Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Abortion Doc Writes Book


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1415658' date='Nov 7 2007, 08:41 AM']We can't afford to dismiss her book as an attempt at capitalising on abortion. Just because a doctor is an abortionist doesn't mean that she's greedy and grasping, the embodiment of all the vices. It's easy to assume that an abortionist must be a terrible person through and through, and that allows us to discount everything s/he says - to our cost.

There is information in that book that we need to look at carefully. How many people who say that they are pro-life would secretly get an abortion? What would drive a protestor at an abortion clinic into the clinic's waiting room? Why do so many people condemn abortion in public but support it in private? And why is abortion so common?

Dr Wicklund is right to raise these questions. They need thinking about. It's easy to dismiss the story of the protestor who sought an abortion of her own. Oh, the abortionist must be lying. No pro-life protestor approached her [i]really[/i]. Abortionists lie. They must do. They're abortionists, what do you expect?

Or we could dismiss the whole book on the grounds that talking about how common abortion is will make it more common. We must keep quiet, not discuss this aspect of it too much. Condemn the book. Condemn the 'work' of the woman who wrote it. But on no account discuss the issues she raises.

We can't afford to do that.[/quote]
While we can't automatically assume everything in the book is a lie, the author's profession certainly casts a shadow on her character.
I do regard the professional abortionist as the worst kind of human being (of course, we can't judge the individual soul, but objectively speaking). This is someone who coldly butchers babies for profit on a constant basis.
We're not discussing some naive person blissfully ignorant of the true nature of abortion here, but a veteran, professional killer.
A lot of the bleeding hearts, I think, tend to be too ready to excuse anyone involved in abortion as not really culpable (after all, only those awful hypocritical evil religious right-wingers can [i]really[/i] do wrong!)

And the one "pro-lifer" getting an abortion I think we can assume is an anomoly rather than the norm. Disturbing, yes, but hardly a death-dealing blow to the whole pro-life enterprise.

However, I'm afraid the culture of death is more widespread than many want to face. We are a society that values comfort and convenience over human life.

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1415803' date='Nov 7 2007, 06:16 PM']Or want one for their grown children?

It happens, and I fear those who condemn abortion most viciously probably have it done by those under there noses more frequently than a random person off the street.[/quote]
This is a slanderous statement utterly without basis.

Yes, there are always some hypocrites out there, but having known those active in the pro-life movement my whole life, I can tell you your statement is absolute nonsense. (Though it was probably made just to get a rise out of people).

Largely baseless accusations of hypocrisy against those who take a moral stand is a favorite tactic of the godless Left. It's similar to the tactic of accusing everyone who opposes the "gay" agenda of being a closet homosexual.
Such ad hominem techniques are used to shift the focus away from the arguments themselves to the character of the one making the argument, and are themselves little more than baseless and cheap insults.

Since you have no idea what you're talking about here, just keep your little pie-hole shut.

Posted

Mmm pie. On a lighter note, how does one perform the action of "warm butchery"?

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1416008' date='Nov 8 2007, 05:15 AM']While we can't automatically assume everything in the book is a lie, the author's profession certainly casts a shadow on her character.
I do regard the professional abortionist as the worst kind of human being (of course, we can't judge the individual soul, but objectively speaking). This is someone who coldly butchers babies for profit on a constant basis.
We're not discussing some naive person blissfully ignorant of the true nature of abortion here, but a veteran, professional killer.
A lot of the bleeding hearts, I think, tend to be too ready to excuse anyone involved in abortion as not really culpable (after all, only those awful hypocritical evil religious right-wingers can [i]really[/i] do wrong!)[/quote]

Abortionists, to put it bluntly, are serial killers. I'm not trying to exonerate people who provide abortions here - they are either perpetrating or collaborating in murder. But many of them genuinely believe that they have the best interests of the woman (and of the baby, horribly enough) at heart. It's clear from the article that Dr Wicklund believes she is doing right by women in trouble. We can't just label her as a profiteer, a parasite on tragedy. And because her desire to help women is sincere (albeit sickeningly skewed) I think we can trust her not to tell outright lies in her book. The pro-life movement could use this book as a manual in how to save lives. Learn more about what drives women to abortion, and work to combat it.

[quote]And the one "pro-lifer" getting an abortion I think we can assume is an anomoly rather than the norm. Disturbing, yes, but hardly a death-dealing blow to the whole pro-life enterprise.[/quote]

I don't believe for a moment that most women in the pro-life community are having secret abortions. But I do believe that it may be disturbingly common amongst people who aren't actively involved in the pro-life movement, but who make a show of being involved in order to maintain a certain social image. Some people are more concerned with escaping the social stigma of abortion than with protecting life - a worrying trend that is evident in the way the subject is dealt with in the press.

Posted

[quote]This is a slanderous statement utterly without basis.[/quote]

Wrong. I have plenty of personal knowledge of this happening. I can't list the details on here but C-mom knows them so don't call me a liar without knowing what I have to say.

[quote]Yes, there are always some hypocrites out there, but having known those active in the pro-life movement my whole life, I can tell you your statement is absolute nonsense.[/quote]
I've been around the pro-life movement for most of my life. By the time I was three I saw more pictures of butchered babies than I'd seen live ones. When I was a baby one of my "family" members (different family than now) was on the cover of Newsweek or 60 minutes or some such nonsence magazine. But I've gotten apart from it because of how I saw people acting. Many people had their hearts in the right place but they went out to protest while their child, grandchild, niece, friend, etc, was being coerced or even forced into an abortion. I don't care what great work you do in the world. It HAS to start at home. I know that there are live children out there because of one protester, I also know this pro-lifer isn't aware of own their children's actions and that there are so many dead because this protester was in jail and wasn't there for them.

[quote](Though it was probably made just to get a rise out of people).[/quote]
Not really, although I don't mind upsetting you.

Posted

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1416334' date='Nov 8 2007, 07:44 PM']Wrong. I have plenty of personal knowledge of this happening. I can't list the details on here but C-mom knows them so don't call me a liar without knowing what I have to say.
I've been around the pro-life movement for most of my life. By the time I was three I saw more pictures of butchered babies than I'd seen live ones. When I was a baby one of my "family" members (different family than now) was on the cover of Newsweek or 60 minutes or some such nonsence magazine. But I've gotten apart from it because of how I saw people acting. Many people had their hearts in the right place but they went out to protest while their child, grandchild, niece, friend, etc, was being coerced or even forced into an abortion. I don't care what great work you do in the world. It HAS to start at home. I know that there are live children out there because of one protester, I also know this pro-lifer isn't aware of own their children's actions and that there are so many dead because this protester was in jail and wasn't there for them.


Not really, although I don't mind upsetting you.[/quote]
I don't think you have anything proving that those active in the pro-life movement coerce people into abortions more than most people. Maybe there are a few hypocrites that have done that, but making this into a blanket accusation about pro-lifers as a whole is baseless and slanderous.

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1416190' date='Nov 8 2007, 01:48 PM']Abortionists, to put it bluntly, are serial killers. I'm not trying to exonerate people who provide abortions here - they are either perpetrating or collaborating in murder. But many of them genuinely believe that they have the best interests of the woman (and of the baby, horribly enough) at heart. It's clear from the article that Dr Wicklund believes she is doing right by women in trouble. We can't just label her as a profiteer, a parasite on tragedy. And because her desire to help women is sincere (albeit sickeningly skewed) I think we can trust her not to tell outright lies in her book. The pro-life movement could use this book as a manual in how to save lives. Learn more about what drives women to abortion, and work to combat it.
I don't believe for a moment that most women in the pro-life community are having secret abortions. But I do believe that it may be disturbingly common amongst people who aren't actively involved in the pro-life movement, but who make a show of being involved in order to maintain a certain social image. Some people are more concerned with escaping the social stigma of abortion than with protecting life - a worrying trend that is evident in the way the subject is dealt with in the press.[/quote]
How do you know this person's sincerity?
Most people don't go out and claim to the world they are motivated by evil and base desires (unless they are pursuing a career as a shock rocker).

While I hate to bring up the old cliche of Hitler again, should we trust that Hitler sincerely was doing what he thought was best for his beloved German people, or even that the holocaust was what was best for the Jews?
Or even if he was sincere in such beliefs, would this sincerity make his actions any less evil?

Should we study the writings and speeches of Hitler or Stalin or other mass-murderers in order to gain truthful insights into reality?

It just seems that in our society we're scared to call evil by it's true name.
It's like people involved in "politically correct" evils such as abortion are always assumed to be well-meaning yet misguided, while only "right-wingers" can be capable of true evil.

Posted

I'm just making the point that not all abortions are done under the "girl who hasn't met jesus" sort of quota. More often its someone who's been convinced that its right for them regardless of their past beliefs. They then begin a secretive journey pain and loss that they brought on themselves all the while thy know someone who's persuading other women to keep their children is "saved" by the pro-life movement.

Now, her statistics are true, although distorted. 1 in 4 childbearing women will experience a terminal pregnancy, in short, a miscarriage. Now a days theses are often taken care of by a D&C which is the abortion procedure, except its done on a dead baby insted of a live one (or in cases of tubal pregnancy the baby is sometimes live but the tube is removed, also.) Statistically those could be counted, misleading, but still true.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1416460' date='Nov 9 2007, 06:18 AM']How do you know this person's sincerity?
Most people don't go out and claim to the world they are motivated by evil and base desires (unless they are pursuing a career as a shock rocker).

While I hate to bring up the old cliche of Hitler again, should we trust that Hitler sincerely was doing what he thought was best for his beloved German people, or even that the holocaust was what was best for the Jews?
Or even if he was sincere in such beliefs, would this sincerity make his actions any less evil?[/quote]

Dr Wicklund writes that she became involved in this 'work' because of a bad experience she had when she underwent an abortion herself. This shows two things: a.) that she believes abortion to be morally acceptable and b.) she wants to stop women who have abortions from suffering from shock, humiliation or bad aftercare. Once again, this doesn't exonerate her. Murder is murder. But there is a difference between thinking, "Oh, I'll become an abortionist because there is a lot of money to be made in that field," and becoming an abortionist because you believe it is in the interests of women's 'reproductive health'. There is no reason to presume that she is motivated by base desires because of this. It's circular logic. Evil has driven her to be an abortionist. She is evil because she is an abortionist. Which?

The parallel between abortionists and the Nazi SS doesn't work. Abortion is murder, but it's not genocide. It is motivated by a very similar mentality, but it's not on the same plane - chiefly because most abortionists don't believe that foeti are human beings or even alive in the full sense of the word. The SS were frighteningly aware of the humanity of their victims, which is why they had to undergo dehumanisation training before being allowed near a concentration camp. (The book [i]Let Me Go[/i] by Helga Sneider has a chilling description of this.) Not all evil is justifiably comparable to Nazism. This doesn't mean that it is any less evil in scope. It means that it is a different manifestation of evil, and has to be approached differently.

[quote]It just seems that in our society we're scared to call evil by it's true name.
It's like people involved in "politically correct" evils such as abortion are always assumed to be well-meaning yet misguided, while only "right-wingers" can be capable of true evil.[/quote]

I don't know why you keep bringing up the question of politics in your replies, because I don't divide sin into political categories. Nobody is trying to condemn one political group and exalt another here.

Posted

i wonder if the 40% number is slightly inflated due to the fact that some people have several over the course of their lives even though many have none at all. if the total number of abortions would cover 40% of the female population, it doesn't mean that 40% is actually having them. i guess though that doesn't really matter. either way, far too many babies are being killed and it makes me sick. much prayer is needed for them! Lord have mercy!

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1416555' date='Nov 9 2007, 11:26 AM']Dr Wicklund writes that she became involved in this 'work' because of a bad experience she had when she underwent an abortion herself. This shows two things: a.) that she believes abortion to be morally acceptable and b.) she wants to stop women who have abortions from suffering from shock, humiliation or bad aftercare. Once again, this doesn't exonerate her. Murder is murder. But there is a difference between thinking, "Oh, I'll become an abortionist because there is a lot of money to be made in that field," and becoming an abortionist because you believe it is in the interests of women's 'reproductive health'. There is no reason to presume that she is motivated by base desires because of this. It's circular logic. Evil has driven her to be an abortionist. She is evil because she is an abortionist. Which?

The parallel between abortionists and the Nazi SS doesn't work. Abortion is murder, but it's not genocide. It is motivated by a very similar mentality, but it's not on the same plane - chiefly because most abortionists don't believe that foeti are human beings or even alive in the full sense of the word. The SS were frighteningly aware of the humanity of their victims, which is why they had to undergo dehumanisation training before being allowed near a concentration camp. (The book [i]Let Me Go[/i] by Helga Sneider has a chilling description of this.) Not all evil is justifiably comparable to Nazism. This doesn't mean that it is any less evil in scope. It means that it is a different manifestation of evil, and has to be approached differently.[/quote]
People can come up with all sorts of rationalizations to defend the most depraved of human actions.
I'm honestly not much impressed from what I've heard recounted of this "doctor's" drivel.

And I simply don't buy that abortionists are ignorant of the fact that they're killing a living human being. They see the bodies every day. The SS would likewise rationalize that the Jews were "subhuman."
Sure abortionists can wilfully deny that they are killing babies, but this is not inculpable ignorance.
And it they're truly so dumb they they don't realize they can't kill what's alive, or so ignorant of basic biology as to think a fetus is not living, they have no business getting an M.D.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1416899' date='Nov 10 2007, 06:05 AM']People can come up with all sorts of rationalizations to defend the most depraved of human actions.
I'm honestly not much impressed from what I've heard recounted of this "doctor's" drivel.

And I simply don't buy that abortionists are ignorant of the fact that they're killing a living human being. They see the bodies every day. The SS would likewise rationalize that the Jews were "subhuman."[/quote]

Firstly, the majority of abortions take place during the first trimester and are usually done chemically. This doesn't make the sin any less grave - it's still murder. But it does mean that there is no visibly human body, and for doctors like Wicklund who go with the viability argument, that is enough proof that the life is only potential and not actual. Pro-life organisations often use pictures of murdered foeti in their awareness raising material, but it's important to realise that most victims of abortion don't look so obviously human. There is also a difference between judging a life to be 'subhuman' and judging a life to be 'potential', even though both judgements are false.

[quote]Sure abortionists can wilfully deny that they are killing babies, but this is not inculpable ignorance.
And it they're truly so dumb they they don't realize they can't kill what's alive, or so ignorant of basic biology as to think a fetus is not living, they have no business getting an M.D.[/quote]

A lot of doctors argue that a foetus is not alive [i]in the human sense[/i]. They have studied to become doctors and they have acquired their qualifications, so it's irrational to accuse them of being ignorant of the basic biology - especially as doctors who support abortion generally go with the viability argument. The best way to bring that down is with philosophy, not biology. The pro-life stance can be proven for sure with a mixture of biological and philosophical arguments, but it's not as simple as you're making out.

It's not enough to attack the medical credentials of doctors who support abortion ("They're too dumb to be real doctors") or to go in for character assassination ("They must be profiteering"). It is detrimental to the pro-life cause to attack the characters and motivations of abortionists, which can rarely be known. It is far better to attack abortion itself, and this is best achieved through demonstrating the full humanity of the foetus.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...