Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Where Should Catholic Music Go From Here? Part 2


Catholic Music Questions  

28 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Here are some new polls to help answer some questions that came up from our last discussion. Please feel free to discuss these questions after you vote. And thank you for supporting Catholic music!

Posted

Wow, a strong number of votes right off the bat! I'm really looking forward to seeing the results of these polls. They should shed a lot more light on what an audience expects of its Catholic musicians.

Posted

Now in hopes of avoiding any spoilers in the polls to those who have yet to vote, assuming someone thinks a Catholic musician should also work in the secular scene, does that mean they would prefer Catholics who currently work in the secular scene to begin devoting time on the side to religious music?

Posted (edited)

I am delighted to see some of my own theories being put down with these polls! Very enlightening! Keep the votes coming!

Edited by abercius24
God the Father
Posted

I think it's funny you're the only one who's posted in the whole thread :P

And yeah, if "catholic music" wants to go anywhere it needs to step out of the little bubble it's been playing in.

Posted

[quote name='God the Father' post='1376031' date='Sep 1 2007, 10:26 PM']I think it's funny you're the only one who's posted in the whole thread :P

And yeah, if "catholic music" wants to go anywhere it needs to step out of the little bubble it's been playing in.[/quote]

Can you give an example of this stepping out process you suggest? I'm not sure I understand.

Cincy Warrior
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1376035' date='Sep 1 2007, 09:29 PM']Can you give an example of this stepping out process you suggest? I'm not sure I understand.[/quote]

This may not be the person's you quoted opinion but here's mine.

Do songs that are not explicitly religious. If you want more non-catholics & non-christians to hear the music you can't just play highly Catholic songs and expect them to like it. Religion turns many off plain and simple. We need to show we are down to earth people like everyone else. Also in general Catholic music in general should work at making better music that is more comparable to secular music quality. This is good even if you are making your music just for Catholics. Don't rely simply on the lyrical content to sell the music. I admit I don't listen to much Catholic music, mostly simply Christian music is in my collection, but if Christian music is still overcoming these problems even when it is getting pretty big, I'm sure Catholic music as a much smaller sub-genre has these things to work on as well.

God the Father
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1376035' date='Sep 1 2007, 11:29 PM']Can you give an example of this stepping out process you suggest? I'm not sure I understand.[/quote]

Like, I don't know, maybe playing a mainstream friendly single? Getting some airwave time, maybe playacting like they're interested in succeeding in the music business as opposed to devoting 100% of their efforts to evangelize.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Cincy Warrior' post='1376065' date='Sep 1 2007, 10:58 PM']This may not be the person's you quoted opinion but here's mine.

Do songs that are not explicitly religious. If you want more non-catholics & non-christians to hear the music you can't just play highly Catholic songs and expect them to like it. Religion turns many off plain and simple. We need to show we are down to earth people like everyone else. Also in general Catholic music in general should work at making better music that is more comparable to secular music quality. This is good even if you are making your music just for Catholics. Don't rely simply on the lyrical content to sell the music. I admit I don't listen to much Catholic music, mostly simply Christian music is in my collection, but if Christian music is still overcoming these problems even when it is getting pretty big, I'm sure Catholic music as a much smaller sub-genre has these things to work on as well.[/quote]
[quote name='God the Father' post='1376072' date='Sep 1 2007, 11:02 PM']Like, I don't know, maybe playing a mainstream friendly single? Getting some airwave time, maybe playacting like they're interested in succeeding in the music business as opposed to devoting 100% of their efforts to evangelize.[/quote]

Thank you both for your honesty. I'm learning a lot from your replies. Let me ask another question, if I may.

I have found that my favorite songs are usually about things I can identify with; things that reflect what I find important in my life -- sometimes funny, sometimes sad, sometimes angry, etc. Is there anything about your identity as Catholics/Christians that mainstream music (or non-Catholic Christian music) seems to neglect? And if so, how can we as Catholic musicians better connect with those aspects of your Catholic/Christian identity (apart from writing good quality music)? And what particular elements of that identity would you like to see?

Edited by abercius24
Posted
:bump: Promote the vote!
Posted

Country music succeeded with simple formulas - songs about dogs, trucks, trains, romance, heartbreak . . . these are not themes unique to "country" artists . . . but they were those
[quote]things I can identify with; things that reflect what I find important in my life -- sometimes funny, sometimes sad, sometimes angry, etc.[/quote] that you mentioned above
Catholic musicians who can present the familiar, and at the same time present the Catholic point of view, with memorable lyrics and pleasing melodies, will find success in the mainstream secular world {caveat - pleasing melodies will vary depending on the listener's demographic}

To borrow from other fields, what will make the Catholic artist stand out as a Catholic artist is not their <self-designated> status as a Catholic artist, but that there are no contradictory aspects of their life . . . to provide an overly simplistic example:
Catholic artist and drunken tour bus . . . jarring dichotomy
(or to borrow from recent headlines - an artist who runs a dog fighting kennel on the side)

A Catholic athlete or businessman is not overtly Catholic in their daily activity, but their behavior, both in and out of the workplace, will reflect their beliefs. A Catholic author will not (always) write about the faith, but the faith will appear in the story they tell . . .

The artists are going to have the difficult job of translating concepts like that to the music world

Posted (edited)

[quote name='journeyman' post='1376333' date='Sep 2 2007, 02:29 PM']Country music succeeded with simple formulas - songs about dogs, trucks, trains, romance, heartbreak . . . these are not themes unique to "country" artists . . . but they were those
that you mentioned above
Catholic musicians who can present the familiar, and at the same time present the Catholic point of view, with memorable lyrics and pleasing melodies, will find success in the mainstream secular world {caveat - pleasing melodies will vary depending on the listener's demographic}

To borrow from other fields, what will make the Catholic artist stand out as a Catholic artist is not their <self-designated> status as a Catholic artist, but that there are no contradictory aspects of their life . . . to provide an overly simplistic example:
Catholic artist and drunken tour bus . . . jarring dichotomy
(or to borrow from recent headlines - an artist who runs a dog fighting kennel on the side)

A Catholic athlete or businessman is not overtly Catholic in their daily activity, but their behavior, both in and out of the workplace, will reflect their beliefs. A Catholic author will not (always) write about the faith, but the faith will appear in the story they tell . . .

The artists are going to have the difficult job of translating concepts like that to the music world[/quote]

You are right. There doesn't have to be such an overtly religious presentation in a song for it to be from a Catholic perspective, but that perspective does need to be uniquely Catholic. That's the key -- to find balance in a natural presentation that is still of a godly point-of-view.

I'm glad you brought up Country Music, because that is probably the one genre of music that is quite tolerant of religious themes. One of the most successful -- and overtly Christian -- "cross-over" songs is "I Can Only Imagine" by Mercy Me, which is probably one of the most popular songs on the Country Music charts. Why is it that mainstream Country Music will tolerate religion, but not Rock, Pop or Rap?

Edited by abercius24
Cincy Warrior
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1376370' date='Sep 2 2007, 02:40 PM']Why is it that mainstream Country Music will tolerate religion, but not Rock, Pop or Rap?[/quote]

If I were to guess I would say the country mainly appeals to conservative types, while most others like rock, rap, & pop appeal to the younger audience & liberal audience.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Cincy Warrior' post='1376375' date='Sep 2 2007, 03:45 PM']If I were to guess I would say the country mainly appeals to conservative types, while most others like rock, rap, & pop appeal to the younger audience & liberal audience.[/quote]

That does make sense, and that fills in a lot more spaces in the big puzzle.

Are you happy with all that mainstream music offers, though, or is there something more that you personally crave?

Edited by abercius24
Cincy Warrior
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1376387' date='Sep 2 2007, 03:03 PM']That does make sense, and that fills in a lot more spaces in the big puzzle.

Are you happy with all that mainstream music offers, though, or is there something more that you personally crave?[/quote]

Well I go to Christian music because in some of the genres I like it is hard to find a good amount of clean stuff, mainly in rap & metal. I also like having music that relates to my life more and Christian music does that more often. I'm not against mainstream music (indie rock is usually a lot easier to find clean stuff in the mainstream) I just feel like I relate to Christian musicians more I guess.

God the Father
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1376173' date='Sep 2 2007, 02:26 AM']And if so, how can we as Catholic musicians better connect with those aspects of your Catholic/Christian identity (apart from writing good quality music)? And what particular elements of that identity would you like to see?[/quote]

I don't want Catholic musicians to connect with my Catholic/Christian identity. I want Catholic musicians to connect with my music listener identity. Make the lyrics mean something if you have to, but don't bombard me with God and Christ. I'm already Catholic I don't need to be told how wonderful God is.

ADD SOME KICK. Could we push the tempo a little bit?

Posted

[quote name='God the Father' post='1376605' date='Sep 2 2007, 09:00 PM']I don't want Catholic musicians to connect with my Catholic/Christian identity. I want Catholic musicians to connect with my music listener identity. Make the lyrics mean something if you have to, but don't bombard me with God and Christ. I'm already Catholic I don't need to be told how wonderful God is.

ADD SOME KICK. Could we push the tempo a little bit?[/quote]

THANK YOU!!!

Posted

[quote name='God the Father' post='1376605' date='Sep 2 2007, 09:00 PM']I don't want Catholic musicians to connect with my Catholic/Christian identity. I want Catholic musicians to connect with my music listener identity. Make the lyrics mean something if you have to, but don't bombard me with God and Christ. I'm already Catholic I don't need to be told how wonderful God is.

ADD SOME KICK. Could we push the tempo a little bit?[/quote]

To an extent, I can agree with you here. And I don't mean "Catholic identity" as in bombard you with Bible cliches like "Praise the Lord". That is a Catholic identity, but its only one type of expression. I mean songs that depict certain Biblical heros, societal challenges, and the daily struggles as a Christian that you may find an identity with. For example, Iron Maiden wrote songs about the Egyptian Pharoahs (Power Slave), the Greeks (Alexander the Great), and seafaring legends (The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner) -- all classic Metal songs. These songs are all about certain people the song writers identified with. I personally find the Maccabees brothers to be my choice Biblical heroes. In fact, I was thrilled when I heard a rumor that Mel Gibson was going to make a movie about the Maccabees. But I'd love to heard a good solid metal song about the Maccabean Rebellion against Rome, as well. The song would easily have a solid connection with the things I value about my Catholic faith. Is there anything like that about your Catholic faith that you wish someone would put into a hardcore song? (By the way, have you heard of the Catholic Metal Band "Seven Sorrows"?)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...