Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Twin Survives Several Abortion Attempts


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1414189' date='Nov 4 2007, 07:58 PM']They didn't even want to try to save Gabriel's [i]and[/i] Ieuan's lives. They wanted to murder one using some perverted and flawed since of "morality."[/quote]

Yes, what they did was probably stupid and wrong, because it seems that killing Ieuen was not the only possible option. However, I do believe it is wrong for us to call anyone a murderer in this situation. First of all, unless you are a doctor or a nurse, you don't know the situation and moreover it could have more specifics to the situation that we do not know.

Second of all, abortion to save a life is not "some perverted and flawed sense of morality." In situations where abortion is used to save the mother's life when both would have died otherwise, this is not perverted. Correct me if I'm wrong, but according to a class I took last semester taught by a very orthodox Catholic priest, this is considered "morally acceptable" by the Church, even if not the best option. I mean, look at St Gianna Beretta Molla. She is a saint because she gave her life for her child. Not everyone in the world has that kind of faith and courage.

The doctors may have been wrong, yes. But we cannot judge these parents for what they did, and we cannot call this "attempted murder" at least without knowing all the details of the situation. Further, how do we know that they weren't guided by God anyway- maybe both of them really would have died if not for this surgery? We should be praising God for this miracle rather than judging the humans involved.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1414189' date='Nov 4 2007, 07:58 PM']They didn't even want to try to save Gabriel's [i]and[/i] Ieuan's lives. They wanted to murder one using some perverted and flawed since of "morality."[/quote]

Ok, I had a long response but it got deleted. Basically, I think it is horrible to be judging these people like this. 1, we're not doctors. 2, We don't know the whole situation. 3, This is NOT "some perverted and flawed since of 'morality.'" The Catholic Church teaches, according to my (orthodox Catholic priest) professor last semester, that ending a pregnancy in order to save another life (eg, when both the mother and baby would die) is "morally acceptable." Not necessarily good, or the best option, but it IS acceptable.

We should be thanking God for this miracle rather than condemning the people involved. How do we know that if they had not intervened and cut the placenta, both babies wouldn't have died? Maybe God was using that.

Finally, look to the example of St. Gianna Molla. Not everyone has that kind of courage and faith. Not everyone is a saint.

Posted

I liked the fact that he was kicking like crazy the next day. My mom was scheduled for a D & C, and when they were wheeling her in, I started kicking like crazy, and she refused to let them operate. She was almost in kidney failure, and only had one kidney anyway, so they thought carrying me would kill her. Doctors can sometimes be wrong.

Posted

hmmmm... I guess my computer was messing with me last night lol... too late to edit as a double post, but if a mod happens to be here, you can delete my second post up there, its just a summary of the first

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Romans1513' post='1414593' date='Nov 4 2007, 11:44 PM']Yes, what they did was probably stupid and wrong, because it seems that killing Ieuen was not the only possible option. However, I do believe it is wrong for us to call anyone a murderer in this situation. First of all, unless you are a doctor or a nurse, you don't know the situation and moreover it could have more specifics to the situation that we do not know.[/quote]

It was wrong it was stupid and it was attempted murder.

[quote name='Romans1513' post='1414593' date='Nov 4 2007, 11:44 PM']Second of all, abortion to save a life is not "some perverted and flawed sense of morality." In situations where abortion is used to save the mother's life when both would have died otherwise, this is not perverted. Correct me if I'm wrong, but according to a class I took last semester taught by a very orthodox Catholic priest, this is considered "morally acceptable" by the Church, even if not the best option. I mean, look at St Gianna Beretta Molla. She is a saint because she gave her life for her child. Not everyone in the world has that kind of faith and courage.[/quote]

What you do not understand is the Doctors believed that Gabriel [b]had to be removed[/b] or he would endanger the life of Ieuan. They could do this by removing Gabriel [b]alive or dead[/b]. They chose dead and to murder Gabriel next to his brother Ieuan instead of even attempting to save his life outside the womb. This means that the argument of "abortion is ok if it saves the life of another" [b]does not apply here[/b]. The doctors could have chosen to remove Gabriel [u]alive[/u] attempting to save his life too and remove what they thought was danger to Ieuan but, they chose instead to murder Gabriel in a perverted since of mercy.

[quote name='Romans1513' post='1414593' date='Nov 4 2007, 11:44 PM']The doctors may have been wrong, yes. But we cannot judge these parents for what they did, and we cannot call this "attempted murder" at least without knowing all the details of the situation. Further, how do we know that they weren't guided by God anyway- maybe both of them really would have died if not for this surgery? We should be praising God for this miracle rather than judging the humans involved.[/quote]

It was attempted murder by the Doctors. It was not guided by God. God countered their attempts. Case closed.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

---

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

Do you know this family? Are you a doctor familiar with every detail of the case? Are you God? What I'm saying is, it is wrong for us to judge everyone involved in this case. I reread the article and it especially struck me that the doctors assumed that Gabriel would not survive outside the womb and so they would let him die with his brother instead of "alone." Yeah, that is really messed up logic. I still do not think that we have ANY right to call them murderers.

Posted

Yay Gabriel!! Great name too!

That mother certainly needs our prayers. Can you imagine the guilt that she must be feeling?? Oh my goodness. I can't even imagine what she must be thinking when her beautiful baby smiles at her and she thinks about what could have happened! How sad.

Hopefully their house is joyous, however.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Romans1513' post='1414942' date='Nov 5 2007, 05:00 PM']Do you know this family? Are you a doctor familiar with every detail of the case? Are you God? What I'm saying is, it is wrong for us to judge everyone involved in this case. I reread the article and it especially struck me that the doctors assumed that Gabriel would not survive outside the womb and so they would let him die with his brother instead of "alone." Yeah, that is really messed up logic. I still do not think that we have ANY right to call them murderers.[/quote]

The doctors involved are not murders, in this case, but they did no doubt attempt to murder Gabriel. What they in the eyes of Holy Mother Church was attempted murder of a unborn child. They are bound to save life not destroy life.

The whole article makes it clear enough to make the charge. The Doctors tried to cut of the umbilical cord the life supply of Gabriel, in hopes that it would cause his death, that is attempted murder. Again in the Doctors jugdement baby Gabriel or his dead body would have had to been removed so as not to endanger the other child. Knowing this there was no reason to kill him when they could have attempted to save his life outside the womb. It is clear from the mothers quote the didnt even want to try.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1414944' date='Nov 5 2007, 05:10 PM']Yay Gabriel!! Great name too!

That mother certainly needs our prayers. Can you imagine the guilt that she must be feeling?? Oh my goodness. I can't even imagine what she must be thinking when her beautiful baby smiles at her and she thinks about what could have happened! How sad.

Hopefully their house is joyous, however.[/quote]


Indeed, indeed, pray!

Posted

Yeah, I'd be careful about judging the mom. Doctors are really convincing, especially when they use the "it's best for the baby" argument, appealing to a woman's natural maternal instinct.

I've seen girls going into abortion clinics while protesting (peacefully, saying the Rosary. I'm getting trained to sidewalk counsel though) and it's obvious that they don't want to be there but they feel forced for the same reason, that not only is it best for them, that it'll be best for the baby in some sick, perverted sense.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...