Guest Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 (edited) You know alot of people need to check themselves on this site. Im talking to the people who think their holy'er then everbody and saying who and who isnt gonna go to heaven. Its a joke, im sick of these 14 year old dudes runnig off at the mouth thinking that they have all the answers when its comes to God. Thinkning that their more catholic then others. Its dumb. Ive been told that its sinister and awful that at my bestfriends brothers funeral that they played p diddy's missing you song at the funeral in a catholic church..... im offened by that. what gives you the right ????? im sick of hearing so called " SUPER CATHOLICS" on here saying who's going to hell........y dont u quit judgeing ?? its played out....... I talk to God everyday through the holy spirt........just because you perform all your "works" it doesnt do anything for you.........ur established through faith...........faith alone saves you.........faith without works is dead......true.....but when you start useing your works as a raknking system to place your self ahead of other people your falling into the devils trap.............. im ranting if this is not you disregard this post......... im just sick of people thinking that there good and better then others read your bible Jesus said noooooooooooooo one is goooooooooooooooooooooooood but God alone peace Edited August 25, 2007 by Guest
Guest Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 im only talking about a few........ so like i said pay no mind to this rant...... most are really nice people on here...... and im thankfull for you guys cuz uv'e brought me closer to my catholic faith.... thank you....
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 Delivery Boy- I'm sorry to hear that your friend died. I had a friend die a few years ago. I don't remember much of the funeral (i was a little hysterical) but after we buried him we had an Traditional Irish Wake with lots of food, booze and story telling and signing his favorite songs. I know how important it is to remember the deceased through they're favorite things. You're absolutely right about one thing: it is not our place to judge, especially to judge who is in Heaven and who isn't. We only know for certain that Satan is in Hell- beyond that, we can not speculate. As for Heaven, we can only know for certain those who the Holy See has declared Saints. Beyond that, we can not speculate. However, I have to remind you that we are Catholic which means that we do not believe in the Reformists "Sola Fida" (by Faith alone). We do believe that Faith without Works is dead. BUT the reverse is much MUCH worse. Works without Faith is exactly what Christ warned us against many times in Scripture when he spoke about the Pharisees and Saducees who would publicly pray and loudly proclaim how good they were. "Do not let your right hand know what your left hand is doing". Not only are those "works" dead unless they are meant in earnest faith, but they put us on the road towards the sin of Pride. I know, i have had trouble with this one many times. But truthfully, while Faith alone will withstand temptation, it is not by not sinning that we obtain heaven, but by [i]doing[/i] the will of God. Therefore, the works of Faith merit us our eternal reward, whereas Faith simply merits our salvation from Hell. Maybe i'm going off on a rant, but coming from a Protestant background, I know how important a point this is! The first spiritual work of mercy is to rebuke the sinner- Good for you for catching some of us in the Pharisees shoes. I hope it wasn't me, but either way my eyes are opened. Now that this work of mercy is complete, do not forget the simplest commandment- to love your neighbor, which means to forgive them their weakness and their faults. Even without an apology. I'll pray for you today, I hope you will pray for me and for all those on this board who are suffering from the "sin of the pharisees shoes". :-)
Aloysius Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 ... aren't you arguing in the debate table that non-Catholics gotta go to hell against peops sayin that they might have some unknowable chance? I don't understand your position... the majority of phatmass peeps tend to be sayin "we don't know the salvation or damnation status of anyone, here's what we know is the best way to be saved: get in the Catholic Church" we are saved by grace alone; which works through faith, which is sustained by works. faith without works is dead and all that, just to be clear. there's a lot of conflicts that occur with personal preferences at stuff like funerals. my family got real mad when the church wouldn't let them sing danny boy in the Church, but then we had it sung at the grave site and it was amazing. the funeral's about praying to God for the dead person, all songs ought to be prayers to God. pdiddy's song is just about missing the person (right? I'm not familiar with it) and as such probably would've been much cooler at the grave site. but no worries, no one meant any malicious intent or nothin by it from what it sounds like... people just gotta remember that inside the Church we want to center things around God, even at funerals we ought to be more centered around God than the dead person.
Resurrexi Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1370353' date='Aug 25 2007, 04:42 AM']You know alot of people need to check themselves on this site. Im talking to the people who think their holy'er then everbody and saying who and who isnt gonna go to heaven. Its a joke, im sick of these 14 year old dudes runnig off at the mouth thinking that they have all the answers when its comes to God. Thinkning that their more catholic then others. Its dumb.[/quote] This is an internet forum. Don't get worked up about things that are said to you here. [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1370353' date='Aug 25 2007, 04:42 AM']Ive been told that its sinister and awful that at my bestfriends brothers funeral that they played p diddy's missing you song at the funeral in a catholic church.....[/quote] It [i]is[/i] sinister and the priest who permitted that to occur committed the grave sin of liturgical abuse. [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1370353' date='Aug 25 2007, 04:42 AM']im offened by that. what gives you the right ?????[/quote] You shouldn't be offended that we are telling you that liturgical abuse is wrong. You should be offended that the priest who said that Requiem Mass permitted that song to be played. [quote]im sick of hearing so called " SUPER CATHOLICS" on here saying who's going to hell........y dont u quit judgeing ?? its played out.......[/quote] It is a dogma of the Holy Catholic Church founded by our Lord Jesus Christ that outside of her there is no salvation. [quote]I talk to God everyday through the holy spirt........just because you perform all your "works" it doesnt do anything for you.........ur established through faith...........faith alone saves you.........faith without works is dead......true.....but when you start useing your works as a raknking system to place your self ahead of other people your falling into the devils trap..............[/quote] I find it strange that you talk to God [i]through[/i] the Holy Ghost, seeing as the Holy Ghost [i]is[/i] God. [quote]im ranting[/quote] Yes, you are. [quote]if this is not you disregard this post.........[/quote] I probably should have. [quote]im just sick of people thinking that there good and better then others[/quote] Don't you mean, "That [i]they're[/i] good and better than others." [quote]read your bible[/quote] Only if it is a good translation which has been approved by the Catholic Church and has footnotes interpreting the Bible according to the teachings of the Holy Catholic Church. [quote]Jesus said noooooooooooooo one is goooooooooooooooooooooooood but God alone[/quote] Our Lord never said that. He did say, "None is good but one, that is God." (cf. St. Mark 10:18). But he never said "noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooo one is gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ooooooooooooooood but Gooooooooooooood aloooooooooooooooooooonnnnneee"
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 Thomas- be nice. For goodness sake. Why do you have to be so vicious? As far as i know from your tag, you are a "separated brethern" so in my book anything you say about the mass might be good reference, but that's it. I stick with my priests and the GIRM to tell me what i need to know, and will disregard what you and all other lay people say. But even if you weren't separated from us, which i hope one day you won't be, picking on someone's spelling and choice of words is not appropriate. A member of our Pham is obviously upset by something, and it is your DUTY to be charitable to them regardless of your feelings toward them or their beliefs. That is different than your duty to rebuke the sinner, but last time i checked not using spell check isn't a sin. If i am overstepping my bounds, moderators feel free to edit or delete. I just feel that Thomas' comment was unwarranted, rude, and inappropriate.
Resurrexi Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 [quote name='CoffeeCatholic' post='1370576' date='Aug 25 2007, 04:32 PM']Thomas- be nice. For goodness sake. Why do you have to be so vicious? As far as i know from your tag, you are a "separated brethern" so in my book anything you say about the mass might be good reference, but that's it. I stick with my priests and the GIRM to tell me what i need to know, and will disregard what you and all other lay people say. But even if you weren't separated from us, which i hope one day you won't be, picking on someone's spelling and choice of words is not appropriate. A member of our Pham is obviously upset by something, and it is your DUTY to be charitable to them regardless of your feelings toward them or their beliefs. That is different than your duty to rebuke the sinner, but last time i checked not using spell check isn't a sin. If i am overstepping my bounds, moderators feel free to edit or delete. I just feel that Thomas' comment was unwarranted, rude, and inappropriate.[/quote] A tag on a forum saying that I'm in "separated brethren" doesn't have anything to do with reality. I am a baptized person. I believe all the truths which the Holy Catholic Church teaches. I acknowledge the Supreme Pontiff, Pope Benedict XVI, as well as all my other lawful pastors. I partake in the Sacraments of the Holy Catholic Church. I moreover, am not affiliated with the sedevacantists, the SSPX or any other heretical or schismatic groups. I assist at the Forma Extraordinaria said by a diocesan priest. I fail to see how I am a "separated brother".
cmotherofpirl Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1370563' date='Aug 25 2007, 06:04 PM']This is an internet forum. Don't get worked up about things that are said to you here. It [i]is[/i] sinister and the priest who permitted that to occur committed the grave sin of liturgical abuse. You shouldn't be offended that we are telling you that liturgical abuse is wrong. You should be offended that the priest who said that Requiem Mass permitted that song to be played. It is a dogma of the Holy Catholic Church founded by our Lord Jesus Christ that outside of her there is no salvation. I find it strange that you talk to God [i]through[/i] the Holy Ghost, seeing as the Holy Ghost [i]is[/i] God. Yes, you are. I probably should have. Don't you mean, "That [i]they're[/i] good and better than others." Only if it is a good translation which has been approved by the Catholic Church and has footnotes interpreting the Bible according to the teachings of the Holy Catholic Church. Our Lord never said that. He did say, "None is good but one, that is God." (cf. St. Mark 10:18). But he never said "noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooooooooooooooooooooo one is gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ooooooooooooooood but Gooooooooooooood aloooooooooooooooooooonnnnneee"[/quote] You reply is exactly what DB is talking about. You know all the rules but have no idea how to express them with charity.
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 25, 2007 Posted August 25, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1370581' date='Aug 25 2007, 06:40 PM']A tag on a forum saying that I'm in "separated brethren" doesn't have anything to do with reality. I am a baptized person. I believe all the truths which the Holy Catholic Church teaches. I acknowledge the Supreme Pontiff, Pope Benedict XVI, as well as all my other lawful pastors. I partake in the Sacraments of the Holy Catholic Church. I moreover, am not affiliated with the sedevacantists, the SSPX or any other heretical or schismatic groups. I assist at the Forma Extraordinaria said by a diocesan priest. I fail to see how I am a "separated brother".[/quote] true- I've never met you in person, i don't know the reason for the tag, and honestly don't care. You aren't the Pope, my bishop, or even my priest, and you certainly aren't the GIRM (because that would make you paper ) Whether you are separated or not is not the point, the fact that you are less than charitable is an even greater indication that I should probably not be listening to you on matters of faith or morals- or really anything. Use Charity like Christ and you can say many things and have your word heard. use harsh words and rudeness and nobody will listen, regardless of who you are or whether what you are saying is true. Beyond that, I trust dUSt- if he gave you that label, there must be a reason. If there isn't, it's you're responsibility to prove that beyond a doubt, and you certainly haven't proven yourself to me.
Romans1513 Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1370563' date='Aug 25 2007, 06:04 PM'][quote] im just sick of people thinking that there good and better then others[/quote] Don't you mean, "That they're good and better than others." [/quote] I think you kind of missed the point on that one. Like, waaaaay missed it.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 I think the problem is charity. STM has all the right "stuff" in his post, but it is just expressed in an uncharitable way. TO DB: I totally understand what you are saying. But Aloysius is correct. The Funeral is for God, but there are other times to grieve for your loved ones (like a wake), where secular songs are appropriate and welcome. CoffeeCatholic did a great job explaining how faith relates to works, and why both are needed.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 EENS, that is one of the most well-reasoned, charitable, and adult responses I've ever read from you. I just wanted to say that. Thank you. God bless, Micah
jeffpugh Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='CoffeeCatholic' post='1370592' date='Aug 25 2007, 06:12 PM']true- I've never met you in person, i don't know the reason for the tag, and honestly don't care. You aren't the Pope, my bishop, or even my priest, and you certainly aren't the GIRM (because that would make you paper ) Whether you are separated or not is not the point, the fact that you are less than charitable is an even greater indication that I should probably not be listening to you on matters of faith or morals- or really anything. Use Charity like Christ and you can say many things and have your word heard. use harsh words and rudeness and nobody will listen, regardless of who you are or whether what you are saying is true. Beyond that, I trust dUSt- if he gave you that label, there must be a reason. If there isn't, it's you're responsibility to prove that beyond a doubt, and you certainly haven't proven yourself to me.[/quote] Well, he's got the "separated Brethren" tag because he is uncharitable. dUSt didn't want people seeing the forum, read his posts and go "wow, what a bunch of arrogant jerks Catholics are". So two things to STM. 1: I rebuke you for being so blunt and uncharitable about that. You could have sufficiently told the truth with empathy as well. 2: I don't mean that you are an arrogant jerk. I'm saying you're passing your post off as that. You're a sinner as well. The priest made an error. Get over it. We're filled with em these days. Pray about it. And STM, if there is anything more to be said about this, you can take this up in a PM with me. I'm finished this. God Bless, all.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1370828' date='Aug 25 2007, 11:16 PM']And STM, if there is anything more to be said about this, you can take this up in a PM with me. I'm finished this. God Bless, all.[/quote] STM can't send PMs.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1370822' date='Aug 26 2007, 12:09 AM']EENS, that is one of the most well-reasoned, charitable, and adult responses I've ever read from you. I just wanted to say that. Thank you. God bless, Micah[/quote] Thank you as well. You set a good example for Catholic Charity on the board. It has taken me a while to truly realize that Catholicism is about Spirituality and not about superiority. Pharisaical Catholicism is that it all about pride and superiority.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1370832' date='Aug 25 2007, 11:19 PM']Thank you as well. You set a good example for Catholic Charity on the board. It has taken me a while to truly realize that Catholicism is about Spirituality and not about superiority. Pharisaical Catholicism is that it all about pride and superiority.[/quote] I'm humbled, but thank you. There are many here more charitable than I am. I'm always worried my posts will outrage everybody and turn people away from Catholicism. The vice I consistently struggle with is a judgmental attitude and a superiority complex. God bless, Micah
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now