas St. Paul directly addresses the reader of scripture, so it is a different matter altogether.
Apotheoun Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1374685' date='Aug 31 2007, 12:00 AM']The west takes St. Peter's dream where Our Lord declared all foods clean as meaning that we are not bound by these dietary laws. The passage in acts describes the discipline imposed by the Council of Jerusalem, I believe. Whilst that discipline may be laudable in place still today in the East, it is my opinion that this is not a mandate of scripture like the veiling of women is, but the description of a fact that the Early Church bound this practice upon the Church at that time. Whereas St. Paul directly addresses the reader of scripture, so it is a different matter altogether.[/quote] I cannot agree with you on this issue, because the West never asserted the idea that Peter's revelation, which occurred before the Synod of Jerusalem, and which said nothing about eating blood, somehow allows Christians to ignore the later divinely inspired injunction against eating blood. In fact, for the first thousand years of Christian history East and West agreed that eating blood was unacceptable, but sadly beginning in the 11th century the West began to break from scriptural tradition on this issue. That said, the text of Acts is clear, for St. James, under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, said that Christians must "abstain from the pollutions of idols and from unchastity and from what is strangled and from blood," and nothing in the scriptural texts, or within the Apostolic Tradition, indicates that this is simply a temporary requirement.
Aloysius Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 What then do you make of St. Paul's command that the only reason to abstain from such meat is so that your neighbor does not stumble?
Apotheoun Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1374873' date='Aug 31 2007, 10:43 AM']What then do you make of St. Paul's command that the only reason to abstain from such meat is so that your neighbor does not stumble?[/quote] It must be read in the light of what the Fathers called the "scopos" of scripture (i.e. revelation understood according to the whole context of salvation history). So, the purity that comes by abstaining from meats offered to idols is not simply related to preventing another person from falling away from the faith, and to read St. Paul in that manner is nothing else but a form of Protestant minimalism. Also, as I have pointed out several times already, St. Paul (and St. Peter in his vision) says nothing about eating blood, and so the quotations are not applicable in trying to abrogate the teaching of the Holy Spirit at the Synod of Jerusalem, which forms a unified whole (i.e., abstaining from the pollutions of idols and from unchastity and from what is strangled and from blood). Scripture is not to be pitted against scripture. Finally, bearing in mind the biblical teaching on the sacred character of blood (i.e., that life itself is contained in blood), it follows that for the Christian the only blood that can be consumed is Christ's blood.
Apotheoun Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1374873' date='Aug 31 2007, 10:43 AM']. . . the only reason to abstain from such meat is so that your neighbor does not stumble?[/quote] I do not believe that that is the "only" reason for not eating food offered to idols, any more than I believe that it is "only" by faith that a man is saved.
Romans1513 Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 What is typically meant by "blood and all things strangled"? ... I mean, like do any of the common meats I eat (like steak, chicken, pork, hamburger, etc.) fall into that category/ how do I know what this involves?
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 So are we sinning by eating such foods?
farglefeezlebut Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 If the Church allows it, doesn't saying it's wrong contradict belief in infallability? I am not saying this to make an argument. I don't know much about this issue and I'm curious.
Apotheoun Posted August 31, 2007 Posted August 31, 2007 [quote name='thedude' post='1375010' date='Aug 31 2007, 01:59 PM']So are we sinning by eating such foods?[/quote] Western Christians need to move away from the constant emphasis upon sin and punishment. In the East one does things, e.g., not eating blood, or -- in the case of women -- wearing a veil during prayer, etc., because it deepens ones commitment to Christ and incarnates His life into our own being, and not because of some canonical penalty. Theology must not be reduced to canon law. Salvation (i.e., [i]theosis[/i]) is an ontologically transformative process, and not a legal declaration.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted September 1, 2007 Posted September 1, 2007 (edited) So is this something westerners just started doing or was there any official declaration from the western Church that led to the current state of affairs? On a related note, what common foods are forbidden by this Biblical directive? Edited September 1, 2007 by thedude
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now