Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1434259' date='Dec 14 2007, 11:49 PM']The book is authored by Hilaire Belloc and Cecil Chesterton. The summary of the book is provided courtesy of Amazon.com, probably written by some random Amazon.com reader for all I know.[/quote]
Ok then. My misunderstanding.

[quote]What do you mean no-one's with me because of Ron Paul?[/quote]
I said no one was with Ron Paul, meaning no one in Congress.

[quote]You heard the name Ron Paul and went absolutely bananas.[/quote]
It seems to me that your the one who goes absolutely bananas everytime I disagree with Ron Paul. I have no idea why. I'm not the one calling his opponent names like "obtuse" and "paranoid" so I fail to see how I'm the emotional one either.

[quote]Look at the picture on the cover of the book, for God's sake, it's a bunch of people wining and dining a politician. "special interests groups" are unelected, right? So what's the difference between that and "unelected interests".[/quote]
Apparently none? :unsure:

[quote]Again, this has little to nothing to do with Ron Paul and his campaign for president. It's a foreward he wrote for a book critiquing the system in place in western democracies before he even announced his candidacy.[/quote]
Oh come now, by the time I got to this thread it had already well established itself as a Ron Paul thread with some mention of Belloc and Chesterson's little brother tossed in. Paul was mentioned in just about every single post, am I right?

[quote]Anyway, saying he changed his tune to run for president is also ridiculous; his few "pork" things (which he saw as giving tax dollars BACK to people who they had been taken from) had nothing to do with his presidential campaign and everything to do with his district. but again, this is not about Paul's presidential campaign, and everything about the systematic problems in western democracies as viewed by Hilaire Belloc and Cecil Chesterton. sheesh.[/quote]
Um, Paul's stance on government spending wasn't "giving tax dollars back to the people" before, so why did it suddenly change? Think maybe it was because he was about to run for president and needed alot more money for a campaign? No, it couldn't be, it's Ron Paul! He's above all that! :rolleyes:

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1434260' date='Dec 14 2007, 11:51 PM']sweet.

this isn't the IHS Press version with Ron Paul's foreward, so Justin can shed all his fears about Ron Paul if he wishes to read it.[/quote]
:rolleyes: I fear reading Ron Paul like a fear a turkey eating me for Thanksgiving dinner. This never was about that, Aloysius.

Posted

yeah, it really couldn't be, because his donations don't even come from those people... they come from the ridiculous army of online supporters. take that 24 hr period where he got 5 million: all organized online, most donaters donated about $100 a piece. it has nothing to do with his presidential run ;)

and no, you're the one that made this into a thread about Ron Paul. I made the thread about the book and mentioned that Ron Paul wrote a forward, the ONLY Ron Paul issue pertinent to this thread is Ron Paul's support for the ideas presented in this book.

it's a thread about a book with a side mention of Ron Paul. and even that mention is not about his presidential campaign, more about his career in congress and his understanding of the systematic problem in our democracy.

anyway, I stand by my idea that you've gone bananas, you came in with the first emotionally charged cheap-shot, calling for tin foil hats. My response is not emotional, it's objective: you're being obtuse.

Posted

and you're still name-calling.

Btw, Ron Paul still changed his tune on government spending to try to get votes and money. Pity its not working for him. Guess their sick of him anyway.

Posted

Oh, and we have so many Ron Paul threads its ridiculous. If Al wants to make every other post of his about Ron Paul I say its high time we have one thread devoted to the subject. This is getting to the point of spam.

Posted

You don't have a lick of evidence that that's remotely a plausible strategy. There is no indication that 1) that would've worked 2) that any politician ever would've thought something like that would work.

politicians pork-barrel to make the constituents of their district happy, when running for larger offices EVERYONE knows that's the time to hide any porkbarrelling you've ever done and button down the hatches, because you're trying to please the whole country now.

Anyone with one poly-sci class would know that you're proposition is total and complete bunk. every political expert on the planet would recognize that, which is why I've seen no one else arguing that. They said he broke his principals, they disagreed with him for doing it, but no one had the political ignorance to suggest that he did it because he thought it'd help his presidential campaign.

"you are being obtuse" remains accurate. it is not ad hominem, it is ad argumentum, because I am referring to the argument you are making, ie this argument you are making is obtuse.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1434270' date='Dec 14 2007, 10:40 AM']Oh, and we have so many Ron Paul threads its ridiculous. If Al wants to make every other post of his about Ron Paul I say its high time we have one thread devoted to the subject. This is getting to the point of spam.[/quote]
This thread is about a book by Hilaire Belloc. Until you came, you can see I attempted to keep the focus on that. Notice Raph responded about Paul, I said no, this is about "The Party System by Hilaire Belloc and Cecil Chesterton". It was you that turned this into a discussion regarding Paul's presidential campaign.

I've made 3 or 4 Ron Paul Threads (and they have all been on different topics which all deserved different threads), and I am a long-time member of this forum and a regulator and have every right to offer some topics for discussion that I think are pertinent for the Catholic community.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1434274' date='Dec 15 2007, 12:49 AM']This thread is about a book by Hilaire Belloc. Until you came, you can see I attempted to keep the focus on that. Notice Raph responded about Paul, I said no, this is about "The Party System by Hilaire Belloc and Cecil Chesterton". It was you that turned this into a discussion regarding Paul's presidential campaign.[/quote]
Oh please, there is no other reason you mentioned Paul except for political campaigning. You put his name up with the authors in the thread title for crying out loud, of course you were campaigning for him!

There's absolutely nothing wrong with campaigning for your guy Al, but when people start debating you don't go bananas with, "The thread is not about his candidacy" line. You look ridiculous.

[quote]I've made 3 or 4 Ron Paul Threads (and they have all been on different topics which all deserved different threads)[/quote]
Is that it? We have so many Ron Paul threads its preposterous, and difficult to keep track of them all. It would be simpler if they were consolidated. I'm not sure why you're so against the idea. Alot of message boards limit there Paul topics to one thread precisely for this reason, it has nothing to do with me being for or against Ron Paul.

[quote]and I am a long-time member of this forum and a regulator and have every right to offer some topics for discussion that I think are pertinent for the Catholic community.[/quote]
Sure you do, but why do you need all the different threads to do it? Limit it to one and we can have all sort of wonderful discussions in one convenient place.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...