Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

When not sexually active, would there be any issues about taking birth control pills?

Posted

Morally, no. However, there are lots of undesirable side effects as well, and can cause you to be infertile for some time after you have stopped taking them.

Posted

Depends on why you would be taking them.

Posted

[size=1]Birth control... :wacko:

I would want to know ALL my options before even considering it.

:sick:
[/size]

photosynthesis
Posted

hey L&T! Welcome back!

I hear being on birth control messes up your hormones and can cause infertility. And since it makes your body think it's pregnant, a lot of women report being in a perpetual state of "moodiness" while on the Pill.

Posted (edited)

Thanks for the welcome, Photosynthesis.

I got it for cramps, that one or two very painful days of the month. I have tried over the counter meds for it, also prescription double strength Aleve, Carispprodol, and Skelaxin. I'm looking to not wear heating pads and sit around drinking several cups of very hot tea a day in addition to medicine to hopefully not hurt. I asked the doctor about infertility and she said that it won't make me infertile, at least not without years and years of use. I have a prescription for Orthotricyclin.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted (edited)

I also got it for cramps and to keep me regular because I was extremely irregular and heavy. I currently have a prescription for Orthotricyclin-lo. I have been on and off of it since I was 16.

I recently tried to go onto Yaz with disastrous consequences, lost 20lbs. on it because of constant vomiting, had extreme side pains and almost went to the emergency room. My cousin got migraines with Yaz. Bad Yaz.

Edited by rachael
Posted

As far as I know it's not objectively immoral to use birth control if you are not having sex. However, it's definitely something to avoid as best as you can, given the side effects. Beyond that I don't really know the situation or exactly how effective BC would be in comparison to your other options.

I would get a few other opinions about whether BC will make you infertile. That's just me.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='rachael' post='1393983' date='Sep 27 2007, 01:17 AM']I also got it for cramps and to keep me regular because I was extremely irregular and heavy. I currently have a prescription for Orthotricyclin-lo. I have been on and off of it since I was 16.

I recently tried to go onto Yaz with disastrous consequences, lost 20lbs. on it because of constant vomiting, had extreme side pains and almost went to the emergency room. My cousin got migraines with Yaz. Bad Yaz.[/quote]
Sorry to butt in here, but I was watching these commercials for Yaz with Jennie and I had to look at her and ask: "now, Jennie, is there any reason, as a woman, that you would ingest something called 'yaz'?"

You'd think they could at least come up with a better term. The first thing that comes to my mind is that it sounds like some sort of street term for a date-rape drug: "yeah, I slipped her a yaz."

It just sounds creepy.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1393986' date='Sep 27 2007, 01:33 AM']Sorry to butt in here, but I was watching these commercials for Yaz with Jennie and I had to look at her and ask: "now, Jennie, is there any reason, as a woman, that you would ingest something called 'yaz'?"

You'd think they could at least come up with a better term. The first thing that comes to my mind is that it sounds like some sort of street term for a date-rape drug: "yeah, I slipped her a yaz."

It just sounds creepy.[/quote]
It wasn't too fun taking them either. :mellow:

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='rachael' post='1393987' date='Sep 27 2007, 01:39 AM']It wasn't too fun taking them either. :mellow:[/quote]
Maybe they got the name from the sound you make while hacking up your guts. :mellow:

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1393988' date='Sep 27 2007, 01:44 AM']Maybe they got the name from the sound you make while hacking up your guts. :mellow:[/quote]
:lol_roll:

Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' post='1393979' date='Sep 27 2007, 02:07 AM']I got it for cramps, that one or two very painful days of the month. I have tried over the counter meds for it, also prescription double strength Aleve, Carispprodol, and Skelaxin. I'm looking to not wear heating pads and sit around drinking several cups of very hot tea a day in addition to medicine to hopefully not hurt. I asked the doctor about infertility and she said that it won't make me infertile, at least not without years and years of use. I have a prescription for Orthotricyclin.[/quote]
There is nothing morally wrong or illicit about taking a medication that has contraceptive properties for the purpose you describe, but only if that is your only intent. There's a minor possibility for scandal among your peers, but if you're discreet, that's highly unlikely. There is nothing wrong with taking this path if it is the most medically sound solution.

I would do a little more research; I've worked in pharma, and let's just say that contraceptives are held to a different, looser, set of safety standards than other drugs approved by the FDA, purely for political reasons. There's no drugs on the market, prescription or OTC, other than chemotherapy drugs, that have more voluminous ISI (important safety information), or more frequent death rate. If you have ANY problem with circulation or blood clotting, I'd stay away.

Also, if you're looking to get married, you should stop taking the meds at least 6 months beforehand. There's plenty of side effects, including increased possibility of birth defects, increased chances of embryo splitting (twins, triplets, etc.), increased chances of miscarriage, among other things.

I'm assuming that since this is just for cramps, it's a lower dosage than someone using it for contraceptive purposes, which would mean lesser risks. Is this the case?

My best advice would be to find an orthodox Catholic doctor -- one that would normally be unwilling to provide contraceptives for contraceptive purposes -- and let him know your situation. They will be more likely to give you an honest answer.

DISCLAIMER: I am not a doctor. I highly recommend talking to a doctor -- preferably a Catholic one -- for medical advice. I'm just advising you to proceed with caution.

Posted

I would seriously reconsider using the pill in [u]any[/u] circumstance, even as a means to help with cramping or other menstrual irregularities.

When it comes to your body and hormones and the natural working of a cycle (or any system for that matter, be it digestive or immune, etc.), it's best to remember that the goal is always to restore ourselves using the least obtrusive means as possible. Secular doctors [i]love[/i] to hand out birth control for anything these days because it's such a big money business and there's tons of $$ changing hands with the drug companies. Often, though, all that happens is birth control masks the symptoms of internal problems that it has no ability to fix. Add that to the fact that it can have long term effects on fertility and a wide variety of other health issues, and it's something to be avoided at all costs.

When kateri05 is online later today, I'm sure she can offer some more advice, but here's what some quick research shows. ([url="http://www.mothernature.com/Library/Bookshelf/Books/21/155.cfm"]MotherNature.com[/url] has some tips, too.)

Here's a list of [url="http://www.ehow.com/how_2057448_relieve-menstrual-cramps-naturally.html"]natural solutions[/url] to menstrual cramping...


[quote]1. Use heat to find relief. A heating bad or hot water bottle can provide immense relief. A warm bath can also work.
2. Try an ice pack if heat does not help. Sometimes ice will draw the blood out that is causing the cramps.
3. Perform light exercise. Walking, swimming and yoga are all moderate exercises that reduce the severity of cramps. A regular exercise routine can usually help reduce the frequency of cramps.
4. Drink pineapple juice. Pineapples contain a substance called bromelain. Bromelain has been shown to relax the muscles.
5. Purchase a raspberry herbal tea. Many women rely on this tea to help relieve cramps during their period.
6. Cut back on salt and sugar. These substances can cause or worsen menstrual cramps. Avoiding them will relieve the cramps and reduce bloating.

[u]Tips[/u]
* Massage and acupressure have also been shown to be effective in naturally relieving menstrual cramps.
* Eating a balanced diet and exercising often helps to prevent menstrual cramps from occurring.[/quote]

Here's a link from the great NFP group [url="http://ccli.org/nfp/contraception/pill.php"]Couple-to-Couple League[/url] that warns against the Pill. I've abbreviated to highlight some of the risks and side-effects.

[quote][u]Heart and blood abnormalities[/u]

[u]Blood Clots[/u] ...

Studies continue to indicate approximately a 2-fold increased risk of fatal heart attacks among users of the current low-dose pill when compared to non-users... Similarly, the risk of a fatal brain hemorrhage is increased 1.4 times when comparing users to non-users. ...

High Blood Pressure and alterations in the blood clotting mechanisms may be seen in women on the Pill...

[u]Cancer[/u]

Breast cancer has been repeatedly associated with using the Pill...

Breast cancer has been increasing at an alarming rate in recent years, especially among young women. ... This conclusion was demonstrated in a study which found that Swedish women who took the Pill in the 1960s incurred a five times greater increase in breast cancer when compared to non-users...

The increased risk of breast cancer is seen in younger, nulliparous women (never having borne children), and in long duration groups (greater than five years) of Pill users. Large tumors and a worse survival rate are associated with the Pill’s use at an early age.

...

Breast tenderness, enlargement, lumps, and milk secretions also may occur in women using the Pill. Doctors are warned not to prescribe the Pill to women who are "known or suspected" to have breast cancer... It is difficult to say what aggravating effect the Pill’s hormones would have over a truly random sample of women taking the Pill.

Cervical Cancer and cervical dysplasia increase among women who use the Pill.....

Endometrial and Ovarian Cancer appear to have a lower incidence in both women on the Pill and in those who have been previous users of the Pill. Much of this data comes from studies of women who were using the higher dose estrogen/progestin Pill. Currently the low dose monophasic and triphasic pills (less than 50mcg of estrogen) are the only birth control pills available on the U.S. market. It is not known if a similar protective effect will be experienced with the currently used Pill. More time is needed to study this issue, and the slight protective effect is hardly a reason to take the Pill at the risk of so many other side effects.

...

Liver Tumors in younger women (15 to 40 years) have increased as the use of oral contraceptives has increased. Almost unheard of in this age group before the use of synthetic hormones became commonplace, liver tumors usually do not occur until the sixth decade of a woman’s life.

A study by the American College of Surgeons’ Commission on Cancer found "a large peak in the 26-to-30-year age group which corresponds with the increased use of oral contraceptives in this age group."40 Liver cancer in women on the Pill is typically associated with those over 30 who have used it more than four years, but cases of liver cancer in younger women have been cited.41,42,43,44

Other Cancers: Skin cancer (melanoma) has also been found to increase among women on the Pill. Naturally occurring estrogen is involved with maintaining healthy skin tissue. It is reasonable to suspect that exposure to the more potent synthetic estrogen in the Pill increases the risk of this type of cancer.45,46,47

[u]Cycle irregularities[/u]

Women who take the Pill have been reported to experience bleeding or spotting in mid-cycle, changes in menstrual flow, and even loss of menstruation, which can lead them to wonder if they are pregnant. For some, painful menstruation (dysmenorrhea) has been reported to worsen, even though many women take these hormones in an attempt to relieve the problem.48

Although some women are given the Pill for irregular cycles, it does nothing to improve the underlying problem causing the irregularity. Often the irregularity returns when the Pill is discontinued, sometimes more severely.

[u]Are there other side effects?[/u]

Headaches, migraines, mental depression (even to the point of suicide and/or suicidal tendencies), a decrease or loss of sexual drive, abdominal cramps, bloating, weight gain or loss, and water retention; nausea and vomiting(in about 10% of users); symptoms of PMS, vaginitis and vaginal infections, changes in vision (temporary or permanent blindness, and an intolerance to contact lenses); gall bladder disease and either temporary or permanent infertility, when discontinuing the Pill, in users with previous menstrual irregularities or who began the drug before full maturity. Several of the symptoms, such as migraine headaches, contraindicate the use of the Pill because of life endangering complications.[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' post='1393979' date='Sep 26 2007, 11:07 PM']Thanks for the welcome, Photosynthesis.

I got it for cramps, that one or two very painful days of the month. I have tried over the counter meds for it, also prescription double strength Aleve, Carispprodol, and Skelaxin. I'm looking to not wear heating pads and sit around drinking several cups of very hot tea a day in addition to medicine to hopefully not hurt. I asked the doctor about infertility and she said that it won't make me infertile, at least not without years and years of use. I have a prescription for Orthotricyclin.[/quote]

I realize some of the suggestions I pointed out were heat and tea, which you already expressed little interest in. So perhaps I should elaborate :)

There is a big difference between [i]drugs[/i] and [i]medicine[/i]. The latter can consist of natural ingredients meant to restore your body to a state of ideal health. Drugs like The Pill, however, purposely disrupt the natural working of your body to achieve an artificial state of health. And as The Pill disclaimer will even say, it is not guaranteed to help with cramping. It can actually make things [b]worse[/b]! So it is truly something that should be avoided at all costs, except on pain of death - and as of 2007, birth control has not saved any lives :)

Some of the best help with menstrual cramping is often changes in diet. Here are a few examples:

[quote]* Keep a healthy diet including plenty of fresh [b]fruit and vegetables[/b], as well as plenty of [b]wate[/b]r. Attempt to track of how particular foods affect your period.

* Take extra [b]calcium, magnesium and vitamin D[/b]. These minerals are required for proper muscle function; when you are low, muscles (such as the uterus) are more prone to cramping.

* Change your diet slightly if you can, a week prior to menstruation to avoid menstrual cramping; [b]avoid[/b] foods that could cause bloating such as [b]salty foods and alcohol[/b], avoid foods such as [b]dairy[/b] that could contribute to menstrual cramps.[/quote]

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' post='1393979' date='Sep 27 2007, 06:07 AM']Thanks for the welcome, Photosynthesis.

I got it for cramps, that one or two very painful days of the month. I have tried over the counter meds for it, also prescription double strength Aleve, Carispprodol, and Skelaxin. I'm looking to not wear heating pads and sit around drinking several cups of very hot tea a day in addition to medicine to hopefully not hurt. I asked the doctor about infertility and she said that it won't make me infertile, at least not without years and years of use. I have a prescription for Orthotricyclin.[/quote]

Hey. I was on the pill for similar reasons (cramping and irregular, heavy cycles). However, since the problem wasn't hormone-related, it didn't actually help anything, just masked it. I do remember hating Ortho-Tri, though, since it was 3 different levels of hormones. My body certainly didn't know what to do when I came off of them (I was on the pill for 8 years). Anyway, I'd ask about Mefanamic Acid (can't remember the generic name for it). I'm not a doctor, but this is what my uncle (an OB/GYN) recommended when I finally broke down and asked him for advice. And it works really well. If you chart and so know when your period will be, you can start taking this 1-2 days before your period starts, and then it works even better. And this coming from someone who even tried heavy-duty (narcotic) pain meds for cramps before this. Hope this helps.

Posted

Chica, I'm in the same boat as you. Yesterday i was laying on the couch withering in pain. Praise God i didnt have to work.

Personally, I would rather deal with the pain than take birth control. I take a ton of motrin (like, 2 pills every 2 hours) and just smell of elderberries it up. Birth control can really really screw with your body. It can ruin the lining of your uterus, making it nearly impossible to have children later in life. I'd stay away.

Posted (edited)

DP

Edited by chelsea
Posted (edited)

[quote name='chelsea' post='1394128' date='Sep 27 2007, 12:41 PM']Chica, I'm in the same boat as you. Yesterday i was laying on the couch withering in pain. Praise God i didnt have to work.

Personally, I would rather deal with the pain than take birth control. I take a ton of motrin (like, 2 pills every 2 hours) and just smell of elderberries it up. Birth control can really really screw with your body. It can ruin the lining of your uterus, making it nearly impossible to have children later in life. I'd stay away.[/quote]

I do the same. I would never take it just because of the side-effects. Thankfully pro-life researchers are coming up with remedies that do not involve birth control to treat things bc is often prescribed for.

Edited by Totus Tuus
Posted
:bye: hi, LT!

i will pray for you. before i got pregnant, my periods were nasty horrible days of pain. so i can definitely sympathize with you. :ohno:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...