Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

St. Maria Goretti


Recommended Posts

Posted

Care to elaborate on what you believe to be 'sick'?

Posted

the entire topic - its a sick topic

Posted

No it isn't. Yes, rape is sick, but admiring someone who gave up her life so that another person wouldn't commit the sin of rape, is not sick. Forgiving someone who tried to rape you and then stabbed you (eventually resulting in your death) is not sick. It's what we are all called to do: forgive those who have hurt us.

Posted

This topic is sick - as is the inference that if someone doesn't forgive their rapist attacker their sinning and not "christian"

This topic is too personal to me .... so that's where my comments end or I will say something very nasty.

It is sick

Posted

That's not what this thread is about. St. Maria Goretti is a Saint because she did something extra-ordinary, something that most people would find impossible to do. She is an inspiration to us all.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

I was sexually abused as a child, by a man who was mentally retarded. Forgiving him has been very difficult for me, although I was helped by the knowledge that he didn't fully understand what he was doing. Prayer to St Maria Goretti formed a big part of my choice to try and forgive.

GodChild, you seem to be looking at forgiveness as a requirement - a near-impossible task that Christianity demands of vulnerable and broken people. In reality, forgiveness in situations like this is peace. Peace for both the victim and the abuser. If we can't forgive those who hurt us, we allow them to hurt us again and again and again in our memory. Forgiveness is intended to be liberating. When Immaculee Illibagiza, Catholic survivor of the Rwandan genocide, was asked how she had brought herself to visit her family's killer in jail and give him her forgiveness, she replied, "Forgiveness is all I have left to give." She wasn't being masochistic. Far from it. She had freed herself and out of the goodness of her heart she wanted to free a man who will probably be haunted by his past actions until the day he dies. Maria Goretti's story has the same core: peace.

PapaHilarious
Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1402992' date='Oct 15 2007, 09:25 AM']I was sexually abused as a child, by a man who was mentally retarded. Forgiving him has been very difficult for me, although I was helped by the knowledge that he didn't fully understand what he was doing. Prayer to St Maria Goretti formed a big part of my choice to try and forgive.

GodChild, you seem to be looking at forgiveness as a requirement - a near-impossible task that Christianity demands of vulnerable and broken people. In reality, forgiveness in situations like this is peace. Peace for both the victim and the abuser. If we can't forgive those who hurt us, we allow them to hurt us again and again and again in our memory. Forgiveness is intended to be liberating. When Immaculee Illibagiza, Catholic survivor of the Rwandan genocide, was asked how she had brought herself to visit her family's killer in jail and give him her forgiveness, she replied, "Forgiveness is all I have left to give." She wasn't being masochistic. Far from it. She had freed herself and out of the goodness of her heart she wanted to free a man who will probably be haunted by his past actions until the day he dies. Maria Goretti's story has the same core: peace.[/quote]

Beautiful, beautiful words, CA.



Is there any image more humbling in [i]The Passion[/i] than Christ forgiving the men who crucify him?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1402945' date='Oct 15 2007, 06:53 AM']I do not know whether she even realised that she would die. It's extremely unlikely that she saw two stark choices, rape and death, and chose the latter. Alessandro could have overpowered her and raped her no matter how much she struggled, so it wasn't as if she had a real choice. The power was in his hands, and she knew it and was afraid for his soul.[/quote]
But I do believe she had a choice of either being brutally stabbed by him, whether she would die or not, though death would seem pretty evident here, if she resisted or not. Thus is what Pope Pius XII said in his homily at her canonization. And from the accounts I've read on her life, I've never read that he would have stabbed her like this either way. It was either he stab her, or she stop resisting him. Yes, the power was in his hands, but her choosing to resist him to the point that she did very likely caused him to then resort to stabbing her.

Purity is definitely a huge part of her story. It is one of both purity and forgiveness. But regarding purity, I don't think it's right to belittle her courageous act in resisting Alessandro. She is indeed a martyr for chastity as Pope Pius XII declared her. I don't think it's for us to decide something else.

Yes, for sure those who are raped do not loose their true virginity. But I don't think comparing this to St. Maria's case is right, to almost say her sacrifice wasn't worth it, or she didn't need to do that. No, of course she wouldn't have committed a mortal sin if she didn't resist him like that, of course not.

And she still, I believe, would have become a saint if this happened, though probably not officially canonized because her life wouldn't have been as well known. In the accounts I've read on her, it mentioned this many times her life of virtue beforehand - how it wasn't simply this act that caused her to be canonized. She was truly a prayerful and holy child. Her peers used to called her "The Little Old Lady" because of how pious she was.

But returning to her resisting Alessandro, she did so at the cost of being brutally stabbed, and that was heroic. And I think her sacrifice was very well worth it. She was both defending herself, and trying to prevent Alessandro from committing this sin. Purity is a huge part of her story. And her martyrdom is such a great witness to the world.

Statement of Alessandro's written on his deathbed (source - documentary [url="http://www.aquinasandmore.com/index.cfm/title/Fourteen-Flowers-of-Pardon,-DVD/FuseAction/store.ItemDetails/SKU/3217/index.htm"][i]Fourteen Flowers of Pardon[/i][/url]):
[quote]"I ask pardon of the world of the outrage done to the martyr Maria Goretti and to purity. I exhort everyone to keep away from immoral shows, from dangers, from occasions that can lead to sin."[/quote]

Edited by Margaret Clare
Posted

The thing is, she resisted him but he most likely could have overpowered her if he wished. Instead he chose to stab her to death. It was her admirable choice to resist and risk death, but ultimately it was his decision to kill her instead of raping her.
Regardless of the confusion about this incident, she is a great example for us all, to stand up for what is right, even in the face of death.

Posted

That is true, but somehow I find the saints who really struggled with temptations against chasity (Servant of God, Dorothy Day, St. Augustine, St. Mary Magdelan) more relateable in that regard. Really tho, you can pray to any saint for anything. Allasandro's actions really illustrate the dangers of pornography.

hyperdulia again
Posted (edited)

.

Edited by hyperdulia again
Posted

When one tries to make a point about St Maria Goretti's story, and how she chose death over "sin"--yeah, it probably wouldn't have been a sin if she gave in. But that's why she's a martyr.

When you make a point against St Maria, you're making a point against all of the church's martyr saints, and against Jesus Christ Himself. None of them had to stand up for their faith in the face of death, and under those circumstances, none of them probably would have been culpable, but that's why they're saints.

Is your problem with St Maria Goretti, or with the idea of martyrdom in general?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='dUSt' post='1403197' date='Oct 15 2007, 06:30 PM']When one tries to make a point about St Maria Goretti's story, and how she chose death over "sin"--yeah, it probably wouldn't have been a sin if she gave in. But that's why she's a martyr.

When you make a point against St Maria, you're making a point against all of the church's martyr saints, and against Jesus Christ Himself. None of them had to stand up for their faith in the face of death, and under those circumstances, none of them probably would have been culpable, but that's why they're saints.

Is your problem with St Maria Goretti, or with the idea of martyrdom in general?[/quote]

My problem is with those who state she died for the sake of her purity...when she would not have lost her purity if she gave in. I think what Maria did was heroic, wonderful, that she was a beloved saint, and that one could pray to her for the virtue of chastity. I just think it's important to clarify that if she had given in, she would have commited no sin, that she would have still been "a virgin" in the spiritual sense, so that those who were victims of abuse do not feel they are "damaged goods" or that it was their fault. I do not have a problem with what she did, or who she was, but I do take issue with the way her story is portrayed by some. Like I said, I do not see how chastity is a major theme here, when she was never tempted to sin against chastity. I have no doubt God was at work, however, because of the conversion of Allasandro.

Edited by friendofJPII
Posted

First of all, Cathoholic Anonymous, thank you so much for your thoughts. You've put Maria's heroism in words better than anyone here, in my humble opinion. :)

Now, in defense of my patroness, she was defending both herself and Allessandro; she was a young woman of faith, and she knew it well....I really doubt she would question her purity if he did choose to rape her.

It spoke volumes about Maria's compassion for others when she held the spiritual and psychological well-being of her attacker above her own. Though I can't provide an exact citation, Christ did say there was no greater love than a sacrificial one. She was willing to give her life for someone who did her harm. Who better deserving of the title 'saint' than one who imitated His Love so well?

She's been a blessing to me, that's for sure, especially being young in a world where purity is mocked. :)

Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1403237' date='Oct 15 2007, 09:43 PM']It spoke volumes about Maria's compassion for others when she held the spiritual and psychological well-being of her attacker above her own. Though I can't provide an exact citation, Christ did say there was no greater love than a sacrificial one. She was willing to give her life for someone who did her harm. Who better deserving of the title 'saint' than one who imitated His Love so well?[/quote]

John 15:12-13 perhaps?

[quote]This is my commandment: love one another as I love you. No one has greater love than this, to lay down one's life for one's friends[/quote]

Posted (edited)

That's the one, dear, thank you. ^_^

Edited by MissyP89
Posted

Quite welcome Missy. Had John open anyhow. :)

Posted

Any catholic saints who were women, raped and LIVED - any catholic saints the Church recognises as heroic for LIVING after being raped?

In my personal opinion, what St Maria did was not heroic - most women would choose death over being raped. I know if I had the choice, i would have. A Saint more worthy of being a patron for rape victims would be a saint who was raped and lived with the violation ..... are there any such saints?

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1402992' date='Oct 16 2007, 02:25 AM']I was sexually abused as a child, by a man who was mentally retarded. Forgiving him has been very difficult for me, although I was helped by the knowledge that he didn't fully understand what he was doing. Prayer to St Maria Goretti formed a big part of my choice to try and forgive.

GodChild, you seem to be looking at forgiveness as a requirement - a near-impossible task that Christianity demands of vulnerable and broken people. In reality, forgiveness in situations like this is peace. Peace for both the victim and the abuser. If we can't forgive those who hurt us, we allow them to hurt us again and again and again in our memory. Forgiveness is intended to be liberating. When Immaculee Illibagiza, Catholic survivor of the Rwandan genocide, was asked how she had brought herself to visit her family's killer in jail and give him her forgiveness, she replied, "Forgiveness is all I have left to give." She wasn't being masochistic. Far from it. She had freed herself and out of the goodness of her heart she wanted to free a man who will probably be haunted by his past actions until the day he dies. Maria Goretti's story has the same core: peace.[/quote]


Well if this woman becomes a patron saint of rape victims it would be more fitting.

I'm sorry, but whereas I can see St Maria as a patron for purity - i do NOT see her as a patron for rape victims ... firstly, she didn't experience rape.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...