Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote]what are the different consequences for the viewer?[/quote]

i suppose its different for everyone, but i think that, particularly men, have much more potential to be led into lustful thoughts with visual imagery than with the written word.

also, something about SEEING it makes it seem more real, and less fictionalized, does that make sense?

Posted

[quote]phatmass has filters...[/quote]

that's carp :)

Posted

One of the texts we are using in my Creeds class is The Holy Longing by Ronald Rolheiser, OMI, and he actually has a section on pornography. It says, "What is wrong with pornography is not that there is something wrong in seeing the sexual act. Sex is not dirty or sinful. What is wrong with pornography is that it overstimulates our archetypal erotic energies, leaving us no choice but to act out those energies (as a mythical god or goddess might, without restraints and limits) or to go into a depression, namely to turn on the cooling mechanisms inside of us, restrain those energies, and then sizzle in inchoate frustration as they slowly cool.... What is problematic is that this is not an event meant to be watched. It is too raw. Love is meant to be made behind closed doors. Every society has had taboos about sex, about having it and about exhibiting it. The wisdom in the taboo against exhibition is not first and foremost, about morality and sin. It is about protecting people's souls from the kind of unhappiness that (the people he was talking about) experienced..."

And no, I have not figured out why this text is required reading for a class on Creeds, but no one asked my opinion.

Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1388377' date='Sep 19 2007, 09:00 AM']i suppose its different for everyone, but i think that, particularly men, have much more potential to be led into lustful thoughts with visual imagery than with the written word.

also, something about SEEING it makes it seem more real, and less fictionalized, does that make sense?[/quote]

Yes, that makes sense, thank you for the clarification.

Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1387792' date='Sep 18 2007, 11:05 AM']I think most romance novels are porn for women.[/quote]

I whole heartedly agree. Men are aroused by sight; women by words. Given this, porn and "romance novels" achieve the same end with their intended audiences.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1388482' date='Sep 19 2007, 02:52 AM']One of the texts we are using in my Creeds class is The Holy Longing by Ronald Rolheiser, OMI, and he actually has a section on pornography. It says, "What is wrong with pornography is not that there is something wrong in seeing the sexual act. Sex is not dirty or sinful. What is wrong with pornography is that it overstimulates our archetypal erotic energies, leaving us no choice but to act out those energies (as a mythical god or goddess might, without restraints and limits) or to go into a depression, namely to turn on the cooling mechanisms inside of us, restrain those energies, and then sizzle in inchoate frustration as they slowly cool.... What is problematic is that this is not an event meant to be watched. It is too raw. Love is meant to be made behind closed doors. Every society has had taboos about sex, about having it and about exhibiting it. The wisdom in the taboo against exhibition is not first and foremost, about morality and sin. It is about protecting people's souls from the kind of unhappiness that (the people he was talking about) experienced..."

And no, I have not figured out why this text is required reading for a class on Creeds, but no one asked my opinion.[/quote]
THat is an excellent quote and so clearly explains the problem with porn.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1388482' date='Sep 19 2007, 12:22 PM']One of the texts we are using in my Creeds class is The Holy Longing by Ronald Rolheiser, OMI, and he actually has a section on pornography. It says, "What is wrong with pornography is not that there is something wrong in seeing the sexual act. Sex is not dirty or sinful. What is wrong with pornography is that it overstimulates our archetypal erotic energies, leaving us no choice but to act out those energies (as a mythical god or goddess might, without restraints and limits) or to go into a depression, namely to turn on the cooling mechanisms inside of us, restrain those energies, and then sizzle in inchoate frustration as they slowly cool.... What is problematic is that this is not an event meant to be watched. It is too raw. Love is meant to be made behind closed doors. Every society has had taboos about sex, about having it and about exhibiting it. The wisdom in the taboo against exhibition is not first and foremost, about morality and sin. It is about protecting people's souls from the kind of unhappiness that (the people he was talking about) experienced..."

And no, I have not figured out why this text is required reading for a class on Creeds, but no one asked my opinion.[/quote]

So does this mean that any description of sexual activity beyond a certian limit would be inherently problematic, or would it be possible for descriptions of sexuality to actually express the beauty of sexuality?

Hmm.. when I think of it, it appears that the martial intimacy is meant to be experienced between husband and wife, and any description of it to a third party (the reader) would as Ronald Rolheiser says, "overstimulate our archetypal erotic energies".

So, any description of sexuality in fiction is problematic. What do you think?

Posted

[quote name='Innocent' post='1391888' date='Sep 23 2007, 09:29 PM']So does this mean that any description of sexual activity beyond a certian limit would be inherently problematic, or would it be possible for descriptions of sexuality to actually express the beauty of sexuality?

Hmm.. when I think of it, it appears that the martial intimacy is meant to be experienced between husband and wife, and any description of it to a third party (the reader) would as Ronald Rolheiser says, "overstimulate our archetypal erotic energies".

So, any description of sexuality in fiction is problematic. What do you think?[/quote]

For women I think its very easy for any verbal description to slip into lust and porn.

Posted

He was specifically talking about a group of middle aged people who were old college friends, on a cross country RV trip, who were having a great time until the night they spent in a camp ground where a bunch of college aged kids were frolicking, everywhere apparently. The rest of the trip, these couples seemed to be unhappy and irritable. It had overwhelmed them to see these young people copulating out in the open.

I think that in written fiction, where you are basically creating an imagine in your mind of the story, you can better control the amount of stimulation that you create, so as not to overwhelm yourself. The more explicit and detailed the writing, the harder it would be to limit your stimulation. With video, that goes out the window. It is at the discretion of the actors and the director as to how stimulated you become. You can shut your eyes and still hear it. The only way to shut it completely out is to skip over that part of the movie. It is much easier to skip a few sentences or paragraphs in a book.

Before I married, I was always very careful to skip over parts of books, and fast forward through movies that I felt might violate my personal chastity. Since I've been married, I have allowed myself to watch or read things I never would have before, and I'm certainly not talking about pornography. I would never watch something deemed to be morally offensive, but there are many even pg movies that contain scenes that made me uncomfortable before. It has filled in some gaps for me on movies that had parts that didn't make sense to me before because I had skipped over certain other parts. The same for books. Even in parts of books that I had read before, now I visualize different things since I'm a bit less innocent now.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1391920' date='Sep 24 2007, 07:23 AM']For women I think its very easy for any verbal description to slip into lust and porn.[/quote]


It might not apply only to women, but also to men who prefer literature to film as a means of entertainment.

I think they too would fall into lust easily with words. After all, evil is a perversion of something good, isn't it?

It occurs to me that the reason it would be problematic to read any level of sexual description would be that the reader would be, in effect, permitting someone else (the author of the literature) to stimulate the erotic energies in the reader, even though it is done through the medium of literature and not directly. (Thus it becomes a mental affair between the author and the reader.) This stimulation of erotic energies should be reserved only for marriage.

In that angle, it could be said that films or literature that have descriptions or depictions of martial acts are (or, have the potential to be, even if they were intended as an artistic expression by the director/author) another kind of virtual sex, like phone sex or sex chat.


There are spme people of the view that a married couple could read such literature to each other. Would this be justified? I have doubts about it.

Edited by Innocent
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1391923' date='Sep 24 2007, 07:27 AM']I think that in written fiction, where you are basically creating an imagine in your mind of the story, you can better control the amount of stimulation that you create, so as not to overwhelm yourself. The more explicit and detailed the writing, the harder it would be to limit your stimulation. With video, that goes out the window. It is at the discretion of the actors and the director as to how stimulated you become. You can shut your eyes and still hear it. The only way to shut it completely out is to skip over that part of the movie. It is much easier to skip a few sentences or paragraphs in a book.[/quote]

Yes, but for someone who knows he has a tendency to lust in such a situation, reading such materials would be to place himself willingly in a proximate occassion of sin. So there might be some difference, between literature and film, but in practice it is vague, since once one slips into the state of lust, he is no longer in complete control of his actions, being dominated by lustful passion, and could easily go in search of more stimulating material. Thus it is imperative to avoid that first taste of seemingly permissable material. Do you agree?

Posted

I do agree that pornography can be an addiction. Any addiction can escalate. Some people can become addicted after one taste of a drug. My foster sons both had dads who were alcoholic, and their mom was an alcoholic and addict. I let them know from an early age that they were genetically susceptible to addiction, and the only way to avoid it was to never take that first drink, or first taste.

I never put a lot of thought into it before this discussion, but I've never been a chick flick kind of person, and instead always tended to watch cartoons or sci/fi. Maybe that is because there are a lot less inappropriate things in between robots.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...