Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Parishioners, Priests To Dig Deep For Abuse Victims


Recommended Posts

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

what a buncha

Posted

[quote]Priests aren't selling Amway products.[/quote]


aren't they? :mellow:

Posted

btw, i have no problem with them using the money i normally contribute for whatever the church deems it worthy to be used for. i am freely giving my 5-10% for whatever the Church needs.


however, that being said, i am certainly not obliged to give extra for something that shouldn't have happened if the hierarchy in america was doing what they were supposed to be doing.

especially in an archdiocese with no pro-life office that actually has any staffers <_< and they didn't have any staff before the scandals either. hmmph.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1399603' date='Oct 8 2007, 09:50 PM']No monasteries are not "exiles" they are places. And people are exiled to places. If a man has been ordained to the priesthood and remains a believing Catholic after the end of his secular punishment, the Church cannot throw him away; but She should send him away.[/quote]


:offtopic: I know monasteries are places, but just because a priest is bad does not mean that the monastery is the place to pawn him off to. Monks have real lives with their own real struggles and aspirations. I don't think it is generally practiced that bad diocesan priests just get kicked off to a monastery to solve any problems. Maybe they can have their ability to [i]publicly[/i] exercise their faculties taken away or something, but it's a misconception of monasticism to think that you just drop bad priests into monasteries. Cappie, am I wrong?

[quote name='hot stuff']Ok seriously folks

This "I'm not about to pay for " attitude is a bit naive. Unless of course you have never put a dime into the church coffers. (And if that's the case, you've got absolutely nothing to complain about)

Where do you think the money has come from to pay off these lawsuits so far? Where do you think the money will come from in the future? Priests aren't selling Amway products. They aren't working in a factory. The Diocese doesn't get financed from the government.

Of course we're going to pay. We already have and we'll do it some more.[/quote]

Again, I agree with hot stuff's logic (never thought that would happen :P ) on this one guys.

Edited by Totus Tuus
Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1399665' date='Oct 8 2007, 11:13 PM']btw, i have no problem with them using the money i normally contribute for whatever the church deems it worthy to be used for. i am freely giving my 5-10% for whatever the Church needs.
however, that being said, i am certainly not obliged to give extra for something that shouldn't have happened if the hierarchy in america was doing what they were supposed to be doing.

especially in an archdiocese with no pro-life office that actually has any staffers <_< and they didn't have any staff before the scandals either. hmmph.[/quote]


I get that.

We can argue about the ability for money to heal. We can argue about the irresponsibility of the hierarchy. We can grouse about being stuck with the bill.

But as long as we're Catholic, it will be our bill to pay. There's just no way around it. And my concern is how we approach that can either strengthen or weaken our individual faiths.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

It is certainly not my bill to pay. If a priest is a convicted molester or a bishop knowingly moved criminals around put them in jail. If there is insurance coverage the insurance company pays. If a shrink said a man was safe and he was put back in a parish and more crimes were committed the shrink and his insurance should pay and he would lose his license. The church CAN pay for therapy if there is a conviction, but these million dollar payouts are ridiculous and are egged on by greedy lawyers who collect at least half.

My diocese is giving voluntarily giving money to people who claimed they were molested. The cases can't be tried, some of alleged abuse happened 40 years ago, and the priests have been dead for 20 years, so clearly these people are just out for money. It is a voluntary christian act, not extortion.

But the people who should not pay are the ordinary parishoners.

Posted

Where does the money come from to pay the therapist?

Where does the money come from to pay the insurance premium?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1399837' date='Oct 9 2007, 11:44 AM']Where does the money come from to pay the therapist?

Where does the money come from to pay the insurance premium?[/quote]

If a priest or bishop is convicted the church can pay for the first 5 years of therapy, send them the bill. That way you see the people are actually going and getting help and we are not financing lawyers lifestyles.
Insurance come out of the budget like any other regular payment.

Posted

again

who funds the budget?

Posted

It is so sad. I could never afford a full month's salary. I give what I can. If the Church was suffering, I would try to give more.

The priests were wrong, but, unfortunately, the faithful suffer for it. :ohno:

hyperdulia again
Posted

"i have no problem with them using the money i normally contribute for whatever the church deems it worthy to be used for"

Agreed.

"I don't think it is generally practiced that bad diocesan priests just get kicked off to a monastery to solve any problems."

Do not get me started on what has been generally practiced in this country. Having said that, I know monks have specific vocations and busy lives; but despite how offensive I find the actions of some molester priests I recognize that most of them intended to live lives of service to Christ and His Church. If they are repentant (after the end of their secular punishment), I see no wisdom in the Church just cutting them loose. They may fall back into the temptation to act out sexually with children. The Church has used and as far as I am aware continues to use monasteries and convents as places of reflection and repentance for priests and religious who are once again loyal children of God, but who have fallen into certain notorious sins.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...