curtins Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 Would saying "God forbid" be breaking the 2nd commandment?
prose Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 If you were asking God to forbid something... Then I don't think it would be.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 I don't think so, as I've never heard it used in anything other than a prayerful sense.
curtins Posted January 5, 2008 Author Posted January 5, 2008 well I was kinda being sarcastic, I think I said something like they attack romney cause he's mormon they attack huckabee cause hes evangelical God forbid a catholic were to run
KnightofChrist Posted January 5, 2008 Posted January 5, 2008 (edited) The answer is yes if the comment is not a prayer. The meaning of Vain is "having no real value". If the comment is not a prayer and directed to God, it would be taking the Lord's name in vain. Because it would have no real value it would be vain. Edited January 5, 2008 by KnightofChrist
let_go_let_God Posted January 6, 2008 Posted January 6, 2008 I agree with KOC, any use of the Lord's name that isn't referring to Him directly or using the Lord's name in a way that is not reverent is a violation of the 2nd commandment. God bless- LGLG
Paladin D Posted January 9, 2008 Posted January 9, 2008 (edited) [quote name='let_go_let_God' post='1442705' date='Jan 6 2008, 01:29 PM']I agree with KOC, any use of the Lord's name that isn't referring to Him directly or using the Lord's name in a way that is not reverent is a violation of the 2nd commandment. God bless- LGLG[/quote] Therefore, a suprise reaction or that one of awe such as "Oh my G**" is using the Lord's name in vain? For some reason I always equated vain as to desecration (such as using God's name along with a curse word). It makes sense, but this is where it can get dicey. What about when people say "Oh my gosh"? Most people know you're just replacing 'God' with 'gosh'. Would it be wise just to avoid the phrase all together? I find this startling because no one has ever corrected me on this. I knew using Christ's name or the Holy Family in the same manner was vain, but never honestly put two and two together with the 'omg' phrase. Edited January 9, 2008 by Paladin D
let_go_let_God Posted January 9, 2008 Posted January 9, 2008 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1443561' date='Jan 8 2008, 10:32 PM']Therefore, a suprise reaction or that one of awe such as "Oh my G**" is using the Lord's name in vain? For some reason I always equated vain as to desecration (such as using God's name along with a curse word). It makes sense, but this is where it can get dicey. What about when people say "Oh my gosh"? Most people know you're just replacing 'God' with 'gosh'. Would it be wise just to avoid the phrase all together? I find this startling because no one has ever corrected me on this. I knew using Christ's name or the Holy Family in the same manner was vain, but never honestly put two and two together with the 'omg' phrase.[/quote] I believe it's all in context. If a person says "gosh" but means "God" then yes I believe it is a sin, but there are people like me that do say "omg" as oh my gosh, and to keep it clear when I type in chat it is omgosh. My friends all know it and think I'm a dork for it but that's fine. But back on topic the whole OMG thing where G is clearly meant for God yes it is using the Lord's name in vain. We've been working with our youth group kids on this one because not a lot of people think about it since the use of omg is so wide spread. God bless- LGLG
prose Posted January 9, 2008 Posted January 9, 2008 I got lynched here once when I wrote omg. And I honestly always think oh my goodness. But thank goodness Phatmassers were so cautious of the fate of my soul that they blasted me for it. Yes, I think "Oh my God" is a swear. No, I think "Oh my Gosh" is not. God in vain is the Lord's name in vain. Gosh is not the Lord's name.
Paladin D Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 Well I have a life long habit of saying OMG, boy it's gonna be hard to curb it. Which brings up another question: What about actors/actresses who curse or use such language on TV or movies? Is it permissible depending on the context of the situation and/or role?
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 I listened to a wonderful Protestant speaker talk about how gosh, darn, heck, shoot, and (this was added by a different Protestant) fudge are all said with the same intention and really mean the same thing. You can tell how they come from the same words. Anyways, I actually live by this and by not saying those, never cussing is really easy. And then I knew a Priest who told my friends in Confession to look up the words in their family's original language and use them to get out of cussing. And to answer the original question, I think to use "God forbid" wrongly would be taking His name in vain, though I think you could use it correctly. I think you could use it to describe a person's opinion pretty well, if you actually mean to say that he thinks God does forbid something...Sorry, I'll try to be clearer after a good night's rest. As far as the other words, I think their intention is often the same, which does make an action evil..........
prose Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 Maybe I am feeling feisty, but I am going to argue that is ridiculous. Fudge is not a swear. Neither is gosh, darn, heck, or shoot. It may substitute a swear, but it is not a swear. You clearly don't have the "intent" to swear, or you would have sworn. I am sorry, I think that is being over scrupulous. It is using a word to fill a space. Does it sound more intelligent and mature to not use those words, of course. Because they are a waste of breath, but that doesn't make them a swear.
ardillacid Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1443946' date='Jan 10 2008, 01:42 AM']I listened to a wonderful Protestant speaker talk about how gosh, darn, heck, shoot, and (this was added by a different Protestant) fudge are all said with the same intention and really mean the same thing. You can tell how they come from the same words.[/quote] So what you are saying is that instead of saying darn, I should say beaver dam. Instead of saying shoot, I should say shinobi. Instead of frick I should say floopy. lol.
prose Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 This seems boring but appropriate... [quote]Most researchers agree that swearing came from early forms of word magic. Studies of modern, non-literate cultures suggest that swearwords came from the belief that spoken words have power. Some cultures, especially ones that have not developed a written language, believe that spoken words can curse or bless people or can otherwise affect the world. This leads to the idea that some words are either very good or very bad. By the second book in the series, the world of Harry Potter had its own racial epithet -- "mudblood," a repugnant word for wizards of non-magical parentage. While spoken swearwords from different languages don't sound alike, they generally fall into one of two categories. Most of the time, they are either deistic (related to religion) or visceral (related to the human body and its functions). Some expletives also relate to a person's ancestry or parentage. While some linguists classify racial slurs and epithets as swearwords, others place them in a separate category. So the words themselves are similar, but in different cultures people swear at different times and in different contexts. In the Western, English-speaking world, people from every race, class and level of education swear. In America, 72 percent of men and 58 percent of women swear in public. The same is true for 74 percent of 18 to 34 year olds and 48 percent of people who are over age 55 [ref]. Numerous language researchers report that men swear more than women, but studies that focus on women's use of language theorize that women's swearing is simply more context specific.[/quote]
prose Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='notardillacid' post='1444086' date='Jan 10 2008, 12:54 PM']So what you are saying is that instead of saying darn, I should say beaver dam. Instead of saying shoot, I should say shinobi. Instead of frick I should say floopy. lol.[/quote] You would sound funny yelling "shinobi!!" when you stubbed your toe or something....
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 (edited) [quote]So what you are saying is that instead of saying darn, I should say beaver dam. Instead of saying shoot, I should say shinobi. Instead of frick I should say floopy. lol.[/quote] Actually, all I said was I don't use those words and you should never say a word intending it like a cuss word. Oh, and that I used to listen to Protestant radio. Edited January 10, 2008 by qfnol31
ardillacid Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1444092' date='Jan 10 2008, 02:01 PM']Actually, all I said was I don't use those words and you should never say a work intending it like a cuss word. Oh, and that I used to listen to Protestant radio. [/quote] Well seeing as I already use those other ones (gosh or darn...etc), God wouldn't be any less displeased if I just replaced them with their more offensive term (god or beaver dam...etc).
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2008 Posted January 10, 2008 I wouldn't say that at all. But you're proving to me your intention if this is your line of reasoning...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now