Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I can only give you something from my own experiences. I had two different Catholic roommates in college. Both suffered with serious cramps. One decided to go on the pill. One decided to take that one to two days off as a zombie on painkillers/muscle relaxers. The one on the pill became sexually active withing 6 months. The other was a virgin on her wedding night. I don't know if the first one would have become active or not except for being on the pill, but I do know she told me that knowing she was on it made the decision to have sex a little easier. I've suffered with cramps for 35 years now. I haven't died from them, although at times it feels like I am going to.

Posted

The natural remedies here (light exercise, Calcium, etc.) unless they include walking over two miles a day. I'm not good at getting up early enough to do that on a regular basis and my other stuff during the day and not be walking around after dark. I could only hope that attending a larger campus would help, but the breaks would not be fun. By the time I finish tracking how particular foods affect my period, I will be taking a day off of work every month.

XIX, I talked to the pharmasists opinion too when I dropped the prescription off. (It is currently on hold since I won't need either med for over a week.) As I understand, the fertility effect will depend on the individual woman and her hormones, but probably would not have a significant effect.

adt6247, I will talk to my regular doctor to see what he thinks, but I have to go with the professionals on my insurance.

chelsea, that can't be good for your liver. I hope you drink a lot of fluid and don't take a lot of other meds. (I have to have a blood test every year or so because of another med I take.)

Posted (edited)

It's weird, but my computer doesn't show that I posted last here unless I view this thread.

CatherineM, I appreciate your warning. I am still more worried about being dateless for the next several years than I am about that. (It seems more likely considering me.)

How do you stand that kind of pain and still get work done or not have everyone in the office figure out why your are not in on about a monthly basis? (And can you still have sick days to use when you do get sick?)

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

I haven't read this whole thing but wanted to chime in that exercise really does help.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1394985' date='Sep 28 2007, 09:15 PM']I haven't read this whole thing but wanted to chime in that exercise really does help.[/quote]
I think that is part of why living in the dorms helped several years ago. Unless I am doing that much walking though, ouch. I have a low pain tolerance for that stuff and frankly, I'm scared that I will have some first days like some other ones I have had and have a midterm or have to be at work without being a griping pain to the rest of the department.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1394009' date='Sep 27 2007, 09:49 AM']There is nothing morally wrong or illicit about taking a medication that has contraceptive properties for the purpose you describe, but only if that is your only intent. There's a minor possibility for scandal among your peers, but if you're discreet, that's highly unlikely. There is nothing wrong with taking this path if it is the most medically sound solution.

I would do a little more research; I've worked in pharma, and let's just say that contraceptives are held to a different, looser, set of safety standards than other drugs approved by the FDA, purely for political reasons. There's no drugs on the market, prescription or OTC, other than chemotherapy drugs, that have more voluminous ISI (important safety information), or more frequent death rate. If you have ANY problem with circulation or blood clotting, I'd stay away.

Also, if you're looking to get married, you should stop taking the meds at least 6 months beforehand. There's plenty of side effects, including increased possibility of birth defects, increased chances of embryo splitting (twins, triplets, etc.), increased chances of miscarriage, among other things.

I'm assuming that since this is just for cramps, it's a lower dosage than someone using it for contraceptive purposes, which would mean lesser risks. Is this the case?

My best advice would be to find an orthodox Catholic doctor -- one that would normally be unwilling to provide contraceptives for contraceptive purposes -- and let him know your situation. They will be more likely to give you an honest answer.

DISCLAIMER: I am not a doctor. I highly recommend talking to a doctor -- preferably a Catholic one -- for medical advice. I'm just advising you to proceed with caution.[/quote]

A very educated post. :)

Try taking a daily multi vitamin, maybe you have deficiencies that make these cramps unbearable.

Posted

I had intolerable cramps for two weeks (!) because of the cafeteria food. I stopped eating it and didn't have cramps the next time. So maybe you can take a look at some of the food you are eating. (I had way more problems than that with the cafeteria food, but reaction to food does play a big part in how our body functions.) Keep away from too much salt and eat potassium and calcium.

Posted (edited)

after watching the below video. i dont know if id want such chemicals in my body, or to financially support such things...then again i dont have to suffer with such pains......pains which could be offered up to God for the healing of marriages, fidelity..and end to abortion...?
..i wonder l what did all the women do before 1960's?
united in Love, sacrifice, suffering, prayer! -EJ-
The Pill video
[url="http://www.godtube.com/view_video.php?viewkey=4a4dabc3bdccdb3c60bd"]http://www.godtube.com/view_video.php?view...bc3bdccdb3c60bd[/url]
PAX

Edited by EJames2
Posted

Light-I deal with it with pharmaceuticals. My doctor and I have worked a balance on a mild muscle relaxer that allows me to still function with a smaller amount of pain, but remain functional enough to not just sleep. When I worked, I would have someone give me a ride or take the bus on those days so that I didn't have to worry about driving while on the drugs. I could have driven safely probably, but I knew my reaction time would have been less. I also take a water pill, and that seems to help a lot. When I worked, I had a frank discussion about the subject with my boss, and that I would need a day or a half of a day once a month in order to maintain my religious convictions. He was a Methodist minister, and head of an ecumenical organization, so he understood that he needed to concede this point in order to look understanding of other faiths. I also used it to get off to go sing at funerals. I think he was afraid I'd sic a picket line full of nuns on him.

let_go_let_God
Posted

Also if you are going to take it, look into taking some form of "low hormonal" pill. I am on a version of that with few and little side effects. Secondly I'm in the same boat as you. I had debilitating cramps for a week and a half and no "non medical" treatments helped unless I was sleeping.

One thing I do advise though is to pray even more diligently if you must start. The temptation is much greater to fall IMHO but the more you pray the more God can help you though the tough parts.

If you want to talk more, PM me. I'm in a similar boat as you.

God bless-
LGLG

P.S. Good to see you back L&T

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='EJames2' post='1395076' date='Sep 29 2007, 04:23 PM']..i wonder l what did all the women do before 1960's?[/quote]

My great-grandmother kept whiskey around for that purpose. . . :lol:

I would add that, from my own experiences, it is really difficult to convince a doctor to take you [i]off [/i]the pill once you're on it. That's why I was on it for so long. I didn't question it when I was put on it, as I didn't know enough (I was 16), but then trying to find a doctor that would take me off was really difficult. No one wanted to change it because it was working. I finally found one that respected my wishes and gave me something that is non-hormonal and really works just as well.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='EJames2' post='1395076' date='Sep 29 2007, 04:23 PM']..i wonder l what did all the women do before 1960's?[/quote]

My great-grandmother kept whiskey around for that purpose. . . :lol:

I would add that, from my own experiences, it is really difficult to convince a doctor to take you [i]off [/i]the pill once you're on it. That's why I was on it for so long. I didn't question it when I was put on it, as I didn't know enough (I was 16), but then trying to find a doctor that would take me off was really difficult. No one wanted to change it because it was working. I finally found one that respected my wishes and gave me something that is non-hormonal and really works just as well.

Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1395429' date='Sep 30 2007, 04:50 AM']My great-grandmother kept whiskey around for that purpose. . . :lol:

I would add that, from my own experiences, it is really difficult to convince a doctor to take you [i]off [/i]the pill once you're on it. That's why I was on it for so long. I didn't question it when I was put on it, as I didn't know enough (I was 16), but then trying to find a doctor that would take me off was really difficult. No one wanted to change it because it was working. I finally found one that respected my wishes and gave me something that is non-hormonal and really works just as well.[/quote]


:sweat:

Also, I would like to add a quote from Archbishop Fulton Sheen that points to the dangers of taking it.

[size=4]Birth Control is neither about birth nor control. [/size]

  • 4 months later...
missionseeker
Posted

Sometimes, I'd really like to kill Eve.

Posted

As a personal note, one of my aunts wasn't getting her peroid (back in the 80's) and so she was put on birth control to "kick" her hormones into action. She went off sometime in college and she's the mother of five now.

I've had horrible cramps but I chose not to go on meds because as I grew they became less and now maybe once a year I get cramps and vomiting bad enough to be incapacitated, and only once during my peroid at that, however if it was all the time and multiple days I'd have taken birth control. My period was so draining and I would get so weak it took me over a week to recover...making my ability to be active during the month a whole 2 weeks.

After age 16 it got better and after 21/22ish it was alot better.

Posted

Mefenamic acid. It's the way to go.

I used to vomit and faint all the time. I wouldn't leave my bed for the first 2 days. Now, because of Mefenamic acid, I can do anything. I've played hockey on the first day and was fine. It's amazing.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Man alive, I would never go on the pill. I knew someone that did and her body is so screwed up, she's had so many miscarriages, a tubal pregnancy, and can't really successfully get and stay pregnant now because of all the extra hormones dumped into her body for years.

It's also complicating when you're trying to stop taking the pill and going to something like NFP later on in life when you get married.

Posted

I would avoid the pill at all costs. There ARE alternatives. Don't be sold on the pill by a doctor. I hope you can find a solution and if not its called redemptive suffering.

missionseeker
Posted

so, uh, today as i was not in class, but curled up in a ball on my bed kind of sleeping, I wrote this.

I don't feel like starting a thread...

I am often inclined to kill Eve.

"So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was a delight to the eyes, and that the tree was to be desired to make one wise, she took of its fruit and ate.... To the woman he said, 'I will greatly multiply your pain in childbearing; in pain you shall bring forth children.'"

He wasn't lying.

Most of us (girls) have experienced some of the result of this punishment (and I dare say hope to experience the full result; let's put this into perspective, shall we?). The world tells us that we really shouldn't have to bear it. In fact, it tells us not to bear it. I mean, who really wants to be debilitated for two or three days or more every month? Who wants to not be able to function normally, who wants to be barely able to move and yet must move because of things to do and places to be? Who likes not being able to eat for wanting to vomit or simply smelling food and wanting to vomit? Who wants to miss class or work or anything every time "that time" rolls around? Who wants to do this, especially when there are options that allow it to be completely avoided? Not I, I can tell you that for sure.

I'm not saying it's wrong to treat the pain. I would never say that. I almost think it's more wrong to not treat it, especially if it is regularly extreme. But when the treating it becomes thinking of it as a horrible burden and hating being a woman, when the pain stops being treated and it begins to be the functions themselves that are being treated, then perhaps we should re-examine our way of thinking about it.

Even if we must think of it as a burden, we should remember that God's idea of a burden is an oppurtunity to love Him and to love others. Human suffering is not without purpose. And I have to think that a suffering given to one sex rather than both is a special kind of suffering. It is, of course, a suffering in tune with our nature (for God could never make us not in tune with our natures), one that reaffirms the vocation of women.

Love is suffering. The ultimate example that we have of this is Christ. "No greater love is there than this: to lay down one's life for his friends." That's kind of what's asked of us. Only we aren't to die- as much as we may feel that death is coming, but to live (as women) for our friends, our family, our (potential, future... lol) spouses and children. We give up our bodies for those we love. I never thought I'd say it and I never EVER thought I'd write it, especially not in a public space, but the period is a beautiful thing. It is an oppurtunity to love by suffering. It reminds me of some words in one of my most favorite prayers ever (which I'll post at the end) "and only this love, grounded on suffering, can carry the Cross of my Lord Jesus Christ. Love without egotism, without relying on self, but enkindling in the depth of the heart an ardent thirst to love and suffer for all those around us: a thirst that neither misfortune nor contempt can extinguish..." And we have a chance to love like that, to use basically our entire lives as a way of showing love.

And it's from this type of suffering that life comes (which, of course, brings a different type of suffering, a type about which I can say nothing, because I know nothing). And even for those women who do not have children, life can spring from this suffering because she can still care for others and live for others in a way that brings them to Christ and, hence, to Life.

There is testing going on for a drug that suspends the period indefinitely. As much as I think I'd like to say "wow, how wonderful!" I'm much more wary of what this will do to women. And to men. Forget the physical side effects, which I doubt I could begin to imagine (really, how screwed up would your body be after that?) what are the psychological effects going to be? I'm reminded of a (dun dun dun) Chesterton quote: "Do not free a camel of the burden of his hump; you may be freeing him from being a camel." Women have already been "freed" from the burden of fertility- the results of being a woman. And now they can be free from the burden of being a woman. This means that men no longer have to be men. They have been "freed" from the burden of responsibility and now they can be free from the burden of impatience and respect.

But if we suffer ourselves to be women, then we suffer for women and for men and for God's kingdom- for Life.


This prayer was written by Blessed Miguel Pro. He was martyred in Mexico in November of 1927.
Does our life become from day to day more painful, more oppressive, more replete
with afflictions? Blessed be He a thousand times who desires it so. If life be
harder, love makes it also stronger, and only this love, grounded on suffering,
can carry the Cross of my Lord Jesus Christ. Love without egotism, without
relying on self, but enkindling in the depth of the heart an ardent thirst to
love and suffer for all those around us: a thirst that neither misfortune nor
contempt can extinguish... I believe, O Lord; but strengthen my faith... Heart
of Jesus, I love Thee; but increase my love. Heart of Jesus, I trust in Thee;
but give greater vigor to my confidence. Heart of Jesus, I give my heart to
Thee; but so enclose it in Thee that it may never be separated from Thee. Heart
of Jesus, I am all Thine; but take care of my promise so that I may be able to
put it in practice even unto the complete sacrifice of my life.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1453610' date='Jan 31 2008, 09:24 PM']Mefenamic acid. It's the way to go.

I used to vomit and faint all the time. I wouldn't leave my bed for the first 2 days. Now, because of Mefenamic acid, I can do anything. I've played hockey on the first day and was fine. It's amazing.[/quote]

Amen! I think it's called Ponstel in the US, but it works wonders. I had horrible cramps and nausea before, but the Mefenamic acid helped so much. I only wish my doc had mentioned it before putting me on the pill first. :( Oh well, it's worked out now.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...