Innocent Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 (edited) I was wondering about the moral and ethical issues related to the description of sexual acts in fictional literature. [size=1](Of course, I mean serious literature, not romance novellas!) [/size] I was not able to come to a decision about this. Do you think it is acceptable in some cases, or is it pornography in all cases? ([url="http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a6.htm#2354"]CCC2354[/url]) Or is it acceptable if graphical descriptions are not used? (But this would be vague since the level of graphical description is not easy to define objectively.) Or if it would be necessary to show some insight into the human nature of the characters? [In this light, would it be acceptable for the author to even describe perversities to give more insight into a particular character?] What do you think? Can a conclusion be reached based on Church teaching? Edited September 18, 2007 by Innocent
cathoholic_anonymous Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 (edited) Like nudity in art, I accept it. Literature is a study of human beings, and our sexuality is a part of who we are. I dislike trashy romance novellas and wouldn't touch them with a barge pole, as they aim to provide cheap thrills rather than to tell a good story, but literature is another question. The study of literature isn't totally subjective. I can say unequivocally that the poetry of John Donne is leagues away from the verses that a woman I know likes to scribble down and call poetry. It's not all about personal taste. As far as sex in literature is concerned, however, you do need to assess it subjectively. I was a very precocious child where written language was concerned (I could read fluently by the age of two) and I ate up every book that I came across. I wouldn't go anywhere without one. There was talk of sending me for special therapy or some such thing because I wouldn't talk to people, I wouldn't concentrate in class - I just read and read and read. But while my reading age was literally off the chart, my emotional age was not. I was still a child. I read books as a child in primary school that I revisited in college and found wonderful. On first reading, the sex in them was frightening and disturbing. I should never have read books like [i]I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings[/i] as an eight-year-old. The description of the rape made me vomit out of fear and disgust - especially as Ritie was not much older than me. You need to use your good judgement and your knowledge of yourself. Some fiction won't be enjoyable for you and it won't benefit you. Make your decisions based on your mind and personality, as well as the quality of the literature. Edited September 18, 2007 by Cathoholic Anonymous
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 I think that it's okay if it's necessary to the plot and if it is sort of just implied. There's no good reason to go into detail. The audience should be very well aware of what sex is. If they're not, then they're probably too young to be reading that book anyway. I think Romeo and Juliet does a good job of it...they get married and go off together...and (if I remember correctly) the next thing you see is Romeo trying to get out of Juliet's bedroom before he gets caught by her parents. Of course, the older movie has some unnecessary nudity in it...it's artistically done, but it's still unnecessary.
PapaHilarious Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1387751' date='Sep 18 2007, 07:46 AM']I think that it's okay if it's necessary to the plot and if it is sort of just implied. There's no good reason to go into detail. The audience should be very well aware of what sex is. If they're not, then they're probably too young to be reading that book anyway. I think Romeo and Juliet does a good job of it...they get married and go off together...and (if I remember correctly) the next thing you see is Romeo trying to get out of Juliet's bedroom before he gets caught by her parents. Of course, the older movie has some unnecessary nudity in it...it's artistically done, but it's still unnecessary.[/quote] Good points, Raphael. Explicit sexual detail is just pornography disguised as art. It's an old trick that has been used in movies since the 1890s. As has been said on Phatmass previously, [i]Song of Solomon[/i] is a very good example of how it is possible to reverence the beauty of God's design in our bodies and the gift of faithful love. Unfortunately, such examples are definitely the exception in literature (and film).
Sojourner Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 I think most romance novels are porn for women.
Innocent Posted September 18, 2007 Author Posted September 18, 2007 (edited) [quote name='PapaHilarious' post='1387785' date='Sep 18 2007, 09:18 PM']Good points, Raphael. Explicit sexual detail is just pornography disguised as art. It's an old trick that has been used in movies since the 1890s. As has been said on Phatmass previously, [i]Song of Solomon[/i] is a very good example of how it is possible to reverence the beauty of God's design in our bodies and the gift of faithful love. Unfortunately, such examples are definitely the exception in literature (and film).[/quote] Can you name any examples of such proper reverence for sexuality (as God's design) in literature and film? Edited September 18, 2007 by Innocent
PapaHilarious Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='Innocent' post='1387813' date='Sep 18 2007, 09:56 AM']Can you name any examples of such proper reverence for sexuality (as God's design) in literature and film?[/quote] Good question. Nothing comes to mind. I'm sure it's theoretically [i]possible[/i], though.
CatherineM Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 I have found in the past that I tend to automatically skip through those parts of books, and fast forward past in movies. I was always careful about what I let my foster kids watch. I sheltered myself to such an extent that I still have to ask my husband sometimes what something means when I hear it on the news. I don't feel any less educated.
PapaHilarious Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1387824' date='Sep 18 2007, 10:09 AM']I have found in the past that I tend to automatically skip through those parts of books, and fast forward past in movies. I was always careful about what I let my foster kids watch. I sheltered myself to such an extent that I still have to ask my husband sometimes what something means when I hear it on the news. I don't feel any less educated.[/quote] [i]The Screwtape Letters [/i]has a great chapter about how successful the Devil has been with labeling things "Puritanical." That's so true of our culture: that you're some kind of prude or weirdo if you don't enjoy seeing and hearing inappropriate behavior.
Innocent Posted September 18, 2007 Author Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='PapaHilarious' post='1387822' date='Sep 18 2007, 10:36 PM']Good question. Nothing comes to mind. I'm sure it's theoretically [i]possible[/i], though. [/quote] You think it is theoretically possible? Then for sure among the vast output of literature and film, there are sure to be some instances of such reverence for sexuality. Such writers and directors should be encouraged, then.
Innocent Posted September 18, 2007 Author Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1387824' date='Sep 18 2007, 10:39 PM']I have found in the past that I tend to automatically skip through those parts of books, and fast forward past in movies. I was always careful about what I let my foster kids watch. I sheltered myself to such an extent that I still have to ask my husband sometimes what something means when I hear it on the news. I don't feel any less educated.[/quote] You have kept yourself pure. Very inspiring.
CatherineM Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 There is a group of Mormons, I think, that actually sell edited copies of DVD's. Kind of like how they would have to edit it to show on TV 20 years ago. I've been meaning to look them up, but keep forgetting. Innocent-I have always believed in the purity prayer, especially the part about protecting my eyes, the window to my soul, from anything that might dim the luster of a heart that should mirror only Christ-like purity. I know that makes me silly, and old fashioned, and frankly, I do get embarrassed having to ask my husband about things that a middle aged women should probably know. On the other hand there is a simplicity in not knowing some things. I think my husband likes the idea that he doesn't have to worry about any of my old boyfriends showing up at the door since I never had anyone but him.
PapaHilarious Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='Innocent' post='1387842' date='Sep 18 2007, 10:26 AM']You think it is theoretically possible? Then for sure among the vast output of literature and film, there are sure to be some instances of such reverence for sexuality. Such writers and directors should be encouraged, then.[/quote] I actually am a writer/director in Hollywood as well as being an author. I see very little evidence of those in power actually respecting the dignity of their actors. Instead, thanks to the all-mighty Dollar, it is much more common to put them in sexually suggestive situations of various sorts to titillate the audience. That being said, I will never condone such behavior in anything I work on, so I will take your encouragement personally. Thank you.
Sojourner Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 I would say there are instances where sex is treated more respectfully than others ... there is, in my mind, a big difference between a harlequin novel and other novels I've read that contained parts about a sexual encounter. There is such a scene in "Shadow of the Wind," which although it describes an encounter between two unmarried people is still really beautifully written ... done not in a way to elicit arousal or titillation but as a part of the plot and character development. I've read other such scenes in other books that are done with that in mind. However, I've also read sex scenes in books where it's obvious that some marketing genius thought it should be there in order to sell more books. It comes up quite a bit in adult sci fi/fantasy novels, and those parts I always skim. I think that's one of the reasons I prefer to read young adult novels along those lines ... less likely to include graphic scenes.
hoosieranna Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1387981' date='Sep 18 2007, 02:44 PM']I There is such a scene in "Shadow of the Wind," which although it describes an encounter between two unmarried people is still really beautifully written ... done not in a way to elicit arousal or titillation but as a part of the plot and character development.[/quote] Off topic for just a sec: I love that book! I bought it in Wales.
Sojourner Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='Nadezhda' post='1388037' date='Sep 18 2007, 03:20 PM']Off topic for just a sec: I love that book! I bought it in Wales.[/quote] I've never met anyone else who read it! I absolutely loved that book. It is the only real novel I read last year. (I read a bunch of young adult carp). His second novel hadn't been translated last I checked and it is too much work to read it in Spanish.
PapaHilarious Posted September 18, 2007 Posted September 18, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1388050' date='Sep 18 2007, 02:25 PM'] I've never met anyone else who read it! I absolutely loved that book. It is the only real novel I read last year. (I read a bunch of young adult carp). His second novel hadn't been translated last I checked and it is too much work to read it in Spanish. [/quote] you just said "carp." hilarious good analysis back there, though. there certainly must be more examples in literature than in film. really, that's no surprise though, since sex has been intermingled with film since it's conception.
kateri05 Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 plus a visual of sex or sexually linked activities has much different connotations and consequences for a viewer than a description on a page.
Innocent Posted September 19, 2007 Author Posted September 19, 2007 [quote name='kateri05' post='1388282' date='Sep 19 2007, 07:16 AM']plus a visual of sex or sexually linked activities has much different connotations and consequences for a viewer than a description on a page.[/quote] Other than the fact that a video/photographic visual involves models/actors who have debased sexuality in the act of acting/posing for the film/photo, and thus the viewer has encouraged this perverse activity, what are the [u][i][b]different [/b][/i][/u] consequences [i][u][b]for the viewer[/b][/u][/i]?
cmotherofpirl Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 [quote name='PapaHilarious' post='1388074' date='Sep 18 2007, 05:56 PM']you just said "carp." hilarious [/quote] phatmass has filters...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now