Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What *exactly* Is Lust?


Recommended Posts

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

So, as most people here know, I'm a scrupulant, and since I'm soon to be married, I've been particularly scrupulous lately about lust, because I'm afraid it's all too natural to slip into it.

What exactly is lust? We know, of course, that it takes place in the mind of the one lusting and is acted out in certain ways.

When a person speaks, the body is expressing the soul. Let's say that person A says something. Person B, who hears it, knows that it is Person A that is talking, rather than knowing simply that Person A's gums are flapping, but not attributing that speech to Person A himself. It is implicit in Person B's hearing those words that there is something deeper than just moving lips and spoken words: a person, Person A, is speaking. Person B, likewise, does not need to make a conscious effort to keep in mind when responding that he is speaking to a person. Person B already subconsciously understands that and responds accordingly.

Is the same true for body language? Is the same true for sexual body language? When a man and his wife are together...in the marital way...does a man automatically and subconsciously, upon seeing his wife, whose souls speaks through her body, see her as a person, or does his mind see a body and only a body, requiring him to make up for it with a conscious effort to keep her soul in mind as well, so as not to lust after her, but to love her whole person? I ask because this seems much more difficult than spoken language, as it is hard to get lost in spoken words and hear only the words themselves, but not seem to notice that it is a person speaking, whereas one could easily imagine a man getting caught up in the language of the body so much that he fails to realize that it is the expression of something much deeper. This seems compounded for a man who is not used to seeing the language of the body, such as a newlywed, which is why the whole thing makes me so anxious.

Anyway, I'm all confused, and it is important, because in the end, it comes to this: if, when the lover desires the other on sight of the body, the soul automatically interprets through the body of the other that it has a soul and loves that soul, then no extra effort is needed...two people can act without straining to think consciously about what the soul is already unconsciously taking into account. If, on the other hand, the soul does not automatically do this, then one would have to do that himself, consciously, or else fall into lust. However, that would make for very little if any enjoyment, as the whole thing would be a sort of scrupulous duty.

Input?

God bless,

Micah

Posted

Lust is implies something illicit or unrestrained, inordinate with your state.

I agree with everything you have stated so far. According to Theology of the Body and its interpretation, the opposite of love is not hate, its use. We are not a dualists. The body and the soul are in conjunction with each other. Like you were saying, sin starts in the mind. I think the most important thing is to keep your mind in the right place towards your wife or husband. A person is never to be a means to an end. If you fully love your husband or wife and have open communication and are close to the sacraments, I think you need not worry about the purity for your sexual expression towards each other.

Something I recently heard was a caution against prudery (viewing an ankle is scandalous i.e. amish views). It is important to be prudent without going to the extreme of inordinate prudery. Sexuality is an amazing gift that should be used properly.

I engaged to be married as well, and have had similar concerns, but on the female end of things. The best thing for me has been to talk with my fiance about it (of course, very carefully. It's not good to sit around talking about sex all of the time with the person you're about to marry.) Couples need to talk about their concerns. We are always sure to point of if something, verbal or physical, does not seem like an act of love towards the other.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Yeah, I agree that it's not smart to talk about sex all that much before marriage...which is why my fiancee and I really only discuss the things that bother us.

I think the whole problem for me comes from a goofy view of reality. I was somewhat formed in my teenage years by some silly philosophies, including one that sort of makes too much out of consciousness. It would state that only what we are conscious of is truly real, which is of course an extremely poor form of subjectivism. While I rid myself of this philosophy as a whole, I find that I am often still, unintentionally, affected by some of its tendencies.

One such tendency is that I often view the world as exterior and my consciousness as interior. Since conscious thought is reality (in this philosophy), then my consciousness is sort of like a virtual reality machine...I have to have a replica of all the things on the outside if I want to affect reality. For instance, this worldview often affects the way I pray...I have this silly idea that I have to be completely conscious of God's existence or else He's not there and I'm not praying to Him. It's like everything I want to relate to in the outside world has to have a counterpart in my conscious little mental image. Of course, God is infinite, so that makes prayer very difficult...

Anyway, I think this whole situation arises out of that. I have this silly idea that in order to truly love my fiancee, I need to love her in my mind first, in this little consciousness world...but her soul is ultimately not accessible to me, lol...so I can never put her whole person in there, and if I can, it's not really her, just a replica...while this whole method works with inanimate objects, when it comes to persons, it's impossible, and actually does damage to the person.

In reality, it's a type of dualism that separates the spiritual and the physical into two interrelated, but separate groups...not two groups that intertwine, one affecting the other, but two entities that only distantly affect one another.

What is needed is a firm grasp that reality is beyond myself and that I am part of it. With that, I needn't act with love toward a mental concept first, but really and truly love the real person, not the image, in front of me. I need a more earthy reality...I need to realize that she's really here, and that I really am loving her, and that what I do with the body really is happening.

As I said, I believe these things, but the contrary view still sneaks in from time to time.

God bless,

Micah

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1390834' date='Sep 22 2007, 05:24 PM']It's like during meditation trying to have a "picture" of God in your mind, which only distracts your real meditation. But, if you generally treat the other with respect and moderation, then I think in the "act" you will be able to practice the virtue of chastity without thinking too much (if that makes sense). It's like when eating, you have to be careful not to be gluttonous, but you should enjoy the meal while keeping proper limits in the back of your mind.[/quote]
I think you hit the nail on the head. That's exactly what I meant in my second post. Sure, it's nice to have a mental image to aid you as a reminder, but if Jesus were in front of you, would you be all that busy trying to conjure up an image of you worshiping Him or would you just get down and worship Him, really and truly present before you?

I try to have a "picture" in my mind of precisely what I mean to do...and I try to hold on to that picture as if I need it in order to do the real thing. I suppose if, instead, I concentrated on the actual reality in the real world, I would be just as able to interact with the world, but directly...almost like stepping out of virtual reality into the real world...everything would be crisper and I would be much more aware of what everything was really like. My love for Jennie would be directed toward her directly. I wouldn't need to think about my love for her...my love would be incarnate...a touch would be my love...a kiss would be my love...it needn't be all abstract...it needs to be earthy and gritty and real.

Thanks, Era. :)

Posted

My husband was my first, and we were both 43, so I had a lot of fear and potential embarrassment to deal with. What really helped me was Theology of the Body, specifically the overall theme of "naked without shame." What also helped was the TOB making it so clear to me that when you marry, you basically give yourself completely to your spouse and vice versa. So my body belongs to my husband, and his body belongs to me. I don't think that it is lust to desire to be with him. Marital pleasure is God's gift to us. Most importantly, the feeling of being open to life (even at our advanced elderly ages) takes any notion that you are acting out of lust out of the equation.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1390976' date='Sep 22 2007, 08:09 PM']My husband was my first, and we were both 43, so I had a lot of fear and potential embarrassment to deal with. What really helped me was Theology of the Body, specifically the overall theme of "naked without shame." What also helped was the TOB making it so clear to me that when you marry, you basically give yourself completely to your spouse and vice versa. So my body belongs to my husband, and his body belongs to me. I don't think that it is lust to desire to be with him. Marital pleasure is God's gift to us. Most importantly, the feeling of being open to life (even at our advanced elderly ages) takes any notion that you are acting out of lust out of the equation.[/quote]
The problem was more a matter of whether one would be able to love the whole person when confronted with the body. I don't doubt the whole TOTB thing, but what was bothering me was the idea that I would be so overwhelmed by the newness of the body that I wouldn't even consider her soul. As I said, I think this was coming from the difficulty I have with my mentality; if I realize that this is not just some situation to deal with in my mind (in which case I can't mentally conceive of her whole person), but in reality, then I am struck with the fact that I couldn't possibly miss her whole person, unless I was deliberately trying to give no thought to her soul and intentionally focusing on the body alone, because her whole personhood will be right there, not all of it visible, but still all of it present, her body and her soul expressing itself through her body.

Okay, I've got the situation figured out and I now have to stop thinking about this because it's not wise to focus on these issues before marriage any more than necessary to face the concern itself.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

I had one other thing I wanted to add. When someone has had patches on their eyes for medical reasons, they don't take them off all at once in a bright room for fear that they will be overwhelmed. They take them off slowly in a dark room. We took things in stages, slowly so that I wouldn't be overwhelmed.

Posted

Raphael, Im workin on the paper. So I did not read the thread. Im just answering the questions

Lust=self-serving, an attraction moved to satisfy only self. The object of desire is seen as a resource to pervert in order to satisfy that urge

Sex desire that is good= seeks to experience the other person. Desires not to destroy or pervert, but to experience and know. To share, to give plessure not just experience plessure.

Longing/desire sexually for your spouse is a good thing as long as she is not seen as a resource to satisfy your urge. Your desire is to be one with her. To experience her and open yourself to her in a way not open to others.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1390986' date='Sep 22 2007, 07:31 PM']I had one other thing I wanted to add. When someone has had patches on their eyes for medical reasons, they don't take them off all at once in a bright room for fear that they will be overwhelmed. They take them off slowly in a dark room. We took things in stages, slowly so that I wouldn't be overwhelmed.[/quote]
sounds like you married the right guy

Posted

I feel like loving a woman and rejecting lust while engaging in the marital embrace should be one fluid motion. Not like "I have to do this but then I also have to think about not lusting." More like "love love love love love love love love love love love love love."

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1391022' date='Sep 22 2007, 09:34 PM']I feel like loving a woman and rejecting lust while engaging in the marital embrace should be one fluid motion. Not like "I have to do this but then I also have to think about not lusting." More like "love love love love love love love love love love love love love."[/quote]
Yes, you're right. If we focus on the positive, it becomes possible to do great things easily. If we focus on avoiding the negative, it becomes a challenge and a battle littered with souls.

Posted

And if you are scrupulous, I'm sure you are aware that it is a challenge to focus on the positive.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1391165' date='Sep 22 2007, 11:09 PM']And if you are scrupulous, I'm sure you are aware that it is a challenge to focus on the positive.[/quote]
Yes. Yes, I am. It always seems more important to avoid the negative.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1391023' date='Sep 23 2007, 08:06 AM']Yes, you're right. If we focus on the positive, it becomes possible to do great things easily. If we focus on avoiding the negative, it becomes a challenge and a battle littered with souls.[/quote]

Hey, that's a great thought.

Posted

Just as a quick side note, I am not familiar with Theology of the Body. I should learn about it though...

As far as philosophy goes, we are not separated into body and soul, but we are a unified body and soul. As the body cannot live without the soul, the body cannot be set apart from the soul. When a man looks upon his wife he would not say "I am looking at your body," but rather "I am looking at you." I think that the way that you would fall into lust is only if a married man consciously separated her body from her soul in which case he would be objectifying her and his thoughts would then be those of looking at her body. When we look upon someone, we look upon their personhood. Lust is when we fail to recognize their personhood and look merely upon their body.

When you look upon your parents, or a co-worker, or your fiance (or spouse), your mind isn't thinking "This is the body of my mother," but rather, "This is my mother." I think as humans, we naturally recognize someones personhood unless we are consciously objectifying them. When a man looks at pornography, we are not saying with our minds, "This is Sue Smith," but rather, "This is a body part."

God bless you and your fiance!
-Marcus

withouthavingseen
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1390839' date='Sep 22 2007, 06:38 PM']What is needed is a firm grasp that reality is beyond myself and that I am part of it. With that, I needn't act with love toward a mental concept first, but really and truly love the real person, not the image, in front of me. I need a more earthy reality...I need to realize that she's really here, and that I really am loving her, and that what I do with the body really is happening.[/quote]

Micah / Raph,

You wrote "I need to realize that she's really here... is really happening," and I think it is kinda funny. In a later post you wrote that you need to stop thinking about it. I agree with you. The solution to a mind game or a philosophical problem isn't usually thinking about it until you get sick (ad nauseam?!). The solution is to get out of the game by playing a different one.

Observations:

(1) If you've made a sacrificial effort to be chaste before marriage, you can be confident that you love your fiancee. That seems to be your case.

(2) In your marriage, you will continue to find ways to serve her.

(3) Let's that service to your bride be an integral part of all your married life. Make a game out of it. Anyway, making a game of things has always helped me to take them more seriously, in a converse way. "If I can stay at my desk and work for 1 hour, then I will win and get to have a chocolate bar!" I'll say to myself. You might do something similar, "Can I find and do 3 ways today to serve my wife that I never did before?"

(4) Even in bed, maybe try to make a game out of serving your wife. Make an effort to perceive (and NOT analyze) what she is enjoying and what she is not, and then direct your great love toward serving her.

(5) It will take trial and error, but with time, you will get better and better and making her happy in all the aspects of your marriage. And conversely, you will find yourself happier and happier the more you lose yourself in making her happy.

God bless!

withouthavingseen
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1391170' date='Sep 23 2007, 12:14 AM']Yes. Yes, I am. It always seems more important to avoid the negative.[/quote]

No! That's a trick of the devil to make our life miserable. Of course scruples is better than mortal sin. Sure. But that's not the point. The whole essence of Christianity is NOT some moral code (ours is very little different than any other traditional religious code). The whole essence of Christianity is a deep interior change of heart that makes it so that we instinctively love and do the good, and not even worry about it any more. This transformation is NOT within our power or control to work by simple vigilance. If it were, we wouldn't need Christ within us.

Luke 18:20-22, [i]You know the commandments: `Do not commit adultery, Do not kill, Do not steal, Do not bear false witness, Honor your father and mother.'" And he said, "All these I have observed from my youth." And when Jesus heard it, he said to him, "One thing you still lack. Sell all that you have and distribute to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; and come, follow me."[/i]

Of course we must make every effort to avoid sin, especially mortal sin, at all costs. St. Philip Neri said, "Do whatever you like, just please never sin!" And St. Augustine, "Love, and then do what you will." Once we have gotten to a point of not commiting mortal sins on a regular basis, it is time to switch gears, or else we will never make spiritual progress. In fact, as long as we are staring terrified at mortal sin, and nervously eyeing the line in the sand dividing virtue from vice, we will always be only a millimeter from stumbling across it. Which gives the Devil his easy victory. Without grace, we would all fall very quickly into the greatest depravity. But what I've learned in my struggle against scruples is that God's grace really does shatter sin, and fear, and fear of sin. Scruples are about control - I have to do X, Y, and Z to prove myself to God.

But I cannot prove myself to God. He already knows what I am. He is trying to show Himself to me, and as long as I try to run the show, I can never see Him or receive His love. We cannot even rid ourselves of our own scruples (you have probably tried, and been frustrated by failure). Our whole culture trains us to try to be "grown ups" and "put together" and "in charge". But our Father just wants us to be His little boys and girls, resting in Him, and receiving from Him everything we need. He wants to give us grace to overcome scruples and find real peace, deep peace, even in the face of our own sinfulness. It is an amazing thing to be able to wage merciless war against sin in ourselves, while relaxing and enjoying life. It is freedom.

Ask Jesus to show you the Father's great love, and to grant you rest. Go to him.

Matthew 11:28-29, [i]Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn from me; for I am gentle and lowly in heart, and you will find rest for your souls.[/i]

Make that your prayer. I will pray for you too. Scruples is such a paralyzing thing - a trick of the devil.

Posted (edited)

I'm not married but I often think that once people are married, if they have a well-formed conscience they will have the grace of having their conscience inform them which feelings are lust and which feelings are natural and acceptable desires for their spouse. And of course, inappropriate desires for [i]anyone[/i], spouse or not, are not a sin until they are let loose in the imagination (as opposed to being stopped once the person becomes conscious of them).

I don't think that's too theoretical because I know marriage confers special graces, like the grace to raise the children God sends.

Edited by Totus Tuus
Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1393026' date='Sep 25 2007, 07:27 PM'](as opposed to being stopped once the person becomes conscious of them).[/quote]
Tell me if you disagree.

I'm not sure most people actually have the mental focus to stop a sexual thought at once. Seeking to banish them is one thing, but a lot of bad thoughts can linger for quite some time without being embraced or wanted or consented to. My point is, just because you are struggling with a thought for an extended period of time does not mean that you are necesarily sinning.

I might be wrong though. It wouldn't be the first time...I was wrong once when I was 14, and again a few years later I was wrong for doubting my rightness. :mellow:

:whistle:

No seriously, I might be wrong about this.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='XIX' post='1393148' date='Sep 26 2007, 10:08 AM']My point is, just because you are struggling with a thought for an extended period of time does not mean that you are necesarily sinning.[/quote]

That's something I'd like to understand better, too.

Let me suggest a hypothetical situation:

Suppose the lustful thought first entered my mind through my own imprudence or over-confidence in my own strengths, ("Just a little look won't hurt, I'm not actually going to act out on it. Just a tiny little look. It will only last a few seconds. There can't possibly be anything wrong in it." - All lies. I'm not fooling anyone, least of all God.) then I feel that there is some sinfulness involved in struggling with that sinful thought, because it germinated because I could compromise God's standard of sexual morality with my own jury-rigged adulterated standard created for my convenience.

Of course, struggling for some time and then ultimately not giving in to the temptation to entertain the sinful thought is something of merit.

On the other hand, if I were doing something innocent, and by pure chance, something stimulated the germ of a sinful thought in my mind, there is no sinfulness involved during the struggle.

I have to struggle with sinful thoughts many times. I consider that my struggles are an indication that I don't love God sufficiently enough to [i]want[/i] to do His will. If I loved Christ more passionately, I would not have to struggle so much.

Edited by Innocent

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...