Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Parishioners, Priests To Dig Deep For Abuse Victims


Recommended Posts

Posted

The Catholic Diocese of San Diego is asking parishioners and priests to make contributions to help pay for the recent $198.1 million sexual abuse settlement.

A memo issued this week by Bishop Robert Brom asked priests to contribute one month's salary, the Associated Press reported.

"We cannot ask of others what we are unwilling to do ourselves," Brom wrote in the memo to about 280 priests, whose monthly salary can be as much as $1,535.

The donation requests will help "cover the expense involved in compassionate outreach to our brothers and sisters who suffered sexual abuse within the family of
the church," the memo said.

The idea came from current priests who saw it as a gesture toward the 144 people who allege they were abused by clergy members and church workers when they were minors.

"It's a way of kind of righting some of the injustices done to them and also start the healing process," said the Rev. Ned Brockhaus of St. John of the Cross in Lemon Grove.

Judy Bethel, a Catholic and San Diego resident, said that if Brom hadn't sought Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection for the diocese in February, he could have settled the suits for less money.

"I think he's asking us to bear the cost of his mistakes," Bethel said. "I, for one, am not willing to do this."

The average payout will be $1.38 million per victim, according to the terms of the agreement announced last month.

The San Diego diocese will pay about $107 million of the total; the rest will come from insurance and the Diocese of San Bernardino, which was once part of the San Diego diocese.

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='cappie' post='1399023' date='Oct 7 2007, 05:35 PM']"It's a way of kind of righting some of the injustices done to them and also start the healing process," said the Rev. Ned Brockhaus of St. John of the Cross in Lemon Grove.[/quote]


sorry, but as someone who went through molestation for years, money isn't going to "right any wrong" I'm not even sure it will help "start the healing process." perhaps they will find peace and feel that justice has been given but it doesn't make it right or better. And it doesn't help heal.

homeschoolmom
Posted

How in the world can you ask innocent families to pony up a month's salary?

missionseeker
Posted

it only says priests specifically.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='cappie' post='1399023' date='Oct 7 2007, 06:35 PM']The Catholic Diocese of San Diego is asking parishioners and priests to make contributions to help pay for the recent $198.1 million sexual abuse settlement.

A memo issued this week by Bishop Robert Brom asked priests to contribute one month's salary, the Associated Press reported.

"We cannot ask of others what we are unwilling to do ourselves," Brom wrote in the memo to about 280 priests, whose monthly salary can be as much as $1,535.[/quote]
These three sentances together, to me, implied that they were asking for large contributions of parishoners.

Posted

i don't know if i'm okay with this. asking parishioners who had nothing to do with priests being moved around, bishops taking little to no steps to remove them, putting innocent children in harm's way. these people are asked to help the diocese that caused so much harm?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I think the monetary amounts are absolutely ridiculous.

Posted (edited)

i wouldnt pay. anyone can say "thats not christian" but I can love priests without paying for their mistakes.

Edited by chelsea
Posted

[quote name='chelsea' post='1399471' date='Oct 8 2007, 04:47 PM']i wouldnt pay. anyone can say "thats not christian" but I can love priests without paying for their mistakes.[/quote]


What do you think we've been doing for years?

and honestly I don't have a problem with it.

Posted

You have to love teh American way. There is nothing that money can't solve as long as you give the lawyers half of the money.

hyperdulia again
Posted

I think the dioceses need to be penalized, severely. I don't think as a lay Catholic and as a parent I should be penalized for the bad actions of some clerics.

Posted

[quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1399525' date='Oct 8 2007, 07:22 PM']I think the dioceses need to be penalized, severely. I don't think as a lay Catholic and as a parent I should be penalized for the bad actions of some clerics.[/quote]

Again

Where do you think the money is coming from?

hyperdulia again
Posted (edited)

I am an Orthodox Catholic. I am meek and docile before the authority of the Church of God. I will not however let my Orthodoxy lessen my shock and my anger at the idea of the Bishops of God's Church recklessly turning perverts loose on the Faithful. There are very few Bishops in this country with clean hands. There are very few dioceses in this country that don't bear the scares of this recklessness.

The Dioceses should be punished. In this country the Church has recognized the civil authority as competent to deal with these matters (She didn't have to). The civil authority has actually dealt quite lightly with the American Dioceses--as compared to the severity of what was done (far worse than had the same actions by committed by men who were not Sons of the Church). The idea of the Bishop of a Diocese of the Catholic Church after being penalized by the Courts, or settling with victims of child rape by priests not reaching into the considerable financial reserves of the American Dioceses to pay these victims; but expecting the scandalized, ill-cared for, misused laity to do so, is possibly the most repulsive thing I've ever heard. Almost as repulsive as Bishops trading pederasts, and sending them into our parishes and our homes without warning.

Edited by hyperdulia again
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1399526' date='Oct 8 2007, 07:23 PM']Again

Where do you think the money is coming from?[/quote]


I agree with hot stuff. I don't think there is anything wrong with the diocese asking for help, because 1) they are not demanding it, and 2) where on earth else are they going to get the money? Aside from the aforementioned fact that [i]money[/i] might not heal the wounds, it is being required of them to pay, and they need the money to do so.

hyperdulia again
Posted

If a given diocese is willing to be audited and prove that it cannot pay. Then the laity would have the duty of coming up with the money, but the Church in the US is entirely to secretive about money, for me to simply *trust* that there is a financial imperative. Money will not help heal, but the cost might make our shepherds realize what witnessing thousands of broken lives did not make them realize--people who molest children need to be handed over to suffer the severest penalties the state has for them; after release if they are repentant, they should be exiled to monasteries, forever.

Posted

[quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1399587' date='Oct 8 2007, 09:25 PM']after release if they are repentant, they should be exiled to monasteries, forever.[/quote]

Monasteries are not exiles.

hyperdulia again
Posted

umm..huh?

hyperdulia again
Posted (edited)

No monasteries are not "exiles" they are places. And people are exiled to places. If a man has been ordained to the priesthood and remains a believing Catholic after the end of his secular punishment, the Church cannot throw him away; but She should send him away.

Edited by hyperdulia again
Posted

I wouldn't pay a cent ... let them get help from the same one, in whose name they do such evil.

Posted

Ok seriously folks

This "I'm not about to pay for " attitude is a bit naive. Unless of course you have never put a dime into the church coffers. (And if that's the case, you've got absolutely nothing to complain about)

Where do you think the money has come from to pay off these lawsuits so far? Where do you think the money will come from in the future? Priests aren't selling Amway products. They aren't working in a factory. The Diocese doesn't get financed from the government.

Of course we're going to pay. We already have and we'll do it some more.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...