friendofJPII Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) St. Maria Goretti and Rape Victims This question has been on my mind for awhile... Whenever the inspiring story of St. Maria Goretti is told, it is usually stated that she endured great suffering in order to maintain her purity, which is true. However, it is important to note that Allesandro attempted to rape her, and if she had chosen not to fight back in fear for her life, she would still have maintained her purity and spiritual virginity, for virginity is much more than a physical state. She definitely exercised heroic virtue by attempting to fight him off, however, might we be sending the wrong message to rape victims if we don't add the stipulation that even if she would have remained passive, she would have committed no sin? After all, rape is an act of violence, not an act of sex. In addition to being honored for her witness to chastity, I feel she should also be exonerated for placing the welfare of her attacker's soul ahead of her own life, and for pardoning him while experiencing excruciating pain on her deathbed. Chastity is a theme in the story, but not the main theme, imo. The conversion of Allesandro later in life was also a great testament to the infinite depths God's mercy. Has anyone else had similar thoughts? Edited October 14, 2007 by friendofJPII
Totus Tuus Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 I have always wondered that, too. If I were in a position where fighting back would mean certain death, I don't know what I would do. See, with Maria Goretti they always quote "death before sin", as if not fighting back would have been a sin. But I don't know if that's the proper implication or not. I wish someone would clarify that according to Church teaching. I know it is very explicit in the Catechism that we are to defend our lives even if it means killing our aggressor. But do we allow ourselves to be raped if we do not have the means to fight back successfully without being shot/stabbed/killed?
Autumn Dusk Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 I've always found it rather troubling the way the story is portrayed. I mean I'm glad she forgave the guy and all but I hardly see any issues of purity in it unless there's a part of the story we don't know.
Totus Tuus Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1402151' date='Oct 14 2007, 01:26 AM']I've always found it rather troubling the way the story is portrayed. I mean I'm glad she forgave the guy and all but I hardly see any issues of purity in it unless there's a part of the story we don't know.[/quote] I'm not sure what you mean by that. She was trying to defend her physical virginity, which I do believe is very admirable. I think something else that plays in is, she was not allowing Alessandro to go through with the sin (though he had already committed it in his will). Recall that she was saying "If you do this, you will go to hell!"
friendofJPII Posted October 14, 2007 Author Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1402152' date='Oct 14 2007, 12:29 AM']I'm not sure what you mean by that. She was trying to defend her physical virginity, which I do believe is very admirable. I think something else that plays in is, she was not allowing Alessandro to go through with the sin (though he had already committed it in his will). Recall that she was saying "If you do this, you will go to hell!"[/quote] I think what she did was heroic, but it was not required. Honestly, if I were in the position of either being raped or stabbed to death, I would prob allow myself to be raped, rather than get stabbed to death, esp. if I had little children who were dependent on me. In order to be exhonerated for chastity, wouldn't you have to be tempted to be unchaste? Maria was not tempted to sin w/Allasandro ---she was repulsed by him. In regards to chastity, I believe Dorothy Day is a more relateable example. She left a man she was living with in a commn law marriage and with whom she had a daughter to become Catholic. Later on, in her writings, she writes about how much she missed the intimacy, yet she remained steadfast in her choice for God. Edited October 14, 2007 by friendofJPII
Autumn Dusk Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 I don't think the fact that she fought should be taken as some sort of heroic thing. That she fought has no bearing on her purity. You don't "allow" yourself to be attacked either way. Either way its just as horrible. [quote]she was saying "If you do this, you will go to hell!"[/quote] Thats almost the most ridiculous thing I ever herd, one for her to say that while she was being victimized. And I'd like to know how we have some many "accurate" quotes from a saint who lived long ago.
CatholicCid Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1402178' date='Oct 14 2007, 12:50 AM']Thats almost the most ridiculous thing I ever herd, one for her to say that while she was being victimized. And I'd like to know how we have some many "accurate" quotes from a saint who lived long ago.[/quote] Actually, she died in 1902, so it really wasn't that long of a time ago. I would think the more important part would be her forgiveness of her attacker. Fighting off her attacker was of course a herioc thing, but should not be taken as denouncing victims. Possibly the idea is to look at how she tried to fight him off in fear of the his soul's safety for the sins he was to commit, not for her own saftey. In a moment when she had every right to be afraid for her own life, she still thought with concern for the one hurting her. I never realized she died at the age of 12, always thought her to be older. Edited October 14, 2007 by CatholicCid
friendofJPII Posted October 14, 2007 Author Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) I can see how some modern feminists would interpret this story to believe that the Church supports some archiac notion of female sexuality--where physical virginity is esteemed before personal safety---which is why I feel the in this situation the forgiveness issue should be stressed over the chastity issue, I really don't see how chastity is a major issue here---other than in how Allasandro was so negatively influenced by pornography. IMO, it was an act of violence, not an act of sex. Edited October 14, 2007 by friendofJPII
Autumn Dusk Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 I'm not a feminist in any way shape or form but I still find the way this story is portrayed to many completely wrong.
Sister Rose Therese Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 I may have miss understood her story but the way I understood it was subtly different. I understood that her attacked demanded, at knife point, for her to have sex with him. She refused and he stabbed her multiple times. I don't remember hearing of him grabbing her or trying to force himself on her physically, or her physically fighting him. Now she could have consented to having sex with him to save her life. This reason would have greatly mitigated her culpablilty in such an act. But it doesn't quite seem to be the same situation you normally hear of with rapes. It really did seem to put her in more of a situation of choice than most rape victims get.
friendofJPII Posted October 14, 2007 Author Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) This is one account I found on the internet.... [/quote] [i]«Maria!» exclaimed Alessandro. «What do you want?»—«I want you to follow me.»—«Why?»—«Follow me!»—«Tell me what you want, or I won't follow you.» Faced with this resistance, the boy took her violently by an arm and dragged her to the kitchen, where he barred the door. The child screamed, but the noise did not carry to the outside. Not succeeding in making his victim yield, Alessandro gagged her and brandished a dagger. Maria trembled but did not give way. Furious, the young man tried with violence to tear her clothes off. Maria freed herself of her gag and cried out, «Don't do it… It's a sin… You will go to Hell!» Little concerned with the judgment of God, the miserable soul raised his weapon: «If you don't want to, I will kill you.» In the face of her resistance, he stabbed her repeatedly with his knife. The child cried out, «My God! Mother!» and fell to the floor. Believing her dead, the assassin threw his knife aside and opened the door to flee, when he heard that she was still groaning. He retraced his steps, picked up his weapon and stabbed her all over once more, then climbed to his room and locked himself in. Maria had received fourteen serious wounds; she had fainted.[/i] In any event, I don't think she was given much of a choice. It was either..."have sex me or I kill you"....what kind of choice is that? I have a problem with the Church (or whoever) saying that she died rather than forsake her purity. She [b]would not [/b]have lost her purity if she had remained passive in order to save her life. At 12, she was still a child and not have been fully culpable anyway. What message are we sending to rape victims or those who were molested as children? That because they did not fight off their molestor they lost their purity? that they are somehow tainted? In many date rape situations today, women put themselves at greater risk by wearing immodest clothing, drinking too much, or by going far (enough) and not making thier intentions clear. I'm not saying that they are at fault...but if they had exercised greater prudence they may not have been placed in that situation. In Maria's case, she did absolutely nothing wrong, and was living a holy life...so imo, if she had allowed herself to be raped she would not have been culpable at all. Edited October 14, 2007 by friendofJPII
Autumn Dusk Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 Thats not like any story I've read about Goretti. Its also kinda fishy to have a, what amounts to a transcript, of a violent event, Maria died soon afterward and there were many emotions at play with Alessandro.
Justin86 Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 The only thing I really know about Maria Goretti was that her assailant was actually at her canonization ceremony. I that was touching, in a way.
LilyofSaintMaria Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 I wanted to give you my thoughts and some needed info about this wonderful saint! This last time Alessandro pleaded for Saint Maria to relent, was not the first. He begged her several times before and said to her if she told anyone what he said, he would kill her. Now, did Saint Maria at any time thought of relenting to his pleas? I wouldn't be surprised if the answer was yes. One one hand, she knew if she did she would commit a mortal sin and one she would be truly contrite for. Alessandro, on the other hand, would commit a mortal sin as well, but and one he would harbor in his soul with satisfaction. She was constantly bombarded with this temptation for she lived with Alessandro for most of her life! If I was in her shoes, I would be certainly scared to death. At the age of 12 I really don't know what I would have done - if I would have told my parents what Alessandro was asking of me even in the face of his murderous threat. Would I have said anything if telling on Allessandro would have thrown my family out into the streets as it would have done to Maria's family being that her mother (her only parent at this time) was under the cruel partnership with Alessandro's father. Saint Maria did fight off this temptation as much as she could by doing as the Church recommends: to stay away from bad companions and near occasions of sin, to pray, and have a strong devotion to Mary. She wanted at all costs to never give into mortal sin or be the "go between" of another person's mortal sin. Saint Maria knew that when Alessandro ran back to the house where Maria was sitting alone mending with the baby that he was about to make her do what he had been wanting to do for months. She ran out to the balcony in full view of the workers to get away from him. But then Alessandro carried her into the house and locked her in. She screamed but no one heard her. He had the knife prepared to kill her sitting right as his side - one he had made just to do the job. He demanded - but Saint Maria would not give in. She screamed to him how this would affect his immortal soul, but Alessandro would not listen. He stabbed her ferociously - something he would have done after he had got his way with her if she had let him. Saint Maria knew she had no choice - she would die either way and she wanted to die without mortal sin. But God, in His mercy kept her alive till her confession was heard. Saint Maria forgave Alessandro, it seems, even before he had stabbed her. She repeated several times on her deathbed, without any hesitation, that she forgave Alessandro and wanted him to be with her in heaven. By the way, Most of Saint Maria's life has been taken from Assunta's (Maria's mother) testimony, Alessandro's testimony before and after his conversion, Alessandro's father, and Maria's testimony on her deathbed. She lived in our past century. So there is not much room for error . . . Saint Maria Goretti is my one of my patronesses and I hope most of you will be able to appreciate the example of holiness she left us. Bernadette
Sister Rose Therese Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 I did not know that her attacker had grabbed her and tried to tear her clothes off. I think I may not have expessed myself very well. The point I was trying to make was that Saint Maria Goretti was given the choice between rape and death. She chose heroically. I don't think most rape victims, and I could be wrong, are even given that choice. There are other saints who have been raped or raped and killed and were never given that choice. The choice that Saint Maria Gorreti faced was a choice between allowing herself to be an accomplice to sin under duress or to be murdered. How many of our early Christian martyrs were tortured and killed because the would not offer incense to a false God at the threat of death. Some had incense placed in their hands and their hands placed in the fire in order to make them offer the incense and they would not even allow their hand to open. They did this knowing they would be killed for it. I find this rather similar.
friendofJPII Posted October 14, 2007 Author Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) I do not see how Maria could have been guilty in any way, shape, or form of mortal sin if she did resist Allasandro in fear for her life. In order to commit a MS one must 1) know the sin is of grave matter 2) [b]freely [i][/i]choose [/b][i][/i]to do it anyway will [b][/b]full consent of the will. Obviously if one is only 12 years old...and if one is told they will be killed if they don't have sex w/ someone who is much older and stronger than they, then the free choice clause of the MS component could not be met. Besides, if Allasandro was planning to attack and kill her he would have been committing a mortal sin anyway. I do not deny that Maria was a holy girl, a beloved saint, and that she exercised heoroic virtue. All I am saying is that her story is more about forgiveness, the divine mercy of God (I loved the part where Allasandro converts, attends her cannonization ceremony with her mother, and then becomes a monk to live out the rest of his days in penance and prayer) than it really is about chastity. I think those who exhonerate Maria should point out that if she had given in to Allasandro she would have commited no sin. In this day of age were child sexual abuse is so common and so many ppl suffer the trauma for their entire adult lives, such a clause is necessary. Edited October 14, 2007 by friendofJPII
Totus Tuus Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1402178' date='Oct 14 2007, 01:50 AM']I don't think the fact that she fought should be taken as some sort of heroic thing. That she fought has no bearing on her purity. You don't "allow" yourself to be attacked either way. Either way its just as horrible.[/quote] I think that she fought was very admirable. [quote]Thats almost the most ridiculous thing I ever herd, one for her to say that while she was being victimized. And I'd like to know how we have some many "accurate" quotes from a saint who lived long ago.[/quote] You are not required to believe that she said that. But I think it's very presumptuous to think that a quote can't be accurate because it's about a hundred years old. That's just a ridiculous claim. As for it being ridiculous for her to say that, that is also a very silly thing to say. How is her concern for his soul ridiculous? [quote]I would think the more important part would be her forgiveness of her attacker. Fighting off her attacker was of course a herioc thing, but should not be taken as denouncing victims. Possibly the idea is to look at how she tried to fight him off in fear of the his soul's safety for the sins he was to commit, not for her own saftey. In a moment when she had every right to be afraid for her own life, she still thought with concern for the one hurting her.[/quote] This is what I, too, was trying to get across. Edited October 14, 2007 by Totus Tuus
Totus Tuus Posted October 14, 2007 Posted October 14, 2007 [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1402267' date='Oct 14 2007, 11:39 AM']Thats not like any story I've read about Goretti. Its also kinda fishy to have a, what amounts to a transcript, of a violent event, Maria died soon afterward and there were many emotions at play with Alessandro.[/quote] I believe Maria lived like two more days after she was stabbed. Also, her younger siblings were around. I don't know how old they were or if they would have been able to recount the story though.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted October 15, 2007 Posted October 15, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1402145' date='Oct 14 2007, 07:19 AM']I have always wondered that, too. If I were in a position where fighting back would mean certain death, I don't know what I would do. See, with Maria Goretti they always quote "death before sin", as if not fighting back would have been a sin. But I don't know if that's the proper implication or not. I wish someone would clarify that according to Church teaching. I know it is very explicit in the Catechism that we are to defend our lives even if it means killing our aggressor. But do we allow ourselves to be raped if we do not have the means to fight back successfully without being shot/stabbed/killed?[/quote] As Maria struggled against Alessandro, she cried out, "No! It would be a sin!" My understanding of the situation was that she was trying to save Alessandro from committing sin, not her own purity. (Being raped does not cause you to lose your spiritual purity, after all.) She did not want him to have that terrible thing on his conscience. She had his soul in mind, as well as her own welfare, and this is what made her so holy - like a true follower of Christ, she was able to love a man who was trying to do a horrible thing to her. I do not know whether she even realised that she would die. It's extremely unlikely that she saw two stark choices, rape and death, and chose the latter. Alessandro could have overpowered her and raped her no matter how much she struggled, so it wasn't as if she had a real choice. The power was in his hands, and she knew it and was afraid for his soul. Edited October 15, 2007 by Cathoholic Anonymous
LilyofSaintMaria Posted October 15, 2007 Posted October 15, 2007 I agree with the forgiveness part, too, of her story. I find that to be much more of an example than her fight to stay chaste, but her death was what made her life stand out so that she was considered for canonization. Just that fact should make us look into it more and admire it, I think. I love the similarity Sister Rose Therese wrote: [i]How many of our early Christian martyrs were tortured and killed because the would not offer incense to a false God at the threat of death. Some had incense placed in their hands and their hands placed in the fire in order to make them offer the incense and they would not even allow their hand to open. They did this knowing they would be killed for it. I find this rather similar. [/i]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now