God Conquers Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 I'm gonna quote Francis Cardinal Arinze at this juncture: "Provided that it is done with full respect for their human dignity and freedom," Arinze -- himself an adolescent convert -- said that "if a Christian did not try to spread the Gospel by sharing the excelling knowledge of Jesus Christ with others, we could suspect that Christian either of lack of total conviction on the faith, or of selfishness and laziness in not wanting to share the full and abundant means of salvation with his fellow human beings." Share the knowledge. Can't be done just with actions. That's why one of my least favorite "quotes" which isn't even historically true is the one that everyone always says St. Francis said: "Preach the Gospel always, when necessary use words." It's ALWAYS NECESSARY to use words. Biggest problem for most Catholics isn't that they don't want to, its that they don't know how.
Era Might Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 We will have to disagree. It is not always necessary to use words, and actually, I think it is sometimes a hindrance to the Gospel when we use words. Some people are ready to hear the deeper contents of the faith, and we should be prepared for that, but more often in our society I don't believe this is the case. My family, for example, is not ready for that. When I first converted, I tried to force conversations with them about the faith because I felt like otherwise I was failing to evangelize, but I've learned that the only thing that is going to convert them is the witness of my life and God's grace. [quote][The Church] carries out this first proclamation of Jesus Christ by a complex and diversified activity which is sometimes termed "pre-evangelization" but which is already evangelization in a true sense, although at its initial and still incomplete stage. An almost indefinite range of means can be used for this purpose: explicit preaching, of course, but also art, the scientific approach, philosophical research and legitimate recourse to the sentiments of the human heart. This first proclamation is addressed especially to those who have never heard the Good News of Jesus, or to children. But, as a result of the frequent situations of dechristianization in our day, it also proves equally necessary for innumerable people who have been baptized but who live quite outside Christian life, for simple people who have a certain faith but an imperfect knowledge of the foundations of that faith, for intellectuals who feel the need to know Jesus Christ in a light different from the instruction they received as children, and for many others. --Pope Paul VI, "Evangelii Nuntiandi"[/quote]
Lil Red Posted December 20, 2007 Author Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1436540' date='Dec 20 2007, 11:38 AM']But I think that's a different issue. I agree that we have to, as dUSt would say, convert Catholics to Catholicism. But I think Catholics who do know and live their faith share it, in a uniquely Catholic way. I don't think we should try to imitate Jehovah's Witnesses just to be more "active." As in the Liturgy, being "active" does not always mean doing something external. There isn't one uniform way to evangelize, but I think in general, the best way to evangelize is in our lives, with people we know. If someone hands out tracts to everyone at work, for example, is that evangelization? Technically yes, but how many of those people would convert? Probably none (and I'm not saying tracts should never be used). But if you form friendships at work, and let your faith shine through your life, and through your speech when God provides opportunities, then I think that is an effective evangelization, because the faith is not an abstraction. It does not exist apart from people who live it. I'm not saying it is never beneficial to present the faith to people who we don't have a relationship with. There are definitely times for that, but I don't think that should be the primary model. The Apostles were in a unique situation, when the faith was largely unknown. They had to make the basics known, but today most people in our society know *about* the faith even if they don't know it deeply. What they need is witnesses of its power in real life. If we tell someone that they have a mediator in Heaven, what does that mean to them? Most people aren't ready for that, but when they see the power of the Son of God in our lives, then they will want to know about him. But of course, for that to work we have to be living our faith fully, and not be scared to live it in front of other people. Again, I'm not disregarding the need for explicit verbal witness along with our "pre-evangelization" as Pope Paul VI called it. But when we evangelize, we are basically dealing with the deepest question in life. If you go up to a stranger and start talking to them about what they should do for a living, they may not take you seriously because that's such a personal matter. How much more so when a stranger is telling them how to save their souls? We have to prepare them to to deal with the most important question in life: their relationship with God. And I think Catholics are very good at planting seeds, and watering them when the time is right.[/quote] i guess i go back to the example of the disciples, though. these men didn't just convert people by their example, they preached to them. they told them of the Good News. and they preached in such an effective way that thousands were converted. [quote name='Era Might' post='1436540' date='Dec 20 2007, 11:38 AM']But I think that's a different issue. I agree that we have to, as dUSt would say, convert Catholics to Catholicism. But I think Catholics who do know and live their faith share it, in a uniquely Catholic way. I don't think we should try to imitate Jehovah's Witnesses just to be more "active." As in the Liturgy, being "active" does not always mean doing something external. There isn't one uniform way to evangelize, but I think in general, the best way to evangelize is in our lives, with people we know.[/quote] but if all everyone is doing is assuming that they will convert people by their example, and not talking about their faith with others, does that really evangelize anyone?
Era Might Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1436572' date='Dec 20 2007, 02:21 PM']i guess i go back to the example of the disciples, though. these men didn't just convert people by their example, they preached to them. they told them of the Good News. and they preached in such an effective way that thousands were converted.[/quote] There were a lot of things different about the early Church. For example, our Liturgies today are very different than then. Not only does the world around us change, but the methods of the Church develop. The essential spirit of what the Apostles did is always valid. Our Lord gave us the command to take the Gospel to the ends of the earth. But we can't artificially impose their methods today, just as we can't impose their Liturgies today. [quote]but if all everyone is doing is assuming that they will convert people by their example, and not talking about their faith with others, does that really evangelize anyone?[/quote] It's not a matter of word vs. deed. We should always be prepared to explain our faith, and should look for opportunities to do so. But I don't believe we should try to force a message on people before they are ready. I know a someone who turns everything into a discussion about the Gospel. I don't believe that is effective. People may be receiving the "information" of the Gospel, but I believe that turns them away from it. We should live our faith fully and in public, but not pressure people to join us. That doesn't mean we shouldn't explain the faith when we have an opportunity, but that we shouldn't try to force people to deal with the most important question in life when they are not ready. It's like an employee walking around a store asking if you need help, telling you about what is on clearance, pointing things out to you, and you want to be left alone. It's not just about the information, it's about giving it when they are ready and when the time is right.
Lil Red Posted December 20, 2007 Author Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1436581' date='Dec 20 2007, 12:42 PM']There were a lot of things different about the early Church. For example, our Liturgies today are very different than then. Not only does the world around us change, but the methods of the Church develop.[/quote]agreed [quote name='Era Might' post='1436581' date='Dec 20 2007, 12:42 PM']The essential spirit of what the Apostles did is always valid. Our Lord gave us the command to take the Gospel to the ends of the earth. But we can't artificially impose their methods today, just as we can't impose their Liturgies today.[/quote]i guess i don't agree on this point, but need to formulate a response. right now it's jumbled. [quote name='Era Might' post='1436581' date='Dec 20 2007, 12:42 PM']It's not a matter of word vs. deed. We should always be prepared to explain our faith, and should look for opportunities to do so. But I don't believe we should try to force a message on people before they are ready. I know a someone who turns everything into a discussion about the Gospel. I don't believe that is effective. People may be receiving the "information" of the Gospel, but I believe that turns them away from it. We should live our faith fully and in public, but not pressure people to join us. That doesn't mean we shouldn't explain the faith when we have an opportunity, but that we shouldn't try to force people to deal with the most important question in life when they are not ready. It's like an employee walking around a store asking if you need help, telling you about what is on clearance, pointing things out to you, and you want to be left alone. It's not just about the information, it's about giving it when they are ready and when the time is right.[/quote]but shouldn't we exert (not sure if that's the word i want) at least a gentle pressure? if all people know of us is that we are "good people", and our "good actions" but never inquire further as to what drives us to be "good people", then how is that evangelization?
Era Might Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1436594' date='Dec 20 2007, 02:54 PM']but shouldn't we exert (not sure if that's the word i want) at least a gentle pressure? if all people know of us is that we are "good people", and our "good actions" but never inquire further as to what drives us to be "good people", then how is that evangelization?[/quote] It depends on the situation and on the person. I don't mean to suggest that there is a manual for evangelization. Each person has to exercise wisdom and prudence, and act as they see best. But I think the major point I'm making is that we shouldn't try to imitate the methods of non-Catholics just because they seem more "active," or try to artificially impose methods of the past today.
God Conquers Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 Certainly not. At issue is not whether prudence and wisdom need to exercised in the work of evangelization, but what the current situation is in the Church with regards to "sharing our hope". Red's question was whether we, as Catholics, are doing enough. Most would respond negatively, looking at the average church-going Catholic. I think most Catholics give phenomenal witness of life, and I agree that this "pre-evangelization" is a necessity. We get nowhere with people, and act against charity when we do not offer ourselves in relationship with others before we offer Jesus Christ. However, it is true that, [i]at some point[/i] in every relationship, there must arise a concrete opportunity to, in words explain the reason for our hope. And this is where we fall short I believe.
prose Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1436572' date='Dec 20 2007, 01:21 PM']i guess i go back to the example of the disciples, though. these men didn't just convert people by their example, they preached to them. they told them of the Good News. and they preached in such an effective way that thousands were converted. but if all everyone is doing is assuming that they will convert people by their example, and not talking about their faith with others, does that really evangelize anyone?[/quote] Was it their preaching that converted thousands? Or the Holy Spirit? Or Both? Priests preach at every Mass, and some are excellent preachers with tonnes of zeal, and yet thousands aren't converted. It was more than the words acting at the time, I would say. I would guess that they could have said very little, and that the blessings from their holy lives were so evident, that the few things they did say, or ahd to say, were what converted thousands. I tell people about my faith, but I definitely think it is more important to live my faith. If people can look at me and see that I have integrity (my actions match my words), then I am evangelizing. If they do not know my faith, there is certainly an element lacking, but I don't feel as though I need to continually remind them that I am Catholic. So I would say, yes, assuming one can convert people by example is reasonable. Can they do so without saying ANYTHING about their faith? No. Can they without continually talking about their faith, yes.
Era Might Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='God Conquers' post='1436671' date='Dec 20 2007, 04:37 PM']Red's question was whether we, as Catholics, are doing enough. Most would respond negatively, looking at the average church-going Catholic.[/quote] That is a separate matter. That is is an issue of catechesis. Lil Red was "not talking about the general Catholic population, who are very under-catechized, but those who know their faith and love it." I believe that those who know their faith and love it do share their hope, but not in the model that is popularly associated with evangelization (preaching in the street and door-to-door). In general, I don't believe those are effective methods today (and I say in general, because I'm not saying they are never an option). [quote]However, it is true that, [i]at some point[/i] in every relationship, there must arise a concrete opportunity to, in words explain the reason for our hope. And this is where we fall short I believe.[/quote] I believe Catholics who "know their faith and love it" do explain their faith in words, when they have the opportunity. But they don't try to force that opportunity. In my experience, when people see you practicing your faith, they want to know WHY you practice your faith. That is always a great opportunity, even if it's a small explanation. I disagree that every relationship we have must lead to an explicit discussion of our faith. It depends on the situation. Some sow the seed and others water. But we should never HIDE our faith. It should be on display so others may see our good works, and give praise to our Heavenly Father. We have to live our faith fully.
God Conquers Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 Thousands converted because of BOTH the Holy Spirit and the preaching of the apostles. I think the key to the apostle's success, and what is sorely lacking today, is the type of preaching and what they were preaching. On most Sundays I hear sermons ranging on many topics, some which come close to talking about our faith, some which range far away. St. Paul's preaching and attitude need to become normal for every catholic. Attitude: Philippians 1:18 All that matters is that Jesus be proclaimed. This is what brings me joy. Preaching: 1 Cor 1:23, 2 Cor 2:12, 2 Cor 4:5, Eph 3:8- Who Jesus Christ is and how to live in relationship with Him.
Era Might Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='prose' post='1436683' date='Dec 20 2007, 04:47 PM']So I would say, yes, assuming one can convert people by example is reasonable. Can they do so without saying ANYTHING about their faith? No. Can they without continually talking about their faith, yes.[/quote] This is an excellent summary of what I was trying to say.
God Conquers Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 Interesting... I don't disagree with you about the planting/watering analogy, but I was speaking from the perspective of the person being evangelized... what if nobody ever waters? I've encountered many Catholics who don't know how to explain their faith, and consequently don't look at those opportunities.
Era Might Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 I think that's a legitimate point, that maybe Catholics need to look for opportunities more (and be formed better to respond to those opportunities). We are always in need of renewal. But I think we have to keep the emphasis on being witnesses in daily life, and I think Catholics have that right focus. Some people are called to be formal missionaries, some people to be Priests, some people to be monks and nuns. But for most lay Catholics, I think St. Therese's "little way" is good to keep in mind. They don't need to convert the world, they can be witnesses to the people in their lives.
Lil Red Posted December 20, 2007 Author Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1436771' date='Dec 20 2007, 03:36 PM']But for most lay Catholics, I think St. Therese's "little way" is good to keep in mind. They don't need to convert the world, they can be witnesses to the people in their lives.[/quote] i guess i don't see it as enough. to me, in a way, it's a cop out. "i'm a good person, and people can see that i live my faith so i see no need to talk to them about my faith" and i say this knowing full well that i fall short of doing my part to spread the hope. and i'm not saying that people have to inject God/Catholicism into every conversation with someone. but if you never tell them about the reason for your hope, what good is that?
Era Might Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1436776' date='Dec 20 2007, 05:41 PM']i guess i don't see it as enough. to me, in a way, it's a cop out. "i'm a good person, and people can see that i live my faith so i see no need to talk to them about my faith"[/quote] I agree that we have to talk about our faith. I disagree that Catholics don't do that. They do it when opportunities present themselves in daily life. You don't have to go door-to-door to evangelize. Someone may feel called to do that, but that does not have to be the general model.
rkwright Posted December 20, 2007 Posted December 20, 2007 I think there are two different groups of people we're talking about here. The first are the non-Catholics, possibly even non-Christians. Often these people are not won over with words or arguments, but witnessing some action or event. To walk up to a stranger and start preaching is probably not the best, and honestly might even turn them off to the faith. To go about your daily life and someone see something that you do out of the ordinary, maybe its praying before you take a test, maybe its just a positive attitude towards life, these might spark questions and you can go from there. The second group are what I will call 'close Catholics'. These might be family members, both extended and immediate. These people have the basics but are probably poorly educated. But they don't see your good works so much as evidence of your faith as just who you are. My family would say, thats just how I am, not his faith has changed his life. To these people words might be necessary (I hate using the word necessary here... but I'm going to). Someone needs to be teaching the average Catholic true devotion, and more than just once a Sunday. I can't tell you how many times I grew up going to mass, hearing the Homily, and then never discussing it again. We should be. Everyone was a good Catholic, but no one was a devout Catholic; and thats what we all need to be. So I think words work very well to make people better Catholics; but maybe not so well at converting outsiders.
Lil Red Posted December 20, 2007 Author Posted December 20, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1436778' date='Dec 20 2007, 03:48 PM']I agree that we have to talk about our faith. I disagree that Catholics don't do that. They do it when opportunities present themselves in daily life. You don't have to go door-to-door to evangelize. Someone may feel called to do that, but that does not have to be the general model.[/quote]i'm not saying any person has to go door-to-door. maybe i'm speaking from more personal experience? [quote name='rkwright' post='1436779' date='Dec 20 2007, 03:49 PM']I think there are two different groups of people we're talking about here. The first are the non-Catholics, possibly even non-Christians. Often these people are not won over with words or arguments, but witnessing some action or event. To walk up to a stranger and start preaching is probably not the best, and honestly might even turn them off to the faith. To go about your daily life and someone see something that you do out of the ordinary, maybe its praying before you take a test, maybe its just a positive attitude towards life, these might spark questions and you can go from there. The second group are what I will call 'close Catholics'. These might be family members, both extended and immediate. These people have the basics but are probably poorly educated. But they don't see your good works so much as evidence of your faith as just who you are. My family would say, thats just how I am, not his faith has changed his life. To these people words might be necessary (I hate using the word necessary here... but I'm going to). Someone needs to be teaching the average Catholic true devotion, and more than just once a Sunday. I can't tell you how many times I grew up going to mass, hearing the Homily, and then never discussing it again. We should be. Everyone was a good Catholic, but no one was a devout Catholic; and thats what we all need to be. So I think words work very well to make people better Catholics; but maybe not so well at converting outsiders.[/quote]good points.
-I---Love Posted December 21, 2007 Posted December 21, 2007 After reading everyones points, I do agree w/ LilRed to begin with. My reaction was the same reading the beginning of the encyclical. And maybe it was so for me because I feel that I personally lack in doing this. Concerning people with whom we have some form of a relationship w/, from my own limited experience, I do not see many devout Catholics or otherwise, evangelizing through words at ANY point in the relationship. Of course, this is difficult for me to measure, but it seems to me that we "cop out." My experiences are from middle class suburbean families in the US and Germany. Actions are indeed more necessary, but words usually are important at some point. I agree, there is a time, and place, must wait till ppl are ready, etc., etc.. That is all important and not to be disregarded. But, that enthusiasm for hope is lacking. The Cardinal Arinze quote applies. I can't articulate my thoughts since I now forget them......but I'm w/ Lil Red. As to why words are important: GK Chesterton (The Ball and the Cross): "Well, we won't quarrel about a word," said the other, pleasantly. "Why on earth not?" said MacIan, with a sudden asperity. "Why shouldn't we quarrel about a word? What is the good of words if they aren't important enough to quarrel over? Why do we choose one word more than another if there isn't any difference between them? .....If you're not going to argue about words, what are you going to argue about? Are you going to convey your meaning to me by moving your ears? The Church and the heresies always used to fight about words, because they are the only things worth fighting about. --------- It just seems to me, that today in our society too many words are used that don't mean anything. And then, people aren't "ready" to use words concerning the more important questions. And so maybe that's why evangelizing w/ actions is "safer" than with words, because people are scared to commit to words when they really mean something......
Adrestia Posted December 21, 2007 Posted December 21, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Era Might' post='1436704' date='Dec 20 2007, 03:58 PM']I believe Catholics who "know their faith and love it" do explain their faith in words, when they have the opportunity. But they don't try to force that opportunity. In my experience, when people see you practicing your faith, they want to know WHY you practice your faith. That is always a great opportunity, even if it's a small explanation. I disagree that every relationship we have must lead to an explicit discussion of our faith. It depends on the situation. Some sow the seed and others water. But we should never HIDE our faith. It should be on display so others may see our good works, and give praise to our Heavenly Father. We have to live our faith fully.[/quote] yeah. I couldn't think of another word for pathognomonic when I was typing this morning. was rushing to get to work. sorry for the sloppy word usage. replace "pathognomonic" with "a sure sign of" -- In fact, I would have said that the desire to spread hope is a sure sign of faith in Christ. -- Edited December 21, 2007 by tgoldson
God Conquers Posted December 23, 2007 Posted December 23, 2007 [quote name='rkwright' post='1436779' date='Dec 20 2007, 06:49 PM']I think there are two different groups of people we're talking about here. The first are the non-Catholics, possibly even non-Christians. Often these people are not won over with words or arguments, but witnessing some action or event. To walk up to a stranger and start preaching is probably not the best, and honestly might even turn them off to the faith. To go about your daily life and someone see something that you do out of the ordinary, maybe its praying before you take a test, maybe its just a positive attitude towards life, these might spark questions and you can go from there. The second group are what I will call 'close Catholics'. These might be family members, both extended and immediate. These people have the basics but are probably poorly educated. But they don't see your good works so much as evidence of your faith as just who you are. My family would say, thats just how I am, not his faith has changed his life. To these people words might be necessary (I hate using the word necessary here... but I'm going to). Someone needs to be teaching the average Catholic true devotion, and more than just once a Sunday. I can't tell you how many times I grew up going to mass, hearing the Homily, and then never discussing it again. We should be. Everyone was a good Catholic, but no one was a devout Catholic; and thats what we all need to be. So I think words work very well to make people better Catholics; but maybe not so well at converting outsiders.[/quote] Bang on man! Although, many times we do need to let the outsiders know the basics of our faith, once we've convinced them by our actions.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now