Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

If you want, I can explain more later, but right now all I'm going to say is that there's been a bad situation at my parish that recently turned downright ugly, and it resulted in the pastor telling a friend of mine to leave the parish and never come back despite the fact that he wasn't even guilty of any wrongdoing (and there are lots of witnesses who can vouch for that too). Please pray that right will win.

Oh, btw, as if that weren't bad enough, now that my friend is "banned" from our parish, as of today he's started attending Mass at a chapel of the Society of St. Pius X, which, as most of us know, is at best suspended and at worst schismatic.

Posted

Shoot Dave, saying a prayer for your friend and your pastor.

Posted

Definitely prayers for the situation and all those involved! :bigpray:

Posted

Praying for all to be brought into light...

Posted (edited)

Very sorry to hear about that. :(

I hope there is a change of heart in the decision soon.

I'll say a prayer for him.

Edited by Paladin D
Posted

I didn't think SSPX was just suspended. I thought they were schismatic and their masses weren't even really valid. Perhaps someone might be able to point me to some information that would clear that up -- I'd appreciate it.

Is your parish the only Catholic parish (in communion with Rome) where attending mass is available? He can't just attend at another parish?

I'll remember your friend and this situation in my rosary today. God bless!

A Yearning Heart
Posted

Hi Dave,
I didn't even know people could be banned!
I feel sorry for your friend, as he appears to be the innocent in all this. I would definately talk to him about SSPX and suggest, gently, that he may prefer to attend another Catholic parish for the Sacraments, if available at a nearby parish, until things are sorted out with the Parish Priest involved. Maybe try also to speak to the Priest aswell? and maybe ask those witnesses also speak to him? (not to gang up on him, but individually?)
Being banned on the spot sounds alot like a heat of the moment comment. I hope it works itself out.
In the meantime, you have my prayers for all involved.
Monica

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

Prayers. I agree with the advice given above.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1382438' date='Sep 10 2007, 05:26 AM']I didn't think SSPX was just suspended. I thought they were schismatic and their masses weren't even really valid. Perhaps someone might be able to point me to some information that would clear that up -- I'd appreciate it.

Is your parish the only Catholic parish (in communion with Rome) where attending mass is available? He can't just attend at another parish?

I'll remember your friend and this situation in my rosary today. God bless![/quote]


I think its the "illicit but valid" thing. The Masses are still valid but not approved, or something to that effect (I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong). I am pretty sure Dave attends a Tridentine parish--given that fact his friend probably wishes to continue attending a Forma Extraordinaria Mass and the SSPX is the nearest he can find.

Prayers for your friend, Dave. I hope the situation is rectified soon.

Posted

I'm praying, but I wanna hear this story.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1382498' date='Sep 10 2007, 11:53 AM']I'm praying, but I wanna hear this story.[/quote]

:blush: I'm curious, too. I just didn't want to be the only one asking for all the juicy details.

Posted (edited)

That's a sad situation. When Christians forget the central call of the gospel to forgiveness and reconciliation with one another as we are forgiven by and reconciled to God, it does such damage to the individuals involved and to the church overall. Even sadder to hear this of your priest, who has a special position of trust within the church for care of his flock. Prayers. :sign:

Edited by Terra Firma
Posted

My mother in law is banned from attending any Catholic church in their town. It's a middle sized college town in Southern Alberta, so there are 3-4 churches I think counting the Ukrainian Catholic one. She has schizophrenia, and pretty much refuses to take her medication. She has had a number of nasty incidents. She doesn't get psychotic or violent, just mean. When we were dating, my husband described her as "prickly" to me. She actually tried to get my immigration derailed and get me deported from Canada.

She did succeed in getting our marriage canceled two days beforehand. She called our priest and told him all sorts of lies about the both of us, and he had to do due diligence before rescheduling. We had to go to all kinds of counseling, and he practically contacted every member of my family in the US, and anyone who had ever known me before he was satisfied that she had lied about me. Our priest actually locked the doors to the church on our wedding day after the wedding party went inside in fear that we might have crashers disrupt the service.

My husband said the final straw with the priests in her home town was when she made cinnamon rolls in the shape of the male organ and gave them out at church. On the positive side whenever my girl friends and I discuss problems with our mothers in law, I win hands down.

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1382438' date='Sep 10 2007, 04:26 AM']I didn't think SSPX was just suspended. I thought they were schismatic and their masses weren't even really valid. Perhaps someone might be able to point me to some information that would clear that up -- I'd appreciate it.[/quote]

Their Masses are valid but illicit. And the bishops of the SSPX are schismatic and excommunicated. However, Cardinal Hoyos has recently stated that the priests of the SSPX, while suspended, aren't in schism.

Even so, we as Catholics are supposed to avoid Masses and other sacraments celebrated by suspended priests except in extreme cases.

[quote]Is your parish the only Catholic parish (in communion with Rome) where attending mass is available? He can't just attend at another parish?[/quote]

It's not the only Catholic parish in the area, but my friend strongly prefers the TLM, and he hates the lackadaisical attitude shown by so many priests and laity at most of the parishes he's been to; for him it's a major source of distraction (not to say that I think it's sufficient reason to attend an SSPX chapel; I really don't know what to think, actually, but as for me personally, my conscience wouldn't let me attend an SSPX Mass for any reason at all). That doesn't mean he won't attend Novus Ordo Masses at all; he often does so for daily Mass.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1382635' date='Sep 10 2007, 01:12 PM']My mother in law is banned from attending any Catholic church in their town. It's a middle sized college town in Southern Alberta, so there are 3-4 churches I think counting the Ukrainian Catholic one. She has schizophrenia, and pretty much refuses to take her medication. She has had a number of nasty incidents. She doesn't get psychotic or violent, just mean. When we were dating, my husband described her as "prickly" to me. She actually tried to get my immigration derailed and get me deported from Canada.

She did succeed in getting our marriage canceled two days beforehand. She called our priest and told him all sorts of lies about the both of us, and he had to do due diligence before rescheduling. We had to go to all kinds of counseling, and he practically contacted every member of my family in the US, and anyone who had ever known me before he was satisfied that she had lied about me. Our priest actually locked the doors to the church on our wedding day after the wedding party went inside in fear that we might have crashers disrupt the service.

My husband said the final straw with the priests in her home town was when she made cinnamon rolls in the shape of the male organ and gave them out at church. On the positive side whenever my girl friends and I discuss problems with our mothers in law, I win hands down.[/quote]

Where in Alberta are you from?

Posted

We live in Edmonton, my inlaws live in Lethbridge, six+ hours away thankfully. I'm from much, much farther south. I actually moved from St. Pete, Florida to Edmonton in the middle of January. I was living 2 blocks from the beach. On the other hand, I don't have to evacuate for hurricanes here.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1382635' date='Sep 10 2007, 03:12 PM']My mother in law is banned from attending any Catholic church in their town. It's a middle sized college town in Southern Alberta, so there are 3-4 churches I think counting the Ukrainian Catholic one. She has schizophrenia, and pretty much refuses to take her medication. She has had a number of nasty incidents. She doesn't get psychotic or violent, just mean. When we were dating, my husband described her as "prickly" to me. She actually tried to get my immigration derailed and get me deported from Canada.

She did succeed in getting our marriage canceled two days beforehand. She called our priest and told him all sorts of lies about the both of us, and he had to do due diligence before rescheduling. We had to go to all kinds of counseling, and he practically contacted every member of my family in the US, and anyone who had ever known me before he was satisfied that she had lied about me. Our priest actually locked the doors to the church on our wedding day after the wedding party went inside in fear that we might have crashers disrupt the service.

My husband said the final straw with the priests in her home town was when she made cinnamon rolls in the shape of the male organ and gave them out at church. On the positive side whenever my girl friends and I discuss problems with our mothers in law, I win hands down.[/quote]
Wow. :eek:

Posted (edited)

Ok, here's the thing.

"Tom," the aforementioned friend of mine at my parish, has basically had a long-running feud with "Jerry," another guy at my parish. They're both 2 really strong-willed guys, so I guess it's normal that people like them would clash. However, to be blunt, "Jerry" is a flat-out bully at times. He's been extremely rude to me and others in our social circle. Even worse, 2 female friends of mine, who are sisters, have for a long time tried to avoid "Jerry" because he often harasses them (not sexual harassment though). Even worse, their brother once told "Jerry" not to bother his sisters, and "Jerry" grabbed him and threatened him (this actually took place in the parish social hall one Sunday after Mass). The brother talked to our pastor, and Father said he would definitely do something about it. But he never did.

But I digress.

Anyway, fairly recently "Jerry" wrote to the archdiocese falsely accusing "Tom" of being a pedophile, telling lies and half-truths to prove his point. Well, our pastor found out about it and forbade "Tom" from serving at Mass or teaching in any capacity. Now, "Tom" defended himself to Father, but even so, I guess Father was just trying to "play it safe." Since then "Tom" has at least tried to be civil to "Jerry," but "Jerry" just plain won't acknowledge him. Things finally came to a head this past Saturday after daily Mass. On his way out the door after Mass, "Tom" decided to be magnanimous and held the door open for others who were also on their way out at the moment, one of whom was "Jerry." Well, as he exited, "Jerry" intentionally elbowed "Tom," and it was obvious to everyone (there were several witnesses) that it was intentional. "Tom" was like "Excuse me!" and merely elbowed "Jerry" back. That's when all hell broke loose -- "Jerry" grabbed "Tom" and started choking him, yelling "Don't ever touch me again!!!!!!" and knocking off "Tom's" glasses in the process. "Jerry" is about 60 pounds heavier than "Tom" anyway. So some people pulled "Jerry" off "Tom." By then someone had gone and gotten Father, and he was pretty upset. So he spoke to them individually, asking them what all had happened. And he was like, "Y'all just need to avoid each other." I think he also talked to the witnesses as well, and they all agreed that "Jerry" had instigated the whole thing and was clearly in the wrong. So anyway, one of the witnesses suggested that "Tom" file a police report, as allegedly "Jerry" has caused similar problems at previous parishes. So he did (they didn't really take any action, though), and Father, on hearing about it, wasn't exactly thrilled. He was like, "You do realize I'll have to let the archdiocese know about this, right?!" Apparently there must be a rule where a priest has to let the archdiocese know if there are any police-related incidents on parish grounds. And "Tom" was like, "Well that's good; I mean, what if he tries doing something like that at any more parishes?" Later that day Father called "Tom" and said, "I've been thinking a lot about this, and I've decided not to let you or "Jerry" come back to this parish." "Tom" was like, "That's unjust! You're denying me the sacraments just for defending myself?" And Father didn't really respond to that; his mind was made up, and apparently he just wanted to sweep it under the rug and forget about it.

To tell you the truth, I'm kind of glad he banned "Jerry," but "Tom" was only trying to defend himself!

Edited by Dave
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...