Aloysius Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 [url="http://www.amazon.com/dp/1932528113?&camp=212361&creative=383841&linkCode=wss&tag=lothba-20"]The Party System[/url] by Hilaire Belloc (Author), Cecil Chesterton (Author), Ron Paul (Foreword), Sforza Ruspoli (Preface) [quote]Book Description Pertinent to America, Britain, and other Western democracies, this book explains that what people believe happens in national assemblies and parliaments is radically different from the reality. Instead of being places where debate is intense, passionate, and aimed at the national interest, the fact is most members of these institutions act on behalf of powerful, unelected interests. They know, implicitly, who really runs the country—and their only real task is to decide if they want to try and rock the boat (thereby risking their salary, their reputation, their future), or stay silent for fear or favor. The book demonstrates beyond any doubt that the very nature of the system is hostile to democracy as laypeople understand it.[/quote] This book looks like a MUST READ for any Catholic with an interest in politics.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 Sorry, but I can't take Ron Paul seriously. Libertarianism offers some good things, but he's too extreme from what I've seen. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Aloysius Posted December 13, 2007 Author Posted December 13, 2007 This book is by Hilaire Belloc and Cecil Chesterton. Ron Paul simply wrote a forward.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 Forgive me because I know you're going to think I'm an idiot, but who's Cecil Chesterton?
Aloysius Posted December 13, 2007 Author Posted December 13, 2007 Gilbert's little bro he was also a journalist, served in parliament, and became Catholic just like G.K. the title of the book in the OP is a link to Amazon, btw, they have an about the author section.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1433935' date='Dec 13 2007, 03:17 PM']Gilbert's little bro he was also a journalist, served in parliament, and became Catholic just like G.K. the title of the book in the OP is a link to Amazon, btw, they have an about the author section.[/quote] Cool.
goldenchild17 Posted December 13, 2007 Posted December 13, 2007 I think I'll pick it up. I don't think that Paul is too extreme. I do think that all the other Repub candidates are just far too lax which makes him look bad. Going against the grain sticks out like a sore thumb.
Aloysius Posted December 14, 2007 Author Posted December 14, 2007 so now Hilaire Belloc is a conspiracy nut? honestly, you do realize it's possible to disagree with someone and not think absolutely everything attached to their name is complete trash. are you claiming that the experience of these writers who have participated in parliaments and congresses are nothing more than fringe conspiracy theorists? I do plan to purchase this book, I'll let you know how it is.
Justin86 Posted December 14, 2007 Posted December 14, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1434240' date='Dec 14 2007, 09:42 PM']so now Hilaire Belloc is a conspiracy nut? honestly, you do realize it's possible to disagree with someone and not think absolutely everything attached to their name is complete trash. are you claiming that the experience of these writers who have participated in parliaments and congresses are nothing more than fringe conspiracy theorists? I do plan to purchase this book, I'll let you know how it is.[/quote] Well, anyone who claims there's some sort of secret society who really is in control, is saying there's a conspiracy. I'm not sure why you have your panties in a twist because I put a hat on Belloc. Edited December 14, 2007 by Justin86
Aloysius Posted December 14, 2007 Author Posted December 14, 2007 Where did it say anything about a secret society? It talked about special interest groups being in charge in the summary of the book I posted. Anyone who can't see that that is true is blind. [quote]most members of these institutions act on behalf of powerful, unelected interests.[/quote] that's what made you pull out the tin foil? we're not just talking about the late 20th century American congress, we're also talking about the early 20th century British Parliament, and the writers in the book have experience in both. you do not have experience in either, I think they might be a little less on the fringe of something than you might be.
Justin86 Posted December 14, 2007 Posted December 14, 2007 Where did it say that? [quote]Book Description Pertinent to America, Britain, and other Western democracies, this book explains that what people believe happens in national assemblies and parliaments is radically different from the reality. Instead of being places where debate is intense, passionate, and aimed at the national interest, [b]the fact is most members of these institutions act on behalf of powerful, unelected interests. They know, implicitly, who really runs the country—and their only real task is to decide if they want to try and rock the boat (thereby risking their salary, their reputation, their future), or stay silent for fear or favor.[/b] The book demonstrates beyond any doubt that the very nature of the system is hostile to democracy as laypeople understand it.[/quote]
Justin86 Posted December 14, 2007 Posted December 14, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1434242' date='Dec 14 2007, 10:02 PM']Where did it say anything about a secret society? It talked about special interest groups being in charge in the summary of the book I posted. Anyone who can't see that that is true is blind. that's what made you pull out the tin foil?[/quote] That and this: [quote]They know, implicitly, who really runs the country—and their only real task is to decide if they want to try and rock the boat (thereby risking their salary, their reputation, their future), or stay silent for fear or favor.[/quote] It just sounded kinda weird. If he had said something like special interests groups, or foreign lobbyists, I wouldn't have batted an eye.
Aloysius Posted December 14, 2007 Author Posted December 14, 2007 .... and? powerful unelected [b]interests[/b] exert a great amount of influence and pressure in Washington as they did in early twentieth century British Parliament.
Justin86 Posted December 14, 2007 Posted December 14, 2007 I'm still not sure if he's really saying what you're saying, but if he is he sure could have worded it better. I mean, "they know, implicity, who runs the country" sounds like something right from the mouth of a conspiracy nut. Again, if he said "special interest groups", or "foreign lobbyists" and left it at that I wouldn't have batted an eye, but going on like that is just makes him look crazy.
Aloysius Posted December 14, 2007 Author Posted December 14, 2007 It's Hilaire Belloc, one of the most respected Catholic historians of the 20th century, who had actual experience in the British Parliament. He's talking about something which is dangerous to all western democracies... so unless he uses the word "illuminati" it's not exactly indicating some secret society. in any event, you seem to simply have a ridiculous aversion to any such idea. Now, I think any unevidenced claim of conspiratorial societies running the country is ridiculous. but instead of lambasting it for being unevidenced, you lambast it for merely indicating the possibility that parliaments and congresses are ineffective against "powerful interests". your polemics hinder your logic so much, that it seems that if a claim of a secret society running the country came out and it was [i]evidenced[/i], you'd have the same reaction as you do to unevidenced conspiracy theories. it's illogical. you don't dismiss ideas out of hand for no reason, you dismiss them if they're unevidenced. this particular book seems to be from the perspective of someone who has experience in parliament (not some conspiracy nut) and be about something which generally affects all western democracies, ie a systematic flaw (hence the title: The Party System) I really think it was the name Ron Paul that made you PARANOID that there would be a conspiracy theory. haha ironic, huh.
Innocent Posted December 14, 2007 Posted December 14, 2007 (edited) Those who, (like me) are unable to find this book in the neighbourhood bookstore can download or read online (for free, of course) the scanned and digitised version of the book from the Internet Arvhive. [url="http://www.archive.org/details/partysystem00belluoft"][color="red"][b]HERE[/b][/color][/url] is the link. Edited December 14, 2007 by Innocent
Justin86 Posted December 14, 2007 Posted December 14, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1434248' date='Dec 14 2007, 10:32 PM']It's Hilaire Belloc, one of the most respected Catholic historians of the 20th century, who had actual experience in the British Parliament. He's talking about something which is dangerous to all western democracies... so unless he uses the word "illuminati" it's not exactly indicating some secret society.[/quote] I have no idea what exactly an "unelected interest group" is. First time I've ever heard the phrase. Oh, and are we talking about Belloc or Ron Paul? I was under the impression Paul was the one who wrote the article I was quoting so where'd Belloc come from again? [quote]in any event, you seem to simply have a ridiculous aversion to any such idea.[/quote] Um, not really. Everybody knows there are lobbyists running around in Washington. Never heard of "unelected interests groups" whom the politicians know really run the country though. Now if Ron Paul [i]meant[/i] lobbyists that's one thing, but why not use words we all know instead of coming up with your own vocabulary that can be easily be that of a conspiracy nut? I'm just trying to say Paul's language is confusing, and doesn't really say one way or another about secret societies. That being said I'm also not necessarily accusing Paul of believing that secret societies run America, but it could definitely be construed from what he wrote in this forward. That's all I'm saying. Please stop putting words in my mouth. [quote]Now, I think any evidenced claim of conspiratorial societies running the country is ridiculous. but instead of lambasting it for being evidenced, you lambast it for merely indicating the possibility that parliaments and congresses are ineffective against "powerful interests". your polemics hinder your logic so much, that it seems that if a claim of a secret society running the country came out and it was [i]evidenced[/i], you'd have the same reaction as you do to unevidenced conspiracy theories.[/quote] Absolutely not true. If I was presented hard, actual evidence that George Soros, Halliburton, Big-Oil, Justin Timberlake, or whoever the wackos are claiming is running the country this week than I would believe it. [quote]it's illogical. you don't dismiss ideas out of hand for no reason, you dismiss them if they're unevidenced. this particular book seems to be from the perspective of someone who has experience in parliament...[/quote] Sometimes all that makes you is the voice of one crying out in the desert--only this time there's a perfectly good reason for why no one else is with you. That's Ron Paul. At least on foreign policy anyway, IMO. I have never once accused Ron Paul of being involved in a conspiracy as I have no evidence for that so I'm not sure why you think I'm paranoid about Paul. I don't really trust the man as I disdain all politicians, and I do believe all the hype over him balancing the budget is rather laughable considering he changes his tune on government spending when he's running for president, but that's really no reason to single him out for hatred or suspicion. It's Washington, baby. Everybody is the scum of the earth.
Aloysius Posted December 14, 2007 Author Posted December 14, 2007 The book is authored by Hilaire Belloc and Cecil Chesterton. The summary of the book is provided courtesy of Amazon.com, probably written by some random Amazon.com reader for all I know. There's a link in the OP. Paul wrote a foreward for the book. What do you mean no-one's with me because of Ron Paul? This has like, 2% to do with Ron Paul, all Ron Paul has to do with it is that he seems to agree with Hilaire Belloc here and have a perspective pertinent to more modern times. You're being absolutely obtuse. You heard the name Ron Paul and went absolutely bananas. Look at the picture on the cover of the book, for God's sake, it's a bunch of people wining and dining a politician. "special interests groups" are unelected, right? So what's the difference between that and "unelected interests". Again, this has little to nothing to do with Ron Paul and his campaign for president. It's a foreward he wrote for a book critiquing the system in place in western democracies before he even announced his candidacy. Anyway, saying he changed his tune to run for president is also ridiculous; his few "pork" things (which he saw as giving tax dollars BACK to people who they had been taken from) had nothing to do with his presidential campaign and everything to do with his district. but again, this is not about Paul's presidential campaign, and everything about the systematic problems in western democracies as viewed by Hilaire Belloc and Cecil Chesterton. sheesh.
Aloysius Posted December 14, 2007 Author Posted December 14, 2007 [quote name='Innocent' post='1434249' date='Dec 14 2007, 08:55 AM']Those who, (like me) are unable to find this book in the neighbourhood bookstore can download or read online (for free, of course) the scanned and digitised version of the book from the Internet Arvhive. [url="http://www.archive.org/details/partysystem00belluoft"][color="red"][b]HERE[/b][/color][/url] is the link.[/quote] sweet. this isn't the IHS Press version with Ron Paul's foreward, so Justin can shed all his fears about Ron Paul if he wishes to read it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now