Resurrexi Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 I'm sorry for being uncharitable in my post. I was sort of angry at how rude the original post by Delivery Boy was. If I'm not mistaken, he made this thread because he was mad that I recommended (very charitably, btw) that he read a certain encyclical and that I agreed with Prose that he should use proper spelling and grammar.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1370866' date='Aug 26 2007, 12:09 AM']I'm sorry for being uncharitable in my post. I was sort of angry at how rude the original post by Delivery Boy was. If I'm not mistaken, he made this thread because he was mad that I recommended (very charitably, btw) that he read a certain encyclical and that I agreed with Prose that he should use proper spelling and grammar.[/quote] You know, I know we all do it...I do it, too...but I think we all need to work on the whole "I'm sorry, but...[insert mitigating circumstance here]." Let's all be men and not try to make excuses. If we say something, charitably or uncharitably, and someone calls us on it for our own good, then that's fine, and if someone calls us on it to pick a fight, then that's not fine, but in either case, if we use it to excuse our own retaliation, are we really being responsible? Again, that's something I need to work on, but I've been thinking lately because of something one of my volunteers and friends said...if we're not willing to sever all ties to sin, overcome our sloth, pride, greed, lust, and all our other vices, and make a radical turn toward Christ...will we ever truly advance in sanctity, which is the only road by which we may reach heaven, or will we simply remain stagnant, convinced that we're "good enough?" I don't know about y'all, but I want to be a radical Christian, and I think that recognizing my own flaws, faults, vices, and sins, which I see so often in others but so often overlook in myself, has really given me a big push. I want to be radically devoted to Christ...who's with me? God bless, Micah
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 (edited) [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1370866' date='Aug 26 2007, 01:09 AM']I'm sorry for being uncharitable in my post. I was sort of angry at how rude the original post by Delivery Boy was. If I'm not mistaken, he made this thread because he was mad that I recommended (very charitably, btw) that he read a certain encyclical and that I agreed with Prose that he should use proper spelling and grammar.[/quote] Thank you for the apology Thomas. The other day I made a mistake. There was a reason, I was filled with emotion, and I was upset. My boyfriend, to whom the mistake had been made, rightfully deserved an apology- and I gave it to him. But, unlike any time before, I with held the "But" at the end of the "i'm sorry". I literally bite my tung. The night passed and the next day, Joey brought up the situation in passing and i was given the opportunity to explain myself- my excuse was asked for, and so i gave it. After that, I've decided this is the perfect way to deal with my "I'm sorry, buts". I want to give an excuse, I really do, and I know (think i know) that it's a pretty darn good one. But all that really matters in the end to the other person is that apology. I swallow my "but" and let it move on. IF in the future an excuse is requested, a reason is asked for, then i will (gladly) give it. But there's no reason for it to be said to begin with. Beyond that, I see you're taking steps, Thomas. Keep it up. As for Delivery Boy, I can understand your distress and discomfort when the forum turns critical. If you are feeling that way, let the other person know- Tell them that you are feeling attacked by their comments (perhaps PM them- that would be better) and give them the opportunity to repent! Never leave someone without the opportunity to become a better person! As I said before, the first spiritual work of mercy is to rebuke the sinner. That isn't to point out all their faults so you can feel better, or so your faults look less (i'm sure you knew that) but so that person has the opportunity to stop sinning if they did not realize their actions were sinful. I'm going to post another comment about something else i've been thinking about in regards to this thread. but it should be separate. please read below Edited August 26, 2007 by CoffeeCatholic
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 I've been thinking a lot about this thread today and I've come to a conclusion I think needs to be brought up. There's been a lot of discussion about a priest who allowed a secular song at a funeral mass and the appropriateness of that action. I think we all need to remember who our Priests are, and what them mean to our faith. Priests are ontologically different than lay people, having been ordained into the line of Malchizidech (sp?). Through this ordination, they were granted the special privilege in sharing with their bishop a greater access to the gifts of the Holy Spirit, a more direct line to understanding Christ's will. Above Priests, Bishops are even more blessed with understanding in this area, and our beloved Pope has been blessed through his office with full access to the gifts of the Holy Spirit. Now, this makes these men of the cloth much more responsible for their actions than the lay person, both because they have a greater ability to comprehend God's will and therefore should have a less difficult time accomplishing it, and also because they are in positions of authority and their misdeeds could lead a great many faithful astray. However, it is because of the blessing of ordination that we, as lay people, have a distinct responsibility towards our priests. It is our duty to respect them continually, and trust them always. This is because we know without a doubt that these men have a better ability to understand God's will, and therefore if we follow them we should be more likely to follow God's will. This does not mean that these men can't choose to not follow Christ, they are still human, they can still sin and choose to cut themselves off from the Holy Spirit. But at times when we suspect this, it is our responsibility to confront them- one on one. We should not be talking about our priest's actions between ourselves, not only is that gossip, but it can lead others into doubt and to distrust the clergy. Therefore, I challenge everyone here who is a lay person to respect our priests and bishops. We should not be discussing the wrong doings or possibly liturgical abuses caused by them. Period. It is one thing to ask whether or not it is appropriate to approach a member of the clergy, whether a certain action is or is not permissible. But it is not our place, as Lay men and women, to judge the priest or bishop for their faults. We simply are not able to because we know that we are not blessed with the gift to understand the Lord in the way that ordination allows. I know that there are quite a few priests on this board, and I applaud you with the highest esteem and regard! Thank you for everything, and thank you for humbly submitting yourself to this task! Please continue to pray for us lay persons that we may have a greater understanding of the role that you play in salvation's history. And finally, if you do have a problem with a certain priest, confront them, not Phatmass. If that is impossible, write to your Bishop, or even the Holy See. Or if you feel that something that was mentioned on this board was inappropriate on the part of that priest, I challenge you to seek out one of our members who is a man of the cloth and confide your concerns in him. If it is a reasonable concern, I'm sure that he will be able to tell you the appropriate course of action, if there is one. I hope i haven't put any of you clergy members up to anything you weren't expecting! I'm sorry if i have. Anyway, that's my .02. I hope everyone has a restful night, God bless!
cmotherofpirl Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1370816' date='Aug 26 2007, 12:01 AM']I think the problem is charity. STM has all the right "stuff" in his post, but it is just expressed in an uncharitable way. TO DB: I totally understand what you are saying. But Aloysius is correct. The Funeral is for God, but there are other times to grieve for your loved ones (like a wake), where secular songs are appropriate and welcome. CoffeeCatholic did a great job explaining how faith relates to works, and why both are needed.[/quote]
cmotherofpirl Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1370866' date='Aug 26 2007, 01:09 AM']I'm sorry for being uncharitable in my post. I was sort of angry at how rude the original post by Delivery Boy was. If I'm not mistaken, he made this thread because he was mad that I recommended (very charitably, btw) that he read a certain encyclical and that I agreed with Prose that he should use proper spelling and grammar.[/quote]
Didymus Posted August 26, 2007 Posted August 26, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1370563' date='Aug 25 2007, 05:04 PM']It [i]is[/i] sinister and the priest who permitted that to occur committed the grave sin of liturgical abuse.[/quote] this is exactly what he was referring to
chelsea Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 Props, DB. And, since when does the catholic church think that only catholics get salvation? I've always been taught (BY PRIESTS!) that people outside of the catholic church CAN go to heaven...
jeffpugh Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1370869' date='Aug 26 2007, 12:19 AM']You know, I know we all do it...I do it, too...but I think we all need to work on the whole "I'm sorry, but...[insert mitigating circumstance here]." Let's all be men and not try to make excuses. If we say something, charitably or uncharitably, and someone calls us on it for our own good, then that's fine, and if someone calls us on it to pick a fight, then that's not fine, but in either case, if we use it to excuse our own retaliation, are we really being responsible? Again, that's something I need to work on, but I've been thinking lately because of something one of my volunteers and friends said...if we're not willing to sever all ties to sin, overcome our sloth, pride, greed, lust, and all our other vices, and make a radical turn toward Christ...will we ever truly advance in sanctity, which is the only road by which we may reach heaven, or will we simply remain stagnant, convinced that we're "good enough?" I don't know about y'all, but I want to be a radical Christian, and I think that recognizing my own flaws, faults, vices, and sins, which I see so often in others but so often overlook in myself, has really given me a big push. I want to be radically devoted to Christ...who's with me? God bless, Micah[/quote] Yeah I'm with ya. I'll take up my sword for the cause. Oh, and CoffeeCatholic, great posts.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 [quote name='chelsea' post='1371241' date='Aug 26 2007, 09:21 PM']Props, DB. And, since when does the catholic church think that only catholics get salvation? I've always been taught (BY PRIESTS!) that people outside of the catholic church CAN go to heaven...[/quote] oh they can! But it is only THROUGH the Church that these people (or any person) is saved. Basically to enter Heaven one must be Baptized (explicitly or implicitly) into the Body of Christ. Non-Catholics can be saved By Baptism of Desire, or blood etc. Basically the best bet for Salvation is in the Church, because Salvation can only come through the Church.
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 exactly EENS, and thanks music man :-D Explaining salvation of non-Catholic's is tough. It's one of those things I ponder a lot during adoration (since I'm trying so hard to get my family into the church before they die!). The official Catechism teaches that there is no salvation outside of the church- this follows the "no one can come to the father except through me" and "I am the way and the truth and the life" stuff. (yes, those are reversed, i'm too lazy to put them in the right order). But God is too good! He's got it all figured out! I heard a priest give this story as an explanation before- but it really only makes sense to Catholics. A Lutheran man married a Catholic woman, and after a few a few years of marriage and lots of discussions, he decided to try out Catholicism. So he went to RCIA and met regularly with this priest. Finally, after all this questions had pretty much been answered, he had just one more. "Father, I was raised Lutheran, as you know, and my mother was a strong Lutheran woman. My father left her with 8 young children all to herself, and she worked full time and raised us all with love and devotion. Never once did she raise a hand against us, and I never heard her complain, and she was always there on Sunday morning to praise God in our Lutheran church. She passed away about 5 years ago- are you going to tell me that this saint of a woman is not in heaven?" The priest thought for a second and then responded: "Son, if your mother was everything that you just described to me, then it's very likely that she is in heaven." The man responded: "So then, Father, what's the point of becoming Catholic if you're telling me I can get to heaven as a Lutheran too?" Again, the priest paused to think: "Because, son, you have to be a really good Lutheran to get into heaven, but only a mediocre Catholic." ---------------------- Now, obviously this makes sense to us- if we are able to follow the path set out to us, there's no need to be extraordinary- we can get there with the sacraments and the grace they bestow (that may mean sliding into purgatory on our hiney, but we'll get there). But it makes sense that it would be more difficult for one separated from the church to receive that grace, and they might not have received the sacraments that make things so much easier. But if St. Margaret of Cortonia can make it, or even the poor soul that St. Therese was praying for who converted right before his execution, it is possible for all. Just tougher.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 actually you might have to be a bad lutheran and a good Catholic to get into heaven.
Resurrexi Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 [quote name='CoffeeCatholic' post='1371340' date='Aug 26 2007, 09:34 PM']exactly EENS, and thanks music man :-D Explaining salvation of non-Catholic's is tough. It's one of those things I ponder a lot during adoration (since I'm trying so hard to get my family into the church before they die!). The official Catechism teaches that there is no salvation outside of the church- this follows the "no one can come to the father except through me" and "I am the way and the truth and the life" stuff. (yes, those are reversed, i'm too lazy to put them in the right order). But God is too good! He's got it all figured out! I heard a priest give this story as an explanation before- but it really only makes sense to Catholics. A Lutheran man married a Catholic woman, and after a few a few years of marriage and lots of discussions, he decided to try out Catholicism. So he went to RCIA and met regularly with this priest. Finally, after all this questions had pretty much been answered, he had just one more. "Father, I was raised Lutheran, as you know, and my mother was a strong Lutheran woman. My father left her with 8 young children all to herself, and she worked full time and raised us all with love and devotion. Never once did she raise a hand against us, and I never heard her complain, and she was always there on Sunday morning to praise God in our Lutheran church. She passed away about 5 years ago- are you going to tell me that this saint of a woman is not in heaven?" The priest thought for a second and then responded: "Son, if your mother was everything that you just described to me, then it's very likely that she is in heaven." The man responded: "So then, Father, what's the point of becoming Catholic if you're telling me I can get to heaven as a Lutheran too?" Again, the priest paused to think: "Because, son, you have to be a really good Lutheran to get into heaven, but only a mediocre Catholic." ---------------------- Now, obviously this makes sense to us- if we are able to follow the path set out to us, there's no need to be extraordinary- we can get there with the sacraments and the grace they bestow (that may mean sliding into purgatory on our hiney, but we'll get there). But it makes sense that it would be more difficult for one separated from the church to receive that grace, and they might not have received the sacraments that make things so much easier. But if St. Margaret of Cortonia can make it, or even the poor soul that St. Therese was praying for who converted right before his execution, it is possible for all. Just tougher.[/quote] That story the priest told isn't totally truthful. The Protestant woman would have to be invincibly ignorant and follow the Law of Nature to go to heaven.
jeffpugh Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 Well, more like not a mediocre Catholic... though, you can scrape by with "just enough", but it far from benefits the Body of Christ.
XIX Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 If you are even nominally Catholic, you have a very real possibility of dying with the sacraments.
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1371347' date='Aug 26 2007, 11:37 PM']That story the priest told isn't totally truthful. The Protestant woman would have to be invincibly ignorant and follow the Law of Nature to go to heaven.[/quote] Yes, she would have had to have follow the law of nature, considering that is God's law laid out for man. "Invincibly ignorant" isn't correct though. That means that she would have an IQ of 25 (the lowest possible without death). That's obviously not that case for man. I think what you mean is she would have to have had no inkling that perhaps a protestant religion was not what God intended for His church. THIS is a real possibility, and provides her the "ignorance of sin" clause in the conditions for mortal sin. If you don't know it's sinful, then the action is bad, but the sin can't be held against your soul.
Resurrexi Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 [quote name='CoffeeCatholic' post='1371364' date='Aug 26 2007, 09:57 PM']Yes, she would have had to have follow the law of nature, considering that is God's law laid out for man. "Invincibly ignorant" isn't correct though. That means that she would have an IQ of 25 (the lowest possible without death). That's obviously not that case for man. I think what you mean is she would have to have had no inkling that perhaps a protestant religion was not what God intended for His church. THIS is a real possibility, and provides her the "ignorance of sin" clause in the conditions for mortal sin. If you don't know it's sinful, then the action is bad, but the sin can't be held against your soul.[/quote] Invincible ignorance is a theological term for being ignorant through no fault of your own.
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1371370' date='Aug 26 2007, 11:59 PM']Invincible ignorance is a theological term for being ignorant through no fault of your own.[/quote] good enough- I'm no theologian, just a Catholic. In Psychology terms it means an IQ of 25!!! haha! I love the difference in definition there... very telling.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 27, 2007 Posted August 27, 2007 This is not meant as a rebuke of the priest in question, but the approach per se: I just read the story about the priest and that was TOTALLY the wrong response. As a catechist, I would feel like I had completely failed my job if I gave that response. First, it makes the Lutheran guy feel as though Catholics are saying they're part of a special discount club. Second, it makes it sound like exceptional Lutherans are equal to mediocre Catholics. The fact is that exceptional Lutherans are most likely doing more with the less they have than the mediocre Catholics are doing with the more they have...on the level of the response of faith and the cooperation with grace (the subjective level), an exceptional Lutheran is closer to God than a mediocre Catholic (although a Catholic in the state of grace is objectively closer in as much as he is closer in the Church and receives the Eucharist). The reason the person should desire to be Catholic shouldn't be that it makes things easier, but because it is fuller, more authentic, and has far more to do good things with. That's why you have great theologians in the Church today who were former non-Catholics...they did exceptionally well with the little they had and probably would have had a decent chance at heaven, but regardless, they wanted to be Catholic because they knew it was the right thing to do and was more pleasing to God, not because they wanted a way they could be less fervent in their faith and still get saved. Converting for that reason is, quite frankly, no conversion at all.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now