Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Where Should Catholic Music Go From Here? Part 2


Catholic Music Questions  

28 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

sounds like everyone wants a catholic Mat Kearney

Posted

catholic music shall go where the people go.

Posted

[quote name='desertwoman' post='1377133' date='Sep 3 2007, 05:01 PM']catholic music shall go where the people go.[/quote]

The people of the Church, or society in general?

RobeofJustice
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1378175' date='Sep 4 2007, 06:38 PM']The people of the Church, or society in general?[/quote]


Peps of every color, race and planet!!!

Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1378175' date='Sep 4 2007, 09:38 PM']The people of the Church, or society in general?[/quote]


The Church. Like an old saying of Mos Def and Talib when people asked him where is hiphop going. The answer is, where the people are going.

Where is the Church going?

Where is the Church?

Where are the psalmists of the Church?

If they are there, and they have a genuine love of music and the Church, then the possiblities are endless. If the Church is not limited, then why should the music that is an byproduct of the people be limited? It will be here to glorify God, the Church, and to edify.

This is what is holding back CAtholic music, and it had a hold onto the HHH scene for a while. But they are finally breaking out of the box. There is music to edify, to teach, and to enjoy... and the different genres are breaking through to the mainstream because its good music created from the heart of the musicans.

Posted

[quote name='desertwoman' post='1378489' date='Sep 5 2007, 08:11 AM']The Church. Like an old saying of Mos Def and Talib when people asked him where is hiphop going. The answer is, where the people are going.

Where is the Church going?

Where is the Church?

Where are the psalmists of the Church?

If they are there, and they have a genuine love of music and the Church, then the possiblities are endless. If the Church is not limited, then why should the music that is an byproduct of the people be limited? It will be here to glorify God, the Church, and to edify.

This is what is holding back CAtholic music, and it had a hold onto the HHH scene for a while. But they are finally breaking out of the box. There is music to edify, to teach, and to enjoy... and the different genres are breaking through to the mainstream because its good music created from the heart of the musicans.[/quote]

Many are saying that the Church is entering a new Springtime full of the fruits you speak of. I guess those of us who are already getting things started have a lot to look forward to!

Posted

Just 6 more votes and we'll start discussing the results. Promote the vote!

RobeofJustice
Posted

[quote name='zealousrap' post='1376905' date='Sep 3 2007, 09:22 AM']sounds like everyone wants a catholic Mat Kearney[/quote]


"somethins in the air tonight..."

"Mark (Matt's) words somethins bout to break.."

RobeofJustice
Posted

[quote name='desertwoman' post='1378489' date='Sep 5 2007, 06:11 AM']The Church. Like an old saying of Mos Def and Talib when people asked him where is hiphop going. The answer is, where the people are going.

Where is the Church going?

Where is the Church?

Where are the psalmists of the Church?

If they are there, and they have a genuine love of music and the Church, then the possiblities are endless. If the Church is not limited, then why should the music that is an byproduct of the people be limited? It will be here to glorify God, the Church, and to edify.

This is what is holding back CAtholic music, and it had a hold onto the HHH scene for a while. But they are finally breaking out of the box. There is music to edify, to teach, and to enjoy... and the different genres are breaking through to the mainstream because its good music created from the heart of the musicans.[/quote]

xcuse my ignorance. What;s HHH?

Cincy Warrior
Posted

[quote name='RobeofJustice' post='1380813' date='Sep 8 2007, 02:51 AM']xcuse my ignorance. What;s HHH?[/quote]

Holy Hip Hop

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Cincy Warrior' post='1380950' date='Sep 8 2007, 12:39 PM']Holy Hip Hop[/quote]

More votes!!! Please. :)

Edited by abercius24
Posted

All talk and no vote??? Inquiring minds want to know...

Posted

[quote name='Cincy Warrior' post='1376065' date='Sep 1 2007, 10:58 PM']Also in general Catholic music in general should work at making better music that is more comparable to secular music quality.[/quote]

:yes:

Posted

I was hoping for at least 30 votes before we start, but I can't make everybody wait. We'll discuss the results by tomorrow night at the latest. Thank you all for your patience.

Posted (edited)

Thank you to all those who voted. I was hoping for the minimum 30 for some statistical significance, but we'll deal with the margin of error this poll gives us for the first question. Here are the results of the first question so far:

Should Catholic musicians also do work in the secular scene?
Yes [ 13 ] [52.00%]
No [ 2 ] [8.00%]
I don't think it matters [ 9 ] [36.00%]
Other [ 1 ] [4.00%]

I asked the first question because I am getting the idea that many fans don't think Catholic musicians should work exclusively in Catholic music. This poll basically confirms my suspicion. If you ask most Catholic musicians, they will tell you that their work is more of a ministry than it is job. I guess they find the response from the audience is one of a religious nature, which seems very odd to mix with an audience that just likes hearing a good tune. My experience with the secular scene (limited mainly at the college level) was always very shallow -- and many times SEXUAL. After my return to the Church, I found working in that scene to be way too much of an occassion of sin. Most professional musicians I know also find a sexual response from their audiences, which they either have learned to adapt to in their own way, or have basically given in to.

On one hand, I can see religious projects being a healthy escape -- and possibly a strengthening experience -- for secular musicians. Working in the secular scene can also allow a Catholic artist to network with other great musicians and strengthen their own craft. On the other hand, I know very few people who can truly appreciate their audiences after they have been treated like a sex symbol. As well, everyone knows that mainstream musicians are not usually symbols of virtue. This begs the question as to whether a person with a few (or many) recent indiscretions can appropriately present a religious song without coming off as a hypocrite. I guess it really depends on the individual's personality. There are big questions that come up given this big divergence of opinion between Catholic musicians and their fans.

Given how deep this particular poll topic is, I'll let everyone respond first. Maybe we'll get 5 more votes in the other two poll questions before we move on to them.

So, do you want your Catholic musicians to be subject to the "sex symbol" culture found in mainstream music?

Edited by abercius24
Posted

yes, stand up and face the beast. unless they can't handle the heat. otherwise they shouldn't be kiddin themselves, trying to be entertainers...

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1384277' date='Sep 12 2007, 02:05 PM']yes, stand up and face the beast. unless they can't handle the heat. otherwise they shouldn't be kiddin themselves, trying to be entertainers...[/quote]

So somebody who plays a monster guitar should completely refrain from performing because they find the screaming girls in the front to be an occassion of sin for them? Wouldn't it be better for them to perform for an audience with girls who have better manners -- as we find at Catholic shows?

And do you think the average musical artist is strong enough to avoid being consumed by the sex symbol culture? Maybe a good spiritual director is what would make the difference? Are the clergy and religious ready to support Catholic musicians who work in the mainstream to help them on that level? Or do we somehow justify the sins of mainstream performers because we've somehow lost our concern for their spiritual welfare, and only appreciate them more for their usefulness -- like a utility? I have a suspicion that its a little of both without most people realizing it. I'd like to hear more responses on that level. Thanks for your input, Didy!

Posted

i'm a professional musician...been playing gigs 4 over 25 years...i returned 2 my catholic faith in 2001 at the age of 27...i write and record catholic music...but i still gig on the weekends in clubs and saloons...
i just Opus Dei it...offer my playing up 4 the souls in the club..sing my songs about God and they all dance like crazy...cuz it's funky...
they know what i'm about and they dig it cuz i play good music...along with my jams i play motown, rock-n-roll, jazz, and funk...it's not crass though...so, my audience gets a taste of purity...

i do play "Me and Mrs. Jones" once and a while cuz that's my jam...but i do tell the people b4 i start that i DO NOT promote or endorse adultery...

(i just giggled)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...