Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

On Abstaining "from Blood, And From Things Strangled"


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='1375270' date='Aug 31 2007, 06:51 PM']So is this something westerners just started doing or was there any official declaration from the western Church that led to the current state of affairs?

On a related note, what common foods are forbidden by this Biblical directive?[/quote]
There was no official declaration from the Western Church on this issue; instead, people in the West simply began to ignore this bibilical directive (at first sporadically) beginning around the 11th century.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1375334' date='Aug 31 2007, 08:34 PM']There was no official declaration from the Western Church on this issue; instead, people in the West simply began to ignore this bibilical directive (at first sporadically) beginning around the 11th century.[/quote]

What is the official position of the bishops of the Eastern Catholic Churches?

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1375361' date='Aug 31 2007, 08:07 PM']What is the official position of the bishops of the Eastern Catholic Churches?[/quote]
I am not aware of any decree issued by the Ruthenian bishops in the United States that would alter the divinely inspired prohibition against the eating of blood**, but many Eastern Catholics -- especially in America -- have been heavily Latinized, and so the actual practice of a large number of the lay faithful is probably indistinguishable from that of the Latins.

The text below gives the rules for fasting in the Byzantine Churches:

[quote][b]Traditional Byzantine Rite Fast and Abstinence: Russian rite, Ruthenian rite, Melkite rite, Greek rite [/b]

([i]Cf. Fr. R. Janin, A.A., "Les Eglises orientales et Les Rites orientaux," Paris, 1922[/i])

There is no distinction between fast and abstinence; the fast essentially bears on the quality of the food and not the quantity. These rules are for all the Byzantine rites but it should be noted that the Russian rite is much more severe with other stricter prescriptions and nine different degrees of fasting. In villages and monasteries the ancient custom remains in vigour whereby it is forbidden to eat before Vespers. All must fast from seven years of age.


[b]1. Great Lent:[/b]

48 days. Forbidden are: Food cooked with fat, fish, oil, eggs, milk products, wine. Oil is permitted on Saturday and Sunday. Fish is permitted on the feast of the Annunciation and Palm Sunday.

[indent]Russians add:
All Mondays, Tuesdays and Thursdays (& Wednesday of Holy Week) the food may only be cold and dry.[/indent]Good Friday nothing may be eaten.


[b]2. Apostles [a.k.a., Peter and Paul] Lent:[/b]

This varies from 9 to 42 days depending on the feast of Easter. It begins on the first Monday after Pentecost until the feast of Saints Peter and Paul. This Lent has the same rules as Great Lent but oil and fish are tolerated (in some places) except on Wednesdays and Fridays.


[b]3. Assumption [normally called, Dormition] Lent:[/b]

From 1st - 14th August. A difficult Lent permitting only olives and vegetables cooked in water; oil is tolerated on Saturdays and Sundays.


[b]4. Christmas [a.k.a., St. Philip's] Lent:[/b]

For the 40 days before Christmas. The same restrictions as for Great Lent but oil and fish are permitted except on Wednesdays and Fridays.


[b]5. Weekly:[/b]

Wednesdays and Fridays are days of strict fast.


[b]6. Forbidden food:[/b]

Like most oriental Christians, the Catholics of Byzantine rite kept the Mosaic ban on eating blood, suffocated animals and certain animals considered impure; and which Oriental Church Councils have many times renewed. Catholics and schismatics [i.e., Eastern Orthodox] are equally faithful in this matter.[/quote]
**Any decree permitting the eating of blood would be null and void, because it would be in open violation of the divinely inspired teaching of sacred scripture.

Posted

[quote]All must fast from seven years of age.[/quote]

[quote]Good Friday nothing may be eaten.[/quote]


seven year olds are expected to eat no food at all on good friday? :blink:

i'm not sure if that's possible, or really such a good idea.

Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1375613' date='Sep 1 2007, 11:30 AM']seven year olds are expected to eat no food at all on good friday? :blink:

i'm not sure if that's possible, or really such a good idea.[/quote]
It has only been done for more than 1,700 years.

Posted

Once again I should make mention of the fact that the Eastern Churches do not follow the juridicism of the West (i.e., ordering the Christian life according to the concepts of sin and punishment). Thus, if a person is spiritually too weak to fast the entire day he may eat a small amount of bread, with water, tea or fruit juice, after sunset.

Posted

Apotheoun,

I'm still hung up on what Romans 1513 and TheDude asked about what common foods should be avoided? I'm guessing blood sausage is out. (I've never had it.)
But, what about burgers, ham, steak, chicken, etc.

Thanks,
Paddington

Posted

Any food with blood in it is forbidden (beef, chicken, etc.), but the blood can be drained from an animal if it is slaughtered correctly.

Thus, when I eat meat, which I do not do often, I buy kosher meats, because they are slaughtered so that the blood is drained from them. I believe it is also possible to broil the blood out of some meats during the cooking process, and this is another way to avoid eating blood.

Posted

For the sake of discussion, here is Fr. George Haydock's Bible Commentary for Acts 15:20

[quote name='Haydock's Bible Commentary']Ver. 20. Things strangled and from blood. In these prohibitions, the Church indulged the particular feelings of the Jews, that the bond of union between them and the Gentiles might be more closely united; the latter in these two instances giving way to the prejudices of the former, who in their turn gave up much, by submitting to the abolition of the ceremonial law of Moses. This prohibition was of course only temporary, and to cease with the reasons, which gave rise to it. (Menochius) --- The Jews had such a horror of blood, that they considered those who eat it as defiled, and violators of the law of nature. The Lord had in effect from the beginning forbidden the use of blood to Noe [Noah], (Genesis ix. 4.) which he likewise reported in the strongest terms in Leviticus viii. 26. By this we see the great authority of God's Church, and Councils which may make permanent or temporary decrees, such as are fitting for the state of the times or peoples, without any express Scripture at all, and by this authoritative exaction, things become of strict obligation, which previous to it, were in themselves indifferent. (Bristow)[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1375689' date='Sep 1 2007, 01:31 PM']For the sake of discussion, here is Fr. George Haydock's Bible Commentary for Acts 15:20[/quote]
That is a nice modern commentary, but I will continue to follow the unbroken Tradition of the Church on this issue.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1375703' date='Sep 1 2007, 02:59 PM']That is a nice modern commentary, but I will continue to follow the unbroken Tradition of the Church on this issue.[/quote]

Not terribly modern seeing as it's from 1859.

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1375705' date='Sep 1 2007, 02:03 PM']Not terribly modern seeing as it's from 1859.[/quote]
That is quite modern. The Popes all throughout the first millennium constantly issued directives ordering the observance of this Apostolic Tradition, and the Eastern Churches have maintained it from the first century to the present day.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1375706' date='Sep 1 2007, 03:05 PM']That is quite modern. The Popes all throughout the first millennium constantly issued directives ordering the observance of this Apostolic Tradition, and the Eastern Churches have maintained it from the first century to the present day.[/quote]

Do you have a quote or a document from a Supreme Pontiff saying that?

Posted

Although I do not have the quotes at hand, Pope Zacharias (8th century) in a letter that he wrote to St. Boniface forbade the eating of blood, and Pope Gregory III (circa 731) imposed a severe penance on anyone who ate blood or strangled animals. In fact, even Cardinal Humbert (11th century), when defending the Roman Church against the attacks of Patriarch Michael Cerularius, attested to the fact that the eating of blood was wrong, and that it could be done only if one's life was in danger (i.e., in order to avoid starvation).

Posted

Was the source of these quotes a reliable source?

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1375850' date='Sep 1 2007, 05:24 PM']Was the source of these quotes a reliable source?[/quote]
The actual quotations can be found in Migne's [i]Patrologia Latina[/i] -- which I do not have access to at the moment -- because that is where the writings of Pope Zacharias, Pope Gregory III, and Cardinal Humbert can be found.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1368562' date='Aug 22 2007, 11:31 PM']It means that an animals blood must be drained after it is slaughtered.

The West maintained this practice up until the beginning of the second millennium.[/quote]

WHen I hunt/fish this is the common practice also. It is best for the meat. Makes the Salmon nasty to keep the blood in. Makes the boat messy. But it is worth it.

But how does this work for meat that has the blood cooked out. Or Steak?

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1375135' date='Aug 31 2007, 05:53 PM']Western Christians need to move away from the constant emphasis upon sin and punishment. In the East one does things, e.g., not eating blood, or -- in the case of women -- wearing a veil during prayer, etc., because it deepens ones commitment to Christ and incarnates His life into our own being, and not because of some canonical penalty. Theology must not be reduced to canon law.

Salvation (i.e., [i]theosis[/i]) is an ontologically transformative process, and not a legal declaration.[/quote]

I respect you a ton. I love reading your writing.

Posted

I intend to do some research into this before commenting further. It has certainly piqued my interest.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1375135' date='Aug 31 2007, 05:53 PM']Western Christians need to move away from the constant emphasis upon sin and punishment. In the East one does things, e.g., not eating blood, or -- in the case of women -- wearing a veil during prayer, etc., because it deepens ones commitment to Christ and incarnates His life into our own being, and not because of some canonical penalty. Theology must not be reduced to canon law.

Salvation (i.e., [i]theosis[/i]) is an ontologically transformative process, and not a legal declaration.[/quote]


How does confession work with theosis? Is it any different than in a standard western way? When I was taught patristics and Augustine it was with the model of theosis and I try to move with that as best as I can. But I dont see it in much modern theology.

Do you think it is possible for a catholic to buy into the salvation model of theosis and still be catholic?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...