Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

in reading the pope's encyclical on hope, (i'm not very far into it) on number 3, he talks about St. Josephine Bakhita, "the hope born in her which had 'redeemed' her she could not keep to herself; this hope had to reach many, to reach everybody." this is the same hope that drove the apostles to convert thousands, and our hope should inspire us to reach out to all with our hope, to evangelize others.

since every Catholic receives this hope when they are baptized, how come we do not have that same kind of passion, that same driving need to share this hope with others? and i'm not talking about the general Catholic population, who are very under-catechized, but those who know their faith and love it.

Posted

Grace gives us the ability to act, but we still have to choose to act.

In what way do you think Catholics don't share their hope?

Posted

i guess i'm talking about evangelization

Posted (edited)

This advent season I've started writing a weekly 'letter' to the Catholic side of my family. My extended family are all Catholic, and I would say good Catholics; but not really devoted 110% to the faith, or at least you wouldn't know it because no one talks about it (kinda what you are asking Lil Red, no one is spreading the Hope). After the first letter went out I was having dinner with my grandfather later that week and he said that faith is just not something we talk about. He gave a bunch of reasons why, the way he was raised, ect. But I think that like my grandfather, the average good Catholic, and even the devout ones, are scared to spread the Hope that is our Christian faith. We're scared we'll offend others, or we might be a 'Jesus Freak', or people might think we're judging. He said that his faith was only a private thing (compare that to the section called "Is Christian Hope Individualistic").

Anyways, thats my little rant. I'm not sure why people aren't spreading the hope like the Pope talks about, but its lame. And it needs to change with us; thus my letters :)

Edited by rkwright
Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1436326' date='Dec 19 2007, 06:31 PM'](compare that to the section called "Is Christian Hope Individualistic").[/quote]
like i said, i'm not very far :)

Posted

you'll get to it soon! no worries!

Its a good one. I'm always amazed at how much the Pope talks about politics. He goes into great depth about the politics and advancements of the 18th and 19th century.

I have a Mac and it has a speech to text thingy (maybe my PC does too) and I highlighted the whole document and had the computer 'read' it to me while I followed along. Its cool if you can stand the computer voice and I finished in about 1 1/2 hours.

Posted

I think Catholics do evangelize, but I think the emphasis on evangelization for Catholics is in their day to day life, being a witness in their behavior and forming relationships with other people. This usually leads to opportunities to share the faith more explicitly, without making others feel pressured.

I think we have to be careful about pushing the faith on people when they are not ready, because it can turn them away from the faith, especially if they feel like they're just a target for conversion. We can make it seem like we're robots with a pre-recorded message.

Posted

I agree with your point Era, but I think for many Catholics this might be more of an excuse just to go on day to day living. If most Catholics feel that they're basically good people, then they can just go on living their lives and hope that it spreads the message.

Posted

I don't think a lot of Catholics know [i]how[/i] to evangelize. I too try to evangelize in my daily life and I have been able to reach others this way, but, yes, it does take intentional effort. Just being a "good guy" isn't always effective.

Posted

I know very many Catholics that love to spread their faith and hope. In fact, I would have said that the desire to spread hope is pathognomonic for faith in Christ.

Posted

[quote name='Daniel9' post='1436386' date='Dec 20 2007, 12:00 AM']I don't think a lot of Catholics know [i]how[/i] to evangelize. I too try to evangelize in my daily life and I have been able to reach others this way, but, yes, it does take intentional effort. Just being a "good guy" isn't always effective.[/quote]

This is the key issue I believe.

We have not been properly catechized in this regard. The Church has fallen into a "maintenance model" (where the focus is on maintaining congregations and obviously doesn't work) but is now slowly turning back into "mission model", where we look always outwards to evangelization and sharing the Good News.

The biggest problem is that most (even very holy and good) Catholics do not know how explain their faith to others in a way that is SIMPLE and easy to understand.

If I asked 10 Catholics who go to Church regularly to share the Gospel with me, I doubt any could do it effectively.


Fortunately it's my mission in life to teach'em!

Posted

hahaha tgoldson...

THE BISHOP!

Posted

[quote name='tgoldson' post='1436431' date='Dec 20 2007, 08:26 AM']I know very many Catholics that love to spread their faith and hope. In fact, I would have said that the desire to spread hope is pathognomonic for faith in Christ.[/quote]

I don't think that's the word you were looking for. I wouldn't consider Catholicism to be a disease.


Sometimes I think the greatest need to evangelize Catholicism is to Catholics.

Posted

"Sometimes I think the greatest need to evangelize Catholicism is to Catholics."

YES!

[url="http://www.cco.ca"]Catholic Christian Outreach[/url]

Look for us on a University Campus near you.

.... If you live in Canada.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1436170' date='Dec 19 2007, 02:59 PM']in reading the pope's encyclical on hope, (i'm not very far into it) on number 3, he talks about St. Josephine Bakhita, "the hope born in her which had 'redeemed' her she could not keep to herself; this hope had to reach many, to reach everybody." this is the same hope that drove the apostles to convert thousands, and our hope should inspire us to reach out to all with our hope, to evangelize others.

since every Catholic receives this hope when they are baptized, how come we do not have that same kind of passion, that same driving need to share this hope with others? and i'm not talking about the general Catholic population, who are very under-catechized, but those who know their faith and love it.[/quote]

This is exactly what i was thinking when i read that section!

Evangelizing=spreading hope... we need to desire that everybody have the Reason for our Hope--Jesus Christ, our Liberation, Peace, Joy!

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1436336' date='Dec 19 2007, 06:51 PM']I think Catholics do evangelize, but I think the emphasis on evangelization for Catholics is in their day to day life, being a witness in their behavior and forming relationships with other people. This usually leads to opportunities to share the faith more explicitly, without making others feel pressured.

I think we have to be careful about pushing the faith on people when they are not ready, because it can turn them away from the faith, especially if they feel like they're just a target for conversion. We can make it seem like we're robots with a pre-recorded message.[/quote]see next response.


[quote name='rkwright' post='1436341' date='Dec 19 2007, 06:57 PM']I agree with your point Era, but I think for many Catholics this might be more of an excuse just to go on day to day living. If most Catholics feel that they're basically good people, then they can just go on living their lives and hope that it spreads the message.[/quote]exactly! and honestly, would the disciples have used the same excuse to not actively spread the message of hope to all they knew? or st. josephine bakhita? or any of the saints? i realize that there is a difference in how to spread the hope that we have, but it just seems like there aren't many people out there that actively spread the Good News.
[quote name='tgoldson' post='1436431' date='Dec 20 2007, 06:26 AM']I know very many Catholics that love to spread their faith and hope. In fact, I would have said that the desire to spread hope is [color="#FF0000"]pathognomonic[/color] for faith in Christ.[/quote]umm, :unsure: use smaller words. i'm not very smart.
[quote name='Seven77' post='1436490' date='Dec 20 2007, 10:04 AM']This is exactly what i was thinking when i read that section!

Evangelizing=spreading hope... we need to desire that everybody have the Reason for our Hope--Jesus Christ, our Liberation, Peace, Joy![/quote]i'm glad i wasn't the only one!

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1436515' date='Dec 20 2007, 12:49 PM']exactly! and honestly, would the disciples have used the same excuse to not actively spread the message of hope to all they knew? or st. josephine bakhita? or any of the saints? i realize that there is a difference in how to spread the hope that we have, but it just seems like there aren't many people out there that actively spread the Good News.[/quote]
What do you mean by actively spreading the Good News? Thousands of people come into the Church every year, so we have to be doing something right.

Posted
:idontknow: i dunno, maybe i'm speaking more of my experience here in my city.

yes, we have many people coming into the local Church every year. but especially in my parish, most of them are poorly catechized, so do they even know the hope they are receiving? i doubt it. and i would say that the only reason one of the local evangelical churches is still open is because it's full of fallen away Catholics.
Posted

But I think that's a different issue. I agree that we have to, as dUSt would say, convert Catholics to Catholicism. But I think Catholics who do know and live their faith share it, in a uniquely Catholic way. I don't think we should try to imitate Jehovah's Witnesses just to be more "active." As in the Liturgy, being "active" does not always mean doing something external. There isn't one uniform way to evangelize, but I think in general, the best way to evangelize is in our lives, with people we know. If someone hands out tracts to everyone at work, for example, is that evangelization? Technically yes, but how many of those people would convert? Probably none (and I'm not saying tracts should never be used). But if you form friendships at work, and let your faith shine through your life, and through your speech when God provides opportunities, then I think that is an effective evangelization, because the faith is not an abstraction. It does not exist apart from people who live it. I'm not saying it is never beneficial to present the faith to people who we don't have a relationship with. There are definitely times for that, but I don't think that should be the primary model. The Apostles were in a unique situation, when the faith was largely unknown. They had to make the basics known, but today most people in our society know *about* the faith even if they don't know it deeply. What they need is witnesses of its power in real life. If we tell someone that they have a mediator in Heaven, what does that mean to them? Most people aren't ready for that, but when they see the power of the Son of God in our lives, then they will want to know about him. But of course, for that to work we have to be living our faith fully, and not be scared to live it in front of other people.

Again, I'm not disregarding the need for explicit verbal witness along with our "pre-evangelization" as Pope Paul VI called it. But when we evangelize, we are basically dealing with the deepest question in life. If you go up to a stranger and start talking to them about what they should do for a living, they may not take you seriously because that's such a personal matter. How much more so when a stranger is telling them how to save their souls? We have to prepare them to to deal with the most important question in life: their relationship with God. And I think Catholics are very good at planting seeds, and watering them when the time is right.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...