Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What *exactly* Is Lust?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[quote]Just as a quick side note, I am not familiar with Theology of the Body. I should learn about it though...[/quote]

Slappo, go here. You to Raph...

www.christopherwest.com

"If you have the funds get the Created and Redeemed series. It's worth every penny.

Mr. West tells the story of two bishops walking down the street. They come upon a prostitute scantily clad. One bishop immediately looks away while the other looks intently at the woman. The one who looks away says "Brother Bishop you must look away". The other Bishop says "there I see a daughter of God who has been abused by men". He is not enslaved by his lust but rather desires the good of the woman and recognizes that the great dignity of being made in the image and likeness of God has been obscured in this woman. He sees that dignity. This is what we must strive to attain. Lust is the roadblock to us seeing the true value of the human body. Love on the other hand values the person for who they are rather than what they can do for you.

Now interestingly enough Mr. West asks which of the men did the right thing. The answer is both. The one knew that he could not look at the woman without lusting and such a look is like trampling a flower and so should be avoided. I have found it good that when I look at a woman who is attracitve, the second my mind starts going in the wrong direction I automatically say a Hail Mary. It really helps.

It should also be noted that marriage is not a license to lust even after your wife. So be careful of that as well. You are to make yourself a gift to her in the marital act. If this is the goal then the pleasure will be greater for the both of you. Guaranteed.

Through learning the truth and through the sacraments we can overcome our lustful tendancies that seem so natural in us.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

Two good articles from Mr. West's site:

[url="http://www.theologyofthebody.com/10-13-06.asp"]http://www.theologyofthebody.com/10-13-06.asp[/url]
[url="http://www.theologyofthebody.com/10-27-06.asp"]http://www.theologyofthebody.com/10-27-06.asp[/url]

Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1393148' date='Sep 25 2007, 11:38 PM']Tell me if you disagree.

I'm not sure most people actually have the mental focus to stop a sexual thought at once. Seeking to banish them is one thing, but a lot of bad thoughts can linger for quite some time without being embraced or wanted or consented to. My point is, just because you are struggling with a thought for an extended period of time does not mean that you are necesarily sinning.

I might be wrong though. It wouldn't be the first time...I was wrong once when I was 14, and again a few years later I was wrong for doubting my rightness. :mellow:

:whistle:

No seriously, I might be wrong about this.[/quote]

Basically that is exactly what I was saying. It is a fact that impure thoughts do not become sinful until we know they are there and choose not to banish them.

Posted

[quote name='Innocent' post='1393343' date='Sep 26 2007, 11:01 AM']That's something I'd like to understand better, too.

Let me suggest a hypothetical situation:

Suppose the lustful thought first entered my mind through my own imprudence or over-confidence in my own strengths, ("Just a little look won't hurt, I'm not actually going to act out on it. Just a tiny little look. It will only last a few seconds. There can't possibly be anything wrong in it." - All lies. I'm not fooling anyone, least of all God.) then I feel that there is some sinfulness involved in struggling with that sinful thought, because it germinated because I could compromise God's standard of sexual morality with my own jury-rigged adulterated standard created for my convenience.

Of course, struggling for some time and then ultimately not giving in to the temptation to entertain the sinful thought is something of merit.

On the other hand, if I were doing something innocent, and by pure chance, something stimulated the germ of a sinful thought in my mind, there is no sinfulness involved during the struggle.

I have to struggle with sinful thoughts many times. I consider that my struggles are an indication that I don't love God sufficiently enough to [i]want[/i] to do His will. If I loved Christ more passionately, I would not have to struggle so much.[/quote]

Once a priest quoted St. Augustine to me, and this is what he said: "Birds will fly. You haven't done anything wrong until you let them land on your head and make a nest in your hair".


That seems to apply to the situations your hypothesizing.

Posted

[quote]Once a priest quoted St. Augustine to me, and this is what he said: "Birds will fly. You haven't done anything wrong until you let them land on your head and make a nest in your hair".[/quote]

oh this is so brilliant!! i am going to remember this and use it in my theology classes! :)

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1391023' date='Sep 22 2007, 10:36 PM']Yes, you're right. If we focus on the positive, it becomes possible to do great things easily. If we focus on avoiding the negative, it becomes a challenge and a battle littered with souls.[/quote]
A - M - E - N !


[quote name='Raphael' post='1391170' date='Sep 23 2007, 12:14 AM']Yes. Yes, I am. It always seems more important to avoid the negative.[/quote]
I feel u bro.

Posted

That you fear to do your beloved wrong, and that you fear to do your Beloved wrong is a song from heaven called "Piety". From what I understand, scruples are a disordered form of piety. As you aren't gnawing your hands off for fear of evil while typing, I am supposing your scrupulousity is not unmanageable. If that is your cross in life, rejoice!

I am sure there are a dozen people who can define and advise on matter of principle many times better than I. I'll still give my own advice nonetheless, as Lust and I have a long history.

First, congratulations! Ah to be married!

Now, let's get to the business at hand. Yes, to lust is to use. Lusting for a woman is a burning for relief, not for the other. Lust is in mechanical repetition, not in yearning. Lust will darken your heart and close your mind upon itself in a recursive loop. Lust will focus you upon yourself, and you seek pleasure in your spouse only for your own ego.

But do not worry overmuch. Have you not received the waters of Baptism? Have you not the Body and Blood of God assimilated within your own? Have you not the seal of oil upon your brow? Have you not two angels watching over your marital embrace? Have you not a ready Confessor to heal you of those sins that might deaden your senses of spirit?

As long as you faithfully speak and listen earnestly to your wife, pray with her, and remain faithful to the Sacramental life that you have been entrusted to live, grave sin is far from you. Indeed, you will be guarded and protected even more than you are at this moment, for Eros was created good too.

How can I say these things? Because I have already done everything wrong. Though I have repented, and my wounds may not bring me death, the scars remain. I look upon my scars and know now in the light of the Church what is right from wrong. I suppose that I would be of a scrupulous nature too, had I not chosen first to be the most wretched of sinners.

If Christ Jesus can bring grace to my thoroughly impure carcass, that it may one day bring forth Jesus substantially to the Church, how much easier grace will be for you, who are more sensitive to piety than I. Pray for Prudence and Wisdom, and what fear can avail you in your embrace?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...