Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

images of an animated cat and mouse chasing each other in a Catholic Church are running through my head...

prayers, indeed.

Posted

Give the priest a break, he did the right thing. If he let 'Tom' stay, that would most likely provoke 'Jerry' into confronting 'Father' and raising hell. It may not be the most fair thing for 'Tom', but 'Father' has to be practical and be realistic about his human limitations. Letting either party stay would be construed as chosing one side over the other and would likely divide the parish as people take sides.

It's probably best for both Tom & Jerry (which one's the mouse? LOL) to go to another parish and start fresh. Tom may be more innocent than Jerry, but he shouldn't have elbowed back and he already has had bad 'rumours' told about him that Father had to react to.

Posted

Sounds like if Tom is now attending a SSPX parish he's either not good at making decisions, has a problem with obedience, or both.

To me, the priest did the right thing. Sounds like two trouble makers who need to grow up. I don't buy in to the whole one party is guilty and the other innocent theory... in my thirty two years of existence, I've never witnessed any type of "feud" where only one side was guilty.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1382757' date='Sep 10 2007, 06:21 PM']Sounds like if Tom is now attending a SSPX parish he's either not good at making decisions, has a problem with obedience, or both.

To me, the priest did the right thing. Sounds like two trouble makers who need to grow up. I don't buy in to the whole one party is guilty and the other innocent theory... in my thirty two years of existence, I've never witnessed any type of "feud" where only one side was guilty.[/quote]Obedience, sha'medience.... Tom and Jerry both have a problem with maturity and are more adept at assigning responsibility instead of accepting responsibility.

Posted

I am not sure what to say. I would have asked them both to leave also. However, "Tom" should look into a defamation charge against "Jerry". Accusations such as that one are never to be taken lightly.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1382757' date='Sep 10 2007, 06:21 PM']Sounds like if Tom is now attending a SSPX parish he's either not good at making decisions, has a problem with obedience, or both.

To me, the priest did the right thing. Sounds like two trouble makers who need to grow up. I don't buy in to the whole one party is guilty and the other innocent theory... in my thirty two years of existence, I've never witnessed any type of "feud" where only one side was guilty.[/quote]

Easy for you to say, as you haven't been there or actually witnessed any of the stuff that has happened. Nor have you seen "Jerry's" irrational and even violent clashes with others at times. I have. "Tom" may have his faults, but being violent and an all-around troublemaker isn't among them. I will thank you not to talk about "Tom" or any of my other friends that way.

Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1382742' date='Sep 10 2007, 06:01 PM']Give the priest a break, he did the right thing. If he let 'Tom' stay, that would most likely provoke 'Jerry' into confronting 'Father' and raising hell. It may not be the most fair thing for 'Tom', but 'Father' has to be practical and be realistic about his human limitations. Letting either party stay would be construed as chosing one side over the other and would likely divide the parish as people take sides.[/quote]

There have been so many people who have seen "Jerry" in action (not just in that instances but in others -- both in my parish and elsewhere) that even a blind man could see that "Jerry" was in the wrong.

[quote]It's probably best for both Tom & Jerry (which one's the mouse? LOL) to go to another parish and start fresh. Tom may be more innocent than Jerry, but he shouldn't have elbowed back and he already has had bad 'rumours' told about him that Father had to react to.[/quote]

Maybe he shouldn't have elbowed back, but that isn't adequate reason for banning someone from a parish.

Posted

Like I said, Tom should be pursuing defamation charges.

Posted

And another thing ... isn't there something in canon law that says that a priest can't just forbid someone from attending a parish?

Posted

Given the current environment regarding pedophilia, I can understand the priest being cautious due to legality and liability issues. But I am glad that there were a crowd of witnesses standing up for Tom. I hope he follows through with charges. If the other guy indeed bullies people at other parishes, he needs to stop, and it is easier to do if he has a record.

However.....

[quote name='dUSt' post='1382757' date='Sep 10 2007, 05:21 PM']Sounds like two trouble makers who need to grow up. I don't buy in to the whole one party is guilty and the other innocent theory... in my thirty two years of existence, I've never witnessed any type of "feud" where only one side was guilty.[/quote]

Once again, I need to lock horns with you.

For one thing, Dave is in a far better vantage point to make the determination.

For another, I don't know if you've ever witnessed bullying or dealt with family members who have substance abuse problems and get violent, but how is the victim guilty? Just because he defends himself or sticks up for himself? Self-defense means that you are a troublemaker that has to grow up? Does not the Cathechism have a section on legitimate defense? Does not the Bible talk about governors being appointed for the punishment of the guilty and the reward of the innocent? And even if the innocent party may be 1 or 10% to blame, does that justify the other party doing physical violence?

In all charity, you need to re-evaluate some of your views.

Posted

Norse,
The bible also teaches about turning the other cheek. It's a difficult situation and Dave pointed out that both parties are 'strong willed' and it's been a long running fued. Neither of us have all the details, nor were we privvy to the private conversations with 'Father'.

Just because Jerry continues to provoke Tom, at some point, Tom must decide to no longer respond to the povocations. Even children learn at some point, to stop poking their sibling back. The apparent fact that neither party could let things go (ie, filing the police report) demonstrates that both parties are willing to participate and both are contributing. Yes, one party may demonstrate as bring MORE culpable, but that is not the point. Turn the other cheek and forgive your brother 7 times 70. You know I'm not a woos, nor a pacifist, but eventually one party has to accept injustice in this world and just offer their suffering up. God is the final judge that will reward the innocent and punish the guilty with perfect mercy and perfect justice.

It's unreasonable to think that Father will be able to achieve a perfect solution and bring peace to this long standing fued that has obviously escalated beyond all reason. It's not like Jerry is attacking random people as he left the Church, there's a reason he attacked Tom, regardless of it was justified or not. Bringing in the police is Tom turning to Civil Athorities for justice and not turning to God for justice. Fair or unfair, Father is in charge of the parish and should be able to kick both out. It's not like either was excommunicated. The conflict had escalated to extreme behavior and it seems reasonable that Father may have decided to utilize an extreme measure to attempt to shock either party to reason.

Posted

Anomaly, "Tom" has been turning the other cheek with "Jerry" for a long time! "Tom" was never mean to "Jerry" in any way; he always remained civil no matter how big a jerk "Jerry" was being. Heck, after "Jerry" told those malicious lies about "Tom," "Tom" was even able to joke about it and apparently harbored no bitterness whatsoever. If YOU were the one being lied about, could YOU do the same thing? Hmmmmm????

Posted

the most we can do here on the phorum is to offer Dave our prayers for this unfortunate situation. :sign:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1382806' date='Sep 10 2007, 06:36 PM']Norse,
The bible also teaches about turning the other cheek. It's a difficult situation and Dave pointed out that both parties are 'strong willed' and it's been a long running fued. Neither of us have all the details, nor were we privvy to the private conversations with 'Father'.

Just because Jerry continues to provoke Tom, at some point, Tom must decide to no longer respond to the povocations. Even children learn at some point, to stop poking their sibling back. The apparent fact that neither party could let things go (ie, filing the police report) demonstrates that both parties are willing to participate and both are contributing. Yes, one party may demonstrate as bring MORE culpable, but that is not the point. Turn the other cheek and forgive your brother 7 times 70. You know I'm not a woos, nor a pacifist, but eventually one party has to accept injustice in this world and just offer their suffering up. God is the final judge that will reward the innocent and punish the guilty with perfect mercy and perfect justice.

It's unreasonable to think that Father will be able to achieve a perfect solution and bring peace to this long standing fued that has obviously escalated beyond all reason. It's not like Jerry is attacking random people as he left the Church, there's a reason he attacked Tom, regardless of it was justified or not. Bringing in the police is Tom turning to Civil Athorities for justice and not turning to God for justice. Fair or unfair, Father is in charge of the parish and should be able to kick both out. It's not like either was excommunicated. The conflict had escalated to extreme behavior and it seems reasonable that Father may have decided to utilize an extreme measure to attempt to shock either party to reason.[/quote]

Anomaly,

Pardon me for not being a better sola scriptura fundamentalist, but the Catholic Church does not take the "turn the other cheek" scripture so literally that it excludes self defense. Remember, "Tom" was physically assaulted. He is within his legal and Catholic rights to defend himself and to file the police report. And he could be doing oher people in the future a service, so for him not to file the police report would be negligence on his part. I wonder how many people would have been spared his harassment if someone had refused to "turn the other cheek" when his bullying started?

Bullies don't change through "turning the other cheek". They change by being stood up to.

Secondly, the way things turned out shows that he cannot turn to the Church for justice, can he?

As I said, I can understand Father wanting to avoid liability issues, but that also means "Tom" also has the right to defend his rights, too. And the fact that Tom has witnesses on his side shows where to look for the truth in this situation. This is his leverage; he should use it.

However, I do think that he should attend a NO mass that is not in schism rather than a TLM that is in schism.

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='Dave' post='1382814' date='Sep 10 2007, 07:43 PM']Anomaly, "Tom" has been turning the other cheek with "Jerry" for a long time! "Tom" was never mean to "Jerry" in any way; he always remained civil no matter how big a jerk "Jerry" was being. Heck, after "Jerry" told those malicious lies about "Tom," "Tom" was even able to joke about it and apparently harbored no bitterness whatsoever. If YOU were the one being lied about, could YOU do the same thing? Hmmmmm????[/quote]So what is it? Is it a long standing feud between two strong willed people or not? You're posting on an internet forum while obviously choosing Tom's side. People have tried to be reasonable and assume the Pastor is not a complete raving lunatic and may have some logic and reason behind his choice. Yet you continue to just defend Tom as being the perfectly innocent victim.
Whatever.
I'll give you some advice you may like.
Get with Tom, hire a Canon Lawyer, and file a lawsuit against Father with the Diocese.
Print up a flyer asking for donations to a legal defense fund and pass them out in the Parish Hall with donuts on Sunday.
If you get enough money, encourage Tom to hire a Civil Lawyer and sue Jerry for defamation, while obtaining a restraining order against him.
If Tom is innocent, he'll win a decree from the Bishop to re-instate him in the parish and a judgement against Jerry, forcing Jerry to find another parish.
Bada-boom, justice is served.

Posted

Yeah, good idea. Listen to Anomaly.

And be sure that Tom mentions that he attends an SSPX parish when he gets with that canon lawyer.

Dave, if you don't want negative opinions about Tom, then A) don't post about Tom on a public message board or B) do a better job at making Tom appear innocent.

As a reminder, here's what YOU said about Tom:
- he's in a long standing fued with another guy
- he attends a SSPX parish
- he was told by a priest not to come back to his church

Are we suppose to canonize him?

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1382757' date='Sep 10 2007, 04:21 PM']Sounds like if Tom is now attending a SSPX parish he's either not good at making decisions, has a problem with obedience, or both.

To me, the priest did the right thing. Sounds like two trouble makers who need to grow up. I don't buy in to the whole one party is guilty and the other innocent theory... in my thirty two years of existence, I've never witnessed any type of "feud" where only one side was guilty.[/quote]
Yeah ... on further review I totally agree.

Posted

Having been in a position of taking a case before the Archbishop before, I can offer one further suggestion. Have everyone who was a witness to the incident write up statements as to what happened, and who was in the wrong. Then put together a petition for Tom's reinstatement to present to your Bishop. If your priest is an "avoid conflict at all possible" kind of guy, and it seems to me as if he is, and just wants this to disappear as quickly as possible, just threatening to send a petition to the bishop will make him reconsider. He won't want to look any worse in front of his boss.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1382869' date='Sep 10 2007, 08:57 PM']Having been in a position of taking a case before the Archbishop before, I can offer one further suggestion. Have everyone who was a witness to the incident write up statements as to what happened, and who was in the wrong. Then put together a petition for Tom's reinstatement to present to your Bishop. If your priest is an "avoid conflict at all possible" kind of guy, and it seems to me as if he is, and just wants this to disappear as quickly as possible, just threatening to send a petition to the bishop will make him reconsider. He won't want to look any worse in front of his boss.[/quote]But what about the flyers? Should they hand them out before mass, or just have them in the parish hall with the donuts?

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...