CatherineM Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 These kinds of things scare me. When we make people think that it is just like having tonsils out, and everyone is doing it, then everyone will be. From the New York Times. I cut and pasted it in case some of you can't view that web site. [b]Telling the Stories Behind the Abortions [/b] Anne Sherwood for The New York Times "Because it is such a secret, we lose sight of how common it is." - Dr. Susan Wicklund By CORNELIA DEAN Published: November 6, 2007 Dr. Susan Wicklund took her first step toward the front line of the abortion wars when she was in her early 20s, a high school graduate with a few community college credits, working dead-end jobs. She became pregnant. She had an abortion. It was legal, but it was ghastly. Her counseling, she recalls, was limited to instructions to pay in advance, in cash, and to go to the emergency room if she had a problem. During the procedure itself, her every question drew the same response: “Shut up!” Determined that other women should have better reproductive care, she began work as an apprentice midwife and eventually finished college, earned a medical degree and started a practice in which she spends about 90 percent of her time on abortion services. Much of her work is in underserved regions on the Western plains, at clinics that she visits by plane. In her forthcoming book “This Common Secret: My Journey as an Abortion Doctor” (Public Affairs), Dr. Wicklund describes her work, the circumstances that lead her patients to choose abortion, and the barriers — lack of money, lack of providers, violence in the home or protesters at clinics — that stand in their way. But she said her main goal with the book was to encourage more open discussion of abortion and its prevalence. “We don’t talk about it,” she said in a telephone interview. “People say, ‘Nobody I know has ever had an abortion,’ and that is just not true. Their sisters, their mothers have had abortions.” Dr. Wicklund, 53, said that at current rates almost 40 percent of American women have an abortion during their child-bearing years, a figure supported by the Guttmacher Institute, which researches reproductive health policy. Abortion is one of the most common operations in the United States, she said, more common than tonsillectomy or removal of wisdom teeth. “Because it is such a secret,” she said, “we lose sight of how common it is.” But Dr. Wicklund acknowledges that abortion is an issue fraught with dilemmas. In the book, she describes witnessing, as a medical student, the abortion of a 21-week fetus. She writes that at the sight of its tiny arm she decided she would perform abortions only in the first trimester of pregnancy. She says late-term abortions should be legal, but her decision means she occasionally sees desperate women she must refuse to help. Dr. Wicklund describes her horror when she aborted the pregnancy of a woman who had been raped, only to discover, by examining the removed tissue, that the pregnancy was further along than she or the woman had thought — and that she had destroyed an embryo the woman and her husband had conceived together. And she describes the way she watches and listens as the women she treats tell why they want to end their pregnancies. If she detects uncertainty or thinks they may be responding to the wishes of anyone other than themselves, she says, she tells them to think it over a bit longer. On the other hand, Dr. Wicklund has little use for requirements like 24-hour waiting periods, or for assertions like those of Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, who said in a recent Supreme Court decision on abortion that the government had an interest in protecting women from their own decisions in the matter. “It’s so incredibly insulting,” Dr. Wicklund said in the interview. “The 24-hour waiting period implies that women don’t think about it on their own and have to have the government forcing it on them. To me a lot of the abortion restrictions are about control of women, about power, and it’s insulting.” Dr. Wicklund said she would put more credence in opponents of abortion rights if they did more to help women prevent unwanted pregnancies. Instead, she said, many of the protesters she encounters “are against birth control, period.” That is unfortunate, she said, because her clinic experience confirms studies showing that emphasizing abstinence rather than contraception may cause girls to delay their first sexual experience for a few months, but “when they do have intercourse they are much less likely to protect themselves with birth control or a condom.” According to the Guttmacher Institute, about a quarter of pregnancies in the United States end in abortion. Dr. Wicklund says that is why she believes far more people favor abortion rights than are willing to admit it in polls. For example, she said in the interview, an abortion ban that seemed to have wide support in South Dakota was put to a vote and “when people got behind those curtains and nobody was watching it was overwhelmingly defeated. Unfortunately, people are not willing to say what they really think.” One of these people might be a woman she recognized as one of the protesters who regularly appeared, shouting, outside a clinic where she worked. Only now the woman was in the waiting room, desperate to end an unwanted pregnancy. Dr. Wicklund performed the procedure. And then there is Dr. Wicklund’s maternal grandmother, a woman she was afraid would disapprove of her work. But it turned out that she had a story of her own. “When I was 16 years old, my best friend got pregnant,” is how the story began. Her friend turned to her and her sister for help. They did the only thing they could think of — putting “something long and sharp ‘up there,’ ” according to the book. The girl bled to death, and the cause of her death was kept secret. “I know exactly what kind of work you do,” the grandmother told Dr. Wicklund, “and it is a good thing.” One question Dr. Wicklund hears “all the time,” she said, is how she can focus on abortion rather than on something more rewarding, like delivering babies. “In fact, the women are so grateful,” Dr. Wicklund said in the interview. “Women are so grateful to know they can get through this safely, that they can still get pregnant again. “It is one of the few areas of medicine where you are not working with a sick person, you are doing something for them that gives them back their life, their control,” she added. “It’s a very rewarding thing to be part of that.”
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1415390' date='Nov 6 2007, 11:13 AM']One of these people might be a woman she recognized as one of the protesters who regularly appeared, shouting, outside a clinic where she worked. Only now the woman was in the waiting room, desperate to end an unwanted pregnancy. Dr. Wicklund performed the procedure. And then there is Dr. Wicklund’s maternal grandmother, a woman she was afraid would disapprove of her work. But it turned out that she had a story of her own. “When I was 16 years old, my best friend got pregnant,” is how the story began. Her friend turned to her and her sister for help. They did the only thing they could think of — putting “something long and sharp ‘up there,’ ” according to the book. The girl bled to death, and the cause of her death was kept secret. “I know exactly what kind of work you do,” the grandmother told Dr. Wicklund, “and it is a good thing.” One question Dr. Wicklund hears “all the time,” she said, is how she can focus on abortion rather than on something more rewarding, like delivering babies. “In fact, the women are so grateful,” Dr. Wicklund said in the interview. “Women are so grateful to know they can get through this safely, that they can still get pregnant again. “It is one of the few areas of medicine where you are not working with a sick person, you are doing something for them that gives them back their life, their control,” she added. “It’s a very rewarding thing to be part of that.”[/quote] [img]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/style_images/ip.boardpr/folder_post_icons/icon8.gif[/img]
PapaHilarious Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 [quote]Dr. Wicklund describes her horror when she aborted the pregnancy of a woman who had been raped, only to discover, by examining the removed tissue, that the pregnancy was further along than she or the woman had thought — and that she had destroyed an embryo the woman and her husband had conceived together.[/quote] that is one of the most disgusting articles i've ever read. i couldn't even finish it. just the thought of talking so casually about chopping a baby into pieces... i wonder if this is how the nazis used to talk about their medical experiments.
jeffpugh Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 How can she go against her nature by doing this? This is hellish.
Romans1513 Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 [quote]Dr. Wicklund describes her horror when she aborted the pregnancy of a woman who had been raped, only to discover, by examining the removed tissue, that the pregnancy was further along than she or the woman had thought — and that she had destroyed an embryo the woman and her husband had conceived together.[/quote] But its just a ball of cells right? A lifeless ball of cells? So it shouldn't matter who the father is, right? Its not like it was a person or anything... Doesn't she realize how hypocritical and stupid this situation was? This article makes me sick.
CatherineM Posted November 6, 2007 Author Posted November 6, 2007 I wonder if she is going to do any public book signings people can protest at.
Lena Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 so, not only is she an abortion doctor, but she is capitalizing off it as well by writing a book. how disturbing.
Dreamweaver Posted November 6, 2007 Posted November 6, 2007 Bernard Nathanson is so much cooler. Keep on praying for the conversion of abortion doctors.
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 Our society is very very ill right now. It doesn't matter what public policy is. Whether abortion was government funded or government banned or what method of sex-ed is taught, the state of our society is morally bankrupt. Even if the barbaric procedure of abortion was banned 100% tomorrow it would not fix the negative attitude our society has towards life. It's quite ironic that we backwards science-ignoring Christians seem to be the only ones to recognize that at the point of conception a new human is created.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 We can't afford to dismiss her book as an attempt at capitalising on abortion. Just because a doctor is an abortionist doesn't mean that she's greedy and grasping, the embodiment of all the vices. It's easy to assume that an abortionist must be a terrible person through and through, and that allows us to discount everything s/he says - to our cost. There is information in that book that we need to look at carefully. How many people who say that they are pro-life would secretly get an abortion? What would drive a protestor at an abortion clinic into the clinic's waiting room? Why do so many people condemn abortion in public but support it in private? And why is abortion so common? Dr Wicklund is right to raise these questions. They need thinking about. It's easy to dismiss the story of the protestor who sought an abortion of her own. Oh, the abortionist must be lying. No pro-life protestor approached her [i]really[/i]. Abortionists lie. They must do. They're abortionists, what do you expect? Or we could dismiss the whole book on the grounds that talking about how common abortion is will make it more common. We must keep quiet, not discuss this aspect of it too much. Condemn the book. Condemn the 'work' of the woman who wrote it. But on no account discuss the issues she raises. We can't afford to do that.
Totus Tuus Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 [quote name='-I---Love' post='1415404' date='Nov 6 2007, 12:24 PM']I wish I wouldn't have read this.[/quote] I'm glad you said that, so I won't read it.
Autumn Dusk Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 [quote]How many people who say that they are pro-life would secretly get an abortion?[/quote] Or want one for their grown children? It happens, and I fear those who condemn abortion most viciously probably have it done by those under there noses more frequently than a random person off the street.
Spamity Calamity Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 I think there are special places in hell for people her...
prose Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 I was curious as to where she came up with it. What study?
prose Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 From the institutes website: [quote]For every 1,000 women of childbearing age (15–44) worldwide, 29 were estimated to have had an induced abortion in 2003, compared with 35 in 1995. The decline was most substantial in Europe, where the rate fell from 48 to 28 abortions per 1,000 women, largely because of dramatic declines in Eastern Europe. On the whole, the abortion rate decreased more in developed countries, where abortion is generally safe and legal on broad grounds (from 39 to 26), than in developing countries, where the procedure is largely illegal and unsafe (from 34 to 29). Significantly, the abortion rate for 2003 was roughly equal in developed and developing regions—26 and 29, respectively—despite abortion being largely illegal in developing regions. Health consequences, however, vary greatly between the two regions, since abortion is generally safe where it is broadly legal and mostly unsafe where restricted.[/quote] How does 29/1000 equal 40%??????
prose Posted November 7, 2007 Posted November 7, 2007 (edited) [img]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/style_images/ip.boardpr/folder_post_icons/icon8.gif[/img] [quote]Guiding Principles • A vision for the future. The Institute envisions a world in which all women and men have the ability to exercise their rights and responsibilities regarding sexual behavior, reproduction and family formation, freely and with dignity. Essential to this vision are societal respect for and protection of personal decision-making with regard to unwanted pregnancies and births, as well as public and private-sector policies that support individuals and couples in their efforts to become responsible and supportive parents, maintain stable family structures and balance parenting with other roles. Equally vital to the Institute’s vision are the eradication of gender inequality worldwide and the attainment of equal status, rights and responsibilities for women. • A comprehensive view of sexual and reproductive health. The Institute regards sexual and reproductive health as encompassing a wide range of people’s needs from adolescence onward. The Institute works to protect, expand and equalize access to information, services and rights that will enable women and men to * avoid unplanned pregnancies; * prevent and treat sexually transmitted infections, including HIV; * exercise the right to choose abortion; * achieve healthy pregnancies and births; and * have healthy, satisfying sexual relationships. Priority attention to those with greatest need. The Institute promotes the sexual and reproductive health of all people, but gives priority attention to the needs, concerns and rights of those whose access to information, services or other societal benefits may be impeded by their age, marital status, geography or income, or because of gender, racial, ethnic, religious or cultural discrimination. • A responsibility to the United States and the world. The Institute is acutely aware of the pressing need to improve the quality of policy and programs concerning sexual and reproductive health in the Unit-ed States, and regards achieving this goal as its primary responsibility. Understanding that the political, cultural and economic power of the United States can have considerable impact on sexual and reproductive health throughout the world, the Institute places a similarly high priority on monitoring and analyzing the effects of U.S. policy on women and men in other countries. The Institute is also mindful that across and within countries, certain commonalities underlie the circumstances in which sexuality is expressed, families or unions are formed, and children are conceived and born. Guided by this awareness, the Institute emphasizes the development and dissemination of the thematic cross-country and country-specific work that will have the greatest relevance globally.[/quote] Edited November 7, 2007 by prose
CatherineM Posted November 8, 2007 Author Posted November 8, 2007 prose-that's what I wondered too. 40% is just beyond belief. I'm not sure that high a percentage of women are even getting pregnant any more.
Dreamweaver Posted November 8, 2007 Posted November 8, 2007 [quote name='prose' post='1415847' date='Nov 7 2007, 06:06 PM']From the institutes website: How does 29/1000 equal 40%??????[/quote] 29 of 1000 is the number of abortions for that year only. I believe 40% is the percentage of women who have had an abortion over the course of their lifetime.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now