Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Twin Survives Several Abortion Attempts


Recommended Posts

KnightofChrist
Posted

[url="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=491443&in_page_id=1770"]We're twinseparable! Happy with his brother, the boy who refused to die[/url]
By LUCY LAING - More by this author » Last updated at 01:09am on 3rd November 2007

Comments Comments (20)
They say twins share a strong bond - but the one between Gabriel and Ieuan Jones was unbreakable.

When doctors found that Gabriel was weaker than his brother, with an enlarged heart,and believed he was going to die in the womb, his mother Rebecca Jones had to make a heartbreaking decision.

Doctors told her his death could cause his twin brother to die too before they were born, and that it would be better to end Gabriel's suffering sooner rather than later.



Thriving: Gabriel, right, with his twin brother Ieuan, is now a healthy 12lb 6oz at seven months

Mrs Jones decided to let doctors operate to terminate Gabriel's life.

Firstly they tried to sever his umbilical cord to cut off his blood supply, but the cord was too strong.

They then cut Mrs Jones's placenta in half so that when Gabriel died, it would not affect his twin brother.

But after the operation which was meant to end his life, tiny Gabriel had other ideas.

Although he weighed less than a pound, he put up such a fight for survival that doctors called him Rocky.

Astonishingly, he managed to carry on living in his mother's womb for another five weeks - until the babies were delivered by caesarean section.

Now he and Ieuan are back at home in Stoke - and are so close they are always holding each other's hand.

Mrs Jones, 35, a financial adviser whose husband Mark, 36, is a car salesman, said: "It really is a miracle. Doctors carried out an operation to let Gabriel die - yet he hung on.

"It was unbelievable."

"When I felt him kicking madly the morning after the operation, I suddenly knew that he was going to hang on.

"The doctors couldn't believe it when they could still hear his heartbeat the next morning."



Rebecca Jones: 'It's a miracle'

Mrs Jones learned she was expecting twins when she was ten weeks pregnant. She said: "When they told us we were over the moon."

But at her 20-week scan, doctors had some devastating news. One of the boys was half the size of his brother.

They didn't know what was causing it, but somehow he wasn't getting enough nutrients.

Then doctors said his heart was three times normal size and it was likely he would have a heart attack or a stroke in the womb.

Mrs Jones said: "They told us that if he died, it could be life threatening for his brother.

"We had to decide whether to end his life and let his brother live, or risk them both."

They said it would be impossible to keep him alive afterwards as he was so poorly.

It would be kinder to let him die in the womb with his brother by his side than to die alone after being born.

"That made my mind up for me. I wanted the best thing for him."

At Birmingham Women's Hospital, when Mrs Jones was 25 weeks pregnant, doctors tried to sever Gabriel's umbilical cord to cut off his blood supply and allow him to die.

But the cord was too thick, and they could not cut through it.

As a last resort they divided Mrs Jones's placenta so that when Gabriel died, it would allow Ieuan to survive. Mrs Jones said: "I put my hands on my stomach thinking of Gabriel. It was devastating. I had said my goodbyes."

But the next morning Mrs Jones felt Gabriel kicking. A scan showed his heart was still beating. She said: "No one could quite believe it."

Gabriel hung on, and his enlarged heart started to reduce in size. He also gained weight.

Mrs Jones said: "They thought it may be because the placenta had been divided. Inadvertently, it had evened out the distribution of nutrition between them, allowing Gabriel to survive.'

When Mrs Jones reached 31 weeks doctors carried out a caesarian to deliver the twins. Ieuan weighed 3lb 8oz and Gabriel 1lb 15oz. Both were kept in hospital, but since going home they have thrived. At seven months, Ieuan weighs 15lb and Gabriel 12lb 6oz.

Mrs Jones said: "The boys are so healthy, they have huge appetites too. Ieuan is the noisy one, while Gabriel is always laughing, it's like he's just so happy to be here.

"There is such a strong bond between them.

"They are always holding hands and if one cries, the other reaches out to comfort him."

"Doctors tried to break their bond in the womb, but they just proved it couldn't be broken."

Posted

read this.

Freaking ghoulish. Made me sick the way they talk about it.

Shouldn't the doctors be trying to save the child's life instead of simply failing to kill it?

Proud2BCatholic139
Posted

All I can say is,

Praised be Jesus Christ Now and Forever. Amen. :)

Posted

watch, the kid will probably sue his parents in 20 years

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1413711' date='Nov 3 2007, 12:41 PM']They then cut Mrs Jones's placenta in half so that when Gabriel died, it would not affect his twin brother.[/quote]
I thought that each baby had their own placenta?

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' post='1413995' date='Nov 4 2007, 02:54 PM']I thought that each baby had their own placenta?[/quote]
Not always.

All I can say is that is an amazing story of God refusing to allow doctors to take a life!

Posted

you know he gonna kick some one's butt when he gets out...

Posted

I don't think cutting the umbilical cord and altering the placenta actually count as abortion techniques. Sad that they tried it none the less, but at least it was in an attempt to save another life rather than to just end a pregnancy like a normal abortion.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Proud2BCatholic139' post='1413981' date='Nov 4 2007, 05:19 AM']All I can say is,

Praised be Jesus Christ Now and Forever. Amen. :)[/quote]

Amen. This is wonderful.

1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1414022' date='Nov 4 2007, 03:44 AM']I don't think cutting the umbilical cord and altering the placenta actually count as abortion techniques. Sad that they tried it none the less, but at least it was in an attempt to save another life rather than to just end a pregnancy like a normal abortion.[/quote]
The intent was to abort the pregnancy, so I think it would count as an abortion technique. A woman getting someone to punch her hard in the belly isn't a normal abortion technique either, but it would get the job done.

I've heard of severing some of the blood vessels in cases like this. I believe it's called twin transfusion. But if the doctors were telling her that they would have to kill the baby it was certainly not the normal treatment. I really don't feel any anger toward this mother. While she did allow the doctors to go ahead and do something, the doctors were giving very bad professional advice to a couple in distress. I'm also guessing that this was in the UK so they may not have had the option of getting a second opinion. The ones who should be ashamed are the doctors. How can a professional OB not know of techniques that non-MDs know about?

Sister Rose Therese
Posted

If they had cut the umbilical cord it would have killed the baby. That is how they get their nutrients. It would be equivalent to cutting off someone's food, water and air.
It just amazes me though the gall they had telling the parents the things they did. But I guess that is today's world for you.
If they knew that dividing the placenta would allow the one baby to live if the other died then why didn't they try that first?

MissScripture
Posted

Another question: If the baby died in the womb, wouldn't the mother's body try to push it out, thus making her go into labor, and possibly causing the other baby to be born really prematurely?

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

[quote name='1337 k4th0l1x0r' post='1414093' date='Nov 4 2007, 11:43 AM']I really don't feel any anger toward this mother. While she did allow the doctors to go ahead and do something, the doctors were giving very bad professional advice to a couple in distress.[/quote]

I agree. It seems she was really heartbroken that they told her it was basically her only option to be sure Ieuan would be okay, so I think if they'd given her any other viable options she would have tried those first.


[quote name='Sister Rose Therese' post='1414105' date='Nov 4 2007, 12:09 PM']If they knew that dividing the placenta would allow the one baby to live if the other died then why didn't they try that first?[/quote]

That's exactly what I was thinking...

Posted

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1414022' date='Nov 4 2007, 02:44 AM']I don't think cutting the umbilical cord and altering the placenta actually count as abortion techniques. Sad that they tried it none the less, but at least it was in an attempt to save another life rather than to just end a pregnancy like a normal abortion.[/quote]


I think they are classified as abortion attempts because they were intended to terminate the pregnancy. We could get technical, but I have no objections to calling it an abortion attempt... seriously, what else would you call it?

Posted

[quote name='R4id3n' post='1414018' date='Nov 4 2007, 02:02 AM']you know he gonna kick some one's butt when he gets out...[/quote]
I was thinking the same thing.

Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1414112' date='Nov 4 2007, 01:05 PM']I think they are classified as abortion attempts because they were intended to terminate the pregnancy. We could get technical, but I have no objections to calling it an abortion attempt... seriously, what else would you call it?[/quote]
Well, it just seems more like an ectopic pregnancy situation to me. The chances of a death weren't the same at all, but It just doesn't seem like their intent was to terminate a pregnancy here. It was to save the life of the other child.

I don't agree with it, but it's no where near as bad as a "normal" abortion.

Posted

That is going to be one angry kid.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1414169' date='Nov 4 2007, 04:49 PM']Well, it just seems more like an ectopic pregnancy situation to me. The chances of a death weren't the same at all, but It just doesn't seem like their intent was to terminate a pregnancy here. It was to save the life of the other child.

I don't agree with it, but it's no where near as bad as a "normal" abortion.[/quote]

It is just as bad as a normal abortion attempt, because it WAS an abortion attempt. Instead of trying to save Gabriel's life outside the womb or let him die naturally outside while attempting to save his life their intent was to kill him next to his brother in some sick since of "mercy", which is ridiculous. And to top it off to even preform this operation endangered the lives of both children. Both could be dead had it not been for God saving their lives.

They didn't even want to try to save Gabriel's [i]and[/i] Ieuan's lives. They wanted to murder one using some perverted and flawed since of "morality."


[quote]"They said it would be impossible to keep him alive afterwards as he was so poorly.

[b]It would be kinder to let him die in the womb with his brother by his side than to [b]die alone [/b]after being born.
[/b]"[/quote]

Posted

For infomation. In the UK there is always the option of a second opinion. I think the mother was badly misinformed but still should not have gone ahead. The placenta of identical twins is the same, because they originate from the same ovum. I think they have accidentally made a very exciting discovery, though they were not trying to - that if one twin is not thriving the thing to do is split the placenta. Oddly enough I think the morality of the situation would be entirely changed if they had intended it in the first place. Also I don't think that splitting the placenta was wrong, though the attempt to cut the umbilical cord was. This is because cutting the umbilical cord is directly willing the death of the child, while splitting the placenta was aimed at reducing the bad consequences of the forseen but not directly caused death of the child.

Posted

For infomation. In the UK there is always the option of a second opinion. I think the mother was badly misinformed but still should not have gone ahead. The placenta of identical twins is the same, because they originate from the same ovum. I think they have accidentally made a very exciting discovery, though they were not trying to - that if one twin is not thriving the thing to do is split the placenta. Oddly enough I think the morality of the situation would be entirely changed if they had intended it in the first place. Also I don't think that splitting the placenta was wrong, though the attempt to cut the umbilical cord was. This is because cutting the umbilical cord is directly willing the death of the child, while splitting the placenta was aimed at reducing the bad consequences of the forseen but not directly caused death of the child.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...